HRM635 Week 4 Discussion
PowerPoint Presentation for Managing Performance through Training and Development
Adapted by
Alan Saks
University of Toronto
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-1
1
Chapter 7
Technology-Based Training Methods
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-2
2
Learning Outcomes
After reading this chapter, you should be able to:
Explain the differences between technology-based training, traditional training, computer-based training, and e-learning
Compare and contrast instructor-led training and self-directed learning as well as asynchronous and synchronous training
Explain how online education and electronic performance support systems are used for training
Explain how a virtual classroom works and how video conferencing, web conferencing, webinars, and webcasts are used
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-3
3
Learning Outcomes
Explain how social media, Web 2.0 technologies, mobile learning, and synthetic learning environments can be used for training
Explain how to design effective computer-based training programs and their advantages and disadvantages for individuals and organizations
Know when to use computer-based training and how to make it effective for learning
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-4
4
Introduction
This chapter focuses on technology-based training methods:
How technology is being used for training
How to design technology-based training programs
The advantages, disadvantages, and effectiveness of technology-based training programs
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-5
5
What Is Technology-Based Training?
Technology-based training involves the use of technology to deliver training programs (e.g., Web-based training, computerized self-study)
Traditional training does not involve using technology to deliver courses (e.g., seminars, lectures)
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-6
In Canada, while instructor-led training is still the most widely used training method (95 percent of organizations), three-quarters of organizations offer some form of self-paced online learning or e-learning, which represents 14 percent of all learning time
77 percent of organizations report that e-learning is becoming more important strategically to their organization’s learning strategy
6
Computer-Based Training
Computer-based training is delivered via the computer for the purpose of teaching job-relevant knowledge and skills
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-7
Can include text, graphics, and/or animation, and can be delivered via CD-ROMs, intranets, or the Internet
7
E-Learning
E-learning is the use of computer network technology such as the Internet or intranet to deliver information or instruction to individuals
It is a specific type of computer-based training in which learners can access training material from a personal computer, smartphone, or tablet
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-8
E-learning is also known as Web-based instruction or WBI
E-learning is a specific type of computer-based learning and refers to the use of computer network technology
8
Training Methods
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-9
Instructor-Led Training
Instructor-led training (ILT) involves training methods with an instructor or facilitator who leads, facilitates, or trains online
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-10
Examples of ILT include online discussions and video conferencing
In some cases the instructor is very involved in the training and leads the process
In other cases the training is self-study and the instructor is available to answer questions and provide assistance
10
Self-Directed Learning
Self-directed learning (SDL) is a process in which individuals or groups take the initiative and responsibility for learning and manage their own learning experiences
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-11
One of the main advantages of CBT is that it can be initiated and controlled by the trainee
The responsibility for learning shifts from trainer to trainee
It is becoming increasingly popular because traditional methods of training lack the flexibility to respond quickly to dramatic and constant organizational change and trainee needs
11
The Benefits and Limitations of Self-Directed Learning
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-12
Review some of the benefits and limitations of self-directed learning as discussed in Table 7.2
12
Asynchronous Training
Asynchronous training is pre-recorded and available to employees at any time and from any location
Using multimedia training programs can include text, graphics, animation, audio, and video
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-13
While the use of multimedia results in greater involvement on the part of the trainee, it is much more expensive to design and develop
13
Synchronous Training
Synchronous training is live and in real time so it requires trainees to be at their computer at a specific time
Trainees from various locations can log on to the training at a set time and receive instruction from a trainer who facilitates a discussion, shows slides, answers trainees’ questions, and provides feedback
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-14
It is live and in real time, so trainees must be available when required
It might involve chat sessions in which trainees log on at the same time and participate in a discussion
More sophisticated training programs involve log-ins from different locations and the trainer facilitates a discussion, shows slides, answers questions, and provides feedback
14
Online and Distance Education
Online and distance education uses computer technology and the Internet to deliver educational content and courses (e.g., post-secondary courses)
Online courses can include text, graphics, and videos as well as quizzes, and downloadable materials
Recent developments include MOOCs and SPOCs
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-15
Before computers, known as correspondence programs
With computer technology, students can take a variety of post-secondary courses and earn a degree or diploma through online education
Can benefit an employer who may have an employee take a program and earn credentials while not missing any work
15
Electronic Performance Support Systems
Electronic performance support systems (EPSS) provide information, advice, and learning experiences to improve performance (e.g., a performance aid that utilizes technology on the job)
The goal of an EPSS is to provide whatever is necessary to aid performance and learning at the time it is needed
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-16
A modern-day version of a performance or job aid that uses technology
Can provide support through assisting, warning, advising, teaching, and evaluating—employees can obtain information to help solve work-related problems
Particularly helpful for jobs that have high turnover or for tasks that are difficult, are performed infrequently, and must be performed perfectly
Other examples of EPSS include online reference tools
16
The Virtual Classroom
A Web-based platform to deliver live, instructor-led training to geographically dispersed learners
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-17
A common method of synchronous training
Allows trainees to participate in live discussions with facilitators and co-workers from any location
Provides significant cost savings and convenience (travel)
17
The Virtual Classroom
The virtual classroom is made possible through the use of:
Videoconferencing
Web conferencing
Webinars
Webcasts
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-18
Each of these methods will be described
18
Video Conferencing
Links an expert or trainer to employees via two-way television and satellite technology
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-19
Can involve the transmission of television signals via cable or through satellite technology
Whatever the means of transmission, the basic idea is that people at two or more locations are able to see, hear, and speak with one another
19
Web Conferencing
A live meeting or conference that takes place on the Internet
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-20
Trainees are connected to the trainers and each other via the Internet and participate from their own computer
20
Webinars and Webcasts
Webinars are seminars that take place live over the Internet
Webcasts are live or recorded videos or audio broadcasts over the Internet
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-21
A seminar or workshop that takes place over the Web (a Web-based seminar)
Can be a presentation, lecture, or workshop and can be interactive by allowing participants to ask and answer questions
Reduces the costs associated with renting a room, travel, and catering
Webcast is a live or recorded video or audio broadcast over the Internet primarily used for presentations
Webcasts are usually one-way communications that do not have an interactive component
21
Social Media
Social media is the use of technology for sharing and exchanging information (e.g., LinkedIn)
Social media is increasingly being used for knowledge sharing and learning
Employees can share information and knowledge through the use of communities of practice
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-22
According to social constructivism, the goal of instruction should be to create interactive learning environments in which training participants learn from instructors, participants learn from each other, and the instructor learns from participants
Web-based instruction is well suited for fostering interactive learning environments
22
Communities of Practice (COPs)
Groups of employees who:
Share similar concerns and problems
Meet regularly to share their experiences and knowledge
Learn from each other and identify new approaches for working and solving problems
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
2-23
23
Communities of Practice (COPs)
The core principles of communities of practice are that learning is social and that people learn from each other while working together on the job
Some communities of practice meet regularly face-to-face, while others use technology to communicate
The technology used for knowledge sharing and communities of practices is typically known as Web 2.0 technology
Copyright © 2016 by Nelson Education Ltd.
2-24
24
Web 2.0
Web 2.0 refers to Internet tools that enable communicating and sharing information and knowledge
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-25
Web 2.0 technology allows anybody the ability to create and distribute knowledge and collaborate with others in the process
25
Web 2.0
Facilitates generative learning, which is a self-initiated and learner-controlled form of collaborative learning in which individuals in a social network share ideas and information, and in the process solve problems and create new knowledge
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-26
Involves much more than traditional approaches to learning in which trainees learn the material provided to them in instructor-led training programs
They initiate and control what they learn, when they learn, and how they learn
26
Web 2.0 Technologies— Blogs and Wikis
Blogs are websites that contain commentary and information on a subject
A wiki is a webpage or collection of webpages in which users share, contribute, and modify information on a topic
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-27
Some of the most popular technologies
Blogs can include text, video, audio, and link to other individuals’ blogs and provide a network of conversations and the exchange of information on a particular topic, subject, or issue
Wikis can focus on particular topics and the content can be created and shared among the users of the website on an ongoing basis
Wikis enable relevant information to be obtained on demand and training material to be constantly revised and updated
27
Web 2.0 Technologies— Podcasts
Podcasts are short audio or video recordings that can be downloaded and played on a mobile device such as an iPod or smartphone
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-28
Employees can access information on demand from any location at their convenience; for example, a sales team can learn about new products directly from the designers
28
Web 3.0
Web 3.0 is a fundamental shift in how individuals will interact with the Web
It consists of three components:
The semantic Web involves technologies that can understand the meaning of data and create customized experiences
The mobile Web allows one to use the Web seamlessly across devices and locations
Immersive Internet involves the use of immersive technologies such as virtual worlds, augmented reality, and 3-D environments
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-29
Web 3.0 is already on the horizon; expected to improve learning and performance and represent the future of learning
29
Mobile Learning (M-Learning)
The use of mobile or portable technologies across locations for obtaining information and training
Mobile technology makes learning accessible across time, location, and device
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-30
These portable or mobile technologies can include iPods, smartphones, MP3 players, and other mobile technology
30
Mobile Learning (M-Learning)
Can be used to deliver short videos or small amounts of bite-sized information to meet a specific learning outcome—microlearning
For example, Black & Decker field reps receive 2- to 3-minute learning modules directed to their PDA (personal digital assistant)
A downside of mobile learning is the potential for distractions that stem from the environment
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-31
M-learning is effective for 2- to 6-minute sessions that address a single learning point or for summarizing previously learned material
Ideal for providing information and support for employees when they are away from the office
31
Synthetic Learning Environments (SLEs)
Technology-based training media that augment, replace, create, and/or manage a learner’s experience with the world by providing realistic content with instructional features
Two examples of SLEs are virtual reality and augmented reality
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-32
M-learning is effective for 2- to 6-minute sessions that address a single learning point or for summarizing previously learned material
Ideal for providing information and support for employees when they are away from the office
32
Virtual Reality
Virtual reality (VR) uses computers to create an artificial three-dimensional experience that simulates and re-creates an actual environment
VR can be used to simulate various conditions in which trainees can immerse themselves in highly realistic situations to solve real work-related problems
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-33
M-learning is effective for 2- to 6-minute sessions that address a single learning point or for summarizing previously learned material
Ideal for providing information and support for employees when they are away from the office
33
Augmented Reality
Augmented reality (AR) is a technology in which computer-generated virtual imagery (e.g., graphics, text, and other visual elements) information is overlaid or superimposed onto a real-world environment in real time
It contains some aspect of reality and is designed to augment the real environment with information integrated into the individual’s real world
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-34
M-learning is effective for 2- to 6-minute sessions that address a single learning point or for summarizing previously learned material
Ideal for providing information and support for employees when they are away from the office
34
Designing Effective Technology-Based Training Programs
Training programs should include active practice and conditions of practice (feedback) (Chapter 4)
Instructional methods found in Chapter 5 can be used—games, simulations, and role plays
Additional design factors include stories, customizing, personalizing the training, human interaction, and feedback
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-35
Computer simulations and games are becoming common approaches
35
Computer Simulations
Provide hands-on training for a particular task—designed to replicate the on-the-job experience
Provide trainees with a realistic experience on tasks that might be too dangerous to learn in the work environment
For example, Mr. Lube uses an online simulation for technicians to learn how to perform an oil change
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-36
Computer simulations are also being used for soft-skills training for skills such as leadership, sales, customer service, and financial services
36
Computer Simulations
Virtual worlds use computers to provide elaborate simulations that involve interactions among and between multiple trainees and objects
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-37
Computer simulations are also being used for soft-skills training for skills such as leadership, sales, customer service, and financial services
37
Games
Computer-based games are designed to engage trainees with realistic and entertaining experiences
Computer-based simulation games involve instruction delivered via personal computer that immerses trainees in a decision-making exercise in an artificial environment in order to learn the consequences of their decisions
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-38
Games are different from simulations in that they are meant to be both entertaining and competitive and include common game features, such as rules
38
Gamification
Gamification is the use of game mechanics and elements from video games to engage and motivate employees in the workplace
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-39
Games are different from simulations in that they are meant to be both entertaining and competitive and include common game features, such as rules
39
Gamification
Should involve three key elements of games:
A story that provides the context and includes characters and settings that are relevant to trainees
Parameters that indicate the basic framework and rules for how the game is played
How trainees will be rewarded and how achievement will be recognized
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-40
Games are different from simulations in that they are meant to be both entertaining and competitive and include common game features, such as rules
40
Role Plays
Role plays can be used in technology-based training programs
For example, Rogers Wireless Communications Inc. has interactive customer-service training programs for sales reps involving role plays
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-41
Role playing can make training programs engaging and the lessons may improve employee performance
41
Stories
Stories are used to engage trainees by providing stories that involve dialogue and characters
Characters can be created to be similar to the trainees and learning can occur as the characters solve problems in the story
Sprint and Volvo have used stories to train employees on how to deliver the company’s brand image when interacting with customers
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-42
Have been used in e-learning to engage trainees
Abstract concepts and dry materials can be livened up with stories that involve dialogue and characters
42
Customization
Customization involves tailoring instructional elements to meet trainee needs and preferences
Training content can also be customized to the needs of each trainee with the use of adaptive learning technology
The technology can change and adapt the training content and material so that the training is tailored to each trainee’s specific needs
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-43
Can increase trainee satisfaction with the training and improve learning
Differences in e-learning preferences indicate that one type of e-learning program is not likely to meet the needs and preferences of all employees
43
Personalization
Personalization refers to structuring the program so that trainees feel they are engaged in a conversation with the program—using conversational vs. formal language
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-44
44
Human Interaction
Human interaction involves including human interaction—trainees are able to interact with the instructor and each other during the training program
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-45
A potential problem of computer-based training for some is the lack of face-to-face interaction with an instructor and other trainees
Trainees may feel isolated and less motivated to learn
By including human interaction in the design of computer-based training programs, this challenge may be overcome through email exchanges, chat rooms, discussion boards, and group projects
45
Feedback
Feedback should be provided to trainees regardless of the nature of the training experience
It can be simple (the answer to a quiz is right or wrong) or more involved (an on-screen virtual coach who provides feedback on how to improve)
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-46
Feedback needs to be provided to trainees
Can include a simple prompt or a virtual coach
46
Benefits of Technology-Based Training—Trainees
Flexibility
Learner control
Self-pacing
Learner-controlled practice difficulty
Adaptive guidance
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-47
Learner control: degree to which the trainee has control over various instructional features during a training session, such as content, sequence, or pace of training
Self-pacing: trainees can work on training tasks as quickly or as slowly as they want
Learner-controlled practice difficulty: the extent to which trainees have control over the level of difficulty of practice opportunities during a training session
Adaptive guidance: an instructional strategy to assist trainees in making effective learning decisions
47
Benefits of Technology-Based Training—Organization
Standardization
Large numbers of trainees/same time
Track employees’ performance in training
Learning management system (LMS)
Travel and overhead costs saved
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-48
Consistency: standardized and consistent training can be delivered to large numbers of employees across the organization and globe
Large numbers/same time: no limit to the number of employees who can be trained, as there are no space or instructor constraints
Track employees’ performance in training: key for mandatory programs that require certification or must attain a certain level of performance by law
Travel and overhead costs saved: travel, facilities, hotel rooms, meals, trainers, employee time off work to travel and attend training
48
Disadvantages of Technology-Based Training—Trainees
Less interpersonal contact and interaction
Computer literacy required
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-49
Less interpersonal contact and interaction—if individuals have a high interpersonal learning style, then CBT disadvantages that employee
Trainees with low computer literacy might resist and fear CBT
49
Disadvantages of Technology-Based Training—Organizations
Up-front development costs
Resistance from employees
Computer literacy
Self-efficacy
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-50
Resistance from employees: some employees who are uncomfortable with computers might refuse CBT
Up-front development costs: extremely costly to develop multimedia programs—estimates of 200 to 300 hours of design and development to produce one hour of instruction
Full-motion colour and sound courseware would likely cost $200,000 for 30 hours of instruction
50
Effectiveness of Technology-Based Training
Studies show it is slightly more effective (6 percent) for declarative knowledge; equally effective for procedural knowledge
Trainees were equally satisfied with both methods
The effectiveness for declarative knowledge was found to depend on a number of factors
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-51
It is worthy to note that a blended approach that combines different instructional methods and includes classroom instruction and the use of computers and technology is most effective
51
Effectiveness of Technology-Based Training
Computer-based training was more effective for declarative knowledge when:
Trainees are older
The instructional methods were different
Trainees were able to choose the training method
Trainees had greater learner control
The training included practice and feedback
The length of the training program was greater
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-52
It is worthy to note that a blended approach that combines different instructional methods and includes classroom instruction and the use of computers and technology is most effective
52
Effectiveness of Technology-Based Training
Blended training, in which computer-based training is used to supplement classroom instruction, has been found to be 13 percent more effective than classroom instruction for teaching declarative knowledge, and 20 percent more effective for teaching procedural knowledge
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-53
It is worthy to note that a blended approach that combines different instructional methods and includes classroom instruction and the use of computers and technology is most effective
53
Summary
Described the meaning of technology-based training, computer-based training, and e-learning
Noted the differences between instructor-led and self-directed learning, synchronous and asynchronous training
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-54
54
Summary
Discussed online and distance education, EPSS, virtual classrooms, video/web conferencing, webinars, and webcasts
Reviewed the use of social media, communities of practice, Web 2.0, and Web 3.0 technologies
Discussed mobile learning and its use for microlearning
Discussed synthetic learning environments (virtual and augmented reality)
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-55
55
Summary
Described how to design technology-based programs and their advantages and disadvantages for trainees and organizations
Concluded with a discussion of the effectiveness of technology-based training compared to traditional training
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-56
56
Key Terms
Adaptive guidance
Adaptive learning
Asynchronous training
Augmented reality
Blog
Communities of practice
Computer-based simulation games
Computer-based training
Customization
E-learning
Electronic performance support system (EPSS)
Gamification
Generative learning
Human interaction
Instructor-led training (ILT)
Knowledge sharing
Learner control
Learner-controlled practice difficulty
Learning management systems (LMS)
Massive open online courses (MOOCs)
Microlearning
Mobile learning (m-learning)
Multimedia training
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-57
57
Key Terms
Online and distance education
Personalization
Podcast
Self-directed learning
Self-pacing
Social media
Small private online courses (SPOCs)
Synchronous training
Synthetic learning environments
Technology-based training
Traditional training
Video conferencing
Virtual classroom
Virtual reality
Virtual worlds
Web 2.0
Web 3.0
Web conferencing
Webcast
Webinar
Wiki
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
7-58
58