The value of dialogue
The Value of Dialogue Scoring Guide
|
CRITERIA |
NON-PERFORMANCE |
BASIC |
PROFICIENT |
DISTINGUISHED |
|
Analyze the value of dialogue in helping teams learn and change. |
Does not describe the value of dialogue in helping teams learn and change. |
Describes the value of dialogue in helping teams learn and change. |
Analyzes the value of dialogue in helping teams learn and change. |
Analyzes the value of dialogue in helping teams learn and change, supporting analysis with theory or real-world examples. |
|
Describe the ground rules required to reach conversational level in a dialogue. |
Does not describe the ground rules. |
Describes the ground rules but does not connect ground rules to the requirements needed to reach conversational level in a dialogue. |
Describes the ground rules required to reach conversational level in a dialogue. |
Analyzes the ground rules required to reach conversational level in a dialogue, supporting the analysis with relevant theory and real-world examples. |
|
Analyze learning related to designing an effective dialogue session. |
Does not describe learning related to designing an effective dialogue session. |
Describes learning related to designing an effective dialogue session. |
Analyzes learning related to designing an effective dialogue session. |
Analyzes learning related to designing an effective dialogue session and provides recommendations for improving the design. |
|
Analyze the ease or difficulty of conversing in a team dialogue session, including the dangers and obstacles. |
Does not describe the ease or difficulty of conversing in a team dialogue session, or the dangers and obstacles. |
Describes the ease or difficulty of conversing in a team dialogue session, or the dangers and obstacles, but not both. |
Analyzes the ease or difficulty of conversing in a team dialogue session, including the dangers and obstacles. |
Analyzes the ease or difficulty of conversing in a team dialogue session, including the dangers and obstacles, providing real-world examples. |
|
Define and compare debate, discussion, and dialogue. |
Does not define or compare debate, discussion, or dialogue. |
Defines and compares debate, discussion, or dialogue, but not all three. |
Defines and compares debate, discussion, and dialogue. |
Defines and compares debate, discussion, and dialogue; and provides real-world examples of each. |