Week 5 - Assignment: Understanding Peer-Reviewed, Primary, and Secondary Sources

6/2/22, 8:19 AM What is the difference between scholarly and peer reviewed journals? - Ask Us!

https://ncu.libanswers.com/faq/168491 1/3

1. NCU Library (https://library.ncu.edu/) 2. Ask Us! (/)

Ask Us! Ask Another Question Type your question keywords

0 options available. Use up and down arrows to browse available options and enter to select one. Search

454 Answers (/search/) Groups (#)

NCU ASC (/asc/) NCU CTL (/ctl/) NCU IRB (/irb/) NCU Library (/) NCU Office of the Registrar (/registrar/)

Topics (#) 6Academic Success Center (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Academic%20Success%20Center&adv=1) 20Alumni (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Alumni&adv=1) 46Business Research (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Business%20Research&adv=1) 1Center for Teaching & Learning (/search/? t=0&g=3393&topics=Center%20for%20Teaching%20%26amp%3B%20Learning&adv=1) 1COMPS (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=COMPS&adv=1) 39Database Problems (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Database%20Problems&adv=1) 65Database Questions (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Database%20Questions&adv=1) 8Database Subscriptions (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Database%20Subscriptions&adv=1) 9Dissertation Center Documents (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Dissertation%20Center%20Documents&adv=1) 65Dissertation Research (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Dissertation%20Research&adv=1) 14Ebook Central Questions (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Ebook%20Central%20Questions&adv=1) 31Education Research (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Education%20Research&adv=1) 10EndNote (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=EndNote&adv=1) 3ERIC (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=ERIC&adv=1) 10Evaluating Information (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Evaluating%20Information&adv=1) 46Faculty (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Faculty&adv=1) 14Google (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Google&adv=1) 25Interlibrary Loan (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Interlibrary%20Loan&adv=1) 23JFK Law (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=JFK%20Law&adv=1) 13Legal Research (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Legal%20Research&adv=1) 27Library Access (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Library%20Access&adv=1) 2Library Workshops (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Library%20Workshops&adv=1) 83Locate items in the Library (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Locate%20items%20in%20the%20Library&adv=1) 55Locate Items Outside the Library (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Locate%20Items%20Outside%20the%20Library&adv=1) 22Marriage & Family Therapy Research (/search/? t=0&g=3393&topics=Marriage%20%26amp%3B%20Family%20Therapy%20Research&adv=1) 23OpenAthens (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=OpenAthens&adv=1) 19Organizing Research and Citations (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Organizing%20Research%20and%20Citations&adv=1) 15Other (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Other&adv=1) 23Psychology Research (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Psychology%20Research&adv=1) 49Reference Management (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Reference%20Management&adv=1) 40RefWorks (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=RefWorks&adv=1) 2Research Consultations (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Research%20Consultations&adv=1) 122Research Techniques (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Research%20Techniques&adv=1) 9Service Desk (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Service%20Desk&adv=1) 4Syllabi (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Syllabi&adv=1) 20Technical Issues (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Technical%20Issues&adv=1) 10Tests & Measurements (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Tests%20%26%20Measurements&adv=1) 10Textbooks (/search/?t=0&g=3393&topics=Textbooks&adv=1)

What is the difference between scholarly and peer reviewed journals?

6/2/22, 8:19 AM What is the difference between scholarly and peer reviewed journals? - Ask Us!

https://ncu.libanswers.com/faq/168491 2/3

Answer

For brief instruction on scholarly vs. peer reviewed journals, please see the Library's Scholarly vs. Peer Reviewed Journals (https://youtu.be/1JLnmO5lFaU) quick tutorial video.

A scholarly publication is regarded as scholarly if it is authored by experts, for experts. The publication is academic in focus as it reports original research (experimentation), research methodology or theory. Generally, scholarly journals are targeted for professional or academic researchers and provide detailed analysis concentrating on a single discipline or academic field. The publisher is typically a professional association or an academic press. Not all scholarly journals use a peer-review process.

Peer-Review Process

Prior to publication, articles are submitted and go through a rigorous assessment that involves review and approval by the author’s peers (experts in the same subject area). The actual evaluations are similar to editing notes, where the author receives detailed and constructive feedback from the peer experts. However, these reviews are not made available publicly. For an example peer review of a fictitious article, click here (http://www.asge.org/assets/0/71542/71546/8fb08afa-9230-422c-9bb5-aefdec2ea04a.pdf) . Peer reviewed journals publish articles only if they have passed through the official editorial process. The peer review and evaluation system is used to safeguard, maintain, and improve the quality of scholarly materials published in serials.

It is important to keep in mind that not all scholarly journals go through the peer review process. Checking the Scholarly/Peer Reviewed limiter in the Library's Roadrunner Search or EBSCOhost Databases, will result in scholarly journal articles, most of which are peer-reviewed. However, Roadrunner and EBSCOhost do not make the distinction between scholarly and peer reviewed journal articles in their results.

For example, a subject search for leadership AND education with the scholarly/peer-reviewed limit checked results in an article from Democracy & Education, a non-peer reviewed publication.

ProQuest, on the other hand, does make the distinction and has separate limiters for scholarly and peer reviewed content. And still other databases (such as SpringerLink, Taylor & Francis, Wiley Online, etc.) include only peer reviewed journals and, therefore, do not have check boxes to limit to this type of content.

Check for Peer-Review Verification

To alleviate any confusion, the Library recommends using the Ulrichsweb (https://go.openathens.net/redirector/ncu.edu? url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ulrichsweb.serialssolutions.com) database to determine whether or not a particular journal is peer reviewed/refereed. To access Ulrichsweb, go to the Library’s home page and then click on A-Z Databases (http://ncu.libguides.com/az.php) . Returning to our example above, we can determine that Democracy & Education not peer-reviewed by checking the publication title in Ulrichsweb, as shown below. The black and white striped referee shirt icon indicates that it is peer-reviewed.

For further information about how to use Ulrichsweb (including instructional screenshots), please see the Library's FAQ here (https://ncu.libanswers.com/faq/168490) .

6/2/22, 8:19 AM What is the difference between scholarly and peer reviewed journals? - Ask Us!

https://ncu.libanswers.com/faq/168491 3/3

It is also important to keep in mind that just because a journal is peer reviewed does not guarantee that all articles in it are included in the peer review process. Some article types in a peer reviewed journal, such as news items, editorials and book and article reviews, may not be peer reviewed.

Faculty and students will need to determine for themselves whether or not they are reading a book review, editorial, introduction, etc. coming from a peer reviewed journal versus an actual research study, for example. The databases will typically not make this distinction for you. For further characteristics of primary/scholarly studies, please see the Library's Academic and Popular Resources (http://ncu.libguides.com/researchprocess/academicandpopular) page.

Topics

Research Techniques (/search/?t=0&adv=1&topics=Research%20Techniques) Evaluating Information (/search/?t=0&adv=1&topics=Evaluating%20Information)

Last Updated Jun 30, 2021 Views 18614 Answered By NCU Library

FAQ Actions

Was this helpful? Yes 138 No 1

Print (#) Tweet (#) Share on Facebook (#)

(https://library.ncu.edu/)

(/academicsuccesscenter)

(/ctl)

(/irb)

(/dissertationcenter)

(/adcenter)

(/jfkresources)

(/officeoftheregistrar)