Reflection

Performance Area

4

3

2

1

Presentation: 2 page, typed, no contractions, clear, neat

Essay follows all formatting rules

Essay violates one or two formatting rules

Essay violates some formatting rules

Essay does not follow most formatting rules

Spelling, grammar, flow of ideas, and punctuation

Essentially Error free

Requires little improvement

Requires some improvement

Requires plenty of improvement

Organization:

Introduction: summarizes the film

Clear description is presented

Description is fairly clear but needs additional work

Description is somewhat clear and needs more work

Description is not clear

Introduction: describes goal of the documentary

Clear description is presented

Description is fairly clear but needs additional work

Description is somewhat clear and needs more work

Description is not clear

Performance Area

8

6

4

2

Relation between documentary, lectures/class discussions, and textbook readings

Relation is clearly stated. Includes specific citations; material in lectures, discussion

Relation is fairly clear but needs a few additional examples

Relation is somewhat clear and examples are not clear/ needs additional examples

Relation is not clear and no examples are provided

Critique

Identifies and assesses questions that should have been raised by the film; identifies strengths and weaknesses of the film

Relatively good job in identifying and assessing questions that should have been raised by the film; identifies strengths and weaknesses of the film

Somewhat identifies and assesses questions that should have been raised by the film;

Section is not included

Conclusion

Skillfully describes knowledge acquired from documentary

Adequately describes knowledge acquired from documentary

Simplistic description ; limited clarity and complexion of thought

No conclusion presented