Behavioral Genetics DB
GENETICS OF ATHLETIC PERFORMANCE
Dr. Katie Dabrowski, PT, DPT
Some beginning concepts
- Darwin’s theory of natural selection = individuals with traits that are favorable are more likely to survive and reproduce.
- Those who are “stronger” are better equipped to handle struggles of the world
- Each individual has a limited capacity to perform exercise – but what determines the limit to that capacity?
- It is proposed that up to 50% of physical fitness is due to genetics
- Athletes may be inherently predisposed to be more fit
- But there may be a trade-off – genetically skilled athletes in one domain may be lesser-than in another domain (a sprinter with power and strength vs. lacking endurance, for example)
- What genes are responsible for an athlete dominating in one sport (let’s say a sprint) rather than another (like a marathon)?
Components of Performance
- Body morphology: Height and body composition
- Aerobic endurance: Ability to sustain an aerobic effort over time.
- Requires the ability of the cardiovascular system to deliver oxygen to working muscles, and the ability of those muscles to utilize that oxygen
- Quantified via VO2max, but other factors like economy and ventilatory threshold influence performance in addition to VO2max
- Muscular strength: Ability of muscle to generate force.
- Quantified via one rep max
- Cognitive factors
- Injury susceptibility
- Nutrition
- Trainability
*
Performance Enhancing Polymorphisms (PEPs)
- PEPs = Genetic variants that, when inherited, can lead to improved athletic performance
- 200+ PEPs exist
Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme
- ACE gene contains the first PEP to be identified
- ACE catalyzes the conversion of angiotensin I into angiotensin II, which affects vasoconstriction and regulation of salt and water homeostasis via releasing aldosterone
- ACE is also responsible for regulating inflammatory reactions to lung injury, respiratory drive, erythropoiesis, tissue oxygenation, and regulation of skeletal muscle efficiency
Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme
- Most common polymorphism associated with ACE is of the I allele
- This polymorphism is associated with improved performance in endurance sports due to higher circulating and tissue ACE activity
- ACE polymorphisms and athletic performance were first studied in Australian National Rowers at the pre-Olympic trials in 1996
- Researchers found significantly increased frequency of I allele in elite rowers compared to normal controls
- Another study investigated the role of ACE polymorphisms on body composition by training men over a 10-week period
- Individuals with the I genotype had a greater anabolic response
- And another study found a relationship between the I allele and mountaineering – individuals who engage in high altitude mountaineering ascending over 8000 meters without supplemental oxygen show an excess in the ACE I allele frequency
ACTN3 R577X
- This gene codes for an important protein found exclusively in the fast type II muscle fibers used during explosive activities
- A polymorphism resulting in a premature stop codon (X) rather than (R) at position 577
- The R allele is advantageous in power events, and the RR genotype is overrepresented in elite power athletes; the X polymorphism is associated with lower sprinting ability and muscle strength
- A study of elite European athletes found that power athletes are 50% less likely to have the XX genotype
NRF1
- NRF1 has a role in mitochondrial biogenesis, oxidative phosphorylation, and increased capacity for energy during exercise
- A study of Chinese men found two SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms) in noncoding regions of NRF1 that were associated with submaximum aerobic capacity (ventilatory threshold)
- These men underwent a strenuous endurance program for 18 weeks of running, swimming, and cycling
- Those without the two SNPs developed significantly better ventilatory thresholds compared to those with the polymorphisms
*
ADRB2
- A study of elite male endurance athletes reported a significant difference in a SNP in the ADRB2 gene
- Sedentary controls had an excess of the Gly allele compared to these elite athletes
- Gly allele is associated with increased body mass index (BMI)
Mitochondrial DNA
- Endurance athletes tend to have enhanced mitochondrial function:
- Increased mitochondrial gene expression
- Increased mitochondrial DNA
- Increased mitochondrial enzyme activity
- Mitochondrial function is linked to aerobic fitness and insulin sensitivity
Nitric oxide synthase
- At rest, increased nitric oxide (NO) production and NO synthase (NOS) inhibition can increase and decrease, respectively, blood flow to skeletal muscle
- NO decreases mitochondrial respiration
- NOS inhibition blocks glucose transport during exercise; NO has the opposite effect
- NOS3, a polymorphism, is linked to increased adaptability of the heart during exercise
Myostatin
- MSTN gene gained interest when a 4-year-old German boy who was homozygous for MTSN mutations and displayed significant muscle hypertrophy
- He was shown to have very muscular thighs and upper arms at birth
- Ultrasonography showed that his quadriceps muscle was 7.2 SD above the mean
- His mother was a former Olympic sprint swimmer and was heterozygous for the same mutation
PPARD
- PPARD (peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-delta) gene = determinants of mitochondrial function
- PPARD:
- Regulates the gene expression in lipid and carbohydrate metabolism
- Affects insulin sensitivity by modifying skeletal muscle glucose uptake
- Polymorphisms in this gene are associated with predisposition to endurance performance
- Frequency of PPARD polymorphism in endurance athletes = significantly higher than controls
*
PGC-1
- PGC-1 regulates the expression of genes for oxidative phosphorylation and ATP production
- Muscle-specific expression of PGC-1 improves performance during voluntary and forced exercise challenges
- PGC-1 transgenic mice have enhanced performance during peak VO2 tests
*
HIFs
- HIFs = hypoxia inducible factors (proteins)
- Help us to understand the body’s response to hypoxia in tissues during increased oxygen demand (muscles working at high intensities)
- The genes controlled by HIFs include those that:
- Stimulate red blood cell production*
- Encode glycolytic enzymes*
- *These things are critical for achieving high levels of anaerobic performance
- Removing HIF causes an adaptive response in skeletal muscle similar to endurance training – aka these muscles are no longer able to be powerful and anaerobic with short bursts, but instead perform best with endurance activities
*
Injury Risk
- Resistance to and/or the ability to recover from injury is another integral factor for optimal performance
- Two main areas studied for genetic links to injury:
- Concussion
- Tendinopathy
*
Concussion
- APOE is the gene most frequently studied with regard to concussion/mild TBI
- It has three isoforms (ε2, ε3, and ε4 alleles), and the ε4 allele has a strong association with Alzheimer’s disease
- This association led to many researchers investigating a possible link between this allele and risk for concussion/outcomes after TBI
- Some studies have found that individuals with the ε4 allele suffer worse outcomes from head injury; boxers with the ε4 allele have higher chronic brain injury scores
Tendinopathy
- Tendinopathy = pain and pathology associated with overuse in/around tendons
- Several genes associated with tendon injuries
- COL1A1
- COL5A1
- COL12A1
- COL14A1
- TNC
- MMP3
- TGFB1
- GDF-5
- We’ll highlight some of them
COL1A1
- Collagen type I alpha 1 gene
- Collagen type I fibrils are a major constituent of bone matrix, forming strong parallel bundles of fibers in tendons and ligaments
- A SNP polymorphism of COL1A1 which results in a T to G substitution is associated with osteoporotic fracture, osteoarthritis, myocardial infarction, lumbar disc disease, and stress urinary incontinence
- TT genotype = reduced risk of cruciate ligament ruptures and shoulder dislocation ruptures compared with GG genotype
TNC
- Tenascin C gene
- Association of ABO blood group with Achilles tendon injury
- O blood = more susceptible to tendon injuries
- TNC gene is closely linked to the ABO gene that determines blood type