assigment

1

International College of Manitoba- Fall 2021

POLS 1502

Reflection Paper Topic & Instructions

Question:

A state is an independent, self-governing political community whose governing

institutions have the capability to make rules that are binding on the population residing within

a particular territory. Consequently, states claim to have “the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory” (Weber, 1970, p. 78). The modern nation-state, has no doubt, been affected by globalization. Globalization is defined in general terms as the fading or

complete disappearance of economic, social, and cultural borders between nation-states. Some

scholars have theorized that states will increasingly become less relevant in a globalized world.

In other words, the sovereignty of states (which gives them a claim as the highest authority

within the territory, while not being subject to any higher external authority), would be

compromised or negatively affected.

Using concrete examples from the real world, write a reflection essay on the nature and

significance of globalization on the sovereignty of the modern nation-state. What do you think

the future of Nation-states in a continuously globalized world would look like?

Important note on reflection essays:

Reflective writing has four basic stages. First, you are asked to explain course materials. Next,

you are challenged to reflect explicitly on how this material calls into question your

preconceptions about the topic. Third, you analyze the conflicts, confusions, or questions that

arise from engaging your preconceptions. And finally, you formulate plans to use the

knowledge gained by the reflective process. In short, reflective writing invites you to search

for the truth rather than develop rhetorical skills.

Important Instructions:

Students will write and submit a 1500-word paper for this topic. Each paper must be typed,

double-spaced, printed single-sided, and use Times New Roman font size 12 and the APA Style

for referencing and citations.

Submission:

Submit your reflection papers to my email- [email protected]

Due Dates: Section 1 - Week 6 (October 11, 2021)

Section 2 – Week 6 (October 12, 2021)

–

2

Essay assignments submitted after the due date will not be accepted. I will consider extensions

on a case by case basis and in accordance with the policies laid out on page 6 of the course

outline. If you have a valid and documented reason for needing an extension of the due date,

please speak with me well ahead of the due date for this assignment.

Summary of Essay Assignment Guidelines:

Minimum Requirements Length:

The paper length must be 1500 words, double spaced and typed (this does not include your

title page, or bibliography page). Your paper must have a cover page with the title of your paper

and your name. The bibliography should be listed on a separate page after the body of the

paper. All pages of your paper must be numbered. Again, use Times New Roman font size 12

and the APA Style for referencing and citations.

Number of references:

Your paper should include a minimum of 6-8 references/sources.

NOTE: Wikipedia (and other similar websites) is not an acceptable source – if you cite Wikipedia, you will lose points.

Content of the Paper

Title Page:

Ensure that you have a suitable title for your essay on your cover page.

Introduction:

Purpose/background: The background, purpose, problem, or question to be considered

is stated clearly. The problem chosen is focused enough to be covered in the space of the

paper, but not too narrow. The introduction must also contain a preview of how the problem or

issue identified will be handled, with a strong thesis statement. This should be done in an

interesting manner to convince and pique the reader’s interest in your paper. Body:

A clear analysis of the information to support the arguments proposed. Your assumptions

are logical, with presentation of evidence to support them. Good integration of assertions. If

sources contradict one another they must be dealt with adequately. Multiple sources are compared

in cases where available without simply listing of information. The points/arguments are internally

consistent, (i.e. one point follows from another logically), plausible and well supported with

sources. Presentation and argumentation must be easy to follow and well organized

Conclusion:

3

The paper must have a conclusion that summarizes the findings adequately and draws

appropriate conclusions. Implications of the findings are discussed where appropriate. If

focusing on a problem, propose ways to fix it. Finish on a note that reinforces your message.

Important Note: Ensure your writing includes

i. Correct spelling.

ii. Correct use of grammar and words (no awkward or inappropriate use of words and phrases)

A clear analysis of the information to support the arguments proposed. Your assumptions are

logical, with presentation of evidence to support them. Good integration of arguments. If

sources contradict one another they must be dealt with adequately. Multiple sources are

compared in cases where available without simply listing of information. The points/arguments

are internally consistent, (i.e. one point follows from another logically), plausible and well

supported with sources. Presentation and argumentation must be easy to follow and well

organized.

iii. Paragraph form: Topic sentences are used to introduce transitions, and the order of

transitions is appropriate, with proper use of punctuations.

iv. Borrowed ideas and statements are given credit (citations used frequently and listed in

bibliography).

Bibliography/References:

Your bibliography or reference section must be on a new page. List all references alphabetically

by author's last name. Only cite materials that were discussed/referenced in your paper. All

materials that were cited in your paper must appear in the reference section.

4

Rubrics for the Reflection Paper to guide students:

Criteria Excellent Very good Average Poor Mark

for

each

Quality of

insights

Paper offers

insights on all

aspects of the

topic/issue,

provides

additional

relevant sources,

asks critical

questions, extend

ideas, challenges

readings/textboo

k materials, show

above-

expectations

reflections. Links

insights from

different

sources/authors

Paper offers very

good insights on

topics/issues,

additional

sources, show

good

understanding,

asks provocative

questions.

Paper

provides a

good

overview and

understandin

g of concepts,

offer few if

any

additional

sources,

show cursory

reflections.

Report provides

an overview but

no significant

insights or

reflections.

Comprehension

of material in

doubt.

5/5

point

s

Writing Writing is clear,

uses correct

grammar and

punctuation,

shows logical flow

and very good

readability.

Contains minor

errors but still

readable.

Contains

several

proofing

errors and/or

errors in logic

and English

language.

Poorly written,

containing

grammatical and

technical errors.

5 /5

point

s

Citation/sourc

es

Cites all sources

properly, in APA.

All sources are

reliable- peer

reviewed/academ

ic sources

Cites most

sources properly

and in APA. Most

sources are peer

reviewed/academ

ic

Inconsistent

citation, cites

some

sources, does

not cite

others, cites

non-

academic/pe

er reviewed

sources

Does not cite at

all, citation

inconsistent,

Majority of

sources not peer

reviewed/academ

ic

5/5

point

s

Total 15

/15