Week 09b Peer Review Feedback

​​Week 09b Peer Review Feedback

This assignment is a peer review to give thoughtful, constructive feedback to your partner. Please read and follow the specific instructions below:

1) Read through your partner's entire paper first without making any comments

2) At the top of your partners paper provide a paragraph or two that addresses the following questions:

· What did you learn that you didn't know before? What windows and mirrors did you find in your partner's paper?

· Does each topic have a balance of shelves (academic/in-class resources) and selves (personal stories and experiences)? Where can your partner add/improve?

· What topics do you think your partner should prioritize? Where can they expand and what can be cut?

· Any big picture comments, reflections, final thoughts?

3) Make any detailed comments (specific parts that are confusing, places to add stories, citation issues etc) on the paper itself using the comment and reviewing tools. (If it is useful use the rubric from Week 08

(Links to an external site.)

to score their paper for them.)

In addition to giving this feedback to your partner, you have one of four options for turning in your feedback.

a) If you commented on a Google doc, submit the link to the paper where we can see your comments back (please make sure that your sharing setting is set to "anyone with this link can view this document" or else we will not be able to open the document and give you credit).

b) Submit a Word doc with the track changes comments so that we can see the feedback that you’re giving back to your partner.

c) Submit your note back to them with the feedback in the text box for this assignment.

d) Submit photos of your handwritten comments back to your partner.