1 Page summary
HCS 420:
RESEARCH METHODS IN HEALTHCARE
Week 13
Implementing the Study and Quality Control in Healthcare Research
Chapter 17
What is Study Implementation?
Study Implementation
- Implementing the plan discussed in the protocol
What does study implementation involve?
Study Implementation
- Involves….
- Assembling resources
- space, staff, and financial management)
- Finalizing protocol
- Pretesting recruitment, measurement, and intervention plans
- Systematic approach to quality control of clinical and lab procedures and of data management
Assembling Resources
What are some examples of resources in healthcare research?
Resources include:
Space, people (i.e. research team members), documents (i.e. manuals, forms), etc.
Assembling Resources
- Space
- Although conducting research online is possible, most research require some physical space
- The Research team
- Could range is size from small (investigator & part-time staff) to large (multiple full-time staff)
- Leadership and team-building
- The Principal Investigator is responsible for leading the research team
Assembling Resources (Contd.)
- Study start-up: Period of study activity before the first participant is recruited
- IRB approval: Getting the study protocol, consent form, and recruitment materials approved before the study begins
- Operations manual and forms development
- The protocol can be expanded to create the operations manual
- The protocol, information on study organization and policies, and a detailed version of the methods section of the study
Assembling Resources (Contd.)
- Database design: Creation and testing of the database that will be used to enter, edit, store, monitor, and analyze the data
- Recruitment: Timely recruitment is often the most difficult aspect of may studies
- It requires adequate time, staff, resources, funding and expertise
Finalizing the Protocol
Finalizing the Protocol
- Pretests and dress rehearsals: Pretests and pilot studies can be used to evaluate the feasibility, efficiency, and cost of study methods
- Pretests are evaluations of specific questionnaires, measures, or procedures that can be carried out by study staff to assess their functionality, appropriateness, and feasibility
- Dress rehearsals involves testing plans for clinic visits and other study procedures in a full scale procedure
Finalizing the Protocol
- Minor protocol revisions once data collection has begun: In general, make as few changes to the protocol as possible once data collection has begun
- Substantive protocol revisions once data collection has begun: Once data collection has begun, major changes (e.g. including different kind of participants or changing the intervention or outcomes are considered serious problems
Finalizing the Protocol
- Closeout: In a longitudinal study, this represents the period during which participants complete their last visit in the study
Closeout (contd.)
- Points to keep in mind:
- Staff should thank participants for their time
- Participants should be informed of the results of clinically relevant lab tests
- In RCTs, participants may be told their treatment status
- Copy of the mailed manuscript should be mailed to participants
- After all participants have completed the study, they may be invited to a reception during which the PI thanks them, discusses the results, and answers questions
Quality Control During the Study
Quality Control During the Study
- Good Clinical Practice (GCP): Guidelines for high-quality research
- Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs)
- The process of implementing the GCP
- SOPs can cover study protocol, operations manual, statistical analysis plan, and data and safety monitoring plan
Quality Control During the Study
- Quality control for clinical procedures
- The operations manual
- Calibration, training, and certification
- Performance review
- Periodic reports
- Specific procedures for drug interventions
Quality Control During the Study
- Quality control for laboratory procedures:
- Attention to labeling
- Blinding
- Blinded duplicates, standard pools and consensus measures
- Commercial laboratory contracts
Quality Control During the Study
- Quality control for data management
- Missing data
- Inaccurate and imprecise data
- Fraudulent data
Quality Control During the Study
- Collaborative multicenter studies
- A coordinating center
- Steering committee
- Sub-committee