McKinsey Model
Design Model Comparison Worksheet
|
|
STAR Model |
McKinsey Model |
|
Strategy |
X The “company’s formula for winning” (Galbraith, 2002, p. 10) that gives it a competitive advantage in the marketplace · The organization’s direction and long-term vision · Includes which products and services it will create, and markets and customers it will pursue · Strategy is typically the starting point for the design effort because it “dictates which activities are the most necessary, thereby providing the basis for making the best trade-offs in the organization design” (Galbraith, 2002, p. 11).
|
X |
|
People |
X Human resources practices related to talent · Hiring, managing performance, learning and development, and programs to grow talent such as rotations and succession plans |
|
|
Rewards |
X Motivation and incentives for achievement of goals · Compensation and recognition, promotions · Goals and measurement systems such as scorecards and dashboards |
|
|
Processes |
X The flow of information that cuts across the structural hierarchy to enable effective collaboration · Decision-making processes and cross-functional collaboration mechanisms · Includes concepts such as networks, shared processes and goals, teams, integrative roles, and matrix structures
|
|
|
Structure |
X Distribution of resources, power, and authority · Role definition, responsibilities, and relationships among departments · Includes concepts such as span of control, centralization and decentralization, and department organizing principles such as functions, products, geographies, or markets |
X |
|
Systems |
|
X |
|
Shared Values |
|
X |
|
Skills |
|
X |
|
Staff |
|
X |
|
Style |
|
X |