FORUMS FOR HUMAN SEXUALITY HEALTH
Chapter 5
Gender and Gender Roles
Sex, Gender, and Gender Roles
- Sex: whether one is biologically female, male, or intersex
- Genetic sex: chromosomal and hormonal sex characteristics
- Anatomical sex: our physical sex; gonads, uterus, vulva, vagina, or penis
- Gender: social and cultural characteristics associated with being male or female
- Gender identity: gender one believes self to be
2
Sex and Gender Identity
- Assigned gender
- Based on anatomical appearance
- Gender variations
- Gender identity
- Internalized feeling of femaleness or maleness
- Gender role
- The attitudes, behaviors, rights, and responsibilities that society associates with each sex
- Influenced by culture, age, ethnicity, other factors
3
Gender-Roles
- Gender-role stereotype:
- A rigidly-held oversimplified belief concerning all males or all females
- Gender-role attitude:
- The belief one has for self and others concerning what’s appropriate for male or female traits
- Gender-role behavior:
- Activities or behaviors a person engages in as a female or male
4
Masculinity and Femininity
- Sexes seen as polar opposites in traditional Western view, e.g. “opposite sex”
- Different qualities associated with different genders
- Sexism
- Some qualities are biologically based, some culturally based
Gender and Sexual Orientation
- Gender, gender identity, and gender role are conceptually independent of sexual orientation
- However, many assume they are closely related
- Heterosexuality has been assumed to be part of masculinity and femininity
- Therefore, some believe that gay men can’t be masculine and lesbian women can’t be feminine.
Gender and Sexual Orientation
- Studies show a link between individuals’
- Negative attitudes towards gay and lesbian people
- And those individuals’ adherence to traditional gender roles
Gender Theory
- What is our relationship between our biological sex as male or female and our gender role as masculine or feminine?
- Do we act the way we act because our gender role is bred in us or because of socialization?
- Gender Theory developed as a field in the ’80s and ’90s to explore the role of gender in society
Gender Theory
- Seeks to understand society through understanding how its organized by gender
- Views gender as a basic element in social relationships
- Examines socially-perceived differences between genders that are used to justify unequal power relationships
Gender Theory in Psychology
- In psychology, gender theory focuses on:
- How gender is created and what its purposes are
- How specific traits, behaviors, and roles are defined as male or female
- How gender creates advantages and disadvantages
- Gender theory rejects the idea that gender differences are primarily biologically-driven
- Operates from a social-constructivist framework
Theories of Socialization
- Social learning theory
- Cognitive development theory
Cognitive Social Learning Theory
- Emphasizes consequences as shaping gender related behavior
- Cognition: Mental processes such as evaluation and reflection
- Includes ability to use language
- Anticipate consequences
- Modeling
Cognitive Development Theory
- Focuses on children’s active interpretation of gender messages at various developmental stages
- Argues that after age 6 or 7, motivation to act like one’s gender is primarily internal, and that gender-role behavior is intrinsic
Social Construction Theory
- Gender expression is an outcome of
- Power
- Language
- Meaning
- Relationship to sexual orientation
- Women
- Men
Gender-Role Learning: Childhood and Adolescence
- Parents as socializing agents
- Manipulation
- Channeling
- Verbal appellation
- Activity exposure
- Connections between sons and mothers
- Ethnic groups
Gender-Role Learning: Childhood and Adolescence
- Teachers as Socializing agents
- Females are more common
- Bias in presentation of topics
- Peers as socializing agents
- Play
- Approval
- Perceptions
- Media
Gender Schemas: Exaggerating Differences
- Interrelated ideas which help information processing
- Cognitive organization of world by gender
- Emphasize dichotomy
- Minimize valuing of the individual
Contemporary Gender Roles
- Women’s roles have changed
- Men’s roles have changed
- Must include diverse groups
- Egalitarian approach to gender roles
Traditional Male Gender Role
- Aggressiveness
- Emotional toughness
- Independence
- Feelings of superiority
- Decisiveness
- Power orientation
- Competitiveness
- Dominance
- Violence
Traditional Male Sexual Scripts: Zilbergeld
- Men should not have or express certain feelings
- Performance is the only thing that counts
- The man is in charge
- A man always wants sex and is ready for it
- All physical contact leads to sex
- Sex equals intercourse
- Sexual intercourse leads to orgasm
Traditional
Female Gender Role
- There are striking ethnic differences in female role
- American middle-class Whites: women as wives and mothers. Recently includes work outside the home
- African Americans: more egalitarian roles for men and women
- Latinas: women subordinate to men out of respect; Gender role affected by age
Traditional Female Sexual Scripts: Barbach
- Sex is good and bad
- It’s not okay to touch yourself “down there”
- Sex is for men
- Men should know what women want
- Women shouldn’t talk about sex
- Women should look like models
- Women are nurturers: they give, men receive
- There is only one right way to have an orgasm
Changing Gender Roles
- Egalitarian position
- Androgyny: flexibility in gender roles, combining elements of each traditional role
Contemporary Sexual Scripts
- Sexual expression is positive
- Sexual activities involve a mutual exchange of erotic pleasure
- Sexuality is equally involving, and both partners are equally responsible
- Legitimate sexual activities are not limited to intercourse but also include masturbation and oral-genital sex
- Sexual activities may be initiated by either partner
- Both partners have a right to experience orgasm, whether through intercourse, oral-genital sex, or manual stimulation
- Non-marital sex is acceptable within a relationship context
Androgyny
- Unique combination
- Combination or instrumental and expressive traits
- Difficulties with expression and expectation
When Sex is Ambiguous
- Intersexuality
- Tran sexuality
- Transgenderism
5
Intersexuality
- Describes people who possess mixtures of male and female genitalia or reproductive physiology
- Prevalence ranges from .0128% to 1.7% of population. Known until recently as “hermaphrodites”
- Shrouded in secrecy by families and medical establishments in the past
Intersexuality
- Hermaphrodites: Old terminology
- Ambiguous genitals: 1/2000 births
- Blended gonads or both gonads
- One ovary and one testis, or testes containing ovarian tissue
- Known until recently as “hermaphrodites”
Chromosomal Anomalies: Turner Syndrome
- Females who lack a chromosome: XO rather than XX
- Occurs in 1/1666 live births
- Female external appearance
- No ovaries
- Hormonal therapy
- Assisted fertility
Chromosomal Anomalies: Klinefelter Syndrome
- Males who have extra X chromosomes: XXY, XXXY, or XXXXY rather than XY
- Occurs in 1/1000 live births
- Variable effects; many men never diagnosed.
- Small firm testes; some female physical traits
- Lower testosterone levels
Hormonal Disorders: Androgen-Insensitivity Syndrome
- Inherited condition occurring in 1/13,000 individuals
- Genetic males whose tissues to not respond to testosterone
- Female genitals, no female internal organs
- At puberty, develops hips and breasts, no pubic hair and no menstruation
- Many experience female gender identity
Hormonal Disorders: Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia
- A genetic female with ovaries and a vagina develops externally as a male
- Due to malfunctioning of adrenal gland
- Occurs in 1/13,000 live births
- At birth, child has ambiguous genitalia
- In the past, doctors and families choose to assign female gender at birth
Hormonal Disorders: DHT Deficiency
- Internal male organs
- Clitoris-like penis at birth
- Undescended testes at birth
- Testes descend at puberty and penis grows
- Socialization
A Related Condition: Hypospadias
- Urethral opening located at non traditional location
- Urethra exists on underside of glans midway through the underside of the shaft or at the base of the scrotum
- Occurs in 1/770 male births
- Repair is possible
Gender Identity
Disorder
- Defined by the APA as a strong and persistent cross-gender identification and persistent discomfort about one’s assigned sex (2000)
- Diagnosis not associated as hormonal or physiological
- Requires experience of distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other areas of functioning
6
Gender Identity Disorder
- The goal of treatment for people with GID is “lasting personal comfort with the gendered self”
- Treatment is individual and multifaceted; can affirm cross-gender identification through:
- Psychotherapy
- Real-life experience living externally as desired gender
- Hormonal therapy
- Sex-reassignment surgery
Transsexuality
- Gender identity and sexual anatomy are not congruent
- Prevalence of transsexuality unknown: estimated 1/50,000 people over 15 yrs
- May occur with heterosexual, homosexual, and bisexual orientations
- Gender reassignment
Transsexual Phenomenon
- Transgender community embraces possibility of numerous genders and multiple social identities
- Other cultures recognize more than 2 genders
- Paradigm shift of gender dichotomy
- Employment protection
Summary
- Gender
- Gender role learning
- Contemporary gender roles
- Ambiguity and gender