800 words
English 103: Analyzing and Interpreting Literature – Assignment 2
|
Category |
Unacceptable (0-1) |
Needs Improvement (2-3) |
Good (4) |
Excellent (5) |
Total Possible Points |
|
Structure (x3) |
Structure is illogical or significantly hinders understanding |
Arguments are difficult to identify; ideas are disjointed |
Evidence is provided & is relevant to the thesis, but transitions and connections are lacking |
Arguments are well integrated; ideas flow logically; main points are identifiable |
6/15 |
|
Analysis (x3) |
No examples are used to support arguments; analysis is missing or incorrect |
Few or weak examples are given to support main points |
Examples are given to support most points, but not all; analysis lacks originality |
All main points are supported with evidence and include original analysis |
6/15 |
|
Thesis (x2) |
Thesis is missing |
Thesis lacks clarity or is not well-developed |
Thesis adequately states the student's argument |
Thesis clearly & logically states the student's argument |
2/10 |
|
Mechanics (x2) |
Incorrect spelling, punctuation, capitalization, and use of standard English grammar hinders understanding |
Several instances of incorrect spelling, punctuation, capitalization, and usage of standard English grammar |
Few instances of incorrect spelling, punctuation, capitalization, and usage of standard English grammar |
No or very few instances of incorrect spelling, punctuation, capitalization, and usage of standard English grammar |
6/10 |
Grade: 20/50
Grader Notes:
· The structure is confusing and goes through several literary works without a proper connecting idea or logical chain of thought. Some form of transition needs to be included.
· The analysis is very dependent upon one source – to such an extent that you have a very modest degree of original analysis.
· The only sentence of your conclusion could somewhat be a thesis, but it is more of an introductory statement. You lack a central idea to which all of your key points will somehow be related. First design your thesis then decide on your key points. This will make the structure a lot more logical.
· Reference list does not conform to the APA guide. In the body of your essay you often forget to place a comma after an introductory phrase. An example is: ‘’ On the same note he advises the reader to always be very keen on how to deal with love because love begins when only the other person becomes convinced and she or he feels that she wants to be involved in the relationship.’’