Need today! Read and answer the questions below. ALSO RESPOND TO A STUDENT

1

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

Sally Hemings and Thomas Jefferson

Questions to think about:

1. Why do you think the accusations made by Callender were ignored during Jefferson’s lifetime

and later by historians? Why do you think Madison Hemings’ assertions were ignored?

2. Why do you think Callender’s claims failed to hurt Jefferson politically? Do you think a similar

scandal would hurt an American president or elected leader today? Why or why not?

3. Did Sally Hemings and Thomas Jefferson love each other? Is this a valid question to ask?

4. Were Madison Hemings and his siblings black or white?

5. Based Madison Hemings’ family history, how common was racial intermixing in 18th and 19th

century Virginia?

6. Madison talks about two promises that were made to his mother. What were they?

7. What does Article IV Section II of the US Constitution have to do with Sally Hemings’ children?

8. Should the DNA tests (and all that they imply) influence how we view Jefferson and his place in

American history? If no, why not? If yes, how should they influence how we view him?

The following two primary sources both make the claim that Thomas Jefferson fathered children by one of his

slaves, Sally Hemings. The first source was written by an embittered former political associate of Jefferson’s,

James Callender, in 1802. Callender was a journalist who had been hired by the Republicans to attack the

Federalists in the run-up to election of 1800. For these verbal attacks Callender, a Scottish immigrant, was

thrown in jail for violating the Alien and Sedition Acts. He was financially ruined, and when he was released

from prison he tried to blackmail Jefferson, who was by then President of the United States, into giving him a

well-paid government job. Jefferson refused to respond to the threat and so Callender “outed” Jefferson’s

relationship with Sally Hemings in a series of newspaper articles. Jefferson never publically responded to the

articles and they did not hurt his political career. (For more on Callender see America Afire, pp. 207‒08, 212,

218.)

The second source is an interview given by an elderly man named Madison Hemings to an Ohio newspaper in

1873. In the interview Hemings stated that he was Jefferson’s son. Until very recently, most historians dismissed

the claims of both Callender and Madison Hemings, along with a few other pieces of evidence that suggested that

Jefferson had had a relationship (and children) with Sally Hemings. Then, in 1998, DNA tests were done on the

descendants of Madison Hemings and the descendants of his brother Eston: these tests proved that these two men

were direct decedents of Thomas Jefferson. Most historians now accept that most or all of Sally Hemings’

children were fathered by Jefferson.

Before the DNA tests, many historians saw Jefferson’s personal life (including whatever relationship he had

with his slaves) as being of marginal importance for our understanding of him as a statesman. Indeed, this is the

way that Jefferson himself would seem to have wanted us to view him: we have volumes upon volumes of his

writings, including political and scientific tracts, personal letters written to friends, and in these Jefferson is

generally very reticent about all aspects of his personal life. However, the DNA tests corroborate what Madison

Hemings asserted: that Jefferson and Sally Hemings had a long-term relationship that began in the 1780s or

2

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

1790s and continued until Jefferson’s death in 1826. Moreover, the relationship appears to have been

monogamous.

Therefore, the DNA tests have prompted historians to reconsider their views of Jefferson. Historians have

begun pouring over all of Jefferson’s writings again, re-evaluating everything he wrote about freedom,

independence, slavery, and race-relations in the light the DNA evidence. One response has been to re-cast

Jefferson as the stereotypical exploitative white slave owner, but the reality seems to have been much more

complex, as Madison’s interview suggests. For instance, Jefferson asserted that enslaved African Americans

were inferior to white Americans, but he also stated that he was not sure whether this was due to a natural

difference between the races or whether the (apparent) inferiority was a result of Africans having been enslaved.

At the same time, Jefferson also held more unsavory views. For example, he thought that beauty was linked to the

lightness of one’s skin color, and that blacks and whites should not intermarry or have children together.

For all the ink that has been spilt by historians in an attempt to understand Thomas Jefferson, the most that

can be said with certainty is that his views on slavery and race-relations were complex ‒ which is why historians

would dearly love to know what Sally Hemings thought about her life with Jefferson. Unfortunately, she left no

writings (that we know of). The closest that we can get to Sally and what her relationship with Jefferson was like,

is the interview that her son, Madison, gave in 1873, along with a few other scattered clues. For instance, in his

memoirs, an overseer who worked for Jefferson named Edmund Bacon recalled that it was his job to manage

Jefferson’s slaves but that his authority did not extend to Sally Hemings and her family. Bacon also recalled that

when Harriet “ran away” from Monticello, Jefferson told him to pay her stage coach fare to Philadelphia and

give her $50.

Perhaps the clearest indication of the nature of the relationship between Jefferson and Hemings involves

what happened after Jefferson died. Jefferson was deeply in debt when he died and most of his estate, including

his hundred slaves, had to be sold to pay off those debts. However, the members of the Hemings family who were

still at Monticello were not sold; they were given their freedom. Sally Hemings lived out her days as a free

woman. 1

I have also included a family tree for the Hemings family, based mainly on the interview with Madison

Hemings.

1 Actually, she remained a slave. The state of Virginia had passed a law making it illegal for slave owners to free slaves who

were over 50 years of age. The implication is that slave owners were freeing, or rather turning out, elderly slaves who could

no longer work in order to save themselves the cost of providing for these older slaves. Sally was 53 when Jefferson died and

so she could not legally be freed. However, she is listed as a free woman in a US census of the early 1830s. Presumably,

then, Jefferson’s heir, his (white) daughter Martha, abided by her father’s wishes that Sally be allowed her freedom.

3

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

A. From James Callender, “The President, Again”, Richmond Recorder, 1 September 1802.2

It is well known that the man, whom it delighteth the people to honor, keeps, and for many years past

has kept, as his concubine, one of his own slaves. Her name is SALLY. The name of her eldest son is TOM.

His features are said to bear a striking although sable resemblance to those of the president himself. The boy

is ten or twelve years of age. His mother went to France in the same vessel with Mr. Jefferson and his two

daughters. The delicacy of this arrangement must strike every person of common sensibility. What a

sublime pattern for an American ambassador to place before the eyes of two young ladies!

If the reader does not feel himself disposed to pause we beg leave to proceed. Some years ago, this

story had once or twice been hinted at in Rind’s Federalist. At that time, we believed the surmise to be an

absolute calumny. One reason for thinking so was this. A vast body of people wished to debar Mr. Jefferson

from the presidency. The establishment of this SINGLE FACT would have rendered his election impossible.

… By this wench Sally, our president has had several children. There is not an individual in the

neighbourhood of Charlottesville, who does not believe the story; and not a few who know it. … Behold the

favorite, the first born of republicanism! the pinnacle of all that is good and great! in the open consummation

of an act which tends to subvert the policy, the happiness, and even the existence of this country!

‘Tis supposed that, at the time when Mr. Jefferson wrote so smartly concerning negroes, when he

endeavoured much to belittle the African race, he had no expectation that the chief magistrate of the United

States was to be the ringleader in shewing that his opinion was erroneous; or, that he should chuse an African

stock whereupon he was to engraft his own descendants. …

If the friends of Mr. Jefferson are convinced of his innocence, they will make an appeal of the same

sort [that Callender had made during the Hamilton-Reynolds’ scandal].3 If they rest in silence, or if they

content themselves with resting upon a general denial, they cannot hope for credit. The allegation is of a

nature too black to be suffered to remain in suspence. We should be glad to hear of its refutation. We give it

to the world under the firmest belief that such a refutation never can be made. The AFRICAN VENUS is said to

officiate, as housekeeper at Monticello. When Mr. Jefferson has read this article, he will find leisure to

estimate how much has been lost or gained by so many unprovoked attacks upon

J. T. CALLENDER

2 As printed in: Sally Hemings & Thomas Jefferson. History, Memory, and Civic Culture, ed. by Jan Ellen Lewis and Peter S.

Onuf (Charlottesville, 1999), pp. 259–60. 3 In 1797 James Callender accused Alexander Hamilton in print of having an affair with a young, poor woman named Maria

Reynolds. Both Hamilton and Reynolds were married. (In fact, Reynolds’ husband knew about the affair and had demanded

that Hamilton pay him off to keep quiet about it!) In 1797 Callender was still allied with Jefferson’s (Democratic-

)Republicans against the Federalists. Hamilton was one of the leading Federalists and so there was a political motive to

Callender’s accusations. When called upon to back up his accusations, Callender produced letters written by Hamilton in

which Hamilton admitted to the affair. Hamilton then took the unusual step of publishing a pamphlet in which he admitted to

the affair but said that it had not compromised his governmental duties and so (here I am paraphrasing) Callender should shut

up about it. Hamilton survived the scandal, but his reputation was somewhat damaged. See also America Afire, pp. 123‒26

and 183‒85.

4

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

B. “Life among the Lowly, No. 1”, Pike County (Ohio) Republican, 13 March 1873.4

I never knew of but one white man who bore the name of Hemings; he was an Englishman and

my great grandfather. He was captain of an English trading vessel which sailed between England and

Williamsburg, Va., then quite a port. My great-grandmother was a fullblooded African, and possibly a

native of that country. She was the property of John Wales, a Welchman. Capt. Hemings happened to

be in the port of Williamsburg at the time my grandmother was born, and acknowledging her fatherhood

he tried to purchase her of Mr. Wales, who would not part with the child, though he was offered an

extraordinarily large price for her. She was named Elizabeth Hemings. Being thwarted in the purchase,

and determined to own his own flesh and blood he resolved to take the child by force or stealth, but the

knowledge of his intention coming to John Wales’ ears, through leaky fellow servants of the mother, she

and the child were taken into the ‘great house’ under their master's immediate care. I have been

informed that it was not the extra value of that child over other slave children that induced Mr. Wales to

refuse to sell it, for slave masters then, as in later days, had no compunctions of conscience which

restrained them from parting mother and child of however tender age, but he was restrained by the fact

that just about that time amalgamation began, and the child was so great a curiosity that its owner

desired to raise it himself that he might see its outcome. Capt. Hemings soon afterwards sailed from

Williamsburg, never to return. Such is the story that comes down to me.

Elizabeth Hemings grew to womanhood in the family of John Wales, whose wife dying she

(Elizabeth) was taken by the widower Wales as his concubine, by whom she had six children – three

sons and three daughters, viz: Robert, James, Peter, Critty, Sally and Thena. These children went by the

name of Hemings.

Williamsburg was the capital of Virginia, and of course it was an aristocratic place, where the

‘bloods’ of the Colony and the new State most did congregate. Thomas Jefferson, the author of the

Declaration of Independence, was educated at William and Mary College, which had its seat at

Williamsburg. He afterwards studied law with Geo. Wythe, and practiced law at the bar of the general

court of the Colony. He was afterwards elected a member of the provincial legislature from Albemarle

county. Thos. Jefferson was a visitor at the ‘great house’ of John Wales, who had children about his

own age. He formed the acquaintance of his daughter Martha (I believe that was her name, though I am

not positively sure,) and intimacy sprang up between them which ripened into love, and they were

married. They afterwards went to live at his country seat Monticello, and in course of time had born to

them a daughter whom they named Martha. About the time she was born my mother, the second

daughter of John Wales and Elizabeth Hemings was born. On the death of John Wales, my

grandmother, his concubine, and her children by him fell to Martha, Thomas Jefferson’s wife, and

consequently became the property of Thomas Jefferson, who in the course of time became famous, and

was appointed minister to France during our revolutionary troubles, or soon after independence was

gained. About the time of the appointment and before he was ready to leave the country his wife died,

and as soon after her interment as he could attend to and arrange his domestic affairs in accordance with

4 As printed in: Sally Hemings, ed. by Lewis and Onuf, pp. 255–58.

5

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

the changed circumstances of his family in consequence of this misfortune (I think not more than three

weeks thereafter) he left for France, taking his eldest daughter with him. He had sons born to him, but

they died in early infancy, so he then had but two children – Martha and Maria. The latter was left

home, but afterwards was ordered to follow him to France. She was three years or so younger than

Martha. My mother accompanied her as a body servant. When Mr. Jefferson went to France Martha

was just budding into womanhood. Their stay (my mother’s and Maria’s) was about eighteen months.

But during that time my mother became Mr. Jefferson’s concubine, and when he was called back home

she was enciente 5 by him. He desired to bring my mother back to Virginia with him but she demurred.

She was just beginning to understand the French language well, and in France she was free, while if she

returned to Virginia she would be re-enslaved. So she refused to return with him. To induce her to do

so he promised her extraordinary privileges, and made a solemn pledge that her children should be freed

at the age of twenty-one years. In consequence of his promise, on which she implicitly relied, she

returned with him to Virginia. Soon after their arrival, she gave birth to a child, of whom Thomas

Jefferson was the father. It lived but a short time. She gave birth to four others, and Jefferson was the

father of all of them. Their names were Beverly, Harriet, Madison (myself), and Eston – three sons and

one daughter. We all became free agreeably to the treaty entered into by our parents before we were

born. We all married and have raised families.

Beverly left Monticello and went to Washington as a white man. He married a white woman in

Maryland, and their only child, a daughter, was not known by the white folks to have any colored blood

coursing in her veins. Beverly's wife’s family were people in good circumstances.

Harriet married a white man in good standing in Washington City, whose name I could give, but

will not, for prudential reasons. She raised a family of children, and so far as I know they were never

suspected of being tainted with African blood in the community where she lived or lives. I have not

heard from her for ten years, and do not know whether she is dead or alive. She thought it to her

interest, on going to Washington, to assume the role of a white woman, and by her dress and conduct as

such I am not aware that her identity as Harriet Hemings of Monticello has ever been discovered.

Eston married a colored woman in Virginia, and moved from there to Ohio, and lived in

Chillicothe several years. In the fall of 1852 he removed to Wisconsin, where he died a year or two

afterwards. He left three children.

As to myself, I was named Madison by the wife of James Madison, who was afterwards

President of the United States. Mrs. Madison happened to be at Monticello at the time of my birth, and

begged the privilege of naming me, promising my mother a fine present for the honor. She consented,

and Mrs. Madison dubbed me by the name I now acknowledge, but like many promises of white folks to

the slaves she never gave my mother anything. I was born at my father’s seat of Monticello, in

Albemarle county, Va., near Charlottesville, on the 19th day of January, 1805. My very earliest

recollections are of my grandmother Elizabeth Hemings. That was when I was about three years old.

5 That is, pregnant.

6

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

She was sick and upon her death bed. I was eating a piece of bread and asked if she would have some.

She replied: ‘No, granny don’t want bread any more.’ She shortly afterwards breathed her last. I have

only a faint recollection of her.

Of my father, Thomas Jefferson, I knew more of his domestic than his public life during his life

time. It is only since his death that I have learned much of the latter, except that he was considered as a

foremost man in the land, and held many important trusts, including that of President. I learned to read

by inducing the white children to teach me the letters and something more; what else I know of books I

have picked up here and there till now I can read and write. I was almost 21½ years of age when my

father died on the 4th of July, 1826.

About his own home he was the quietest of men. He was hardly ever known to get angry,

though sometimes he was irritated when matters went wrong, but even then he hardly ever allowed

himself to be made unhappy any great length of time. Unlike Washington he had but little taste or care

for agricultural pursuits. He left matters pertaining to his plantations mostly with his stewards and

overseers. He always had mechanics at work for him, such as carpenters, blacksmiths, shoemakers,

coopers, &c. It was his mechanics he seemed mostly to direct, and in their operations he took great

interest. Almost every day of his later years he might have been seen among them. He occupied much

of the time in his office engaged in correspondence and reading and writing. His general temperament

was smooth and even; he was very undemonstrative. He was uniformly kind to all about him. He was

not in the habit of showing partiality or fatherly affection to us children. We were the only children of

his by a slave woman. He was affectionate toward his white grandchildren, of whom he had fourteen,

twelve of whom lived to manhood and womanhood. His daughter Martha married Thomas Mann

Randolph by whom she had thirteen children. Two died in infancy. The names of the living were Ann,

Thomas Jefferson, Ellen, Cornelia, Virginia, Mary, James, Benj. Franklin, Lewis Madison, Septemia

and Geo. Wythe. Thos. Jefferson Randolph was Chairman of the Democratic National Convention in

Baltimore last spring which nominated Horace Greeley for the Presidency, and Geo. Wythe Randolph

was Jeff. Davis’ first Secretary of War in the late ‘unpleasantness.’

Maria married John Epps, and raised one son – Francis.

My father generally enjoyed excellent health. I never knew him to have but one spell of

sickness, and that was caused by a visit to the Warm Springs in 1818. Till within three weeks of his

death he was hale and hearty, and at the age of 83 years walked erect and with a stately tread. I am now

68, and I well remember that he was a much smarter man physically, even at that age, than I am.

When I was fourteen years old I was put to the carpenter trade under the charge of John

Hemings, the youngest son of my grandmother. His father's name was Nelson, who was an Englishman.

She had seven children by white men and seven by colored men--fourteen in all. My brothers, sister

Harriet and myself, were used alike. We were permitted to stay about the ‘great house,’ and only

required to do such light work as going on errands. Harriet learned to spin and to weave in a little

factory on the home plantation. We were free from the dread of having to be slaves all our lives long,

7

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

and were measurably happy. We were always permitted to be with our mother, who was well used. It

was her duty, all her life which I can remember, up to the time of father's death, to take care of his

chamber and wardrobe, look after us children and do such light work as sewing, &c. Provision was

made in the will of our father that we should be free when we arrived at the age of 21 years. We had all

passed that period when he died but Eston, and he was given the remainder of his time shortly after. He

and I rented a house and took mother to live with us, till her death, which event occurred in 1835.

In 1834 I married Mary McCoy. Her grandmother was a slave, and lived with her master,

Stephen Hughes, near Charlottesville, as his wife. She was manumitted by him, which made their

children free born. Mary McCoy's mother was his daughter. I was about 28 and she 22 years of age

when we married. We lived and labored together in Virginia till 1836, when we voluntarily left and

came to Ohio. We settled in Pebble township, Pike County. We lived there four or five years and

during my stay in the county I worked at my trade on and off for about four years. Joseph Sewell was

my first employer. I built for him what is now known as Rizzleport No. 2 in Waverly. I afterwards

worked for George Wolf Senior. and I did the carpenter work for the brick building now owned by John

J. Kellison in which the Pike County Republican is printed. I worked for and with Micajab Hinson. I

found him to be a very clever man. I also reconstructed the building on the corner of Market and Water

Streets from a store to a hotel for the late Judge Jacob Row.

When we came from Virginia we brought one daughter (Sarah) with us, leaving the dust of a son

in the soil near Monticello. We have born to us in this State nine children. Two are dead. The names of

the living, besides Sarah, are Harriet, Mary Ann, Catharine, Jane, William Beverly, James Madison,

Ellen Wales. Thomas Eston died in the Andersonville prison pen, and Julia died at home. William,

James and Ellen are unmarried and live at home in Huntington township, Ross County. All the others

are married and raising families. My post office address is Pee Pee, Pike County Ohio.

8

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

9

HIST 120 Dr. Schaffer

Some additional information on the Hemings family tree:

The John Wayles of the family tree is the same John Wales mentioned by Madison Hemings. His

name usually has the former spelling.

Most of the information on the family tree comes from Madison Hemings’ interview. I have

included some additional information about the family of Eston’s wife. Eston inherited his father’s red

hair, fair skin, freckles, and talent for playing the violin. Eston married Julia Ann Isaacs in 1832. Julia

Ann’s father, David Isaacs, was Jewish. Her mother, Nancy West, was a free black woman. David

Isaacs and Nancy West had a long-term monogamous relationship, but maintained separate homes.

Their seven children were born from 1796 to 1819. In 1822 Isaacs and West were charged with

fornication. Why then? Because they had decided to move in together (a move that might have forced

the white community to accept their relationship).

The subsequent histories of the families of Eston and Madison are eloquent testimonies to the

different opportunities that were available to white and black Americans in the nineteenth and earlier

twentieth centuries. Around 1850 Eston, Julia Ann and their children moved to Wisconsin, where no

one knew them. There the family adopted the surname Jefferson and lived as white Americans. Eston’s

descendants included a number of doctors and lawyers. Madison and his family continued to reside in

Ohio, where they lived as African Americans. Madison’s descendants included a number of small

farmers, shopkeepers and domestic servants.