Speech 1311

NM

NI

A

G

E

Section 1 _____ 10 pts

Introduction

· Purpose of the essay is clear to the audience.

· Ethical dilemma is explained clearly. (evaluated in Idea Development)

· Writer addresses why the dilemma calls for an ethical decision.

· Relevant background information is given.

· Thesis is restated and audience understands what will follow.

Section 2 _____ 30 pts

Organization

· Paragraphs start with a topic sentence.

· Sentences support the paragraph’s main ideas.

· Paragraphs are unified and coherent supporting the thesis.

· Logical progression of ideas with a clear structure and sequence.

· Transitions effectively connect sentences and paragraph.

· Conclusion provides closure and restates thesis.

Writing Style and Mechanics

· Writing is smooth, skillful and coherent.

· Variety in sentence structure; effective word choice; no repetition.

· Academic tone and diction are appropriate for essay’s purpose and audience.

· Minimal errors in punctuation, spelling, grammar, and mechanics; no comma splices and run-on sentences.

· The essay reflects a sense of audience.

Section 3 _____40 pts

Use of Sources and Evidence

· Demonstrates skillful use of high quality, credible, relevant sources.

· Evaluates information from sources. Correctly interprets author’s meaning.

· Fully develops and supports ideas using relevant source information.

· Facts are distinguished from opinions.

· Opinions are supported and qualified.

· Opposing views are represented fairly.

Idea Development and Critical Thinking

· Clearly explains the ethical dilemma, ethical standards, implications and consequences of decisions.

· Discusses what they would do if faced with this dilemma and the ethical standard they would use to make the decision.

· Considers how the ethical standard is similar or different from their own core beliefs and ethical values.

· Explains the origin of their core beliefs. Shows how their core beliefs evolved and influences their ethical conduct, thinking, and decision-making today.

Section 4 _____ 20 pts

In-text citations and References

· Outside sources are integrated smoothly in the essay.

· The essay includes correctly formatted in-text citations and a correct References page.

· APA guidelines are followed.

· Two different sources are cited in-text and on the reference page.