hip 3500

Worksheet for Ethical Decision-Making Framework

Introduction: Cite the case that you are using. Describe the situation and the ethical dilemma

1. What patient situation are you researching? Please describe and discuss the individual and the situation.

2. Identify and discuss the ethical dilemma in this case (ie, withholding, withdrawing, assisted suicide, etc.)

Step 1: Identify ethical issues

Identify and discuss the ethical issue(s) involved with this situation (based on 7 ethical/universal principles); other ethical issues?

Step 2: Gather the facts

What are the facts and circumstances? Are there any formal or informal opinions in the media or elsewhere? What are the legal ramifications? Has this issue been decided by the courts before or did it result in new legal direction/new laws?

Step 3: Consider at least two options to address dilemma

Process calls for at least 3 options but for this assignment, 2 are sufficient. With 2 options, they are generally polar opposites, such as to do x or not to do x; need to be credible

Step 4: Weigh and evaluate the potential options

Consider these possible alternatives by analyzing the ethical arguments for and against each action, as well as their possible outcomes.

Option 1:

Arguments for: Arguments against: Option 2:

Arguments for:

Arguments against:

Step 4a: Ethical Theory

What ethical theory (ie, duty oriented or utilitarianism) are you going to use to make the choice? Please discuss/describe the theory. Why are you using this theory?

Step 5: Decide and act. What is your decision and why?

Make your decision. Justify your rationale. Determine action.

Step 6: How would you assess outcomes

How would you, as the Ethics Committee, assess and evaluate both the process and outcomes of your ethical decision making in order to track creative solutions, unanticipated consequences, and overall satisfaction with the results of the plan of action by all of the parties involved?