writing
Directions:
Our ebook reading covers three major composers of the late Baroque
era: Vivaldi, J.S. Bach, and Handel.
For our researched Graded Discussion, find one piece of music by one
of these “big three” composers, and one piece of music by a less well
known composer from the same era to compare.
You'll focus your listening, research and writing on just one movement of each of the two pieces.
Main Post: 80 points (approx. 750-800 words)
Your main post must include accurate, clear info for each of the two
tracks:
● Name of each composer. (one of the big three, and one that is
less well known)
● Title of each piece and movement number or title (if from a
multi-movement work)
● Approx. date of composition for each
● Accurate url to each track, that take the reader directly to the specific movement. (you may use Naxos or YouTube. Naxos is much easier to link to the exact track).
● Background info about each piece. Was it composed for a special occasion or for a particular performer or performing
group? Was it unusual for its time, or is it a typical example of the
period and the genre. Create a brief listening map for each track,
with 2-3 three track timings and musical description of what you
think is interesting and important in the music to share with
readers of your post.
● Be sure to include a brief bibliography of your sources at the end of your post! Please make it a list of urls you used that your fellow students can also consult as they read your main post.
Reply post: 20 points (approx. 200 words)
After making your main post, an interactive reply post to the main post of another student is required.
Make a point of carefully listening to the music in the other students post.
Comment on how it compares or contrasts with one or both of the pieces
you selected. Look up and share a link that you feel is relevant to that
student’s post. To earn full credit the reply post must include this level of
evident interaction with the other student's main post.
More info and suggestions:
Your comparison will be most effective if you choose similar genres
(kinds of pieces), and similar movements. For instance, if you select a
violin concerto by Vivaldi for your discussion post, then find a violin
concerto by a less well known Baroque composer. From each of the two
violin concertos, select the same kind of movement - compare the first
movement of the Vivaldi concerto with the first movement of the other
concerto. ( Or, compare the second movement of one with the second
movement of the other.) Another example would be to compare one
movement of a Handel oratorio with a movement of an oratorio or
cantata or mass by a less well known Baroque composer. Ideally,
choose an aria from each, or a chorus from each. The more closely
related the movements are that you choose to compare, the more
evident it is to the reader that you did the research and listening to be
knowledgeable about the music you selected.
Please DON’T try to cover an entire large genre in your main post.
Select just one movement from each piece and say more about less
music. The expectation is that once you’ve selected a movement, you’ll
listen to it many times as you get to know it well and find things to say for
your listening map.
Background info: stay away from long bios of the composers covered in
our ebook. The assumption is that everybody has read that! Bio
information on the less well known composer is more relevant, and you
can compare that to something in the background of the one of the big
three composers. Finding a connection between the composers is
interesting. Or if you prefer, finding a huge contrast between their
backgrounds can make for a nicely researched main post, especially if
the music you choose is carefully compared.
Be very careful about dates. We are considering the Baroque era to be
from 1600-1750. Note that Vivaldi, Bach and Handel lived later in the era
(1685-1750 roughly for all three). If you choose a Baroque composer
who lived earlier than that, you should comment on that difference of a
generation or more. It is easy to find out when a composer lived, and
usually not too hard to get a date for the composition or at least a rough
estimate.
Genre: please do NOT list “classical” as a genre for MUS 301. Genre for
us is the kind of piece. (concerto, trio sonata, oratorio, cantata,
opera…etc). This is a critical concept that most of you understand from
the reading, but every term I see it misused when students copy and
paste info from the streaming music sources. It’s very important at this
point in the term, since we will soon study music from the Classical
period. (1750-1800). It is so important, that 25 points will be subtracted for using the term "classical" improperly in your post.
The piece and movement you choose from Vivaldi, Bach or Handel
should not be the same as one covered in the ebook listening maps.
You can pick something similar but obviously it is expected that you do
some searching and listening that is fresh, not a summary of what
everyone has already read and listened to in the ebook.
Music urls:
Don’t make your reader hunt and scroll to find your music! You’ll
appreciate other students’ accurate urls when you’re working on a reply
post, too. It is extremely important that the url for each piece goes
precisely to the movement you write about in your post. It is not OK to
post an album url to a long opera, oratorio or a full sonata or concerto
and then expect your reader to scroll through. Plus, that implies you
didn't listen much to the piece as you wrote your post.
Using YouTube? If you are comparing an internal movement of a longer
piece, be sure your shared url starts at the right place. It comes up at the
bottom of the dialog box when you get the shareable YouTube url, where
it indicates “start at:” I suggest you create that precise starting point url
before you write your post, and bookmark or save it somewhere for
yourself, since you’ll need to listen and re-listen to the same movement
as you creat your listening map.
Using Naxos? Please note: this is the easier way to search and find specific movements. Make sure to get the static url to exactly the track you intend to write about. That is an extra step, click the “show static url”
button on the left and copy that carefully for your own notes and your
post. Refer to the Fun With Naxos tutorial in our PSU D2L content.
Finding the ‘less well known’ Baroque composer:
Here are a few urls that came up for me when running Google
searches. You’re welcome to find your own. I used search terms such
as Baroque Music Composers, Female Composers Baroque,
Composers Latin America Baroque, and so forth. As with any research,
you'll find other sources or think of better, more specific search terms as
you start to narrow your focus.
This is a good starting point to find some Baroque composers:
https://bachtrack.com/baroque-month-top-six-women-composers-march-
2017
opens in new window
The Baroque era had fine composers living and working in Latin
America. Again, be careful to notice the dates as you do your research.
https://bachtrack.com/nov-2013-baroque-south-america
opens in new window
https://www.talkclassical.com/29012-araujo-zipoli-baroque-music.html
opens in new window
Wikipedia has a thorough list of composers from the Baroque Era, the
link here takes you to the late Baroque.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Baroque_composers#Late_Baroque
_era_composers_(born_1650%E2%80%9399)
opens in new window
At this site for American composers there’s only one that fits our time
period- reminder to be careful about dates.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronological_list_of_American_classical_c
omposers
opens in new window
Here’s a list of Baroque composers sorted by nationality:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Baroque_composers_by_nationalit
y
opens in new window