MBA635 Week 7 Discussion
PowerPoint Presentation for Managing Performance through Training and Development
Adapted by
Alan Saks
University of Toronto
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-1
1
Chapter 13
Management and Leadership Development
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-2
2
Learning Outcomes
After reading this chapter, you should be able to:
Define “management” and “management development” and explain how these differ from employee training
Describe the main roles, functions, and critical skills of managers
Discuss the issue of leadership development
Understand the differences between transactional, transformational, and authentic leadership
Explain emotional intelligence and its relevance for management and leadership
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-3
3
Learning Outcomes
Describe the models of management skill development
Discuss how error-management training can be used for management development
Describe the content of programs used to develop conceptual, technical, and interpersonal managerial skills
Discuss the different types of management development programs, including management education, management training, and on-the-job management development
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-4
4
Learning Outcomes
Discuss the relationship between After Event Reviews (AERs) and experiential training
Discuss the effectiveness of management and leadership development programs and how that can be improved
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-5
5
Introduction
Developing managers is among the most important, complex, and difficult challenges faced by trainers today
Strong and effective leadership is a fundamentally important driver of organizational effectiveness
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-6
6
Introduction
This chapter explores what managers do (roles and functions), the critical skills they need, and the techniques and guiding principles (training design and delivery) that create the training experiences
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-7
7
Introduction
The chapter also describes several types of management development programs and their content, and it explores the issue of leadership development
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-8
8
What Is Management?
Management is the process of getting things done, efficiently and effectively, through and with other people
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-9
9
Managerial Roles, Functions, Skills, and Development Approaches
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-10
Figure 13.1 describes what managers do: their roles (interpersonal, informational, and decisional) and the functions these roles serve (controlling, organizational, and planning)
However, an additional role has gained importance in the last decades—managers need to provide leadership
Management development is based on the premise that managerial skills and competencies are learnable and that they can and should be nurtured and developed through training
These experiences occur on and/or off the job with instructional systems that are informational and experiential
10
What Is Management?
It is self-evident to management development that managerial skills and competencies are learnable and that they can and should be nurtured and developed through training and related experiences
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-11
11
Management Development vs. Employee Training
Management development differs from employee training because:
Management development focuses on “people skills”
Management development relies heavily on experiential techniques
Management behaviours are highly influenced by the manager’s personality and preferences
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-12
This topic is separate from employee training because managers work mainly though other people (this is a difficult training task)
Also, managerial development relies heavily on experiential techniques
12
Management Development vs. Employee Training
Management development is a longitudinal and gradual process
Incompetent managers can have a catastrophic effect on an entire organization’s ability to survive
Management development has unique strategic significance
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-13
Managerial behaviours are influenced by a manager’s personality and preferences—training needs to take into account these important individual differences
Managerial development is a long-term and gradual process by which the complex skills and competencies of managers are developed over time with training and experiences
An incompetent manager can have a catastrophic effect on the entire organization’s ability to survive—management development has unique significance
13
What Is Management Development?
The complex process by which individuals learn to perform effectively in managerial roles
Effective management requires extensive managerial skills that need strengthening and updating to retain their currency and effectiveness
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-14
Managers’ jobs are not easy
Responsible for delivering results while tending to unforeseen problems and obstacles of all types; for example, supply problems, machinery breakdowns, and personnel issues in a context of change
Additionally, a diverse and sometimes international workforce, frequent technical changes, increased competition, shorter time frames, and a focus on efficiency, increased competition, and many more factors make the job more complex
14
Is Management Development Important?
Management development is without doubt one of the most important applications of training in organizations
An important business investment because managers are responsible for ensuring the organization operates effectively and efficiently
Organizations invest more heavily in managers and in their development because theirs is the pivotal role in organizations
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-15
Managers’ jobs are not easy
Responsible for delivering results while tending to unforeseen problems and obstacles of all types; for example, supply problems, machinery breakdowns, and personnel issues in a context of change
Additionally, a diverse and sometimes international workforce, frequent technical changes, increased competition, shorter time frames, and a focus on efficiency, increased competition, and many more factors make the job more complex
15
Management Development
Managers play fundamental roles including interpersonal, informational, and decisional
Managerial roles are core for main functions of managers: controlling, organizing, and planning (COP)
However, leadership is also recognized as a fundamental skill of managers
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-16
Management development is a multi-billion-dollar business and one of the most important applications of training in Canada
Per capita training expenditures are greater for managers than for any other category of employees
Development of managers is a prudent business investment
16
Leadership
The individual qualities and behaviours that define and shape the direction of the organization and that inspire others to pursue that direction in the face of obstacles and constraints
Many organizations believe that middle or even first-line managers need to exercise leadership
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-17
Over the past 20 years, growing recognition of the exercise of leadership as a fundamental function of managers
17
Core Managerial Roles
According to Mintzberg, managerial activities involve three roles:
Interpersonal
Informational
Decisional
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-18
Interpersonal: leadership (motivates others), liaison (with others within and outside the unit with the goal of securing information used to attain goals), and figurehead (representational role for routine, social, and legal contexts)
Informational: monitor the environment (internal and external), disseminator (informing others about the unit and the unit about developments outside the unit), spokesperson (informing others and “selling” them on plans, values, or goals of the unit)—managers require communication skills!
Decisional: entrepreneur (move the unit in directions to take advantage of opportunities or shift the group to reduce threats), allocate resources (choose proposals and projects to fund and staff), negotiator (interact and bargain with others in the external and internal environment), trouble-shooter (react to unanticipated and unplanned environmental events)
18
Interpersonal Role
Interpersonal roles are the relationships that managers develop with other people because these people can provide significant help (or obstacles) to the attainment of group goals
This involves a leadership, liaison, and figurehead role
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-19
Interpersonal: leadership (motivates others), liaison (with others within and outside the unit with the goal of securing information used to attain goals), and figurehead (representational role for routine, social, and legal contexts)
Informational: monitor the environment (internal and external), disseminator (informing others about the unit and the unit about developments outside the unit), spokesperson (informing others and “selling” them on plans, values, or goals of the unit)—managers require communication skills!
Decisional: entrepreneur (move the unit in directions to take advantage of opportunities or shift the group to reduce threats), allocate resources (choose proposals and projects to fund and staff), negotiator (interact and bargain with others in the external and internal environment), trouble-shooter (react to unanticipated and unplanned environmental events)
19
Informational Role
Managers must monitor the environment, be a disseminator of information, and act as a spokesperson
Managers require communication skills
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-20
Interpersonal: leadership (motivates others), liaison (with others within and outside the unit with the goal of securing information used to attain goals), and figurehead (representational role for routine, social, and legal contexts)
Informational: monitor the environment (internal and external), disseminator (informing others about the unit and the unit about developments outside the unit), spokesperson (informing others and “selling” them on plans, values, or goals of the unit)—managers require communication skills!
Decisional: entrepreneur (move the unit in directions to take advantage of opportunities or shift the group to reduce threats), allocate resources (choose proposals and projects to fund and staff), negotiator (interact and bargain with others in the external and internal environment), trouble-shooter (react to unanticipated and unplanned environmental events)
20
Decisional Role
Managers must make decisions about people, goals, and the means to attain those goals
This involves being an entrepreneur, allocating resources, and being a negotiator and trouble-shooter
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-21
Interpersonal: leadership (motivates others), liaison (with others within and outside the unit with the goal of securing information used to attain goals), and figurehead (representational role for routine, social, and legal contexts)
Informational: monitor the environment (internal and external), disseminator (informing others about the unit and the unit about developments outside the unit), spokesperson (informing others and “selling” them on plans, values, or goals of the unit)—managers require communication skills!
Decisional: entrepreneur (move the unit in directions to take advantage of opportunities or shift the group to reduce threats), allocate resources (choose proposals and projects to fund and staff), negotiator (interact and bargain with others in the external and internal environment), trouble-shooter (react to unanticipated and unplanned environmental events)
21
Managerial Functions
COPL =
Controlling
Organizing
Planning
Leading
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-22
Controlling: process by which activities of the organization and its members are monitored to ensure they contribute positively to the attainment of organizational goals and objectives
Organizing: coordinating and organizing the efforts and tasks of units efficiently and effectively
Planning: defining and developing goals for the organization and the departments/units for which the manager is responsible
Leading: influencing the actions of others such that these actions are coordinated to produce the desired outcomes
22
Leadership: A Critical Function of Management?
Leadership is a function of all management
Leadership does not replace good management; good leaders are also good managers
Managers need to demonstrate leadership because they are responsible for attaining goals and keeping employees committed to goals
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-23
2014 Conference Board of Canada survey shows that for the majority (59 percent) of organizations sampled, the development of leaders is the top learning and development priority
23
Leadership: A Critical Function of Management?
Kouzes and Posner identify five key leadership success factors:
Role modelling
Inspiring a shared vision
Challenging the status quo
Encouraging others to do the same
Recognizing the contributions of others
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-24
This seminal book on leadership practices, The Leadership Challenge, has been used in leadership development programs worldwide
24
Leadership and Its Development: A Work in Progress
Leadership development is among the very top priority for organizations
The development of leaders is very difficult and not always successful
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-25
2014 Conference Board of Canada survey shows that for the majority (59 percent) of organizations sampled, the development of leaders is the top learning and development priority
25
Leadership and Its Development: A Work in Progress
Trait-based leadership
Behaviour-based leadership
Situational leadership
Transactional leadership
Transformational leadership
Charismatic leadership
Authentic leadership
Servant leadership
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-26
Trait-based leadership—leaders were born and not made; only those who possessed the required personal characteristics (called traits) could be leaders (first half of 20th century)
Behaviour-based leadership—following WW2, research developed to suggest that behaviours (not traits) distinguished good from poor leaders and that behaviours could be learned; however, by the 1970s it was believed that the same behaviours could be effective in one context and not another
Situational leadership—effective leadership had to be analyzed as a function of the context in which it was displayed
Transactional leadership—leaders make clear to followers the behaviours and attitudes that are associated with rewards and punishment. Subordinates follow transactional leaders because the path is clear and leads to desired outcomes and/or avoids unpleasant outcomes
Transformational leadership—leaders inspire followers to forgo self-interest and pursue the common good because there is a greater purpose
Charismatic leadership—transformational leaders who are able to engage the emotions of the followers are called charismatic leaders. They present an idealized vision and communicate that vision with confidence
Authentic leadership—these leaders think and behave in ways that truly reflect what they believe to be true and morally right. They are self-aware, ethical, and transparent with regard to others
26
Management Skills
Skills are defined as sets of actions that individuals perform and that lead to valued outcomes
Two types of approaches have been used to identify the skills required of managers
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-27
Emotional intelligence (EI) or emotional quotient (EQ) is based on the recognition that most human interactions have an emotional component; the success of these interactions often depends on how well emotions—one’s own and other people’s—are managed
27
Management Skills
Some authors rely on their extensive experience with management to infer the skills needed for effective management
Others have used empirical surveys of managers, sometimes within a single firm and sometimes across several, to guide their prescriptions
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-28
Emotional intelligence (EI) or emotional quotient (EQ) is based on the recognition that most human interactions have an emotional component; the success of these interactions often depends on how well emotions—one’s own and other people’s—are managed
28
Management Skills
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-29
Table 13.1 represents a summary of the most frequently mentioned skills of effective managers
Many of these involve “people skills”
One of the most important aspects of management involves interacting, communicating, and dealing with people within and outside the organization
29
Emotional Intelligence (EI)
The ability to manage your own and others’ emotions and relationships with others
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-30
Emotional intelligence (EI) or emotional quotient (EQ) is based on the recognition that most human interactions have an emotional component; the success of these interactions often depends on how well emotions—one’s own and other people’s—are managed
30
Emotional Intelligence (EI)
Emotional intelligence involves five sets of skills:
Self-awareness
Self-control
Motivation or drive
Empathy
Interpersonal skills
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-31
1. Self awareness: being aware of, and understanding, oneself and one’s emotions when interacting with others
2. Self-control: managing and regulating one’s emotions (both positive and negative) that arise from encounters and events
3. Motivation or drive: channelling emotions and energies in support of one’s goals
4. Empathy: reading and recognizing the emotions of others and responding to them appropriately
5. Interpersonal skills: the ability to manage interactions with others effectively through an understanding, integration, and management of emotions
31
Emotional Intelligence (EI)
EI is believed to be a learnable and changeable factor
It is believed that EI, like other “soft skills,” can be developed indirectly, through exposure and feedback about one’s conduct with others
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-32
1. Self awareness: being aware of, and understanding, oneself and one’s emotions when interacting with others
2. Self-control: managing and regulating one’s emotions (both positive and negative) that arise from encounters and events
3. Motivation or drive: channelling emotions and energies in support of one’s goals
4. Empathy: reading and recognizing the emotions of others and responding to them appropriately
5. Interpersonal skills: the ability to manage interactions with others effectively through an understanding, integration, and management of emotions
32
Emotional Intelligence (EI)
Training in EI involves group and individual activities that include role-plays, assessments, and practical exercises, all of which serve to enhance self-management and empathy
Managers with higher levels of EI are more effective and successful than managers with lower levels of EI
EI is a critical factor in management development and effectiveness
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-33
1. Self awareness: being aware of, and understanding, oneself and one’s emotions when interacting with others
2. Self-control: managing and regulating one’s emotions (both positive and negative) that arise from encounters and events
3. Motivation or drive: channelling emotions and energies in support of one’s goals
4. Empathy: reading and recognizing the emotions of others and responding to them appropriately
5. Interpersonal skills: the ability to manage interactions with others effectively through an understanding, integration, and management of emotions
33
Project Management and Emotional Intelligence (EI)
Project management requires managers to control, organize, plan, and lead (COPL) a project
Project management refers to the day-to-day functioning of the manager in the accomplishment of the plan
EI dimensions and success in project management are closely related
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-34
Planning is one thing—getting it done is another!
Managing a project means managing feelings (frustration of workers, concerns of clients, anxieties for achieving results within tight timeframes, etc.)
Those who cope with emotions manage projects better and EI can be developed through structured training in the context of project management
34
Project Management and Emotional Intelligence (EI)
Leaders with high levels of both critical thinking skills (a traditional IQ dimension) and emotional intelligence are more likely to be successful
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-35
Planning is one thing—getting it done is another!
Managing a project means managing feelings (frustration of workers, concerns of clients, anxieties for achieving results within tight timeframes, etc.)
Those who cope with emotions manage projects better and EI can be developed through structured training in the context of project management
35
Models of Management Skills Development
A model of management skills development is a basic blueprint that identifies the components or steps to be included in the development of training programs
Most models of management skill development share four basic commonalities
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-36
1. Initial skills assessment—identifying where the people are
2. Skill acquisition—learning and understanding the basic principles associated with the specific skill of interest
3. Skill practice—developing procedural learning by integrating the principles into smooth behavioural actions
4. Skill application on the job—applying the learned principles in job situations that require the skills
36
Models of Management Skills Development
Four basic commonalities of management skills development programs:
Initial skills assessment
Skill acquisition
Skill practice
Skill application on the job
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-37
1. Initial skills assessment—identifying where the people are
2. Skill acquisition—learning and understanding the basic principles associated with the specific skill of interest
3. Skill practice—developing procedural learning by integrating the principles into smooth behavioural actions
4. Skill application on the job—applying the learned principles in job situations that require the skills
37
Error Training for Management Development
Traditional models regard errors as undesirable and detrimental to learning
EMT allows and encourages trainees to make errors
For jobs requiring problem-solving skills, where reproduction of learned behaviours is not sufficient, EMT may be superior
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-38
Specific relevance for management jobs, where constant adaptation to an ever-changing environment is the norm
Managers need to be able to use new skills flexibly in a variety of contexts (adaptive expertise)
EMT is more effective in producing adaptive expertise, and since that type of transfer is required for managerial jobs organizations might consider EMT when developing managers
38
Content of Management Development Programs
Management skills fall into three general categories: conceptual, technical, and interpersonal skills
These three clusters of skills are rarely independent
This categorization provides a useful way to organize management development programs
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-39
Conceptual skills
Problem solving and decision making: usually programs consist of four basic steps (definition of problem, generate alternative solutions, evaluate and select solution, implementation and follow-up)
Planning skills: clarification of the goals the manager wishes to achieve, SWOT analysis, strategies and tactics for implementation, and evaluation
Performance management and goal setting: review, assess, and manage the performance of their units and the people in them (includes goal setting)
Technical skills: ensuring managers are knowledgeable about the departments they manage (marketing managers know something about marketing)
39
Content of Management Development Programs: Conceptual Skills
Managers require three especially important conceptual skills:
Problem solving and decision making
Planning skills
Performance management and goal setting
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-40
Conceptual skills
Problem solving and decision making: usually programs consist of four basic steps (definition of problem, generate alternative solutions, evaluate and select solution, implementation and follow-up)
Planning skills: clarification of the goals the manager wishes to achieve, SWOT analysis, strategies and tactics for implementation, and evaluation
Performance management and goal setting: review, assess, and manage the performance of their units and the people in them (includes goal setting)
Technical skills: ensuring managers are knowledgeable about the departments they manage (marketing managers know something about marketing)
40
Content of Management Development Programs: Technical Skills
Specific courses instruct managers on very specific skills
Controlling budgets requires expertise in computer spreadsheet programs such as Excel
The informational role requires presentation skills
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-41
Conceptual skills
Problem solving and decision making: usually programs consist of four basic steps (definition of problem, generate alternative solutions, evaluate and select solution, implementation and follow-up)
Planning skills: clarification of the goals the manager wishes to achieve, SWOT analysis, strategies and tactics for implementation, and evaluation
Performance management and goal setting: review, assess, and manage the performance of their units and the people in them (includes goal setting)
Technical skills: ensuring managers are knowledgeable about the departments they manage (marketing managers know something about marketing)
41
Content of Management Development Programs: Interpersonal Skills
Interpersonal skills refer to the manager’s ability to interact with others in a constructive manner. This includes skills in:
Communication
Managing conflict
Managing stress
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-42
Interpersonal skills
Communication—central to most management positions. Managers must recognize their own biases and styles, understand their frame of reference, communicate their values, and ensure congruency, clarity, and comprehension
Managing conflict—conflict can be interpersonal or issue based. Managers must manage conflict effectively to deal with organizational problems including treating parties with respect, listening effectively so parties know they have been heard, and allowing parties to share their needs and feelings.
Managing stress—managers need to recognize stress reactions in themselves and in those they manage, because some stress reactions can be dysfunctional and damaging to one’s health and/or work performance
42
Methods of Management Development
All on-the-job/off-the-job techniques have been used in some programs
Some are informational (focus on principles and skill/technique application)
Others are fully experiential (learning by experiences)
Direct experience is the main crucible for managerial and leadership development
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-43
Management development cannot consist of memorizing and applying a set of prescriptions
Managers operate in fluid and varied environments and individuals need to develop their own ways of applying the principles learned in training
By understanding and integrating the principles taught, managers can correctly apply them in a way that is aligned with them and their work group
43
Experiential Learning
Learning that includes skill practice exercises that actively engage and involve the learner
Direct job experiences (job rotation and special assignments)
Formal instructor-led courses including role playing and off-the-job experiences, e.g., outdoor wilderness training
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-44
It is assumed that direct experience allows participants to derive personal lessons and understandings that shape future behaviours
Experiential approaches are thought to build procedural knowledge and motivation to transfer
44
Experiential Learning
Active exercises (doing) designed to engage the learner are the key component of these development efforts
Experiential approaches build procedural knowledge and motivation to transfer
However, the lessons learned from experiences are not always what learners should have learned
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-45
It is assumed that direct experience allows participants to derive personal lessons and understandings that shape future behaviours
Experiential approaches are thought to build procedural knowledge and motivation to transfer
45
Experiential Learning
After Event Reviews (AERs) are formal, structured debriefings held immediately following an experiential learning situation
AERs significantly improve the value of experiential training, especially for trainees with certain personality characteristics (those with higher levels of openness to experience, conscientiousness, and emotional stability)
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-46
It is assumed that direct experience allows participants to derive personal lessons and understandings that shape future behaviours
Experiential approaches are thought to build procedural knowledge and motivation to transfer
46
Methods of Management Development
There are three general approaches to, and techniques for, management development:
Management education programs
Management training programs
On-the-job management development
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-47
It is assumed that direct experience allows participants to derive personal lessons and understandings that shape future behaviours
Experiential approaches are thought to build procedural knowledge and motivation to transfer
47
Management Education Programs
Management education is the acquisition of a broad range of managerial knowledge, principles, and general conceptual abilities
Often conducted by colleges and universities
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-48
These programs target the development of the principles and techniques required to control, organize, plan, and lead effectively
Examples and case studies drawn from specific organizations are used
Principles and techniques of management are presented through lectures and discussions
Examples of content areas are accounting, organizational behaviour, and business statistics
48
Management Education Programs
They target the development of the principles and techniques required to control, organize, plan, and lead effectively
Examples include MBA programs, executive MBA programs, and corporate universities
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-49
Although they tend to be highly informational, they typically include some experiential learning
They use many instructional methods including lectures, role plays, games, simulations, and behaviour modelling
49
Management Training Programs
Programs that involve activities and experiences designed to develop specific and immediately applicable managerial skills
Some take place in the classroom (workshops and seminars) or outside the classroom in alternative settings (outdoor wilderness training)
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-50
Activities and experiences designed to develop specific, immediately applicable managerial skills (e.g., communication, decision making) in a particular organizational setting
50
Management Training Programs
Outdoor wilderness training is highly experiential and helps mangers develop life experience by engaging in physically and psychologically demanding tasks and activities
These programs appear to have their largest impact in increasing the participants’ self-efficacy and their ability to manage time
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-51
Activities and experiences designed to develop specific, immediately applicable managerial skills (e.g., communication, decision making) in a particular organizational setting
51
Sources and Lengths of Management Training Sessions
In North America, training courses tend to be of relatively short duration
The HR departments of some companies develop their own proprietary training packages using their own resources or external consultants
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-52
Activities and experiences designed to develop specific, immediately applicable managerial skills (e.g., communication, decision making) in a particular organizational setting
52
Sources and Lengths of Management Training Sessions
Other companies rely on training programs supplied by specialized firms
An increasing number of management development programs are available through electronic media
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-53
Activities and experiences designed to develop specific, immediately applicable managerial skills (e.g., communication, decision making) in a particular organizational setting
53
On-the-Job Management Development
Programs designed to provide individuals with managerial learning experiences on the job
Two of the most common examples are:
Job rotation
Coaching
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-54
Job rotation gives managers an opportunity to develop and use existing and new skills in a diversity of contexts, with different people, and in different functional contexts
It also helps the participant learn about the organization itself
54
On-the-Job Management Development: Job Rotation
A planned process that involves posting the manager to different jobs, areas, or functions of the organization
Job rotation develops managers by giving them the opportunity to use existing and new skills in a variety of ways, with different people, and in different functional contexts
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-55
Job rotation gives managers an opportunity to develop and use existing and new skills in a diversity of contexts, with different people, and in different functional contexts
It also helps the participant learn about the organization itself
55
On-the-Job Management Development: Coaching
One-on-one structured learning experience to help the manager develop the insights and techniques pertinent to the accomplishment of specific aspects of his job
The key to successful coaching is the qualities of the coach and the manager’s openness to the coaching experience
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-56
Job rotation gives managers an opportunity to develop and use existing and new skills in a diversity of contexts, with different people, and in different functional contexts
It also helps the participant learn about the organization itself
56
On-the-Job Management Development: Coaching
The coach interacts with, and provides feedback to, the manager with the intent of developing his insight, skills, attitudes, and motivation for dealing with more specific challenges
Coaches may be external or internal to the company
Managers are sometimes expected to serve as coaches
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-57
Job rotation gives managers an opportunity to develop and use existing and new skills in a diversity of contexts, with different people, and in different functional contexts
It also helps the participant learn about the organization itself
57
On-the-Job Management Development: Mentoring
Helping less experienced managers understand and gain perspective on the general managerial problems and difficulties they confront
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-58
Job rotation gives managers an opportunity to develop and use existing and new skills in a diversity of contexts, with different people, and in different functional contexts
It also helps the participant learn about the organization itself
58
On-the-Job Management Development: Coaching
Three key ingredients of a great coach:
Goal orientation
Challengers
Person-focused
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-59
Job rotation gives managers an opportunity to develop and use existing and new skills in a diversity of contexts, with different people, and in different functional contexts
It also helps the participant learn about the organization itself
59
On-the-Job Management Development: Coaching
Coaches are most helpful when they structure their efforts to help managers develop five key elements:
Insight
Motivation
Capabilities
Real-world practices
Accountability
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-60
On-the-Job Management Development: Coaching
Coaches face a number of challenges:
Must act to gain the trust of the “coachee”
Obstacles and hurdles
Coaching does help managers become more successful and more effective in accomplishing their tasks
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-61
Is Management Development Effective?
Most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development practices
Differing findings on the effectiveness of management development programs
Some studies suggest programs are effective in increasing learning, yet moderately effective in building expertise
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-62
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
62
Is Management Development Effective?
Burke and Day: Concluded that management training was, at best, “modestly” effective
Collins and Holton: Management training has a major impact on learning and a more modest impact on expertise and organizational outcomes
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-63
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
63
Is Management Development Effective?
Taylor, Russ-Eft, and Taylor: In general, trainees and their supervisors tended to report reasonably high levels of transfer
Effective training programs are built on thorough needs analysis, and during training they provided significantly more practice of learned skills
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-64
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
64
Leadership Training: What’s Wrong and What Is Needed?
Trainees do learn but for the most part this does not produce noticeable behaviour changes and performance improvements on the job
Several common organizational situations that prevent transfer of training in organizations
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-65
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
65
Leadership Training: What’s Wrong and What Is Needed?
Unclear organizational priorities and strategies
Lack of commitment to change by upper management
A reluctance to allow honest discussions of problems
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-66
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
66
Leadership Training: What’s Wrong and What Is Needed?
Inability to identify and nurture talented individuals
Manager’s reluctance (fear?) to tell the truth about barriers to behaviour change on the job
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-67
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
67
Leadership Training: What’s Wrong and What Is Needed?
Leadership training and development needs to be tied to organizational development efforts
Senior management needs to be directly involved with the development of leadership
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-68
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
68
Leadership Training: What’s Wrong and What Is Needed?
Major changes for the Human Resource departments are required
Trainers need to recognize that the display of newly learned behaviours can be difficult and provide on-the-job support
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-69
Conference Board of Canada surveys show that most organizations are not satisfied with the results of their leadership development programs
Differing views throughout the literature regarding effectiveness overall
However, a 2014 Conference Board survey did conclude that organizations that have a stronger learning culture report greater success and satisfaction with their development efforts
69
Summary
Defined management and described roles, functions, and critical skills of managers and how they are developed
Defined management development and why it is important
Examined the development of leaders as a critical function of management
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-70
70
Summary
Described models of management skills development and the content of management development programs
Described methods of management development that involve informational and experiential learning
Discussed management education programs, management training programs, and on-the-job development
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-71
71
Summary
Reviewed research on the effectiveness of management development programs
Concluded with a review of what is wrong with leadership training and what is needed
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-72
72
Key Terms
After Event Reviews (AERs)
Coaching
Emotional intelligence
Experiential learning
Functions of management
Job rotation
Leadership
Management
Management development
Management education
Management training
Mentors
On-the-job management development
Outdoor wilderness training
Skills
Transactional leadership
Transformational leadership
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
13-73
73