Final report
BUSINESS CONTINUITY & CRISIS MANAGEMENT
Thursday, 23 July 2020
AUDIT | TAX I CONSULTING
3
Content
1 Introduction
2 What is BCM and Crisis Management
3 BCM and Risk Management
4 What we know on pandemic crisis
5 What is the impact of crisis
6 What we know on current and expected economic trends
7 BCM Recovery Cycle
8 What should we do post crisis
9 What we expect to see in 2020 and 2021
10 What needs to exist and be operating effectively
11 Q&A
4
Reports that say that something hasn't happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns—the ones we don't know we don't know. And if one looks throughout the history of our country and other free countries, it is the latter category that tend to be the difficult ones
Donald Rumsfeld
5
What is BCM
and Crisis
Management
What is BCM?
Business continuity (BC) is defined as the capability of the
organization to continue delivery of products or services at
acceptable predefined levels following a disruptive incident.
(Source: ISO 22301:2012)
An enterprise-wide program designed to sustainably increase the
resilience of critical business processes of an organization, reacting
appropriately to adverse events and enabling the resumption of key
business activities in a timely and effective manner
Three major plans that are developed as part of BCM
Business
Continuity Plan
1
IT Continuity &
Disaster
Recovery Plan
2
Crisis
Management Plan
3
Business Continuity Management Lifecycle
6
7
What is BCM
and Crisis
Management
What is Crisis Management?
Crisis management is the process by which organizations deal
with disruptive events that could cause serious damage, be it
financial, health & safety, reputation etc.
Crisis management is a vital organizational component to ensure
sustainability of organizations during such situations.
Organizations need to take a rapid approach to ensure effective
crisis management and handling the threat sequentially.
Detection
Notification
Preparation
Response
Recovery
Crisis Management Lifecycle
8
COVID-19
Challenges
Financial Operations Technology
These are some major challenges that organizations have faced during the pandemic due the lack of continuity planning
9
COVID-19
Challenges
Financial Operations Technology
Organizations had issues in managing their cash flows due to sudden reduction in budgets/revenues
Cost management challenges
These are some major challenges that organizations have faced during the pandemic due the lack of continuity planning
10
COVID-19
Challenges
Financial Operations Technology
Inability to manage employee working arrangements (shifts, hours, allocations) accordingly due to lack of
human resource continuity planning
Vendor/Supplier/Sub-contractor related disruptions
Ineffective communication with external parties like clients, gov’t bodies, vendors/suppliers, media, etc.
These are some major challenges that organizations have faced during the pandemic due the lack of continuity planning
11
COVID-19
Challenges
Financial
These are some major challenges that organizations have faced during the pandemic due the lack of continuity planning
Operations Technology
We have seen many organizations were not able to conduct business operations because working from
home infrastructure was not planned
Lack of hardware / software for remote working leading to inability perform daily operations
Security matters were not considered when new technologies were adopted urgently
12
What we know
on the
Pandemic
10.7 Mill Cases reported worldwide,
as of 02 July
5.4 Mill Recovered worldwide,
as of 02 July
-0.8474 Change in US treasury
bond yield since Wuhan
lockdown on 23 January
515,000 Total deaths reported
worldwide
-6% Change in MSCI World
Index of global stocks since
Wuhan lockdown on 23
January
-2.3% Global GDP Tracker
(annualised)
13
Anatomy of the
Crisis
Source: RSM US LLP
Covid-19 outbreak • Loss of confidence
• Increase in uncertainty
• Lower capital and longer-term investment
• Negative wealth effect
• Digital modernisation deferred
Shutdown of normal life and
manufacturing initially in Asia and
then globally
Fiscal
policy
response
Maintain household income via:
• Plugging holes in private balance
sheets
• Increase social safety-net
spending
• Job creation via infrastructure
spending
• Job protection strategies
Monetary
policy
response
• Resumption of low interest rate
regime
• Forward guidance to increase
confidence and suppress long
end of yield curve to stimulate
investor activity
Demand
shock
Financial
shock
Supply
shock
Shutdown Exogenous
shock
• Loss of output from Asian economies
• Loss of income directly and indirectly
dependent on goods from Asian supply chains
• Loss of Asia’s demand for foreign goods
and “foreign” goods produced in Asia (eg
iPhones/tech)
• After initial stockpiling, loss of US/UK
domestic demand for goods due to
uncertainty
14
What is the
impact of
COVID-19?
Staff Lay-offs
Paid/Unpaid Leave
Reduce operational hours
Flexible working arrangement such as work
from home
Work rotation
Reduce/Halt output
Closure of branches/locations
Move to online and delivery services
Cut capital spending
Reduced procurement spending
Cost cutting
Delay projects impacting payments
These are some apparent actions that organizations have taken and we have observed them in the short term.
15
Crisis Management Cycle BCM
Recovery Cycle
Business As Usual
P e rf
o rm
a n c e
First lockdown
accouchement
12 March
Recovery Efforts – Current Focus
Business As Usual
• Emergency/Crisis Response Plan
• Business Continuity plans
• IT continuity plans
Second
Lockdown
announcement
26 March
Third Lockdown
announcement
22 April
Crucial Crisis Response Effort
Time
16
What to do
post crisis?
Phase 1 – Assess the crisis
Assess the current situation (market
condition, recovery efforts, government
directions)
Take the necessary decision to declare
crisis is over and ensure the return of
employees
Phase 2 – Post crisis recovery
Assess the actual impact to the organizations
and develop the necessary strategies and
action plans to ensure full recovery
Establish effective Communications with
stakeholder
Phase 3 – Maintenance
Develop the necessary documentations
and plans following the crisis to enhance
resilience, and ensure continuous
activities
It is important for organization to take a phased approach to ensure recovery are successful and effective
We have addressed some actions that you can take in the upcoming slides.
17
Phase 1 – Assess the crisis
Monitor market conditions and arrange staffing requirements
Ensure the safe return of employees to office and continue to take precautionary measures
Communicate positive messages to your employees and thank for their efforts
Ensure flexibility with leaves and working arrangement
Identify payments that has been delayed or pending repayments from clients/customers
Re-assess technology needs and requirements at this point in time
Revisit your Strategy
Question is, can we deliver all our services/product to our client?
What to do
post crisis?
Immediate Actions to Take
Establish Workforce and
workspace plan
Establish return to office criteria
and checklist
Establish HR plans pertaining to
employee welfare and well being
18
Return/Re-activation Strategies
Requirements for
the returning
Hygiene & other precautionary
measures
Employee return to work
Technology requirements and
changes
Support for reactivation
Business support
Budget & funding management
Workspace planning / analysis
Scenario planning
Rolling forecasts
Revise Strategy (Finance,
investment etc.)
19
Phase 2 – Post Crisis Recovery
Conduct an Impact and Damage Assessment on the organization. e.g. Impact on reputation,
financial, operational, etc.
Assess any insurance coverages that can be claimed
Develop and Communicate strategies and plan to your stakeholders on returning back to
normal operational capabilities. Involvement of PR highly recommended
Conduct lessons learnt from the crisis and identify improvement plans.
Document Post-Crisis report
What to do
post crisis?
Immediate Actions to Take
Independent review of the business
action plans and communications
strategies and plans
Review effectiveness of
crisis communication
plan and strategies
Establish business action plans,
strategies and communication
channels
Monitor current financial
position and establish
plan to limit losses
20
What to do
post crisis?
Communicate re-opening strategies with KFAS centers and
external parties
Build communication plans to protect brand and image with
customers/ visitors/ stakeholders
Increase in digital marketing for communication
Establish effective communication with the contributors
Communication plan & strategies Develop phased approach to the “New Normal”
Determine the scale, pace and depth of immediate crisis
action required to sustain the operations
Centers and employees will need to act on broader
resilience plans amid uncertainty about the future
Consider new approaches to carry out activities/business.
Refocusing resources. Concentration on re-training and
rebuilding workforce capabilities and productivity
Support and promote innovation. Better insight/foresight in
the pursuit of resilience, efficiency and to embrace new
opportunities.
21
Phase 3 – Maintenance
Develop comprehensive BCM program to address crisis in the future
Enhance and fine tune certain operational policies and procedures to adopt
a more resilient perspective
Conduct BCM awareness training to employees to increase awareness
Conduct live simulations/scenarios to enhance preparedness to face such
crises in future
Ensure continuous stress testing and testing of BCM Plans
What to do
post crisis?
Immediate Actions to Take
Develop/ Enhance BCM
Framework
Enhance current operational
policies and procedures
22
Employee mental health and wellbeing
Employers must be mindful of employee mental health upon returning to work.
Kuwait has established a national counseling program (CoronaCare) that provides free
counseling sessions to those affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, i.e.:
Medical health professionals on the frontline
COVID-19 patients
Individuals in institutionalized quarantine
General public
What to do
post crisis?
23
Technology
post crisis
Organizations have adopted the working from home arrangement during the
pandemic
This arrangement involves providing users with certain IT
services/systems/devices to perform work. E.g. Laptops, IP telephones,
Hand held devices, VPN etc.
Due to the fact that operations have alternative working arrangement, users
has been given additional privileges on systems to conduct daily
operations.
Access rights producing segregation of duties conflict (e.g., Creation and
approval process by one person)
System privilege access
Administrative rights on systems
During Crisis
24
Technology
post crisis
These are some steps that your organization can take when the crisis is over and return to office is possible
Technology Post-Crisis Consideration
Remove VPN accounts
Review VPN access logs
Disable access through mobile devices
Ensure all tokens and dongles are returned back
Ensure laptops are returned back
Review all access rights granted to users and align to current situation
Remove administrative and high privilege accounts that are no longer
required
Re-route telephones back to primary office
Immediate Actions to Take
Prepare an IT action plan for
returning to office
Identify requirements for alternative
working arrangement based on the
workforce and workspace plan
Communication to all employees
on IT action plans
25
Post COVID-19
What we would expect to see in during the remaining of 2020 and 2021
Governments continue to support
business
Country policies are changing to address
current situation
Job market slowdown and lower
employment rates
Consumer prices increase
Budget cuts in governmental sector
leading to reduction in projects
Less spending of disposable income
Economy
Social distancing will continue to apply
Companies stress on hygiene in
workplace
Increase in expenditure for hygiene
products
Increase in safety & hygiene awareness
Health
Alternative working environment is a
norm (e.g., Rotation, Work from home,
Less working days a week etc.)
Prudent spending on expansions
Companies adopt digital means including
analytics
At times, requirements for additional
cybersecurity requirements for working
from home conditions
Reassess the need for full capacity
working on-site
Day-to-day operations
26
What Needs to
Exist and Be
Operating
Effectively
27
What Needs to Exist and Be
Operating Effectively
No Items
1 BCM Governance and Structure
2 BCM Program Framework
3 Business Impact Analysis
4 Threat Risk Assessment
5 Resilience strategies
6 Testing
7 Training and Awareness
8 Business Continuity Plans and Operational Recovery Plans
9 Incident Management Plans
10 Crisis Management Plan
11 Compliance and Monitoring
12 IT Continuity plan and disaster recovery plans
13 Cyber Security Incident response plans
Conduct GAP
Assessment and
maturity assessment
Typically Clients request
Develop BCM
Framework program
and plans
Establish workforce
and workspace
return plans
Independent review
of business action
plans (Operation
and IT)
Independent review
of business action
plans and strategies
Enhance operational
procedures (HR,
Finance, Operations
etc.)
Independent review
of communication
plans and
improvement
Establish return to
office criteria and
checklist
Support on HR
recovery action plan
Conduct
independent post-
crisis assessment
RSM Albazie Consulting W.L.L. is a member of the RSM network and trades as RSM. RSM is the trading name used by the members of the RSM network.
Each member of the RSM network is an independent accounting and consulting firm, each of which practices in its own right. The RSM network is not itself a separate legal entity of any
description in any jurisdiction.
The RSM network is administered by RSM International Limited, a company registered in England and Wales (company number 4040598) whose registered office is at 50 Cannon Street,
London EC4N 6JJ.
The brand and trademark RSM and other intellectual property rights used by members of the network are owned by RSM International Association, an association governed by article 60 et
seq of the Civil Code of Switzerland whose seat is in Zug.
© RSM International Association 2020.