For DR. Adeline Zoe

The referee reports are individual reviews of assigned technical academic papers or policy reports. The report should start off with a one-paragraph summary of the main argument of the article, along with any of its strengths. You should describe your main 3-4 critiques in detail as if you were writing directly to the author and conclude the report with more minor comments. A good referee report not only clearly states the shortcomings of the work, but also lays out constructive, detailed and realistic suggestions for improvements.

I have posted two examples of referee reports that I have written below, which are different in style, content and the types of critiques.  I have also posted a short video outlining my expectations of referee reports.