Culminating Interview of an HR Practitioner
Supervisory/Managerial Performance Appraisal Form
Department: ________________________________________________________ Appraisal Date: _____________________________________________________
Surname: __________________________________________________________ First Name: ________________________________________________________
Job Title: __________________________________________________________ Appraiser’s Name: ___________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION:
This performance appraisal is intended to measure a supervisor/manager’s skills and accomplishments over the period under review. Scores and rankings are used as a tool to determine combined performance and attitude and development/training areas. The scores are applied in order of performance, totaled at the end of the section and then the ranking and future path determined.
Scoring:
|
Score |
Category |
Definition |
|
5 |
Excellent |
Objectives delivered before specified time frame and to the quality that exceeds normal standards. |
|
4 |
Very Good |
Objectives delivered within specified time frame and the quality meets the acceptable standard. |
|
3 |
Good |
Progress and quality of work to date is acceptable considering difficulty of goal and impacting factors. |
|
2 |
Fair |
Poor delivery of objective, either quality or time substantially below acceptable standard. |
|
1 |
Poor |
Little or no attempt made at achieving objectives. Poor and untimely delivery. Needs constant reminder of duties |
|
|
* |
Please circle the asterisk that denotes the objective the Supervisor/Manager meets or demonstrates. 5 asterisks are provided for each Attribute discussed. If only 3* have been met by the Supervisor/Manager, the score is 3-Good, 4* met the score is Very Good etc. |
Ranking:
|
Scoring Range |
Performance Category |
|
37 - 45 |
Excellent Performance. Pace-setting performance. Consistently surpasses all standards; innovative. Ideal for upward mobility. |
|
28 - 36 |
Good to Very Good Performance. Consistently exceeds normal expectations for the position but may have some challenges. Discuss areas of strengths and weaknesses and work out a plan to overcome weak areas. Discuss career path and plan for a future within the company/group. |
|
19 - 27 |
Ordinary to Acceptable Performance. Performs to normal expectations of the position in a capable manner and just about meets expectations for quality. Discuss whether the supervisor/manager was given the necessary tools for the job and has the technical expertise needed. Discuss supervisor/manager’s attributes and weaknesses and set out a plan for future training and development. A period for improvement should be established and further review conducted. |
|
10 - 18
|
Fair. Performance is fair but needs improvement. Discuss whether the supervisor/manager was given the necessary tools for the job and has the technical expertise needed. Discuss supervisor/manager’s attributes and weaknesses and set out a plan for future training and development. A period for improvement should be established and further review conducted. |
|
1 - 9 |
Poor Performance. Supervisor/Manager may not have been given the tools or does not have the expertise and experience to perform at this level. May also suggest that there is a lack of willingness or inability to perform the requirements of the position. Requires improvement in quality, quantity and timeliness of work to achieve overall satisfactory performance. Supervisor/Manager to be re-oriented with job functions and skills required and placed on probation of not more than three (3) months after which further review is conducted and termination considered if no improvement. |
SECTION 1: JOB PREPARATION
Was the supervisor/manager given a written job description? Yes No
Was the supervisor/manager given specific targets and objectives? Yes No
Were duties discussed with the supervisor/manager? Yes No
Does the supervisor/manager possess the knowledge and expertise needed for this job? Yes No
SECTION 2: SUPERVISOR/MANAGER GENERAL PERFORMANCE (To be completed by supervisor/manager prior to start of appraisal.)
|
What do you consider to be your most important achievements of the past month/few months?
|
|
What factors have impeded or facilitated the achievement of your objectives?
|
|
What elements of your job interests you the most and the least?
|
|
What elements of your job do you find most challenging?
|
|
Are there any actions, which management can take to enhance your performance?
|
SECTION 3: STRETCH OBJECTIVES
|
Objectives (List the most important ones, if more than 6) |
Achieved |
Not Achieved |
Comments |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SECTION 4 – PERFORMANCE REVIEW
|
|
SCORE |
|
||||
|
Performance Factors (Reflects competencies required for job and desired corporate behaviour at Jakes Holdings Ltd). |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
COMMENT/S |
|
1. Job Knowledge and Application: *Demonstrates knowledge and understanding of job role *Applies skill to produce quality work *Able to perform a wide variety of job-related tasks *Generates alternative solutions to problems and challenges *Seeks and utilizes opportunities for continuous learning and self-development
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2. Planning *Develops realistic plans that meet company goals and future needs *Demonstrates foresight in recognizing potential problems and develops solutions *Foresees changes and trends for department and company *Adheres to set time-lines/deadlines *Establishes and documents goals and objectives
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
3. Budgetary/Expense Control and Reduction *Effectively utilizes staff costs by scheduling staff rotas, leave, overtime *Utilizes materials and equipment to control capital and operating costs *Assists with planning by providing comprehensive justification for budgetary requests *Generates innovative ideas to reduce/contain expenses *Makes sound operating decisions that consider costs/benefits |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
4. Organizational Development *Promotes and actively participates in organizational development processes. *Supports organizations objectives and mission and has made commitment to our Corporate Responsibility *Executes organizational development plan from managers *Keeps management informed and submits timely and useful reports *Work well with senior managers, departments and staff to develop plans |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
5. Organizational Skills *Is well organized, and organizes department *Adheres to priorities and deadlines *Follows through on assignments despite set-backs *Plans and schedules work for staff and employees to meet objectives and goals *Demonstrates flexibility in responding to priorities and organizational changes |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
6. Staff Relationship & Development *Effectively deals with staff conflict *Provides opportunity for growth, challenges and motivates staff *Inspires confidence and respect and motivates employees to achieve department and organizational goals and objectives *Conducts regular reviews and meetings with staff, independently or as a group *Delegates appropriately and promotes prides, respect, honesty, integrity and is fair to all staff
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
7. Performance Standards *Accurately evaluates employees and departmental performance *Effectively communicates Jakes standards to staff especially customer service *Give direct, constructive and appropriate feedback to staff and Managers *Produces neat, accurate, thorough and organized work *Performs to the Standards expected of a Supervisor/Manager |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
8. Problem Solving and Decision Making *Accumulates all relevant information prior to making decisions *Presents well considered and appropriate alternatives when making recommendations *Makes tough and difficult decisions when required to do so *Able to solve staff problems *Finds innovative and improved ways of doing things |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
9. Communication *Effectively presents information, exchanges information and receives information both orally and in writing *Promotes productivity and pride *Appropriately expresses opinions *Keeps staff and managers appropriately informed *Values staff- their differing styles, personalities and opinions |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total Score of Performance Factors: _______/45 MARKS
Total Score Ranking attributed= Total Score of Performance Factors ÷ 9= ________
SECTION 5: PERFORMANCE SUMMARY
Summarize the Manager/ Supervisor’s overall performance (considering objectives, results and competencies). Make additional comments or observations in the space provided. Use a separate sheet, if required.
|
|
SECTION 6: DEVELOPMENT PLAN(Use separate sheet if required)
Overall recommendations should consider activities/actions to improve maintain or enhance performance and motivation, e.g. coaching, training, etc.
|
Short-terms areas for development |
Time-period or by when |
Development process, e.g. training type, social intervention/counselling, etc. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SECTION 7: FUTURE PERFORMANCE (Use separate sheet if required)
|
Performance or Stretch Objectives (state specific objectives if any) |
Time-period or by when |
Action (state how this will be achieved and measured) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SECTION 8: SIGNATURES
Employee:
I agree with this review. I disagree with this review.
My signature does not indicate acceptance of the review but rather that it has been discussed and I have read and understood the review.
Employee Signature:___________________________________ Date:____________________________________
Appraiser:
I have discussed and completed the performance review for this supervisor/manager.
Appraiser’s Name:_____________________________________ Appraiser’s Signature: ______________________________
Date:_________________________________
Reviewing Manager’s Comments:
|
|
Reviewing Manager’s Name:__________________________________ Signature:____________________________
Reviewing Manager’s Title:__________________________________ Date: ________________________________