1 / 4100%
Explain the North American Free Trade Agreement
Clarke Ricks School of Business,
Liberty University
BUSI 690: Policy and Strategy in Global Competition
Dr. Hicks
June 8, 2022
Explain the North American Free Trade Agreement
The North American Free Trade Agreement, abbreviated NAFTA, is an agreement between
the United States, Canada and Mexico that eliminated tariffs and duties on trade between the
three countries. Trade barriers began dropping as of Jan. 1, 1994, and were completely
eliminated on schedule by Jan. 1, 2008. The Office of the United States Trade Representative
(USTR) attributes many improvements in the American economy to NAFTA provisions.
Facts
Free trade agreements between countries are legally binding treaties, which prevents a
nation from imposing taxes on imported goods from the other nations in the treaty. These
taxes are called duties or tariffs, and tend to restrict trade between nations, as the additional
costs are passed along to the consumer, depressing demand for the imported products. Free
trade agreements tend to increase international commerce, but come under frequent criticism
for their detrimental impact to labor forces, established economic institutions and the
environment.
Significance
Trade between the NAFTA nations tripled from 1993 to 2007, rising from $297 billion to
$930 billion.
Time Frame
The United States and Canada previously entered into free trade agreements bilaterally in
1989. The integration of Mexico into existing free trade structures was deliberately paced over
a 15-year period, intended to prevent excessive disruption to the three economies, and to
provide Mexico with time to improve domestic standards to meet several requirements of the
agreement.
Size
The three countries in NAFTA are the world’s largest free trade zone with 444 million
people living in these countries for a combined gross domestic product of $17 trillion per year.
Considerations
Critics of NAFTA, such as Public Citizen, say that the flaw in creating a free trade zone of
this magnitude stems from the different levels of development between the three countries.
Under NAFTA, there are limitations to what restrictions can be placed on the import of goods,
which in turn can affect the passage and enforcement of domestic environmental and labor
laws. The benefits that USTR attributes to NAFTA may have come from other market forces
within the economy, and a sweeping eradication of all trade barriers may not have been
necessary to realize most of that economic benefit.
North American Free Trade Agreement Pros & Cons
The North American Free Trade Agreement ("NAFTA") is a 1994 agreement between the
United States, Canada and Mexico that lifted many restrictions on the imports and exports of
agricultural products between these three nations. Some of the policies went into effect
immediately following the agreement while others took 15 years to implement. All the NAFTA
provisions were in place as of 2008 between the North American countries. Free trade among
these nations has both pros and cons.
Tariffs
One of the primary advantages and purposes of NAFTA was the reduction or full
elimination of taxes on imported goods between these three countries. Since 2008, all tariffs on
agricultural exports between the United States and Mexico no longer exist, and many are
eliminated between Canada and Mexico. However Canada and Mexico still tax sugar, eggs,
poultry and dairy products. The reduced or eliminated tariffs make it easier for these nations to
trade with each other.
Domestic Production
The tariff policies of NAFTA affect only goods produced directly within these three nations.
Products produced in countries outside North America still operate with tariff restrictions. This
is an important advantage for two reasons. It is an incentive for these countries to nurture their
domestic producers. But it also prevents one country from exporting goods within North
America that are purchased from another country outside North America. The policy prevents a
loophole that could effectively remove tariffs on goods other than those produced in North
America.
Job Losses
With the increased ease by which Mexico can import food products from the United
States, the role of Mexican farmers is overwhelmed by the output of American agriculture. This
is a notable con of NAFTA. According to Thomas Net Industry Market Trends, over 1 million
Mexican farmers have lost their jobs as a result of the agreement.
Immigration
It was possible that NAFTA would encourage Mexican citizens to remain in their country
since their manufacturing work could still reach the American market easily. But since the
creation of NAFTA, illegal immigration between Mexico and the United States has only gotten
worse. Over the 10-year period between 1990 and 2000, the number of annual illegal
immigrants doubled, despite the creation of NAFTA in 1994, according to Thomas Net Industry
Market Trends. That NAFTA was not more effective in preventing the immigration crisis is a
disadvantage.
Texas
The state of Texas provides the longest border between the United States and Mexico. The
trade between these two countries often goes through Texas, and this has had a positive effect
on the Texan economy. According to the Mays Business School, the metal and apparel
industries in Texas grew by 13 percent within just one year after the creation of NAFTA due to
flourishing exports to Mexico.
Students also viewed