TEMPLATESAM5.docx

Literature Matrix Template

Topic: Differentiated Instruction (DI)

Instructions

APA Citation

Purpose

Problem

RQs

Methodology

Findings

Implications

For this assignment, you will locate and read four articles with at least two being quantitative research articles that are related to your topic of interest. Due Day 7 of Module 4.

Hayden, S. M., Gubbins, E. J., Cody, R. A., & Boldt, G. T. (2024). Teachers’ perceptions of differentiation following a math curriculum implementation study. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 47(1), 3–29. https://doi.org/10.1177/01623532231215092

To explore teachers’ perceptions of differentiation after they used professional learning and a pre-differentiated, tiered, enriched Grade 3 mathematics curriculum.

Teachers often say they lack the time, knowledge and materials to differentiate, and little is known about what hinders them even when they value it and have support.

What were teachers’ perceptions of differentiation following implementation of a Grade 3 math unit on algebraic thinking, multiplication, and division?

Qualitative study of Grade 3 teachers in the US who took part in a larger multi-state curriculum study (Thinking Like Mathematicians). Teachers received targeted professional learning and the differentiated curriculum materials.

According to a secondary summary, data included pre- and post-surveys, observations, teacher logs and post-implementation interviews, with the findings built mainly on teacher interviews. I could access only the abstract, not the full text, so sample size and coding details still need to be checked.

Teachers reported a better understanding of why differentiation matters and how to differentiate content, and noticed differences in student engagement. They also reported barriers (insufficient time and resources, and district curriculum that was not sufficient by itself), despite positive views.

Critique (from available information): teachers volunteered and may already have been interested in improving math instruction; findings are perceptions, not student outcomes.

Suggests ready-made differentiated materials plus professional learning can build teachers’ understanding of differentiation. However, time and resources remain barriers. This is useful when planning realistic supports for differentiation in my own setting.

Haymon, C., & Wilson, A. (2020). Differentiated reading instruction with technology for advanced middle school students’ reading achievement. Journal of Educational Research and Practice, 10, 70–89. https://doi.org/10.5590/JERAP.2020.10.1.05

To evaluate whether Achieve 3000, a technology-based program for differentiating reading instruction, improved Lexile reading growth for advanced Grade 6–8 students.

Advanced middle school readers at one Tennessee school were stagnant or declining on state reading tests. The school adopted the program without a formal check of its effectiveness, and advanced learners are often overlooked in accountability systems.

RQ1: Does technology-enhanced differentiated instruction through Achieve 3000 impact Lexile growth reading scores for advanced Grade 6–8 students?

RQ2: Does Lexile growth differ by grade level?

Quantitative, ex post facto quasi-experimental pre-test/post-test design with no comparison group.

N = 120 advanced learners (Grades 6–8) at one Tennessee middle school; archived LevelSet Lexile scores from September 2017 to June 2018. Students used the program about 4 hours per month.

Analysis: paired-samples t test (with and without one outlier) and a 2 × 3 mixed-design ANOVA (time × grade).

Lexile scores rose from M = 1,307.67 to 1,492.67 (about +185 points), t(119) = 18.69, p < .001. Gains were larger than the 75–100 points the vendor expects. Grade 6 gained most (about +280), Grade 7 least (about +125), with a significant time-by-grade interaction, F(2, 116) = 38.04.

Critique: no control group, so maturation, practice effects and teacher differences cannot be ruled out; one school and one year; the benchmark for expected growth comes from the program vendor; scores near the 1,600 ceiling; and the study shows the program is associated with growth, not that differentiation caused it.

Shows an example of using leveled, individualized reading material to extend advanced learners, a group often neglected in differentiation. The design limits mean I treat it as suggestive evidence for technology-supported differentiation, not proof.

Kenney, A. W., Dulong Langley, S., Hemmler, V., Callahan, C. M., Gubbins, E. J., & Siegle, D. (2024). Different or differentiated? Recoupling policy and practice in an era of accountability. Educational Policy, 38(1), 134–160. https://doi.org/10.1177/08959048231153612

To investigate how teachers in one US district turned a mandated daily “DI time” policy into classroom practice in a high-stakes testing environment.

Districts mandate differentiated instruction, but policies rarely say how to do it, and accountability pressure may lead teachers to reinterpret differentiation as something easier.

RQ1: Do teachers report enacting classroom practices to align with a district policy of differentiated instruction time?

RQ2: Do the reported practices couple with the definition of differentiation?

Qualitative analysis of interview data from a larger mixed-methods study of gifted programming. Large urban US district (150+ elementary schools, mostly Black and Latin students, about 70% free or reduced-price lunch). 15 school site visits (March–December 2018); 87 semi-structured teacher interviews with Grade 4-5 gifted and general education math and reading teachers. 68 teachers talked about differentiation; the analysis centers on 37 whose descriptions did not match the disciplinary definition.

Coded inductively and deductively in Dedoose, with a shared codebook and inter-rater reliability. Framed by organizational theory (decoupling and recoupling).

Teachers used DI time mainly for rotating centers and for remediation or re-teaching small groups, while advanced students did the same tasks or independent work. Challenge for advanced learners was “an afterthought.” Teachers appeared to believe they were following the policy, but they were providing different, not differentiated, instruction, shaped by pacing guides and test pressure.

Critique: volunteer schools and teachers, high-poverty setting only, interviews without matching observations, and a focus on the teachers who did not differentiate, so it cannot show how common this is.

Warns that grouping, centers or a scheduled DI block are not the same as true differentiation of content, process and product, and that advanced learners can be overlooked. It supports planning differentiation for all levels and protecting time and support for it.

Unal, A., Unal, Z., & Bodur, Y. (2022). Differentiated instruction and kindergarten through 5th grade teachers. Georgia Educational Researcher, 19(2), n2. https://doi.org/10.20429/ger.2022.190202

To examine K–5 teachers’ understanding of differentiated instruction and their perceptions of their ability to implement it.

DI is widely required and promoted, but many teachers are unsure how to apply it, and Georgia policy now requires DI coursework and evaluates teachers on it.

RQ1: What are elementary school teachers’ understanding of DI in K–5 classrooms?

RQ2: What are elementary school teachers’ perceptions of their ability to implement components of DI to meet the needs of students from various backgrounds?

Survey study (the authors label it mixed methods, but the results are mainly quantitative). N = 31 K–5 teachers in a Georgia master’s program (31 of 76 invited), convenience sampling, spring 2020.

Instrument: Tomlinson’s (2001) Teacher Survey on DI, modified by Page (2007): 26 four-point Likert items for “understanding” and the same items for “implementation,” across six components (student interest, assessment, lesson planning, content, process, product), plus two open-ended questions. Analysis: means, SDs and one-way ANOVA by years of experience, with Tukey post hoc.

Teachers reported high understanding (component means 3.10 to 3.93, highest for student interest, lowest for product) and fairly high implementation (content highest, M = 3.62; product lowest, M = 3.24). The only significant group difference was assessment: teachers with 5+ years scored higher (3.87) than those with 4–5 years (3.28), p = .003. Teachers named barriers such as limited DI knowledge, resources and professional development.

Critique: very small convenience sample drawn from the authors’ own program, self-reported data, no student outcomes or observation, several ANOVAs without adjustment, and little detail on how open-ended answers were analyzed.

Shows that even teachers who say they understand DI report using product differentiation least, which is a useful target for my own practice. It also points to professional development, resources and collaboration as needed supports. Findings are about perceptions, not student learning.

For this assignment, you will locate and read four articles with at least two being qualitative research articles that are related to your topic of interest. Due Day 7 of Module 5.

[footnoteRef:1] [1: ]

[footnoteRef:2] [2: ]

[footnoteRef:3] [3: ]

[footnoteRef:4] [4: ]

For this assignment, you will locate and read four articles with at least two being mixed-methods and/or practitioner-oriented research articles that are related to your topic of interest. Due Day 7 of Module 5.

[footnoteRef:5] [5: ]

[footnoteRef:6] [6: ]

[footnoteRef:7] [7: ]

[footnoteRef:8] [8: ]

The numerals below the chart are for endnotes. You can add detailed summaries or notes for each article below the numeral that corresponds to each article in the chart (also feel free to add relevant direct quotes, figures or notes to yourself to help you in your writing process). Endnotes are not required, but you may find them to be a helpful way to organize information for your final presentation.