Journal Article Review (Following the Scientific Method)

Rubric Detail Select Grid View or List View to change the rubric's layout.

Outstanding Very Good Meets Expectations Does Not MeetExpectations

Assignment Content (see assignment instructions for details)

Extent to which assignment criteria are met:

•Summarize the purpose of the study.

•Identify the stated or implied hypothesis [or expected outcome(s)].

•Describe the variables examined in the study.

•Summarize the research methodology used in carrying out the study including study participants, study design, data gathering procedures, and statistical analyses.

19 (38%) - 20 (40%) Thoroughly addresses all required components with a well-developed, cohesive, scholarly, original, and insightful narrative that exceeds expectations.

18 (36%) - 18 (36%) Addresses all required components with a well- developed, well supported, and original narrative.

16 (32%) - 17 (34%) Addresses the required components with sufficient original, accurate, and supported content.

0 (0%) - 15 (30%) Addresses only some or no required components, content is inaccurate, unoriginal, or unsupported.

Critical Thinking and Analysis

Critical thinking, analysis, and synthesis of credible and appropriate source material

19 (38%) - 20 (40%) An insightful narrative which critically analyzes, evaluates, and applies content. Connects concepts throughout assignment with multiple appropriate resources and examples.

18 (36%) - 18 (36%) Content is well developed, analyzed, and synthesized and clearly connected to appropriate resources and examples.

16 (32%) - 17 (34%) Content is presented and supported with some appropriate resources and examples.

0 (0%) - 15 (30%) Content is not supported with appropriate resources or lacks connection to examples or does not show intellectual application of content.

Written Communication and Expression

Writing clarity and quality, spelling, grammar, sentence structure, punctuation, and APA format

9.5 (19%) - 10 (20%) Writing is exceptionally well organized and scholarly. Content is fully synthesized and free of grammatical or spelling errors. Fully meets all APA requirements.

9 (18%) - 9 (18%) Writing is above average, well organized, concise, and written with minimal to no grammatical, spelling, or citation errors. Synthesis of content is well demonstrated.

8 (16%) - 8 (16%) Writing meets basic expectations for clarity, organization, citations, grammar, spelling, and APA, and shows some synthesis, with minimal reliance on quoting.

0 (0%) - 7 (14%) Writing does not meet basic expectations. Lacks clarity, organization, or has significant grammatical, spelling, or APA or citation issues, or does not demonstrate synthesis of source material, with excessive reliance on quoting.

Total Points: 50

Name: PUBH_6033_Week1_Assignment2_Rubric

Description: PUBH 6033D/PUBH 6033P/PUBH 8033/PUBH 8033D/PUBH 8033H Week 1 Assignment 2 Rubric EXIT

Grid View List View

Name: PUBH_6033_Week1_Assignment2_Rubric

Description: PUBH 6033D/PUBH 6033P/PUBH 8033/PUBH 8033D/PUBH 8033H Week 1 Assignment 2 Rubric

EXIT