Periodontal Case Classification
Rubric for Periodontal Paper 1
Baltimore City Community College
Dental Hygiene
Rubric for Periodontal Papers
Please use the following rubric to construct your periodontal papers. This rubric is designed specifically for Periodontal Papers.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Criteria |
10-8 |
7-5 |
4-2 |
1-0 |
|
Patient Identification |
The paper utilizes all available data to clearly state the existing Periodontal condition. In addition, the paper identifies recommended treatment. |
The paper utilizes some of the data to identify the periodontal condition. The paper provides recommendations for treatment. |
The paper identifies the periodontal condition without the utilization of collected data. The paper provides a minimum amount of recommendations for treatment. |
The paper does not utilize the collected data to identify the existing periodontal condition and does not provide recommendation for treatment. |
|
|
10-8 |
7-5 |
4-2 |
1-0 |
|
Symptoms and Rationale |
The paper clearly identifies all contributory factors of periodontal disease and identifies how each factor impacts the patient’s current periodontal condition. Moreover, the paper clearly identifies the prognosis and follow-up procedure including any necessary referrals for the patient. |
The paper identifies most contributory factors of periodontal disease and identifies how each factor impacts the patient’s current periodontal condition. The paper vaguely identifies the prognosis and follow-up procedure including any necessary referrals. |
The paper identifies a few contributory factors of periodontal disease, but does not associate these factors to the patient’s current periodontal condition. The paper lacks a prognosis, follow-up plan, and/or referrals. |
The paper does not identify contributory factors of periodontal disease and fails to mention the prognosis for the patient. |
|
|
7-6 |
5-4 |
3-2 |
1-0 |
|
Scientific Accuracy |
The paper contains a minimum of 5 different references (within the past 5 years), 2 primary resources, and a bibliography/ reference list. |
The paper contains a minimum of 3-4 different references (within the past 5 years), 1-2 primary resources, and a bibliography/ reference list. |
The paper contains a minimum of 1-2 different references (within the past 5-8 years), 1 primary resources, and a bibliography/ reference list. |
The paper does not meet the minimum reference requirements, and does not contain a reference list. |
|
|
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
|
Proper Format |
The paper follows the APA format. The paper meets the required page length and each page is numbered. The paper is properly labeled with appropriate headings. The paper contains a cover page, 12pt font, doubled spaced, and uses Calibri print style. |
The paper meets the required page length and each page is numbered. The paper is properly labeled with appropriate headings. The paper contains a cover page, 12pt font, doubled spaced, and uses Calibri print style |
The paper does not meet the required page length and the pages are not numbered. The paper lacks the proper headings. The paper contains a cover page, 12pt font, doubled spaced, and uses Calibri print style |
The paper does not follow the APA format or meet the basic format requirements.
|
|
|
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
|
Timeliness |
The paper is turned in on or before the due date with the appropriate attached material |
The paper is turned a day after the due date. |
The paper is turned in two days after the due date. |
The paper is turned in 3 or more days after the due date. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Instructor Signature: |
|
Final Grade: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|