critical analysis essay

Some Lessons From The Assembly Line

From: Newsweek

Author: Andrew Braaksma

Last June, as I stood behind the bright orange guard door of the machine, listening to

the crackling hiss of the automatic welders, I thought about how different my life had

been just a few weeks earlier. Then, I was writing an essay about French literature to

complete my last exam of the spring semester at college. Now I stood in an automotive

plant in southwest Michigan, making subassemblies for a car manufacturer.

I have worked as a temp in the factories surrounding my hometown every summer since

I graduated from high school, but making the transition between school and full-time

blue-collar work during the break never gets any easier. For a student like me who

considers any class before noon to be uncivilized, getting to a factory by 6 o'clock each

morning, where rows of hulking, spark-showering machines have replaced the lush

campus and cavernous lecture halls of college life, is torture. There my time is spent

stamping, cutting, welding, moving or assembling parts, the rigid work schedules and

quotas of the plant making days spent studying and watching "SportsCenter" seem like a

million years ago.

I chose to do this work, rather than bus tables or fold sweatshirts at the Gap, for the

overtime pay and because living at home is infinitely cheaper than living on campus for

the summer. My friends who take easier, part-time jobs never seem to understand why

I'm so relieved to be back at school in the fall or that my summer vacation has been

anything but a vacation.

There are few things as cocksure as a college student who has never been out in the real

world, and people my age always seem to overestimate the value of their time and

knowledge. After a particularly exhausting string of 12-hour days at a plastics factory, I

remember being shocked at how small my check seemed. I couldn't believe how little I

was taking home after all the hours I spent on the sweltering production floor. And all

the classes in the world could not have prepared me for my battles with the machine I

ran in the plant, which would jam whenever I absent-mindedly put in a part backward

or upside down.

As frustrating as the work can be, the most stressful thing about blue-collar life is

knowing your job could disappear overnight. Issues like downsizing and overseas

relocation had always seemed distant to me until my co-workers at one factory told me

that the unit I was working in would be shut down within six months and moved to

Mexico, where people would work for 60 cents an hour.

Factory life has shown me what my future might have been like had I never gone to

college in the first place. For me, and probably many of my fellow students, higher

education always seemed like a foregone conclusion: I never questioned if I was going to

college, just where. No other options ever occurred to me.

After working 12-hour shifts in a factory, the other options have become brutally clear.

When I'm back at the university, skipping classes and turning in lazy re-writes seems

like a cop-out after seeing what I would be doing without school. All the advice and

public-service announcements about the value of an education that used to sound trite

now ring true.

These lessons I am learning, however valuable, are always tinged with a sense of guilt.

Many people pass their lives in the places I briefly work, spending 30 years where I

spend only two months at a time. When fall comes around, I get to go back to a sunny

and beautiful campus, while work in the factories continues. At times I feel almost

voyeuristic, like a tourist dropping in where other people make their livelihoods. My

lessons about education are learned at the expense of those who weren't fortunate

enough to receive one. "This job pays well, but it's hell on the body," said one co-worker.

"Study hard and keep reading," she added, nodding at the copy of Jack Kerouac's "On

the Road" I had wedged into the space next to my machine so I could read discreetly

when the line went down.

My experiences will stay with me long after I head back to school and spend my wages

on books and beer. The things that factory work has taught me--how lucky I am to get an

education, how to work hard, how easy it is to lose that work once you have it--are by no

means earth-shattering. Everyone has to come to grips with them at some point. How

and when I learned these lessons, however, has inspired me to make the most of my

college years before I enter the real world for good. Until then, the summer months I

spend in the factories will be long, tiring and every bit as educational as a French-lit

class.