Art Appreciation DB 7
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
PART 4
THEMES
Copyright © 2015 Thames & Hudson
Introduction
Art about war may: educate, inspire, or shock
Can be rich sources of historical information
Should be treated with caution: artists may manipulate scenes to promote a specific political point of view
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Artists choose the subjects of revolution or war for a variety of reasons: to educate us about the realities of conflict, to inspire us through the depiction of heroism, or to shock us into opposing violence.
2
Documenting the Tragedies of War
Artworks can document an event
Artworks can also distort facts or relay a bias
Even photographs and video can be manipulated to persuade the viewer toward a certain interpretation of an event
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
It is important to assess the art of war with great care and attention as to the context in which the work was created.
3
Artwork: Timothy O’Sullivan, Harvest of Death […]
4.7.1 Timothy O’Sullivan, Harvest of Death, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, July 1863. Photograph. Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.
Timothy O’Sullivan Harvest of Death […]
Field of casualties after Gettysburg, an important Civil War battle
Focus on the individual soldier highlights the human aspect
O’Sullivan sometimes staged scenes; we do not know if he arranged this one
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
American Timothy O’Sullivan (1840–1882) took the famous Civil War photograph Harvest of Death after a day at Gettysburg
Removal of some clothes suggests theft
One often assumes that a photograph can be trusted as an accurate documentation of an event
O’Sullivan was known to rearrange bodies and otherwise alter the setting before taking his photos. We do not know if he arranged the corpses or their clothing in order to heighten the emotional impact of this powerful image.
If we knew he had staged the scene in some way, would we doubt the truth of the tragedy he represents?
5
Artwork: Nick Ut, Vietnamese Girl Kim Phuc Running […]
4.7.2 Nick Ut, Vietnamese Girl Kim Phuc Running after Napalm Attack, June 8, 1972. Photograph
Nick Ut, Vietnamese Girl Kim Phuc Running after Napalm Attack
Photograph depicts children fleeing after a napalm attack on their village
Made many Americans question US involvement in the Vietnam War
Ut’s disapproval of the war influenced the way he composed his image
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
The photograph by the Vietnamese Nick Ut (b. 1951) of children running from their village in Vietnam after a napalm attack was so shocking that some, including the U.S. president Richard Nixon, questioned its authenticity when it appeared in newspapers on June 12, 1972
Because of the fame of the photograph, money poured in to save her
She underwent seventeen surgical operations and later emigrated to Canada
Nick Ut became “Uncle Nick” to the little girl and the two have remained in close contact throughout their lives
Although this photograph shows the suffering of a small group of people, it symbolizes for many the tragedy of the entire Vietnam War
7
Artwork: Otto Dix, The War
4.7.3 Otto Dix, The War, 1929–32. Oil and tempera on wood, central panel 80¼ × 80¼”, side panels 80¼ × 40⅛”, bottom panel (predella) 23⅝ × 80¼”. Staatliche Kunstsammlungen, Gemäldegalerie Neue Meister, Dresden, Germany
Otto Dix, The War
Otto Dix fought in World War I
Central panel: death, destruction
Left: soldiers prepared for battle
Right: self-portrait, wounded soldier
Predella: soldier lying in a trench, sleeping or dead
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
German painter Otto Dix (1891–1969), who fought in World War I, recorded the horrors he witnessed in the painted triptych The War
Triptych, traditionally used for religious scenes, elevates his subject
9
Portal Artwork: Degenerate Art
4.8.7 Photograph of the Nazi-curated traveling exhibition “Degenerate Art” (“Enkartete Kunst”) at its first stop at the Hofgarten, Munich, Germany, 1937
Otto Dix, along with other German Expressionists, would later be vilified by the Nazis for his criticism of WWI
10
Warriors and Battle Scenes
Artists record the bravery of warriors, both their successes and defeats
Artworks can be valuable records of critical historical moments
Significance of certain battles
Accurate studies of weapons and uniforms
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
11
Artwork: Palette of Narmer
4.7.4a (front) and 4.7.4b (back) Palette of Narmer, Early Dynastic Period, Egypt, c. 2950–2775 BCE. Green schist, 25¼ × 16⅝”. Egyptian Museum, Cairo, Egypt
Palette of Narmer
Shows unification of Upper and Lower Egypt by the first pharaoh, Narmer
Palettes were used to grind pigment that was painted around the eyes as sun protection
Hierarchical scale: Narmer is larger, indicating his importance
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
One of the earliest surviving ancient Egyptian artworks
Before the reign of Narmer, Egypt was divided into Lower Egypt (in the more fertile south) and Upper Egypt (to the south)
The intertwining of the fantastical long-necked creatures in the third register embodies the unification of Upper and Lower Egypt
13
Artwork: Detail of the Battle of Hastings, Bayeux Tapestry
4.7.5 Detail of the Battle of Hastings, Bayeux Tapestry, c. 1066–82. Linen with wool, 275’ long. Bayeux Tapestry Museum,
Bayeux, France
Battle of Hastings, Bayeux Tapestry
275-foot-long embroidery
Records events surrounding the Battle of Hastings (1066)
Made by skilled women
Took more than 10 years to make
Embroidery process creates clearly delineated figures
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
The Normans, led by William the Conqueror, seized control of England from the Anglo-Saxons
It was probably commissioned by William’s brother Odo, the Bishop of Bayeux in France, shortly after the Norman victory
More than six hundred men, but only three women, are shown in the fifty scenes on the tapestry
Each figure is given a border, which is filled in with stitches running in the opposite direction to the rest of the embroidery, and then outlined in boldly contrasting colors
This process creates a flat sense of space (to guide the viewer in a horizontal direction), and, through repeated patterns, a sense of overall rhythm
15
Artwork: Night Attack on the Sanjo Palace
4.7.6 Night Attack on the Sanjo Palace, from Heiji Monogatari, Kamakura period, late 13th century. Hand scroll, ink and color on paper, 16⅛” × 22’11¼” (whole scroll). Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, Massachusetts
Night Attack on the Sanjo Palace
23-foot-long scroll employs isometric perspective from a bird’s-eye view
Scene depicts the burning of the palace by samurai warriors; emperor captured by opposing clans
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
In the short-lived Heiji era (1159–60) several clans fought for control of Kyoto, the historical capital of Japan
From the Tale of the Heiji Rebellion, a Japanese war epic presented in 5 painted scrolls
This scene shows the burning of the palace by samurai warriors of the Fujiwara and Minamoto clans during the raid in which they captured the emperor Nijo
Soon afterward, another clan, the Taira, rescued the emperor and regained control of Kyoto
The story in the scroll is read from right to left
The artist guides the viewer in that direction using the diagonal lines of the buildings, layering the figures, and the movement of the billowing smoke
Isometric perspective = a system using diagonal parallel lines to communicate depth
Bird’s-eye view = an artistic technique in which a scene or suject is presented from some point above it
17
Compare Bayeux Tapestry and Heiji Monogatari scroll
Multiple scenes meant to be viewed slowly, unravel over time
Long horizontal formats
Celebrate the victors
Representative of the visual style of each period
Detailed and delineated armor and weapons
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
The Japanese samurai are shown with lengthy bows and arching swords
The soldiers of the Bayeux tapestry wear patterned armor and conical helmets, and carry broadswords, kite-shaped shields, and spears
18
Artwork: Tula warrior columns
4.7.7 Tula warrior columns, 900–1000 CE. Basalt, height 15–20’. Tula, Hidalgo, Mexico
Tula warrior columns
Toltec capital of Tula believed to have been largest city in Mexico in 1000 ce
Warrior columns held up the roof of a temple, which no longer survives
Figures show how a Toltec warrior would have looked
They lived in a time of warfare
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Little is known of the Toltec people of Mexico
What we know of the Toltec can be learnt from the legends of later cultures, such as the Aztecs, who often sought to demonstrate an ancestral link with the Toltec
The carved warriors stood high above the city, painted in bright colors
20
Artwork: Benin plaque with warrior and attendants
4.7.8 Benin plaque with
warrior and attendants,
16th–17th century. Brass,
height 18¾”. Metropolitan
Museum of Art, New York
Benin plaque with warrior and attendants
Obas (kings) of Benin were military and spiritual leaders
Commissioned brass artworks to reflect their power; covered the palace
Central figure is a high-ranking chief
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Benin was a West African state that was at its height between 1450 and 1700
Obas commissioned hundreds of artworks, including plaques, to cover the royal palace, many of which depict warriors who followed the orders of the oba
The chief is identified by the ceremonial sword he carries in his left hand, and his elaborate helmet. He is also shown in higher relief than the other figures
He wears a leopard-tooth necklace
Leopards, known for their power and speed, were a symbol of the oba
High relief = a carved panel where the figures project with a great deal of depth from the background
22
The Artist’s Response to War
Artists sometimes create artworks attempting to convey personal experience of war
Cathartic exercise, releasing emotion
Inspires awareness of the realities of war
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
23
Artwork: Francisco Goya, The Third of May, 1808
4.7.9 Francisco Goya, The Third of May, 1808, 1814. Oil on canvas, 8’4⅜” × 11’3⅞”. Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid, Spain
Goya, The Third of May, 1808
Documents Napoleon’s army killing Spanish citizens
Emphasis on one figure
Color
Light
Line
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
The Spanish War of Independence (1808–14) was known for its guerrilla fighting and for the heroism of the civilian population
The Third of May, 1808 documents the French emperor Napoleon’s troops executing Spanish citizens during the French occupation of Madrid in 1808
The painting was commissioned in 1813 by the Spanish king Ferdinand VII to memorialize the event
25
Artwork: Pablo Picasso, Guernica
4.7.10 Pablo Picasso, Guernica, 1937. Oil on canvas, 11’5½” × 25’5¾”. Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofia, Madrid, Spain
Pablo Picasso, Guernica
Franco allowed bombs to be tested on Guernica, a town in Spain
1,000 civilians died in three hours
Picasso did not discuss the work, accepting multiple interpretations
Picasso and the painting would not return to Spain while Franco ruled
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
The attack on Guernica was carried out on April 26, 1937
News of the attack quickly spread to Paris, where Picasso read stories and saw photographs of the devastation
The painting is black, gray, and white, perhaps because Picasso associated the attack with black-and-white newspaper photographs
Expressive faces with distorted necks scream and cry in despair
The bull, often associated with the violence of Spanish bullfighting, is seen by many as a symbol of Franco
Picasso exhibited this large protest statement at the Spanish Pavilion during the 1937 World’s Fair in Paris, France
27
Artwork: Anselm Kiefer, Breaking of the Vessels
4.7.11 Anselm Kiefer, Breaking of the Vessels, 1990. Lead, iron, glass, copper wire, charcoal, and Aquatec, 12’5” × 27’5½” × 17’. St. Louis Art Museum, Missouri
Anselm Kiefer, Breaking of the Vessels
Kiefer’s artworks force viewers to consider horrors of the Nazi regime
Conveys the loss of life and destruction of knowledge during the Holocaust
Shattered glass recalls Kristallnacht
References to Kabbalah, collection of Jewish mystical writings
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Contemporary German artist Anselm Kiefer (b. 1945) was born in Germany just months before World War II ended and grew up in a society ashamed of its past
His artworks force viewers to acknowledge the horrors of the Nazi regime that ruled Germany from 1933 until 1945
Imposing, 27-foot-tall artwork
Heavy lead books appear to be scorched, just like the human beings (also holders of knowledge) who were incinerated in concentration camps
Kristallnacht (Night of the Broken Glass) refers to the night when the Nazis destroyed hundreds of Jewish stores and synagogues in 1938
The words “Ain-Sof,” which mean the infinite presence of God, are written on the arched piece of glass above the bookshelf
Ten lead labels are placed around and on the bookshelf; these represent the ten vessels containing the essence of God as described in the Kabbalah
29
Artwork: Ganzeer, Tanks vs. Bike
4.7.12 Ganzeer, Tanks vs. Bike, with graffiti by Sad Panda, 2011. Cairo, Egypt
Ganzeer, Tanks vs. Bike
Egyptian artist, known for graffiti art criticizing ruling military officials
Tank points its gun at an Egyptian boy on a bike, balancing a tray of bread
Collaborative: other street artists have added to the image
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Egyptian artist Mohamad Fahmy, known as Ganzeer, became internationally famous for his graffiti art criticizing the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF), a council of senior military officials that has ruled his country since the Egyptian Revolution in February 2011
Ganzeer was assisted by a team of volunteers to create the stencils for this work
Later, the artist known as Sad Panda added his trademark figure behind the biker
Another artist, Khaled, painted bodies being crushed under the tank
This recorded an actual event that took place in October 2011, when a group of peaceful civilians, protesting the demolition of a church, were attacked by security forces and the army
Graffiti and other street art has been a major form of protest throughout the uprisings against governments across the Middle East and North Africa, known as the Arab Spring
31
Artwork: Wafaa Bilal, Domestic Tension
4.7.13 Wafaa Bilal, Domestic Tension, 2007. Flatfile Gallery, Chicago, Illinois
Wafaa Bilal, Domestic Tension
Iraqi-born artist
Provocative works raise awareness about US–Iraq conflicts
Brother killed by an American bomb
Interactive performance: artist enclosed in gallery for one month; fired at by a paint gun controlled by anyone over the Internet
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
Perspectives on Art:
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Artist was inspired by a TV news segment about a soldier in Colorado remotely dropping bombs on Iraq
Highlighted the anonymous and detached nature of this current war, and the complete disconnect between the comfort zone here in the U.S. and the conflict zone in Iraq
Bilal wanted to create a physical impact in viewers by enabling them to identify with the physical effect on his body
The project generated worldwide attention, with more than 60,000 shots taken and 80 million hits to the website from 137 countries
33
Remembrance and Memorials
Art can acknowledge historical tragedies in the hope that events will not be repeated
Memorials may address the history of one or many
Designed to comfort and heal
Statements of tragedy, can fuel uprisings
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
34
Artwork: Maya Lin, Vietnam Veterans Memorial
4.7.14a Maya Lin, Vietnam Veterans Memorial, Washington, D.C., 1981–83. Granite, each wing 246’ long, height 10’1” at highest point
4.7.14b Maya Lin, detail of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial: visitors interacting with the wall
Maya Lin, Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Polished black granite, V-shaped wall descends and ascends into the earth
Symbolizes a wound caused by the conflict, but also healing
Names carved in order of death date
Some veterans said design reflected a condemnation of the war
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
The competition to design the monument—which drew more than 1,400 submissions—was won by a 21-year-old American of Chinese descent studying architecture at Yale University, Maya Lin (b. 1959)
The surface is polished because, the artist explained, “the point is to see yourself reflected in the names”
The walls are aligned toward two other monuments, the Washington Monument and the Lincoln Memorial, in order to acknowledge the significance of the Vietnam War to American history
Some veterans thought that rather than uplifting and instilling pride in the soldiers who fought, the monument’s descent into the ground symbolized a moral criticism both of the war and its soldiers
In response to these protests, a bronze sculpture of three soldiers, more traditional in style, was later placed a short distance from the wall
36
Memorial and Controversy: Maya Lin’s Vietnam Veterans Memorial
To find out more about Maya Lin’s response to the Vietnam war and her work’s impact on the public, watch:
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Video:
Artwork: Michael Arad and Peter Walker, 9/11 Memorial
4.7.15a Michael Arad and Peter Walker, 9/11 Memorial, New York. Photo taken 28 July 2011
4.7.15b Michael Arad and Peter Walker, National September 11 Memorial & Museum, New York
Michael Arad and Peter Walker, 9/11 Memorial
Dedicated 10 years after the 9/11 attacks
Square footprints of the fallen towers are now filled with waterfalls that represent the huge loss of life (2,977 people)
Includes the 9/11 Memorial Museum
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts, Third Edition, Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Someare still buried under the site, making it sacred ground in the minds of some. Critics say that because of this, it is therefore inappropriate as a site for a gift shop, admission prices, or gawkers
The edges of the squares are covered with bronze plaques inscribed with the names of the 2,977 who were killed, including those on the hijacked flights on 9/11, those at the Pentagon, and the rescuers who tried to help people escape, as well as victims of the World Trade Center bombing in 1993
39
Portal Artwork: Here is New York
2.8.17 Here Is New York: A Democracy of Photographs, exhibition at the New York Historical Society, September 2007
Here is New York... is an installation of photographs taken by people who recorded what they saw on 9/11
40
Chapter 4.7 Copyright Information
This concludes the PowerPoint slide set for Chapter 4.7
Gateways to Art: Understanding the Visual Arts
Third Edition
By Debra J. DeWitte, Ralph M. Larmann, and M. Kathryn Shields
Copyright © 2015 Thames & Hudson
PowerPoints developed by CreativeMyndz Multimedia Studios
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution
Picture Credits for Chapter 4.7
4.7.1 Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. Prints & Photographs Division, LC-B8184-7964-A
4.7.2 Nick Ut/AP/Press Association Images
4.7.3 © DACS 2018
4.7.4a Egyptian Museum, Cairo
4.7.4b Egyptian Museum, Cairo
4.7.5 Centre Guillaume le Conquérant, Bayeux
4.7.6 Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, Fenollosa-Weld Collection
4.7.7 Photograph Luidger
4.7.8 Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Klaus G. Perls, 1990, 1990.332
4.7.9 Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid
4.7.10 © Succession Picasso/DACS, London 2018
4.7.11 © Anselm Kiefer
4.7.12 Courtesy the artists. Photo JoAnne Pollonais
4.7.13 Courtesy the artist
4.7.14a Stock Connection/SuperStock RM/Diomedia
4.7.14b Zuma Press/ Diomedia
4.7.15a Drew Angerer/Getty Images
4.7.15b Angelo Hornak/Alamy Stock Photo
PowerPoints developed by CreativeMyndz Multimedia Studios
PART 4
THEMES
Chapter 4.7 Art, War, and Revolution