Leisure Tourism: Theory And Application

profileBlanca14
TheSoloTouristandTheTourGroup.pptx

The Rise in Solo Lifestyle

90% of UK adults are comfortable in their own company (OnePoll, 2106)

40% of UK adults would go to the pub alone (OnePoll, 2016)

A third would happily go out for a meal alone (OnePoll, 2016)

The stigma of doing things alone is lessening

Capacity to be alone is a sign of maturity (Storr, 1997)

People living alone make up 28% of all US households (Klinenberg, 2014)

Being alone (or solo activities) is seen by many as a positive lifestyle (both by solo’s themselves and non-solos – jealousy/admiration?!) (Ye-Jin, 2017)

Important to note that solo lifestyle is not always through choice (Putman, 2001)

Impact on social media on solo lifestyle? – Has it brought people together OR pulled them apart?

Does social media make solitary activity easier? Or does it increase the desire for solitary activity?

What is Solo Travel?

If we say “a solo activity is one performed alone without assistance”, is solo travel possible?

This question will be the focus of some of the tutorial

The Rise in Solo Travel

Many travel companies reporting large increases in solo travel bookings (Travelmarketreport, 2014)

Impact on the industry?

Why do people travel alone? (Will discuss in tutorial)

Solo in a group? (will look at in “Tour Group” focus below)

Markets :-

Single retirees

Female travellers

Backpackers? (depends on what we mean by “solo”)

Those at an advanced stage of their “Travel Career?” (Pearce & Lee, 2005)

MINTEL Report; Solo Holidays UK, October 2017 – Key Findings

% Finding % Finding
15% of adults take solo holidays 63% Meeting people with similar interests was important
69% of solo travellers are single people 36% Shared dining was important
36% Of one person households go solo 85% You are free to do your own thing more when travelling on your own
48% gave reason as “I just like going on holiday on my own” 49% Going on holiday on your own can feel lonely at times
25% gave reason as “friends did not/could not go” (20% for family/partner) 45% It’s easier to make new friends when holidaying on your own
20% gave reason as “I have different interests/holiday preferences to my family/partner 33% It can feel more stressful holidaying on your own (e.g. safety, hassle)
49% Have taken a solo city break in last 5 years (why is this type most popular?) 63% You can have more of an adventure travelling on your own

MINTEL Report; Solo Holidays UK, October 2017 – Key Findings

Highlights concept of “pure solo travel”

Indicates that females more interested than males in idea of solo travel – but less likely to have travelled/will travel solo

Those who have been in relationship/married longer are more likely to take a solo holiday than those who have been in relationship/married for a shorter period

In response to how confident you would be doing the following activities on your own:-

71% going to the cinema

62% going on holiday in the UK

59% eating out in a restaurant

50% going on holiday abroad (this was the lowest result of 8 activities)

Motivators and Inhibitors to Solo Travel

Will form part of tutorial

Solo Travel: A Desire for Solitude or (un)Controlled Companionship?

Very little currently written on solo travel – most from a gender perspective

Offers anonymity – is this still the case with social media so prevalent?

Does the solo traveller become a subject of the “tourist gaze?” (Urry and Larssen, 2011)

How does the solo tourist link with Goffman theory of performance?

Possible to experience solitude in crowds (a mental rather than physical state)

Solitude as the positive opposite of loneliness?

An exploratory study of links between individuals’ perceptions of solo tourism and their desires for social interaction and solitude – Literature Review (Some Aspects)

Jordan & Gibson (2005) comment on the unwanted gaze of others in their study of solo women travellers, from a perception of being judged as “sad or lonely” to receiving overtly unwanted sexual attention.

Poria (2006) highlights that tourists can be conscious of others around them and adapt their behaviour accordingly.

Ratner & Hamilton (2015) raised the prospect that an individual may be reluctant to partake in a solitary activity if it was public and they ran the perceived risk of being observed and judged.

It is possible to consider a state of solitude as existing when one is in the presence of others but unobserved (Long & Averill, 2003; Detrixhe et al, 2014).

Those engaging in solo activities can often be stigmatised as lonely (Ratner & Hamilton, 2015)

Can be argued that such individuals are in fact displaying a developed sense of self as they are not in search of immediate social reinforcement (Long et al, 2006)

Velleman (2013) posits that enjoying solitude involves having awareness of enjoying one’s own company. Conscious effort to entertain oneself by keeping busy actually is a distraction from solitude.

There is an evidencable increase in solo lifestyle choices, particularly living alone (Klinenberg, 2012)

Budgeon (2008) notes the importance of choice in validating and embracing singleness.

A distinction must be made between loneliness and solitude, (Goodwin & Lockshin, 1992)

Wang (2006) formalised twenty types of solitude experience, rating them on a scale of desirability (includes self discovery; freedom; boredom and alienation)

It is a reasonable assumption that solo tourists seek different types of solitude perhaps depending on their individual personality and desires

An exploratory study of links between individuals’ perceptions of solo tourism and their desires for social interaction and solitude – Findings & Discussion (Some Aspects)

strongly suggests that a significant majority of individual’s desire some degree of social interaction, no matter the level of solitude they prefer.

The study did not aim to study the degree of solitude in an individuals’ life; rather the degree of solitude they desired.

See paper title for aim of the research

Findings led to a proposed typology of individual’s based on their level of desire for both solitude and social interaction

Next step will be to test this typology by interviewing those who have experience of solo tourism

Proposed Typology Based on Individuals’ Desire for both Solitude and Social Interaction

Social Seekers Do enjoy solitude but only for short periods Associated solitude with negative words (difficult, bored, get lonely etc) It is possible that those such as social seekers are led towards negative thoughts if they lack the capacity to enjoy solitude. (Harris, 2017) Broadly positive views of solo tourists (brave etc) but some negative (lonely, sad, pointless) Negative views perhaps linked to age of respondents (Deresiewicz (2009) previously claimed that young people today cannot see the purpose of having time alone. ) Very unlikely to seek a solo tourism experience Concern over being lonely, nobody to share experience with, unable to speak to new people (Epley and Schroeder (2014) suggest that people struggle to engage with strangers as they believe that others are less keen to connect socially than they themselves are. Like idea of not compromising (shared with respondents across all populated areas of typology) Sociable Loners Exactly half (of 100) respondents in this segment Possible that individuals within this grouping experience solitude positively as proposed by Lay et al (2019) A frequent comment in this study shared between both “social seekers” and “social loners” was the opportunity to meet other people as a solo tourist, which links with previous research (Laesser, Beritelli and Bieger,2008; Bianchi, 2016). Coplan, Ooi and Baldwin (2019) have previously made the case that the lack of a strong desire for social interaction does not necessarily also indicate a preference for solitude. This current research indicates the same may be true for those who do desire social interaction.
Social Ghosts It is not a surprise that no respondent generally does not significantly desire either solitude or social interaction. This finding does indicate the likely importance of situational context in the study of desire of social interaction and solitude. it is possible to visualise a person who enjoys or seeks not to be alone and also desires no social interaction at the same time, in certain circumstances. Consider the individual who is working on an academic paper but prefers to work in a public area such as a coffee shop rather than enclosed in their office. This individual is making an effort to avoid solitude but is also likely to reject any attempt at social interaction from fellow patrons. Cramer and Lake (1998). Hwang, Shin and Mattila (2018) suggest that a solo diner for example may find the social connectedness they seek by eating in proximity of other diners who are together as a group. Isolating Loners This segment is where a limited number (16%) of participants placed themselves. This grouping displayed a desire for solitude and also a lack of desire for social interaction. This might include those who are extremely socially anxious and seek solitude in order to avoid social interaction. However, it might also include those who feel no great need for social interaction as they have a developed sense of self which does not require social reinforcement (Larson, 2016). Views such as “I greatly enjoy solitude;” “I find interactions difficult and exhausting”; “I love being alone and enjoy my own company”; “I often crave quiet times alone.” Several respondents within this segment stated they would “struggle” with social interaction with people they did not know during a solo tourism experience.

Travelling in a Tour Group

Appealing to some solo travellers – why?

Is a solo traveller on a tour group what is meant by “non-pure solo travel?” (An alternative to “pure solo travel” as mentioned by Mintel)

Important to note vast differences in “type” of tour group?

Differ in size, target market, behaviour, experience, level of participation, level of immersion, level/type of interaction (within group and with hosts), level of interest in the destination/subject of tour (i.e. specialist through to generalist)

Better or worse for the environment and host population than independent travellers?

Opportunity to meet new people – like minded people?

Importance of group dynamics

As with any tourism experience, managing expectations is important aspect

Experience (and behaviour) heavily linked to previous experience

Proposed Model of Tour Group Experience & Behaviour

C.Leith

Previous Experience & Expectations

Experience of Tour

Behaviour on Tour

Experience of Others on Tour

Others Behaviour on Tour

The Oz Parable..

Uncontrolled Companionship

Controlled Companionship

What is “The Tour Guide”

Information provider

Source of knowledge

Mentor

Surrogate Parent

Leader

Mediator

Culture Broker

Entertainer

Communicator

Conflict Resolver

Organiser

Problem Solver

Decision Maker

Facilitator of Social Bonding

Translator

A fundamental element of the experience (for better or for worse)

This is a list from a number of pieces of research collated in Curtin (2010)

Depending on the circumstances (and tour) some will be more important that others.

Also, the list is not exhaustive

Is the tour guide less important (and less desired now) due to rise in technology and the wish for individual experiences?

Tour Group Examples

Intrepid Travel

Evan Evans Tours - London Tours

Withlocals

Dragoman Overland

References….

Bianchi, C. (2016) “Solo Holiday Travellers: Motivators and Drivers of Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction”, International Journal of Tourism Research, Vol 18, No.2, pp 197 – 208.

Bowie, D., & Chang, J.C., (2005). Tourist satisfaction: A view from a mixed international guided package tour. Journal of Vacation Marketing. Vol 11(4).

Budgeon, S. (2008) “Couple Culture and the Production of Singleness”, Sexualities, Vol 11, No. 3, pp 301 – 325.

Coplan, R.J., Ooi,L.L., and Baldwin,D. (2019) “Does it matter when we want to be alone? Exploring developmental timing effects in the implications of unsociability”, New Ideas in Psychology, Vol 53, pp 47 – 57.

Cramer, K.M. and Lake, R.P. (1998) “The Preference For solitude Scale: Psychometric Properties And Factor Structure”, Personality and Individual Differences, Vol 24. No 2, pp 193 – 199.

Curtin.S., (2010). Managing the Wildlife Tourism Experience: The Importance of Tour Leaders. International Journal of Tourism Research. 12. pg.219-236.

Deresiewicz, W. (2009) “The End of Solitude”, The Chronical of Higher Education

Detrixhe, J.J., Samstag, L.W., Penn, L.S. and Wong, P.S. (2014) “A Lonely Idea: Solitude’s Separation From Psychological Research And Theory”, Contemporary Psychoanalysis, Vol 50, No. 3, pp 310-311.

Epley, N. and Schroeder, J. (2014) “Mistakenly Seeking Solitude”, Journal of Experimental Psychology, Vol 143, No. 5, pp 1980 – 1999.

Goodwin, C. and Lockshin, L. (1992) “The Solo Consumer: Unique Opportunity for the Service Marketer”, Journal of Services Marketing, Vol 6, No. 3, pp 27 – 36.

Harris.M. (2015). The End of Absence: Reclaiming What We’ve Lost In A World of Constant Connection. Current. New York.

Hwang, Y.H., Shin, J. and Mattila, A.S. (2018) “So private, yet so public: The impact of spatial distance, other diners, and power on solo dining experiences”, Journal of Business Research, Vol 92, pp 36 – 47.

Jordan, F. and Gibson. H. (2005) “We’re Not Stupid…But We’ll Not Stay Home either: Experiences Of solo Women Travelers”, Tourism Review International, Vol 9, pp 195 – 211.

Klinenberg.E. (2014)., Going Solo: The Extraordinary Rise and surprising Appeal of Living Alone. Duckworth Overlook. London.

Kmet, M., (2014). Going it Alone: Solo Travel is Growing. [online]. Available from: http://www.travelmarketreport.com/articles/Going-it-Alone-Solo-Travel-is-Growing. [Accessed 4 December 2017].

Lay, J.C., Pauly, T., Graf, P., and Biesanz.J.C. (2019) “By myself and liking it? Predictors of distinct types of solitude experiences in daily life”, Journal of Personality, Vol 87, pp 633 – 647.

References….

Laesser, C., Beritelli, P., and Bieger,T. (2008). “Solo Travel: Explorative insights from a mature market (Switzerland)”, Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol 15, no. 3, pp 217 – 227.

Larson, R.W. (1990) “The Solitary Side of Life: An Examination of the Time People Spend Alone from Childhood to Old Age”, Developmental Review, Vol 10, pp 155 – 183.

Leith, C. (2020) An exploratory study of links between individuals’ perceptions of solo tourism and their desires for social interaction and solitude, International Conference on Tourism Research, pp 132-138.

Long, C.R. and Averill, J.R. (2003) “Solitude: An Exploration of Benefits of Being Alone”, Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, Vol 33, No.1, pp 21 – 44.

Long, C.R., Seburn, M., Averill, J.R. and More, T.A. (2003) “Solitude Experiences: Varieties, Settings, and Individual Differences”, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, Vol 29, No. 5, pp 578-583.

OnePoll., (2016). Intrepid Travel Infographic: Solitary Existence. [online]. Available from http://www.onepoll.com/project/intrepid-travel-infographic-solitary-existence [Accessed 4 December 2017].

Pearce, P, L. and Lee, U, I. (2005). Developing the Travel Career Approach to Tourist Motivation. Journal of Travel Research. 43(3), 226-237

Poria, Y. (2006) “Tourism and spaces of anonymity: An Israeli lesbian woman’s travel experience”, Tourism, Vol 54, No 1, pp 33 – 42.

Putman.R.D., (2001). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. Simon and Schuster Ltd, New York.

Ratner, R.K. and Hamilton, R.W. (2015) “Inhibited from Bowling Alone”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol 42, pp 266 – 283.

Storr.A., (1997). Solitude. Harper Collins. London.

Urry.J. & Larsen.J. (2011). The Tourist Gaze 3.0. Sage.London.

Velleman, J.D. (2013) “Sociality and solitude”, Philosophical Explorations, Vol 16, No. 3, pp 324 – 335.

Wang, J., Zhu, R., and Shiv,B. (2012) “The Lonely Consumer: Loner or Conformer?”, Journal of Consumer Research, Vol 38, pp 1116 – 1129.

Worthington, J., MINTEL., (2017)., Solo Holidays UK, Mintel Group Ltd.

Ye-jin, K., Asia Today., (2017). Japan Evolving into “Ohitorisama” Nation. [online]. Available from: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/asiatoday/japan-evolving-into-ohito_b_13144474.html [Accessed 4 December 2017].