Who has benefited more from globalisation - developing countries or developed nations?
Assignment 2- Referenced Argument Essay
Week 9
Ways to write body paragraphs
Begin each body paragraph with a topic sentence stating your argument clearly and precisely.
Elaborate on the theme of the topic sentence. Explain it so that a reader can fully understand what your argument is.
Ways to write body paragraphs (cont.)
Use some kind of support for your argument – this is where your use of sources comes in. This is the place for an in-text citation –either a paraphrase or a quotation. Don’t forget to reference appropriately both in the actual essay and also in the list of References.
It is not enough to merely ‘stick in’ a quotation or paraphrase. You must say something about this evidence. What does it demonstrate? Why is it relevant to your position? How does it support your argument?
Don’t just present a quote or paraphrase and expect the reader to work out why you have included it.
Argument essay
1. What are the structure and main parts of an argument essay?
Introduction, Body paragraphs, Conclusion
Analyse the model argument essay:
Should whales be protected?
3. Brief introduction of Tutorial task 4 and 5
Quotation and Paraphrase
Five Components of the Argument Essay
1. The Argument Thesis Statement
Debatable (some people say yes / some say no)
Statement – Not Question
Easier to form if include a suitable verb – should
Sounds more academic if you include a reason
2. Pro-Arguments
3. Support for your Arguments
Counter-Arguments
Refutation
Structure of the Argument Essay
Introduction
General
More Specific
Opposing argument
Argument thesis statement
Preview of structure
Body paragraphs
Two ways to structure the Essay Body: Parallel or Linear method
Conclusion
(same as expository essay)
Brief summary
Restated argument thesis statement
End statement: recommendation
1. LINEAR METHOD
Pro-Argument 1
Pro-Argument 2
Counter-Argument 1
Refutation of Argument 1
Counter-Argument 2
Refutation of Argument 2
Two Ways to Structure the Essay Body
2. PARALLEL METHOD
Pro-Argument 1
Counter-Argument 1
Refutation of Counter-Argument 1
Pro-Argument 2
Counter-Argument 2
Refutation of Counter-Argument 2
Should Whales be protected?
Analyze the model argument essay (p.121)
Read through it and identify the following:
Argument thesis statement
Five parts in the introduction
Arguments in favour (pro-arguments)
Counter arguments
Refutations
The brief summary in the conclusion
Circle every cohesive device and linking expression
What grade would you give to this essay?
Introduction (p.121)
General
Recently, the issue of marine mammals' conservation has been strongly debated by people in many countries.
More Specific
Conservation organizations such as the International Whaling Commission (IWC) and the American Mare Mammal Commission (AMMC) … in many nations.
Opposing argument
Some people suggest banning all commercial whaling activity. Those favour … for commercial purposes.
Argument thesis statement
However, whale products are highly nutritious to consume… should be allowed.
Preview of structure
This essay discusses…
Body paragraphs (p.121)
Argument 1
Counter Argument 1
Refutation 1
Argument 2
Counter Argument 2
Refutation 2
Argument 3
Counter Argument 3
Refutation 3
Argument 4
Counter Argument 4
Refutation 4
In-text citation and references should follow the APA style (week 6).
Argument 1
Argument 2
Argument 3
Argument 4
Cohesive devices and linking expression (p.121)
Introduction
Therefore, however, and, such as, thus
Argument 1
Firstly – argument
Moreover – support
However – counter argument
However – refutation
Argument 2
Secondly – argument
Thus – support
Though – counter argument
However, In addition, although – refutation
Argument 3
Thirdly – argument
Such as – support
In spite of, because – counter argument
However, due to, such as, because of – refutation
Argument 4
Lastly – argument
However – counter argument
However – refutation
Conclusion
In conclusion, because, because, in addition, furthermore
More cohesive devices can be found on textbook page 46-47
Checklist for Assignment 2
Planning
1. No brainstorming necessary
2. Outline – for format follow examples pages 104-106 either parallel or linear form
3. Label where your quotations and paraphrases/ summaries will appear
4. Write thesis statement in full
5. Write preview sentence in full
Checklist for Assignment 2 (Cont.)
Essay Body
1. Essay double-spaced or 1.5
2. Use appropriate font 12 points.
3. Justify left hand margin only – not fully justified. (Use left hand paragraph tab)
4. Required number of in-text citations ( minimum 4 – maximum 7) a. Minimum 2 paraphrases/ summaries b. Minimum 2 quotations
5. Underline the thesis statement
6. Labelling of arguments, counter-arguments, refutations (follow the template provided in the video for week 10)
7. No long quotations, i.e. over 40 words or four lines or more
8. Include word count of essay – (not outline or list of references)
Checklist for Assignment 2 (Cont.)
In-text citations
1. Include author(s)’ surname(s), year of publication and page number(s) when quoting ideas
2. Include author(s)’ surname(s) and year of publication when paraphrasing/ summarizing ideas
3. Use the right format (either author prominent or information prominent)
Checklist for Assignment 2 (Cont.)
List of references
1. On a new page
2. Heading ‘References’ in centred on page
3. Left side justified – not fully justified
4. Double-spacing throughout
5. Correctly formatted according to current APA guidelines
Checklist for Assignment 2 (Cont.)
Submission of Assignment
All necessary document submitted in file
a. Outline
b. Essay
c. List of References
d. Two-columns showing sources used and your in-text citations (paraphrases/ summaries and quotations)
2. Submitted on time
Two- columns – sources used and in-text citations
| Original Texts | My in-text citations |
| but it is essential that cleaner and green electricity sources should be introduced into electricity systems in order to reduce the effects of climate change, and to obtain sustainable development (Marques, Fuinhas & Pereira, 2018). | Furthermore, to implement renewable energy as a replacement for fossil fuels will help reduce emission levels (Marques, Fuinhas & Pereira, 2018). |
| One of the major concerns with the use of energy supplies, such as wind, solar, and wave power, which produce variable output is whether such supplies can provide reliable sources of electric power second-by-second, daily, seasonally, and yearly (Delucchi & Jacobson, 2010). | Wind, water and solar power are all dependent on weather conditions and locations, which creates unreliable sources of energy (Delucchi & Jacobson, 2010) |
Tutorial tasks 4 and 5
In-text citation and referencing - Submission Friday October 9th by 10PM (NZST) online except LO3 (9:00AM-11:00AM) and LO4 (2:00PM-4:00PM) students who will do in their regular class time
Identify formatting mistakes from the given list and write in the correct form according to APA guidelines. You may use your textbook and PowerPoint of Week 6.
Read an extract from a text and produce short quotations in two forms with APA style.
Short quotation: (information prominent)
Short quotation: (author prominent)
3. Read an extract from a text and paraphrase the highlighted sentences in the text.
In-text Citations
Method 1: information prominent
Method 2: author prominent
Ways of referencing: Quotation and Paraphrase
Note:
Information prominent citations are more frequent
Author prominent is useful when the writer is particularly well-known
Method 1: Information prominent
Paraphrase
It is possible for students to reproduce sounds that they hear without understanding what those sounds mean (Ur, 1984).
Short quotation
The learning burden of a word has been defined as "the amount of effort needed to learn and remember it" (Nation, 1998, p. 45).
Method 2: Author prominent
Paraphrase
A recent study by White (2002) has shown the importance of motivation as a predictor of student grades.
Short quotation
White (2002, p.45) maintains that “the primary factor in determining student grade outcomes is motivation.”