Professional Development Plan (KA) Paper

MBA-525 Professional Development Plan (KA) Course: Professional Development MBA-525-MBOL1

Criteria No Submission Novice Basic Proficient Exceptional Criterion Score

Plan Content -

Summary (5

Points) (MBA

6.1, 8.1, 11.1)

/ 5

Plan Content -

SWOT Analysis

(10 Points)

(MBA 6.1, 8.1,

11.1)

/ 10

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

2 points

No summary

provided

Below 3

3 points

Summary

captures

few/some major

aspects of the

plan in a wordy

manner.

3 Points

4 points

Summary

captures

some/all major

aspects of the

plan in an

adequate way.

4 Points

5 points

Summary

captures all

major aspects of

the plan in a

succinct way.

4 – 5 Points

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

6 points

SWOT analysis

not completed.

Below 7

8 points

Analysis missing

two or more

required

components.

7-8 Points

9 points

Analysis missing

one required

component.

8-9 Points

10 points

Each of the four

dimensions of

the SWOT is

completed and

SMART goals

noted.

9-10 Points

6/19/25, 4:57 PM Rubric Assessment - Professional Development MBA-525-MBOL1 - Saint Leo University

https://saintleo.brightspace.com/d2l/lms/competencies/rubric/rubrics_assessment_results.d2l?ou=174976&evalObjectId=571253&evalObjectType=1&userId=129041&viewTypeId=3&rubricId=238909&gr… 1/5

Criteria No Submission Novice Basic Proficient Exceptional Criterion Score

Plan Content -

Present

Findings (15

Points) (MBA

6.1, 8.1, 11.1)

/ 15

Plan Content -

Updated

Personal

SWOT (15

Points)

/ 15

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

2 points

Finding(s) of

assessments not

identified or

explained.

Below 11

12 points

Finding(s) of

assessments are

identified, but

not discussed

enough to reflect

understanding.

11-12 Points

13 points

Finding(s) of

assessments are

summarized and

adequate.

12-13 Points

15 points

Finding(s) of

assessments are

clearly presented

and explained in

own words

reflecting own

understanding of

outcomes.

13-15 Points

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

2 points

SWOT just

restated or

summarized only.

No comparison

made.

Below 11

12 points

Vague update

and comparison;

does not

demonstrate

critical thinking.

11-12 Points

13 points

Adequate update

and comparison;

demonstrates

some critical

thinking.

12-13 Points

15 points

Excellent update

and comparison

to initial SWOT

analysis;

demonstrates

critical thinking.

13-15 Points

6/19/25, 4:57 PM Rubric Assessment - Professional Development MBA-525-MBOL1 - Saint Leo University

https://saintleo.brightspace.com/d2l/lms/competencies/rubric/rubrics_assessment_results.d2l?ou=174976&evalObjectId=571253&evalObjectType=1&userId=129041&viewTypeId=3&rubricId=238909&gr… 2/5

Criteria No Submission Novice Basic Proficient Exceptional Criterion Score

Plan Content -

Development

Opportunity

(15 Points)

/ 15

Writing -

Mechanics (15

Points)

/ 15

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

2 points

Opportunity not

discussed.

Below 11

12 points

Development

opportunity is

briefly discussed

but omits both

actionable items

or timelines.

11-12 Points

13 points

Development

opportunity is

briefly discussed

but omits either

actionable items

or timelines.

12-13 Points

15 points

Development

opportunity is

clearly defined

with actionable

items and

timelines.

13-15 Points

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

2 points

Mechanics are

inadequate for

graduate level

work.

Below 11

12 points

Mechanics need

significant

improvements to

be graduate

level.

11-12 Points

13 points

Mechanics are

adequate, but

need minor

improvement to

be graduate

level.

12-13 Points

15 points

Demonstrates

evidence of

graduate-level

writing skills:

grammar,

punctuation,

sentence

structure,

paragraph

structure, etc.

13-15 Points

6/19/25, 4:57 PM Rubric Assessment - Professional Development MBA-525-MBOL1 - Saint Leo University

https://saintleo.brightspace.com/d2l/lms/competencies/rubric/rubrics_assessment_results.d2l?ou=174976&evalObjectId=571253&evalObjectType=1&userId=129041&viewTypeId=3&rubricId=238909&gr… 3/5

Total / 100

Criteria No Submission Novice Basic Proficient Exceptional Criterion Score

Writing - Paper

Requirements

(15 Points)

/ 15

Writing -

Formatting

Requirements

(10 Points)

/ 10

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

2 points

Paper meets

minimum

requirements

Below 11

12 points

Paper meets

some

requirements

11-12 Points

13 points

Paper meets

most

requirements

12-13 Points

15 points

Minimum paper

requirements (15

pages, topic, 10

peer-reviewed

articles, research,

integration of

core values) are

met.

13-15 Points

0 points

No Assignment

Submitted.

6 points

Formatting

meets minimum

requirements

Below 7

8 points

Formatting

meets some

requirements

7-8 Points

9 points

Formatting

meets most

requirements

8-9 Points

10 points

Follows

formatting

requirements

given (e.g. APA,

section headings,

page numbers,

title page).

9-10 Points

6/19/25, 4:57 PM Rubric Assessment - Professional Development MBA-525-MBOL1 - Saint Leo University

https://saintleo.brightspace.com/d2l/lms/competencies/rubric/rubrics_assessment_results.d2l?ou=174976&evalObjectId=571253&evalObjectType=1&userId=129041&viewTypeId=3&rubricId=238909&gr… 4/5

Overall Score

Level 1 0 points minimum

Level 2 70 points minimum

Level 3 80 points minimum

Level 4 90 points minimum

6/19/25, 4:57 PM Rubric Assessment - Professional Development MBA-525-MBOL1 - Saint Leo University

https://saintleo.brightspace.com/d2l/lms/competencies/rubric/rubrics_assessment_results.d2l?ou=174976&evalObjectId=571253&evalObjectType=1&userId=129041&viewTypeId=3&rubricId=238909&gr… 5/5