PICO and Literature Search
Ijeoma Kemakolam
RubricsforPICO.docx|
Criteria |
Mastery |
Proficient |
Developing |
Beginning |
Unsatisfactory |
Criterion Score |
|
PICO question is properly formatted, per the EBP Step by Step 3 template. |
5 points yes
|
4.5 points |
4 points |
3.5 points |
2.5 points |
/5 |
|
All parts of the PICO are correctly identified for the question. |
10 points 4 parts
|
9 points 3 parts
|
8 points 2 parts
|
7 points 1 part
|
5 points 0 parts
|
/10 |
|
All articles are primary source quantitative research reports |
20 points 4 articles
|
18 points 3 articles
|
16 points 2 articles
|
14 points 1 article
|
10 points 0 articles
|
/20 |
|
All articles help answer the same PICO question |
20 points 4 articles
|
18 points 3 articles
|
16 points 2 articles
|
14 points 1 article
|
10 points 0 articles
|
/20 |
|
Article citations in correct APA format |
10 points no unique errors
|
9 points 1 unique error
|
8 points 2 unique errors
|
7 points 3 unique errors
|
6 points 4 or more unique errors
|
/10 |
|
Articles are no older than 2016 AND PDFs of all articles are provided |
3 points Yes
|
0 points |
0 points |
0 points |
0 points No
|
/3 |
Total /68
Please use articles from EBSCO Academic Search Complete.
Criteri
a
Master
y
Proficient
Developing
Beginni
ng
Unsatisfactory
C
riterion
Scor
e
PIC
O
question is
properly
formatted,
per the EBP
Step by Step
3 template
.
5 points
yes
4.5 p
oints
4 points
3.5 points
2.5 points
/5
All parts of
the PICO
are correctly
identified
for the
question
.
10
points
4 parts
9 p
oints
3 parts
8 points
2 parts
7 points
1 part
5
points
0 parts
/10
A
ll articles
are primary
source
quantitative
research
report
s
2
0
points
4 articles
18 points
3 articles
16 points
2 articles
1
4 points
1 article
1
0 points
0 articles
/20
All articles
help answer
the same
PICO
questio
n
20
points
4 articles
1
8 points
3 articles
1
6 points
2 articles
1
4 points
1 article
1
0 points
0 articles
/20
Article
citations in
correct APA
forma
t
10
points
no
unique
errors
9 points
1 unique
error
8 poin
ts
2 unique
errors
7 points
3 unique
errors
6 points
4 or more
unique errors
/10
Articles are
no older
than 2016
AND PDFs
of all
articles are
provide
d
3 points
Yes
0 point
s
0 point
s
0 point
s
0 points
No
/3
Total
/
68
Please
use articles from EBSCO Academic S
earch Complete.
Criteria
Mastery
Proficient Developing Beginning Unsatisfactory Criterion
Score
PICO
question is
properly
formatted,
per the EBP
Step by Step
3 template.
5 points
yes
4.5 points 4 points 3.5 points 2.5 points /5
All parts of
the PICO
are correctly
identified
for the
question.
10
points
4 parts
9 points
3 parts
8 points
2 parts
7 points
1 part
5 points
0 parts
/10
All articles
are primary
source
quantitative
research
reports
20
points
4 articles
18 points
3 articles
16 points
2 articles
14 points
1 article
10 points
0 articles
/20
All articles
help answer
the same
PICO
question
20
points
4 articles
18 points
3 articles
16 points
2 articles
14 points
1 article
10 points
0 articles
/20
Article
citations in
correct APA
format
10
points
no
unique
errors
9 points
1 unique
error
8 points
2 unique
errors
7 points
3 unique
errors
6 points
4 or more
unique errors
/10
Articles are
no older
than 2016
AND PDFs
of all
articles are
provided
3 points
Yes
0 points 0 points 0 points 0 points
No
/3
Total /68
Please use articles from EBSCO Academic Search Complete.
