Unit 4 FD D

profileTT24
ReadChapt91415Theexpandingfamilylifecycle-Individualfamilyandsocialperspectives5thed..pdf

McGoldrick, M., Preto, N. A. G., & Carter, B. A. (2015). The expanding family life cycle: Individual, family, and social perspectives (5th ed.). Pearson. https://bookshelf.vitalsource.com/books/9780134001180 Chapter 9 Siblings and the Life Cycle Monica McGoldrick Marlene F. Watson Learning Objectives

 Explain the significance of sibling relationships through the family life cycle.

 Describe the effects that age spacing has on sibling relationships.

 Examine how gender roles influence sibling patterns in understanding a family.

 Discuss how class, culture, and race impact sibling patterns.

 List and describe the characteristics associated with a person’s birth order.

 Describe how a disabled sibling impacts family dynamics through the family life cycle.

 Identify and describe patterns that sibling relationships follow during young adulthood.

 Examine how sibling relationships impact couple relationships.

 Discuss the challenges to sibling relationships during midlife and after the death of parents.

 List and describe rules for dealing with sibling relationships through the family life

cycle.er, 2012). The Importance of Sibling Relationships Through the Life Cycle Sibling relationships are the longest that most of us have in life. Indeed, from a life cycle perspective, the sibling bond may be second only to the parent–child bond in importance. In our modern world, spouses may come and go, parents die, and children grow up and leave, but if we are lucky, siblings are always there. During the middle phases of the life cycle, siblings may be preoccupied with partners, children, and work, but as people move through the life cycle, sibling relationships show increasing prominence (Cicirelli, 1994, 1995, 2002; White & Riedman, 1992a; Meinhold, 2006; McKay & Caverly, 2004; Friedman, 2003). Our parents usually die a generation before we do, and our children live on for a generation after us. It is rare that our spouses are closely acquainted with our first 20 or 30 years or for friendships to last from earliest childhood until the end of our lives. Our siblings thus share more of our lives genetically and contextually than anyone else, particularly sisters, since sisters tend to be emotionally more

connected and are likely to live longer than brothers. In fact, we can divorce a spouse much more finally than a sibling (McGoldrick, 1989b). Yet sibling relationships have been largely neglected in the family therapy literature and in the mental health field in general. Children generally spend more of their out-of-school time in childhood with siblings than with anyone else in their lives (McHale & Crouter, 2005) and are more likely to grow up in households with siblings than with fathers. In later life, once parents are gone, the sibling bond can become our primary attachment, though at that point sibling relationships also become optional and may break apart (Gold, 1987, 1989; Norris & Tindale, 1994). Especially in recent times as parents are living longer and often need long-term caretaking, conflicts among siblings can become painfully intensified in late middle age (Friedman, 2003; Connidis & Kemp, 2008; Walker, Allen & Connidis, 2005). It is a great mystery why family scholars and developmental psychologists so often overlook this area of study, given the primary reciprocity of siblings to well-being throughout life (McHale & Crouter, 2005). Apart from Adler’s (1959, 1979) early formulations, followed up by Walter Toman’s Family Constellation (1976), hardly any attention has been paid to siblings in the psychological literature. Luckily, a number of excellent works in the past few years have begun to counter this neglect. For more psychological literature on siblings, see Bank and Kahn’s The Sibling Bond (2008), Kahn and Lewis’s Siblings in Therapy (1988), Barbara Mathias’s Between Sisters (1992), Marianne Sandmaier’s Original Kin (1994), Susan Scarf Merrell’s The Accidental Bond (1995), Frank Sulloway’s Born to Rebel (1996), Victor Cicirelli’s Sibling Relationships across the Life Span (1995), and George Howe Colt’s Brothers (2012). In our view, the neglect of siblings in the literature reflects cultural attitudes that overvalue the individual and nuclear family experience and neglect the lifelong connections that we have to our extended family members throughout the life cycle. We hope that this chapter will encourage therapists to affirm the importance of sibling connections through the life cycle in all clinical assessments, and validate sibling relationships through therapeutic interventions that support and strengthen these bonds and to hold specific sibling sessions when appropriate. Perhaps our therapies would be facilitated if we worked on the basic assumption of including siblings unless there is a reason not to. That is, in doing an assessment, we could start with the question “Why not have a sibling session to understand or help clients in this situation?” rather than starting with the negative and including siblings only if there is a specific sibling conflict, as is the assumption of most clinical guidelines. In some families, relationships with siblings remain the most important throughout life. In others, sibling rivalry and conflict cause families to break apart. Siblings are models for future relationships with friends, lovers, and other contemporaries, and for a significant portion of the population, their strongest and most intimate relationships.

In today’s world of frequent divorce and remarriage, there may be a combination of siblings, stepsiblings, and half-siblings who live in different households and come together only on special occasions. There are more multi-racial and multi-ethnic siblings and families with siblings of different backgrounds, with the potential for greater cultural richness, and also for sibling resentments and conflicts around skin color, race, or ethnicity, which are important to address. Additionally, adoption may result in multi-racial/multi-ethnic siblings with the same potential for increased cultural enrichment as well as possible resentment and conflict in adulthood. There are also more only children, whose closest sibling-like relationships will be with their friends or cousins. There are more two-child families as well, in which the relationship between the children tends to be more intense for the lack of other siblings, especially if their parents divorce or if they are close in age. Thus, sibling relationships may become more salient for the current generation because of all the factors that are diminishing the size of the family and community network. Clearly, the more time siblings spend with one another and the fewer siblings there are, the more intense their relationships are likely to be. Furthermore, siblings who have little contact with outsiders grow to rely on each other, especially when parents are absent, unavailable, or inadequate. Though there has been extremely little research on longitudinal aspects of sibling relationships, siblings generally seem to have a commitment to maintaining their relationships throughout life, and it is rare for them to break off their relationship or lose touch with each other completely (Cicirelli, 1985, 2002). Among the few findings that we have are data showing that siblings of the disabled, especially sisters, are particularly likely to become drawn into emotional caretaking demands from their families. Involving siblings in planning and treatment obviously benefits the whole family. Yet very few programs for the disabled include work with siblings (whether children or adults) as a focus of their intervention. The evidence is that sibling relationships matter a great deal. According to one important longitudinal study of successful, well-educated men (the Harvard classes of 1938–1944), the single best predictor of emotional health at the age of 65 was having had a close relationship with one’s sibling in college. This was more predictive than childhood closeness to parents, emotional problems in childhood, or parental divorce, more predictive even than having had a successful marriage or career (Vaillant, 1977). Myers (2011) found that most adults maintain their sibling relationships over their lives. Thus, given the significance of sibling relationships and their longevity, it seems important for therapists to address conflicts, resentments, and cutoffs whenever possible. Techniques that promote understanding and forgiveness are important for addressing sibling rifts. Forgiveness may have a crucial role in all intimate relationships (Bright, Cameron, & Caza, 2006; Cameron & Caza, 2002; Fincham, Jackson, & Beach, 2006; Waldron & Kelley, 2008), but especially because siblings hold each other’s history and are important to the fabric of life, we should take every opportunity to assist siblings in developing authentic and meaningful connections and to build trust and attachment (Lawler et al., 2005). We must be attentive to enlarging our focus in family therapy to include siblings in order to prevent or heal sibling fractures and facilitate supportive sibling alliances. Even where a sibling is not yet able to maintain a healthy relationship, we can coach clients to open their hearts to possibilities for when the sibling may

reach the point of readiness to engage and repair a broken relationship (McGoldrick, 2011; Wade, 2010). Age Spacing Sibling experiences vary greatly. An important factor is the amount of time brothers and sisters spend together when they are young. Two children who are close in age, particularly if they are of the same gender, generally spend a lot of time together, must share their parents’ attention, and are usually raised under similar conditions. Siblings who are born far apart spend less time with each other, growing up at different points in the family’s evolution and are likely to have fewer shared experiences; they are in many ways more like only children. Sulloway (1996) maintains that children who are closest in age have the greatest competition and rivalry for their parents’ care; therefore, the second sibling has the greatest need to differentiate from the older to find a niche for him or herself. The ultimate shared sibling experience is that of identical twins. They have a special relationship that is exclusive of the rest of the family. Twins have been known to develop their own language and maintain an uncanny, almost telepathic sense of each other. Even fraternal twins often have remarkable similarities because of their shared life experiences. The major challenge for twins is to develop individual identities. Since they do not have their own unique sibling position, there is a tendency to lump twins together. This becomes a problem especially when, as adolescents, they are trying to develop their separate identities. Sometimes twins have to go to extremes to distinguish themselves from each other. Gender Differences Sister pairs tend to have the closest relationships. Sisters generally have been treated differently from brothers in families, given the pivotal caretaking role that sisters typically have in a family. Both brothers and sisters report feeling more positive about sisters (Troll & Smith, 1976) and indicate that a sister was the sibling to whom they felt closest (Cicirelli, 1982, 1995; White & Riedman, 1992a). According to a survey by Cicirelli (1983), the more sisters a man has, the happier he is and the less worried about family, job, or money matters. Sisters seem to provide a basic feeling of emotional security. And the more sisters he has, the more time he will spend raising his own children and the more generous he will be to others (Grant, 2013). The more sisters a woman has, the more she is concerned with keeping up social relationships and helping others (Cicirelli, 1985). Siblings can provide role models for successful aging, widowhood, bereavement, and retirement. They act as caretakers and exert pressures on each other to maintain values. With rare exceptions, fewer expectations for intellectual and worldly achievement are placed on, or allowed to, sisters than brothers. It is interesting that in Hennig and Jardin’s classic study (1977) of highly successful women in business, not a single woman in the sample had had a brother. Research indicates that while the preference for sons is diminishing (Washington, 2007), there is still a greater likelihood that a family with only female children will continue to try for a boy. We have come a long way from the infanticide that other cultures have resorted to when they had daughters instead of sons, but the remnants of those attitudes still exist. Families are more likely to divorce if they have only daughters, and divorced fathers are more likely to lose contact with children if they are daughters, and women pregnant with girls are less likely to

marry (Dahl & Moretti, 2008). On the other hand, recent research has shown that parenting daughters increases feminist sympathies. Fathers of daughters vote significantly more liberally than fathers who have only sons, and the more daughters a father has, the higher his propensity to vote liberally, particularly on reproductive rights issues (Washington, 2007). Unlike oldest sons, who typically have a clear feeling of entitlement, oldest daughters often have feelings of ambivalence and guilt about the responsibilities of their role. Whatever they do, they feel that it is not quite enough, and they can never let up in their efforts to take care of people and make the family work right. They are the ones who maintain the networks; who make Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Passover happen; who care for the sick; and who carry on the primary mourning when family members die. They are central in family process, more often taking responsibility for maintaining family relationships than their brothers. Sisters not only do the majority of the caretaking, but they also tend to share more intimacy and have more intense relationships than brothers, although they typically get less glory than brothers do. From childhood on, most sibling caretaking is delegated to older sisters, with brothers freed for play or other tasks (Cicirelli, 1985). Brother-to-brother relationships appear to be characterized by more rivalry, competitiveness, ambivalence, and jealousy (Adams, 1968; Cicirelli, 1985), while sister relationships are characterized by more support and caretaking. However, societal and intra- family racism based on skin color as a measure of beauty induce rivalry, competitiveness, and ambivalence among sisters and clinicians need to be sensitive to reframing such conflicts as created by the social context rather than by psychological aspects of the family (Watson, 2013). Sister relationships, like those of women friends, are more often devalued than peer relationships involving men. A woman who wants to avoid a move for her husband’s job to be near her sister is considered strange indeed. She will probably be labeled “enmeshed” or “undifferentiated.” Yet it is the sister who was there at the beginning, before the husband, and who will most likely be there at the end, after he is gone. A strong sense of sisterhood seems to strengthen a woman’s sense of self (Cicirelli, 1982, 1985). With the best of intentions, parents may convey very different messages to their sons than to their daughters. In certain cultures, such as Italian and Latino, daughters are more likely to be raised to take care of others, including their brothers. Some cultural groups, such as Irish and African American families, may, for various historical reasons, overprotect sons and underprotect daughters (McGoldrick, 1989a; McGoldrick, Giordano, & Garcia Preto, 2005). Other cultural groups have less specific expectations. Anglos, for example, are more likely to believe in brothers and sisters having equal chores. But, in general, it is important to notice how gender roles influence sibling patterns in understanding a family (McGoldrick, 1989b). Culture, Class, Race, and Ethnicity In addition to early parental loss, temperament, the child’s physical attributes, family traumas, and major life changes related to politics, economics, and emotional factors affecting families, class, culture, and race also powerfully influence sibling patterns. Cultures and classes differ in the expected roles and relationships of siblings (Leder, 1991; McGoldrick et al., 2005; Nuckolls, 1993; Sandmeier, 1994; Sulloway, 1996; Zukow, 1989).

A family’s ethnic identity may determine whether siblings are close, distant, or created equal (Leder, 1991) and the meaning of the siblinghood. Some ethnic groups, such as Asians, may show a greater preference for male children; some, such as African Americans, value the family unit over individual members; others, such as Anglos, give priority to autonomy and self- reliance. Even the concept of sibling rivalry is culture bound, being largely a Western phenomenon that stems from a focus on individual achievement, competition, and status. In contrast, a huge segment of the world’s population dissuades children from assuming the stance of sibling as rival by instilling in them a sense of “we-ness” rather than “I” (Sandmeier, 1994). In cultures that train their children to view each other as necessary, siblings are more likely to have lifelong, enduring ties. In some oppressed cultures, the closely knit sibling bond is also influenced by historical needs for survival. Family members rely on mutual support and aid to fulfill basic material and emotional needs. In African American families, the tradition of tightly woven sibships that was passed down from African culture is combined with the family’s need to function as a unit to deal with the forces of racism (Watson, 1998). Thus, strong sibling bonds may be more necessary for African Americans than for people in cultures that are not affected by oppression and in which siblings can live independently of each other. In cultures in which sibling caretaking is a major form of caretaking, as it is for African Americans, strong emotional attachment, positive or negative, may have a profound effect on siblinghood throughout the life cycle (Watson, 1998). Although large sibships such as those that may be found in Irish Catholic families may also produce older sibling caretakers, this role will probably end with childhood. Among African Americans, however, sibling caretakers tend to continue their role into adulthood. Childhood sibling caretaking helps to prepare them for their lifelong role as each other’s keeper (Watson, 1998). Hence, the expectations of African American siblings have implications for individual and family development throughout the life cycle. Some cultures use the term “brother” or “sister” to convey the depth of a cherished relationship. The Vietnamese, for example, address lovers and spouses as “big brother” or “little sister,” and African Americans may greet one another with the term “Brother” or “Sister” to convey their sense of kinship (Sandmaier, 1994). Such terms of endearment express the particular culture’s valuing of sibling relationships. The family’s emotional map is governed by its cultural roots. Families of Northern European and Anglo backgrounds may discourage strong displays of feeling or affection and will probably view themselves, their siblings, and their parents as a related collection of individuals. German brothers and sisters also may be likely to refrain from showing strong or open affection toward one another because of the cultural prescription to maintain a stiff upper lip (Sandmaier, 1994). In Italian culture, in which the family supersedes the individual, sibling relationships tend to be close, especially between same-sex pairs. In a study conducted by Colleen Leahy Johnson (1982), 63 percent of middle-aged Italian women saw a sibling daily, in contrast to 12 percent of their Anglo counterparts. Among college-educated older Americans, African American siblings were three times as likely as Whites to focus on themes of loyalty, solidarity, and enduring affection. Hence, the cultural message that African Americans receive to stay together and help each other does not disappear as family members move up the class ladder or move toward old age.

In Greek and Jewish cultures, conflicting messages about family loyalty and individual success and competition may add to sibling tensions. Siblings may be fierce rivals at the same time that family cohesion is expected (Sandmaier, 1994). Irish siblings may have deeply ambivalent feelings toward one another. Irish culture’s emphasis on dichotomies and labels may spark sibling rivalry, while simultaneously inducing guilt in the sibling for having bad thoughts. Thus, buried resentments that enable siblings to appear connected while the parents are alive may lead to sibling cutoffs in the wake of parental death. Culturally influenced family rules and scripts set the stage for sibling relationships (Sandmaier, 1994; Watson, 1998). As more Americans face longer lives without partners or children, sibling relationships must be revisited. Our brothers and sisters are potentially emotional and physical resources at all points of the life cycle, but individual needs for attachment and belonging are apt to be more critical at later junctures of the life cycle. In cultures that prize individuality over family unity, siblings’ life cycle patterns may remain distinct and separate as brothers and sisters keep their families of procreation apart. In cultures that demand family cohesion or enmeshment, siblings’ life cycle patterns may become fused, making it difficult for families of procreation to establish their own traditions and ways of relating. Understanding the cultural context of sibling relationships provides a larger framework for addressing individual issues of self-esteem and identity, unresolved issues of childhood, and sibling relationships through the life cycle. A sister from a culture that prefers sons may stop blaming her brother and have greater compassion for her parents once she realizes the cultural script in which they all played a part. Class differences are likely to have a major impact on adult siblings from oppressed cultures or poor families. Unacknowledged or overt resentments may characterize adult sibling relationships for siblings who end up in different socioeconomic groups. Lower-class African American siblings may hold their resentment of middle-class or professional brothers and sisters in check because of cultural expectations of familyhood and their need for physical support. Middle-class brothers and sisters may resent lower-class siblings for relying on them but not feel free to express such resentment because of the sense of family obligation. In Jewish families, sibling resentment or cutoffs may result from intense feelings around the success or lack of success of one’s brother or sister. Parental reactions to successful and non- successful children may exacerbate sibling fissures related to class differences. The need to prove oneself intellectually superior and successful for Jewish siblings may be related to their cultural history and oppression. Class differences between Jewish siblings might adversely affect their relationships, especially if one perceives the other as having had an unfair advantage. Class differences in Anglo families may result in sibling antagonism, but the cultural pattern of individuality and autonomy may obscure such resentments or conflicts. Since these siblings tend not to mingle except for formal family occasions, sibling tensions would go virtually unnoticed and would probably not be dealt with by the siblings themselves. Lower-class family members at

family events may be treated like poor relations, or they may be closed out of family events altogether. Although lower-class family members could be treated negatively by middle-class African Americans, it would not go unnoticed, and the mother would probably intervene on behalf of the lower-class sibling. Regardless of the ethnic or cultural group, class tensions are likely to surface when aging or ill parents require care from children. Class may influence the way rebellion intersects with sibling position. Just as oldest sisters may be more rebellious than oldest brothers because the gender inequities impinge on an oldest sister’s “right” to be the leader, oldest siblings in minority families may become more rebellious than oldest siblings from the dominant groups because of the interaction of social privilege and status with sibling status. Sibling position may exaggerate the class effects of oppression, which lead people to resist the status quo (e.g., making a younger sibling of a poor family even more rebellious). Sulloway (1996) found that, as with the interaction of gender and birth order, the oldest child in a poor family may use a strategy of rebellion against the status quo as the best way to achieve eminence. Radical reformers have tended to come from racial minorities and lower classes, and to be later-borns. In Sulloway’s research, abolitionism attracted the highest proportion of later- borns of any reform movement he surveyed. Still, because Sulloway’s research focused primarily on Europeans who became involved in scientific revolutions, we need further research on culture, class, gender, and sibling patterns from other countries where lives include other spheres of activity and interest. Sulloway suggests that the early parental loss in the upper classes diminishes sibling differences based on birth order, as nannies and other caretakers come in to replace the lost parent, and siblings become more supportive of each other as they share their loss. In middle- and lower-class families, the opposite may happen. The oldest child may be drawn into the burden of parenting younger siblings and becomes even more conservative, leading the younger siblings to become even more rebellious than otherwise. Large sibships reinforce the first-born’s duties as surrogate parent. Racial/Ethnic identity of siblings Racial and ethnic identity can seriously influence relationships for better or worse, particularly if siblings identify with different racial/ethnic groups or are of different racial or ethnic groups through remarriage or adoption, as the following case illustrates. Case Illustration Robert and His Family A White family sought treatment for their adolescent son’s school failure and acting out. Both the mother and father were White, but Robert, the identified patient, the oldest of the three siblings, was slightly darker in skin color. The siblings seemed to taunt him with negative stares and sarcastic remarks. In recounting the family’s history, both the mother and father denied that there were any prior marriages. It was not until the second session that the mother finally admitted to my (MW) probing, that Robert was her son from a prior relationship. At the third session, I specifically asked about Robert’s experience of being darker than his siblings. It was only then that the mother admitted that his father was Black. With my (MW) help in a family session, Robert described being called the N-word by his siblings and the lack of protection and support that he felt from both parents and siblings. He was struggling with his racial/ethnic identity both at home and at school, which contributed to his school failure and acting out. I engaged the

family in a discussion of racism, including corollary White privilege, and its impact on self- identity and development. The siblings, who were younger in age, were modeling the negative behavior of extended family members and of the father who resented his wife’s relationship with a Black man. Like many families, Robert’s family downplayed his siblings’ name calling as “normal” sibling behavior. After hearing Robert’s pain and feelings of not being accepted at home or school, the parents agreed to work on new rules for sibling behavior and to be more open about Robert being biracial. Also, the parents realized the need for them to work on their relationship rather than allow marital resentments to spill over into their parenting. If left unattended, sibling conflicts related to racial and ethnic identity may become entrenched, leading to resentments or cutoffs in adulthood. Parents may be unaware or unable to acknowledge racism in their own homes or its impact on sibling relationships. However, the experience of difference among siblings can impact sibling development and rob siblings of support in adulthood. Racial and ethnic differences in siblings, just like gender, sexual orientation, and abilities can transform these potentially lifelong beneficial relationships into disconnection, distrust, and disharmony unless the differences are acknowledged and dealt with by parents who have the courage to face racism and White privilege and other of society’s oppressive systems. Birth-Order Effects on Sibling Relationships Although birth order can profoundly influence later experiences with spouses, friends, and colleagues, many other factors also influence sibling roles, such as temperament, disability, class, culture, looks, intelligence, talent, gender, and the timing of each birth in relation to other family experiences—deaths, moves, illnesses, changes in financial status, and so on. Parents may have a particular agenda for a specific child, such as expecting him or her to be the responsible one or the baby, regardless of that child’s position in the family. Children who resemble a certain family member may be expected to be like that person or to take on that person’s role. Children’s temperaments may also be at odds with their sibling position. This may explain why some children struggle so valiantly against family expectations—the oldest who refuses to take on the responsibility of the caretaker or family standard bearer or the youngest who strives to be a leader. In some families, it will be the child who is most comfortable with the responsibility—not necessarily the oldest child—who becomes the leader. Parents’ own sibling experiences will affect their children as well. But certain typical patterns often occur that reflect each child’s birth order. In general, oldest children are likely to be the over-responsible and conscientious ones in the family. They make good leaders, because they have experienced authority over and responsibility for younger siblings. Often serious in disposition, they may believe that they have a mission in life. In identifying with their parents and being especially favored by them, oldest children tend to be conservative even while leading others into new worlds; and though they may be self- critical, they do not necessarily handle criticism from others well. The oldest daughter often has the same sense of responsibility, conscientiousness, and ability to care for and lead others as her male counterpart. However, daughters generally do not receive the same privileges; nor are there generally the same expectations for them to excel. Thus, they may

be saddled with the responsibilities of the oldest child without the privileges or enhanced self- esteem. The middle child in a family is in between, having neither the position of the first as the standard bearer nor the last as the baby. Middle children thus run the risk of getting lost in the family, especially if all the siblings are of the same gender. On the other hand, middle children may develop into the best negotiators, more even-tempered and mellow than their more driven older siblings and less self-indulgent than the youngest. They may even relish their invisibility. Frank Sulloway (1996) argues on the basis of a large sample of historical figures that later-born children, both middle and youngest children, are very much more likely to be rebels than are oldest or only children because of the Darwinian imperative for survival. The niche of following in the parental footsteps has already been taken by the oldest, and they need to find a different niche to survive. They therefore tend to be less parent-identified, less conscientious, and more sociable. Traditionally, in many European cultures, younger children, sons in particular, had to be disposed of, since the oldest took over the family farm or business from the father; younger sons tended to become warriors or priests or fulfilled other less conventional roles in society. A middle sister is generally under less pressure to take responsibility, but she may feel the need to try harder to make her mark because she has no special role. She remembers running to catch up with the older sister from childhood and running frantically from the younger one, who seemed to be gaining on her every minute (Fishel, 1979). The youngest child often has a sense of specialness that allows self-indulgence without the overburdening sense of responsibility of oldest children. This pattern may increase in intensity with the number of siblings there are in a family. The younger of two children probably has more a sense of pairing and twinship—unless there is a considerable age differential—than the youngest of 10. Freed from convention and determined to do things his or her own way, the youngest child can sometimes make remarkable creative leaps leading to inventions and innovations. Youngest children can also be spoiled and self-absorbed, and their sense of entitlement may lead at times to frustration and disappointment. In addition, the youngest often has a period as an only child after the older siblings have left home. This can be an opportunity to enjoy the sole attention of parents but can also lead to feelings of abandonment by the siblings. A younger sister tends to be protected, showered with affection, and handed a blueprint for life. She may either be spoiled (especially if there are older brothers) and have special privileges or, if she is from a large family, she may feel frustrated by always having to wait her turn. Her parents may have run out of energy with her. She may feel resentful about being bossed around and never quite taken seriously. If she is the only girl, the youngest may be more like the princess, yet the servant to elders, becoming, perhaps, the confidante of her brothers in adult life and the one to replace the parents in holding the family together at later life cycle phases. Like middle children, only children show characteristics of both oldest and youngest children. In fact, they may show the extremes of both at the same time. They may have the seriousness and

sense of responsibility of the oldest and the conviction of specialness and entitlement of the youngest. Not having siblings, only children tend to be more oriented toward adults, seeking their love and approval and in return expecting their undivided attention. The major challenge for only children is to learn how to get along with others their own age. Only children often maintain very close attachments to their parents throughout their lives but find it more difficult to relate to friends and spouses. Although there are many stereotypes about only children as more selfish and lonely and less able to share, the research does not bear this out. They appear as good at sharing, collaborating, and connecting as other siblings (Sandler, 2013). The number of children in a family is also a determining factor in siblings’ life course. The more siblings there are, the less likely success appears to be, as a function of having to compete for resources (Conley, 2005). Life Cycle Issues in Families With Disabled Siblings We need to plan therapeutically for the lifelong implications that a handicapped child has for all family members, especially for the adjustment and caretaking responsibilities of the siblings. Siblings respond not only to the disabled child but also to parents’ distress and/or preoccupation with the needs of the disabled child. Parents also may shift their hopes and dreams onto their other children, which can create burden and sibling strains (Cicirelli, 1995). Older children tend to make a better adjustment to disability than do younger ones because older children are better able to put the situation in perspective. Relative birth order is also important. A younger sibling may have difficulties associated with needing to assume the role of functional older caretaker sibling (Boyce & Barnett, 1993). Siblings become especially stressed when parents expect them either to be preoccupied with the needs of the disabled sibling or to treat him or her as “normal.” During adolescence, siblings may feel particular embarrassment about a disabled sibling. On the other hand, if they have developed greater maturity through sibling caretaking experiences, they may feel out of step with peers (Cicirelli, 1995). Oldest sisters of disabled siblings are at greatest risk because of increased parental demands on them. Brothers of the disabled tend to spend more time away from the family (Cicirelli, 1995). This is something that clinicians can help families to change. We must gently question parental expectations and encourage parents to include brothers in caretaking and prevent sisters from becoming overburdened. Otherwise, in later life, brothers may become completely disengaged from the disabled sibling, while sisters are left with total responsibility for them. Small families tend to experience more pressure when there is a disabled child because there are fewer siblings to share the responsibility. The pressure seems increased when the disabled sibling is a brother, probably because of parents,’ especially fathers,’ reactions of personal hurt to pride in having a disabled son. Sisters seem more ready to accept the role of caretaker for a brother and to have more sibling rivalry or competition with a disabled sister. In a study of siblings of children with intellectual disabilities, older sisters were more affected than older brothers, because they generally got the lion’s share of the caretaking responsibility for the sibling (Cicirelli, 1995). Their career and family decisions were also the most influenced by the disabled sibling. Sisters tended to be closer to the impaired child than brothers, to be given more responsibilities as well as more information about the sibling’s disability than brothers were. Older sisters were found to enter the helping professions more often than other siblings.

The following is an illustration of the life cycle implications of the imbalance in caretaking responsibilities between an older sister and younger brothers in providing care for a disabled brother. It provides a classic portrayal of the findings in the literature. Case Illustration The Donnelly Family The Donnelly family is of Irish-German and Roman Catholic background. Both parents had died in the past few years of chronic illnesses, leaving behind an oldest daughter, Mary Ann; a younger brother, Jim; and youngest fraternal twin brothers, Michael and Charles. Charles had been born with cerebral palsy. Mary Ann had been reared for a caretaker’s role since childhood; she also had taken care of her chronically ill father for 2 years before his death. And then she cared for her chronically ill mother until her death 2 years later. Although she had attended college and had a successful career as a computer analyst, she was never free to take even an overnight vacation from her brother. When her other brothers distanced themselves from her and Charles in the wake of the mother’s death, Mary Ann began to have unexplained stomach pains, and her family physician referred the family for therapy. The family therapist initially addressed the family’s problems as unresolved mourning and attempted to involve the reluctant brothers in taking some responsibility for the disabled brother in an attempt to reconnect the family by helping them to mourn the death of their mother. Many attempts were made to assemble all family members together. Charles’s twin brother Michael was easier to involve in therapy than the older brother, Jim. Michael had almost cut off from the family when he married his Italian wife, Lucia, of whom the family disapproved. The marriage had occurred shortly after the father had died, and the mother had felt doubly bereft by the loss of her husband and her son, who, she said, chose to leave the family in their time of need. Michael almost seemed to have been waiting for the chance to sort out issues he had with the family. Within 2 months, he sought help for his own marital problems and continued working hard on his connections to his brother and sister. The older brother, Jim, was much harder to involve in the therapy. He made one excuse after another for not attending sessions and then said that his wife’s feelings were hurt because Mary Ann had not attended his daughter’s christening. He assumed unquestioningly that it was the sister’s responsibility to care for Charles, a role Mary Ann herself seemed to accept as hers alone. She presented as guilt ridden and depressed, having pledged undying loyalty to her mother’s dying wish that she care for Charles, despite the fact that her personal and social life had been sacrificed by this commitment. To understand this better, we inquired about the sibling relationships of both parents and discovered that the father, also named Jim, also an oldest son, had been virtually cut off from his sole sister, who had cared for their widowed mother, who was wheelchair bound with multiple sclerosis for many years. We were able to explore with the other siblings the father’s longstanding depression, which they believed resulted from his own unhappy cutoff from his parents. We discovered that the sibling overfunctioning and underfunctioning in the current generation and the imminent cutoffs reflected similar imbalances in both parents’ families that had led to sibling cutoffs at midlife. Mary Ann and Charles initially wanted to ignore Jim and his

family, but the therapist challenged them to try to overcome the family legacy of sibling cutoff. The therapist also challenged Mary Ann and the others with her “duty” and the long-held family and cultural beliefs about sisters’ obligations in caretaking. She has recently been successful in asserting herself with Charles’s doctors regarding their assumptions about Charles’s need for her continual monitoring. She took her first vacation in many years, while Charles went to stay with Michael and his wife. Sibling Positions and Parenting If you have struggled in your own sibling position, as a parent you may overidentify with a child of the same gender and sibling position as yourself. One father who was an oldest of five felt that he had been burdened with too much responsibility, while his younger brothers and sister “got away with murder.” When his own children came along, he spoiled the oldest and tried to make the younger ones toe the line. A mother may find it difficult to sympathize with a youngest daughter if she always felt envious of her younger sister. Parents may also identify with one particular child because of a resemblance to another family member. Whether these identifications are conscious or unconscious, they are normal. It is a myth that parents can feel the same toward all their children. Problems develop when a parent’s need for the child to play a certain role interferes with the child’s abilities or with two siblings’ relationship to each other or to outsiders. A parent’s identification with a child may be so strong that he or she perpetuates old family patterns in the next generation. On the other hand, if their own experience has been different, parents may misread their own children. A parent who was an only child may assume that normal sibling fights are an indication of trouble. Siblings and Adolescent Relationships At least by adolescence, siblings provide important models and alter egos. One sibling may begin to live out a life path for the other, so that they become alternate selves. Sisters in particular also often share secrets, clothes, and sensitivities about their parents’ problems. Gay and lesbian adolescents may have a particularly difficult time at this phase of their budding sexuality, in dealing with peers, parents, and institutions. Having a supportive sibling network can be an extremely important cushion against these rejections, while the lack of sibling support can add to the sense of isolation and rejection children can feel at this time. Obviously, not all siblings are close. Childhood rivalries and hurts carry over into adolescence and adulthood. At family get-togethers, everyone tries, at least at first, to be friendly and cordial, but beneath the surface old conflicts may simmer. By adolescence, sibling dysfunction may require one child to grieve the loss of dreams for another and for their relationship, if the other is seriously dysfunctional, suffering from autism, mental illness, or addiction. Sibling Relationships in Young Adulthood Closeness to siblings has been found to be strong just before they leave their parental home (Bowerman & Dobash, 1974; Troll, 1994). This closeness tends to be followed by a distancing during the early and middle years of adulthood, but at later life cycle phases people rate affectional closeness with siblings higher and conflict lower than do middle-aged siblings (Brady & Noberini, 1987). As they reach young adulthood, sisters often grow farther apart, each focusing on their own friends, work, and relationships and on developing their own family.

Siblings may get together during holidays at the parental home, but often the focus is primarily on the relationship of each to the parents or spouses rather than on their relationships with each other. Support may be weakest at this phase, and competition may be strongest: Who went to the better school? Whose husband or children are more successful? Whose life is happier? The images that each develops of the other are often colored less by their personal interchanges than by the rivalries carried over from childhood or the parental images, transmitted by parents about the other’s life. A younger sister who felt dominated or abused by her older brother may feel uncomfortable even sitting at the same table with him. All the unpleasant memories flood back. Two brothers who spent their childhoods competing in sports, in school, and for parental attention may find themselves subtly competing in the holiday dinner table conversation. Even if there are no major flare-ups, family members may leave the dinner feeling bored or vaguely dissatisfied, glad that such occasions occur only a few times a year. Whether deliberately or inadvertently, parents can perpetuate such old sibling patterns. A mother may compare one child with another, perhaps chiding one for not calling as often as another does. A father might talk repeatedly about how proud he is of his son, not realizing that he is ignoring his daughter. A parent may elicit the support of one sibling in an effort to “shape up” another. Clinically, therapists can do much to challenge such values on behalf of all siblings. It is also at this phase that sisters may move into different social classes as they marry and move, according to the culture’s expectations, to adapt to their husband’s socioeconomic context. They themselves are often not able to define this context, which has traditionally been defined by the husband’s education, work, and financial status. Although some cultures, such as African American and Irish, emphasize friendship between siblings more than other groups, such as Scandinavian or Jewish culture (Woehrer, 1982), the sister bond is generally continued through a mutual sense of shared understanding and responsibility for the family, more than through common interests, especially when class differences between the sisters have developed. Sibling Positions and Marital Relationships Sibling relationships can often pave the way for couple relationships—for sharing, interdependence, and mutuality—just as they can predispose partners to jealousy, power struggles, and rivalry. Since siblings are generally our earliest peer relationships, we are likely to be most comfortable in other relationships that reproduce the familiar sibling patterns of birth order and gender. In general, marriage seems easiest for partners who fit their original sibling pattern, for example, if an oldest marries a youngest, rather than two oldest marrying each other. If a wife has grown up as the oldest of many siblings and the caretaker, she might be attracted to a dominant oldest, who offers to take over management of responsibilities. But as time goes along, she may come to resent his assertion of authority, because, by experience, she is more comfortable making decisions for herself. All things being equal (and they seldom are in life!), the ideal marriage based on sibling position would be a complementary one in which, for example, the husband was the older brother of a younger sister and the wife was the younger sister of an older brother. However, the complementarity of caretaker and someone who needs caretaking or leader and follower does not guarantee intimacy or a happy marriage.

In addition to complementary birth order, it seems to help in marriage if one has had siblings of the opposite sex. The most difficult pairing might be that of the youngest sister of many sisters who marries the youngest brother of many brothers, since neither would have much experience of the opposite sex in a close way, and they might both play the spoiled child waiting for a caretaker. There are, of course, many other possible sibling pairings in marriage. The marriage of two only children might be particularly difficult because neither has the experience of the intimate sharing that one does with a brother or sister. Middle children may be the most flexible, since they have experiences with a number of different roles. Coupling and marriage tend to increase the distance between siblings. Sisters may be pressured by their spouses to decrease their intimacy with each other, and that pressure may create sibling distance that lasts until later life. Maya Angelou (1981) once described the efforts siblings must make to remain connected in spite of spousal pressure. They must work at maintaining their sibling relationships throughout the life cycle. Even if a spouse does not want you to remain connected, you must go when your sister calls. In-Laws, Step- and Half-Siblings The relationship of half- and stepsiblings through life depends on many factors including the distance in age, gender, presence of full siblings in the household, gender of stepparent and continuity of stepparent experience, length of time living together during childhood, marital status, race, social class, religion, parental divorce, proximity and emotional closeness to parents and to each other, and the overall cultural values of family connectedness (White & Riedman, 1992b). In general, they are not as close as full siblings except where circumstances have drawn them into special connection as where a parent or another sibling has been impaired or lost. Nevertheless, people generally define step- and half-siblings as “real” kin, even though the connections are overall weaker than for full siblings. In similar ways, sister-in-law and brother-in-law relationships can have some of the positives of sibling relationships without the tensions, but things only sometimes work out this way. Sisters- in-law share a future but not a biological or childhood history. The interesting aspect of in-law patterns is the extent to which the structure of the family tends to determine in-law relationships, even though family members are so often sure that it is just personality characteristics they are reacting against in rejecting an in-law. Sisters-in-law who marry into families that have only brothers probably have the greatest likelihood of developing positive connections to the new family. The wife of a youngest brother of older sisters is probably in the most difficult position, since this brother may have been treated like a prince. He may be resented though protected by his sisters, whom he probably tried to avoid for their “bossiness.” When he finds a wife, his choice is likely to reflect in part his need for some protection against other powerful females, and his wife may then become the villain, supposedly keeping him from having a closer relationship with his sisters. Nevertheless, family relationships of those who have been raised as kin and peers, such as half- or step-siblings and often also cousins or those who live through adulthood as kin and peers such as sisters- and

brothers-in-law have real clinical importance. They may be significant resources and supports to family connectedness. On the other hand, when their connections are negative, they can be a source of great difficulty. Sibling Relationships in Midlife Often, it is not until midlife that siblings reconnect with each other, through the shared experiences of caring for a failing or dying parent, a divorce in the family, or perhaps a personal health problem, which inspires them to clarify their priorities and to redefine which relationships in life really matter to them. Sometimes, at this point, relationships that have been maintained at a superficial level may break under the strain of caretaking or under the pain of the distance that has grown between them. On the other hand, siblings may now be brought closer to each other. Their relationships may solidify through the realization that their parents will not always be there and that they themselves must begin to put the effort into maintaining their own relationship. In our culture, sisters are generally the caretakers of parents and other unattached older relatives or the managers who have responsibility to arrange for their caretaking. In other cultures, such as in Japan, this role goes to the wife of the oldest son. In our culture, if sisters do not do the primary caretaking, they often feel guilty about it, because the cultural pressure on them by others to do caretaking is so strong. Sibling relationships can be a most important connection in adult life, especially in the later years. However, if negative feelings persist, the care of an aging parent may bring on particular difficulty. While the final caretaking of parents may increase a child’s commitment and closeness to them (Bass & Bowman, 1990), it may either draw siblings together or arouse conflicts over who did more and who felt loved less. If there are unresolved problematic issues in a family, they are likely to surface at this time in conflicts over the final caretaking, the funeral, or the will. At such a time, siblings may have been apart for years. They may have to work together in new and unfamiliar ways. The child who has remained closest to the parents, usually a daughter, often gets most of these caretaking responsibilities, which may cause long-buried jealousies and resentments to surface. Or perhaps sisters may end up in conflict over how to do the caretaking, while brothers remain on the sidelines, offering at times financial support, but less often their time or emotional support for the caretaking. Because it is women who tend to be central in maintaining the emotional relationships in a family, sisters may focus their disappointments on each other or on their sisters-in-law more than on their brothers, who are often treated with kid gloves and not expected to give much in the way of emotional or physical support when caretaking is required. It is at the death of the last parent that sibling relationships become voluntary for the first time in life. While parents are alive, siblings may have contact with and hear news about each other primarily as a function of their relationships with their parents. Once the parents die, siblings must decide for the first time whether to maintain contact with each other. Sibling Relationships After the Death of Parents Once both parents have died, sibling relationships become truly independent for the first time. From here on, whether they see each other will be their own choice. This is the time when estrangement can become complete, particularly if old rivalries continue. The focus may be on

concrete disagreements: Who should have helped in the care of their ailing parent? Who took all the responsibility? Who was more loved? Strong feelings can be fueled by old unresolved issues. In general, the better relationships siblings have, the less likely it is that later traumatic family events will lead to parting of the ways. At the end of the life cycle, sisters are especially likely to be a major support for each other or even to live together. Older women are especially likely to rely on their sisters, as well as their daughters and even their nieces for support (Anderson, 1984; Lopata, 1979; Townsend, 1957). Anderson (1984) found that sisters were the ones whom older widows most often turned to, more often than to children, even though they were not more available geographically. She speculated that the reasons might include sisters’ shared history of experiences and life transitions. She concludes that siblings, especially sisters, take on added significance as confidants and emotional resources for women after they have been widowed. Because siblings share a unique history, reminiscing about earlier times together is an activity in which they engage at many points in the life cycle. Such reminiscing tends to become even more important late in life. It helps all siblings to validate and clarify events and relationships that took place in earlier years and to place them in a mature perspective. It can become an important source of pride and comfort (Cicirelli, 1985). This seems especially meaningful for sisters who tend anyway to define themselves more in terms of context and to place a high value on the quality of human relationships. Cicirelli (1982) found that having a relationship with a sister stimulates elderly women to remain socially engaged with others as well. Although the relationships of sisters, like all female relationships, tend to be invisible in the value structure of the culture at large, sisters tend to sustain one another in time of need throughout life. In old age, they become indispensable. They often become each other’s closest companions, sharing not only a lifetime of memories of home and family, but also even similar housekeeping styles, recipes, and prejudices about how things should be done. The details do matter as we age. Especially as we grow older, it is the details—of our memories, or of our housekeeping, or of our relationships with each other’s children—that may hold us together. Rules of Thumb for Sibling Relationships Through the Life Cycle

1. Take a proactive stance about including siblings in assessment, whatever the presenting problem. Say to yourself, “Why not have a sibling session?” rather than thinking of including a sibling only when the client presents a sibling problem directly.

2. When one sibling is bearing the weight of sibling caretaking for a parent or a disabled

sibling, work to improve the balance of sibling relationships so that the siblings can be more collaborative.

3. Assess and carefully challenge inequities in family roles and emotional and caretaking

functioning of brothers and sisters. In general, sisters tend to be seriously overburdened and brothers to seriously underfunction in terms of meeting the emotional needs of the broader family.

4. Validate the importance of sibling relationships and encourage resolution of sibling

conflicts whenever possible.

We are coming to appreciate more the importance of adult sibling relationships as researchers have observed that family support for caregivers correlates with the presence of siblings (Bedford, 1989, 2005). As we age, some sibling relationships lose the competitive quality of childhood and become more like friendships (McGhee, 1985; Norris & Tindale, 1994). As personal resources may become overtaxed by the demands of frail or demented aging parents, sibling bonds may either become overtaxed or provide the extra energy for caretaking. Sibling relationships may also become closer with aging, as activities and preoccupations of earlier life cycle phases diminish. The loss of a spouse who may have interfered with sibling closeness leaves siblings with more time and need for the comfort and sharing of the sibling bond. Cicirelli (1989) found that attachment is more likely to characterize sibling ties when sisters are involved. It does appear that sibling rivalries generally diminish in later life. Generational solidarity increases and sibling bonds appear to have greater salience for siblings as they age (Norris & Tindale, 1994). Conclusion Throughout the family life cycle, relationships are constantly changing. Our relationships with our parents are the first and, perhaps, foremost in reminding us of our family lineage—where we come from. Without knowledge of our uncles, aunts, grandparents, and great-grandparents, how can we know who we are? Just as important in shaping our personality development are our relationships with our siblings (Adler, 1959, 1979; Sulloway, 1996; Sutton-Smith & Rosenberg, 1970). Unlike our relationships with our parents, friends, and spouses, sibling relationships are lifelong. However, the gender differences are pronounced in sibling relationships. Sibships of sisters tend to differ from sibships of brothers. Whereas brother relationships often are more competitive and superficial, sisters tend to be more connected and deeply involved in each other’s lives and the lives of other family members throughout the family life cycle. Although less honored or glorified, sisters are often the designated caretakers of disabled family members. They are confidantes and healers of the family. Their lifelong friendships become even more significant and stronger after parents die and as they themselves enter old age. Given the importance of these bonds, which are always present in the family therapy context, therapists should become more aware of their influence, initiate more clinical research, and integrate these observations in their interventions. Including siblings in therapy at any point of the life cycle can validate the importance of their relationships; help them to resolve their conflicts, whether recent or deep seated from unresolved childhood conflicts; and strengthen them for their future. Sibling sessions can unlock a client’s stuckness, provide richness to an understanding of a client’s history, and provide relief for dealing with current stresses. A single sibling session may become a pivotal experience in an adult’s therapy. One isolated research scientist who sought therapy because of his wife’s frustration with his emotional distance held a session with his three brothers who came from all over the country for the meeting. All three brothers, who were in their 40s, discussed their different responses to their mother’s mental illness in their childhood and learned that each had become isolated in his own way. Each brother thought his problems were unique and individual, but they discovered as they reviewed their life experiences how profoundly connected they had always been and would always be. This session shifted the

client’s basic relationship with his wife. He now saw himself as a man among brothers going through life together, and felt strengthened in his ability to be open with his wife. As was described earlier, sibling sessions can encourage under-involved siblings to share caretaking burdens, modify gender imbalances, resolve longstanding conflicts, and increase collaboration. Chapter 14 Becoming a Couple: The Joining of Families Monica McGoldrick Learning Outcomes

 Explore how the key dimensions of couple relationships have evolved and changed to form today’s meaning of marriage.

 List and describe factors that influence marital adjustment.

 Define and compare intimacy and fusion.

 Examine how the life cycle stage of becoming a couple is unique for gay and lesbian

couples.

 Discuss the impact that weddings have on couples and their families.

 Explain the role of sexuality in couple relationships.

 Describe the dynamics of triangles that can form between couples and members of their families of origin.

 Discuss the impact that cultural differences can have on couple relationships.

I’ve been married three times. . . and each time I married the right person.

—Margaret Mead For most of history it was inconceivable that people would choose their mates on the basis of something as fragile and irrational as love and then focus all their sexual, intimate, and altruistic desires on the resulting marriage.

—Stephanie Coontz (2005, p. 15) Marriage in our Times This chapter will not consider arranged marriages because the author has not had experience with them. The parameters for arranged marriage seem so different from the general U.S. cultural arrangements for marriage that it would require quite a different chapter to discuss. I apologize for my ignorance on this topic, but it is not one where book learning seems adequate for understanding. Of all dilemmas of the life cycle, the existential dilemma of coupling is probably the most difficult interpersonally. Marriage is the only family relationship we swear is both exclusive and forever, and it is the family relationship least likely to be either.

Couples come in many varieties: gay and straight, married and unmarried, ambitious tall wives and short, nurturing homebody husbands, in spite of stereotypes of the husband as stronger, taller, smarter, with more earning power, and the wife as the physically attractive “helpmeet.” The ideal itself costs us all a tremendous amount in terms of our ability to be ourselves, find harmony in our relationships, and support the tasks of family life. Indeed, a major role for therapists is to normalize the patterns of those who do not fit into traditional stereotypes and to educate couples about the pitfalls of those mythical images (Lerner, 2012). Liza Mundy (2012) thinks we are entering an era when gender roles are changing dramatically in terms of who will be the provider and who will do the caretaking, which she thinks will alter how we mate, how we procreate, and how we raise our children. “It will reshape the landscape of the heart” (Mundy, 2012, p. 7). The meaning of marriage in our time is profoundly different from its meaning throughout all previous human history, when it was tightly embedded in the economic and social fabric of society, and often more about getting good in-laws, increasing the family labor force, and solidifying political and economic power in the community than about finding a life companion (Coontz, 2005). The changing role of women and the dramatic effects of widely available contraceptives, along with our increasing longevity and the mobility of our culture, have contributed to a major redefinition of marriage in our society. While at its best marriage has become more fair and fulfilling for both couples and their children than ever before, when marriage depends on love, flexibility, and equity it becomes more fragile and optional than ever before (Coontz, 2005). The role of marriage in the life cycle has also been changing dramatically (Cherlin, 2013; Hymowitz, Carroll, Wilcox, Bradford, & Kaye). Men and women are having sex earlier, but marrying later and less often than ever before. Of course, the economy is playing a major role here, making it almost impossible for working-class men and even for the middle class to afford marriage. Where marriage used to be thought of primarily as a business and cultural arrangement between families and as the gateway or foundation for adulthood, it is now being thought of more as the capstone or celebration of adult achievement, after the couple have completely worked out their financial independence and career goals, which only really seems to work for the upper middle class (Douthat, 2013; Klein, 2013). Marriage has become a choice or even a status symbol for self-sufficient individuals who no longer require a spouse for survival (Cherlin, 2012, 2013). Indeed, if a man is not able to be “the good provider” and has not moved toward equitable partnership in the administrative and relationship tasks of a family, women often think marriage is not worth undertaking. More people are living together before marriage, living with several partners before deciding to marry, or not marrying at all. Only about 48 percent of U.S. households include married couples, down from 78 percent of households in 1950 (Tavernise, 2011). Marriage rates are decreasing dramatically (33 percent of men and 26 percent of women never marry) and the age of marriage has been increasing dramatically, from age 20 to age 26 for women and from age 23 to age 28 for men in the last 50 years (Bolick, 2011). One of the biggest factors in whether people marry is economic, as demonstrated by their education. Of those with a college education or more, 88 percent of women aged 33 to 44 are married and their divorce rate in the first 10 years is only 17 percent. Meanwhile, of those with less than a high school diploma, only 79 percent have been married and the divorce rate within the first 10 years is 50 percent (Cherlin, 2013). While the overall U.S. rate of marriage declined by 17 percent since 1970, it has declined 34 percent for African Americans and others who are questioning the value of marriage

unless the husband is a real partner (Jones, 2006). A large study of poor women found that about two thirds of them had experienced physical or sexual abuse, and these women, when they had options, were much more reluctant to marry (Cherlin, Burton, Hurt, & Purvin, 2004). They advise that if we want to encourage more marriage among the poor, we need to take measures to directly respond to the high levels of abuse these women bear. It is also interesting that a wife’s being employed lowers the couple’s risk of divorce (Coontz, 2013). Couples are also marrying increasingly for health benefits, which are becoming expensive and hard to hold on to (Sack, 2008). There are, of course, also societal constraints on who can marry whom. Gays and lesbians still struggle to get legal and religious recognition of their relationships. Interracial marriages have also only been legal since the Supreme Court decision in Loving vs. Virginia in 1967. Prior to that, interracial couples could be sent to prison. Those with a college education are most likely to marry others of the same social location and less likely to marry up or down. As the category of couples “married and raising their own children” has become the exception rather than the rule, this group is increasingly the province of the college educated and affluent (Harden, 2007). Andrew Cherlin, for years one of the premier trackers of U.S. marriage patterns, says that as a nation we still seem to believe in marriage more than other Western societies, and the overwhelming majority of people in the United States do eventually marry. And yet we have the highest divorce rate in the Western world and the greatest number of cohabiting relationships that break up more rapidly than those in other Western countries (Cherlin, 2009b, 2012). Cherlin attributes this paradoxical pattern of believing in marriage while practicing divorce to reflect our conflicting values about marriage. We view it as a cultural ideal, but it conflicts with our belief in free choice, which becomes reflected in our high rate of marital breakups. It is also a paradox that we have been creating governmental programs to promote marriage, which they do not seem able to do (Cherlin, 2012). Yet we have fought same-sex marriage more than other countries (Cherlin, 2009a). Cherlin points out that these patterns create great turbulence in American family life, where the coming and going of partners occurs more than elsewhere and is difficult for children, particularly because it is accompanied by a lack of stable community networks. Unfortunately, as Cherlin (2012) makes clear, these patterns often relegate the poor to having children in brittle cohabiting relationships, which are relatively unstable and not the best environment for raising children. While marriage is used to symbolize the transition to parenthood; now it often reflects a greater continuity with the phase of young adulthood, since childbearing, especially for the middle and upper classes, is increasingly postponed for a number of years after marriage. And indeed, increasing numbers of women (20 percent as of 2006) are not having children, double the percent of only 30 years ago (Zezima, 2008). As a multigenerational, communal event, marriage symbolizes a change in status among all family members and generations and requires that the couple negotiate new relationships as a twosome with many other subsystems: parents, siblings, grandparents, nieces, nephews, employers, and friends. In fact, the status changes of marriage may not be fully appreciated by the family until the next phase, the transition to parenthood, which challenges traditional gender roles and multigenerational family patterns even more. Increasingly, women want to have their

own careers and are resistant to having the primary responsibility for the household and child care, nor are they satisfied with husbands who are absent from family life. Men’s participation in child care is increasing, but more slowly. In traditional societies, to talk of the choice to marry or not would be about as relevant as to talk of the choice to grow old or not; it was considered the only route to full adult status. To marry was simply part of the “natural” progression through life, unless catastrophe intervened. Only recently have society’s norms on this been modified, as more of the population do not fit into traditional patterns and raise questions about their viability. Another paradox is the stereotype that men are polygamous and women are monogamous. If this were so, it is strange indeed that there has been so much effort throughout history to control women’s sexuality with censure, veils, genital mutilation, etc. (Barnett & Rivers, 2004). A major problem for our understanding of coupling is that patriarchal rules for male domination in marriage get obfuscated and mystified by the mythology of coupling as a love story of two equals. The patriarchal courtship ideal of Cinderella and Prince Charming gets mystified with a myth of two lovers whose souls and bodies mingle, such that they will think and act as one in a partnership that lasts until death. The contradiction in these two propositions makes marriage a problem for both men and women, but especially for women, a fact which has only recently begun to come to national and international consciousness. When women have options and resources, traditional marriage, where the woman is the “helpmeet,” is increasingly viewed as a bad bargain. Marriage: Sex, Love, Power, Money, and Administration The emotional and sexual dimensions are the ones given priority in the dominant framework, and the issues of power are subtly kept invisible. Key Dimensions of Couple Relationships: Economics (a continuum from family support and finances controlled by one to equally earned and shared) Emotional Connection (a continuum from communication and intimacy to mind control and dependence) Power (a continuum from male privilege, dominance, intimidation, and abuse to partnership, equity, and respect for each partner) Boundaries (a continuum in relation to all other connections: friends, extended family, work, children, and religion—may be tight and controlled by one partner, or flexible in each area) Sexuality (a continuum from sexual intimacy to sexual objectification, rape, and exploitation) Childrearing (a continuum from shared parenting to women’s sole responsibility)

Administration of Chores and Leisure Activities (a continuum from dominance to shared decision making regarding tasks and arrangements for home care, food preparation, health care, education, work, transportation, vacation, and leisure time) The complexity of these dimensions conveys how difficult this life cycle phase is. However, along with the transition to parenthood, which marriage has long symbolized, society has skewed us toward a romanticized view of this transition as the easiest and most joyous, which adds greatly to its difficulty, since everyone—from the couple to the family and friends—wants to see only its happiness. The problems entailed in forming a couple may thus be obscured and pushed underground, only to intensify and surface later on. Furthermore, as Michael Lerner has pointed out, finding a partner, which used to be a community affair, has become an individual decision often made in terms of what the partner can do to satisfy our needs: In the past relationships were embedded in lar-ger communities of meaning and purpose. The relationship was not about itself, but about some larger shared goal. But today, with those communities of meaning in decline, people increasingly look to their primary sexual relationship to become a compensation for the meaninglessness surrounding them. Yet judged against such standards, very few relationships feel adequate (Lerner, 1995, p. 10). More than any other life transition, marriage is viewed as the solution to life’s problems of loneliness, work and career uncertainty, or extended-family difficulties. The joke that there are six in the marital bed is really an understatement. It has been said that what distinguishes human beings from all other animals is the fact of having in-laws. In the animal kingdom, mating involves only the two partners, who, usually mature, separate from their families, and mate on their own. For humans, it is the joining of two enormously complex systems. If couples could fully appreciate the emotional complexity of negotiating marriage from the start, they might not dare to undertake it. Marriage requires that two people renegotiate a great many issues they have previously defined individually or through their culture and family of origin, such as money, space, time, and when and how to eat, sleep, talk, have sex, fight, work, and relax. The power aspect of negotiating these dimensions often remains invisible, since power inequities in most heterosexual couples are highly likely to be obscured by the couple, the extended family, and the accepted rules of society (Carter & Peters, 1996). Decisions must be made about which family traditions and rituals to retain from each side of the family and which ones partners will develop for themselves. Partners have to renegotiate relationships with parents, siblings, friends, extended family, and co-workers once they marry; it is extremely important, especially for women, that they not curtail these relationships, which are an important life-sustaining force and which would leave them vulnerable to isolation and too frequently to abuse in the marriage. Contrary to the widespread cultural stereotypes that marriage is something men should dread and fear, the research supports the opposite—marriage improves men’s mental health, sex lives, and

financial success and leads them to lower rates of drug and alcohol abuse and depression (Barnett & Rivers, 2004; Mundy, 2012). Overall, of course, the real question is not whether marriage is good for people but what is the quality of the marriage. A stressful marriage is not good for anyone’s health, more particularly for women (Parker-Pope, 2010; Gallo, Troxel, Matthews, & Kuller, 2003; DeNoon, 2003). And on the other side, a good marriage can provide social support, increase in well-being, self- esteem, etc. But given the long-term power that patriarchal values and arrangements still have on marriage, women often subtly lose power when they marry, making decisions that are not good for their long-range financial security or self-esteem when they move out of the paid work force and into more of the new family’s caretaking responsibilities. These are not couple issues only. They are the result of our society’s failure to provide social supports that allow couples to spend time caring for others without jeopardizing their own future. Contrary to the stereotypes of the frustrated old maid and the free unencumbered bachelor, so- called spinsters may do better than bachelors, although bachelors are doing better than they used to, perhaps because they are increasingly finding ways to have a meaningful social network. As more and more couples are passing through a stage of living with one or several partners before marriage, the transition to marriage has become much less of a turning point in the family life cycle than it was in the past. Obviously, the meaning of a wedding changes when a couple has been living together for several years and participating jointly in extended-family experiences. Nevertheless, the transition to marriage can create great turmoil, more so if the partners have not yet dealt with their extended family as a couple. Indeed, the parents may have been hoping the couple would break up and now have to acknowledge the centrality of their child’s relationship. It places no small stress on a family to open itself to an outsider who is now an official member of its inner circle, often the first new member added to the system for many years. Parents must now deal with their child and the partner as a twosome, which can radically change the interactional dynamics. The tendency of members to polarize and see villains and victims under the stress of these changes can be very strong and becomes a key issue for intervention to prevent long-term conflict or estrangement. In any case, there seems to be a timing to the phase of coupling. Many people who marry before 20, as we have seen, tend to have more difficulty adjusting to the tasks of coupling and are much more likely to divorce. Those who marry later are less likely to divorce, and marrying later is becoming more the norm than marrying early. Early marriage may reflect cultural patterns (e.g., Latinos) or class norms (e.g., working-class couples), but those who marry early may also be running away from their families of origin or seeking a family they never had. They may leave home by fusing with a mate in an attempt to gain strength from each other. They may have more difficulties later on as a result of their failure to develop an independent identity first. Women who marry late may be ambivalent about losing their independence and identity in marriage, while men who hesitate may be avoiding commitment. Some of those who marry late have seen a negative image of marriage at home; others have been enmeshed in their families and find it hard to leave home, form outside relationships, or develop a secure work situation.

In spite of the trend toward delaying marriage and pregnancy, a majority of people do marry and have children before the age of 35. Naturally those who have children shortly after marriage have relatively little time to adjust to the status changes of marriage and its accompanying stresses before moving on. The timing of marital decisions often appears to be influenced by events in the extended family, although most couples are unaware of the correlation of these events or the process that underlies their decision to marry. People often seem to meet or make the decision to marry shortly after the retirement, illness, move, or even untimely death of a parent or after another traumatic loss. What is amazing, considering the long-range implications of marriage, is that so many couples spend so little time thinking about the decision. The sense of loss or loneliness can be a strong contributing factor in the desire to build a close relationship. A person in need of being “completed” may be blind to the less-than-ideal aspects of a prospective spouse. This desire for completion is likely to lead to difficulty accepting the spouse’s differentness in the course of the relationship. What Makes Marital Adjustment More Difficult? Many factors influence marriage and marital adjustment. At an individual level, it is influenced by the developmental trajectory of both spouses: their level of self-management, emotional, financial, educational and interpersonal competence, the values and beliefs they have about marriage, about the acceptable roles of men and women, and about equity in relationships. One of the most important factors influencing marital adjustment over the entire life cycle is addiction (Vaillant, 2012). Mental illness of a partner and early trauma can also, of course, have profound impact on marital adjustment. While the saying is that “opposites attract,” it appears that the more differences spouses have between them, the harder their marital adjustment is likely to be: differences in life cycle phase, social location, age, ethnicity, race, religion, sibling constellation, and sibling position. An only child marrying 1 of 10 siblings would likely have a harder adjustment than spouses who are both from 2 sibling families. A 25-year-old who has never been married and a 50-year-old with three teenage children are likely to have a difficult adjustment. Cultural differences can also contribute to couple problems over the life cycle (Rastogi & Thomas, 2009). If you marry someone from a similar culture (Italian-Puerto Rican), it may be easier than if you marry someone from an extremely different culture (Korean–Jewish). In general, if either partner remembers his or her childhood or adolescence as unhappy, it is also likely to make marital adjustment more difficult. At a family level, marital adjustment will be influenced by the relationship partners have with their extended families. In general, couples do best when the extended family is supportive, but it is a question whether a cutoff from the family is better than an extended family that is engaged but conflictual, many suggesting that the latter is healthier—at least the family is struggling to stay connected. Overall the greater the distance each partner has from his or her extended family in social class, education, religious beliefs, and other dimensions, the harder it will be to fit the disparate pieces of the systems together. At a social level, there are again many factors influencing marital adjustment, beginning with the availability of economic and health cushions to support the couple, and also whether their community provides a sense of validation or “home” to ease their adjustment. Indeed indications

are that marriage actually tends to isolate partners from other people in ways that pose potential long-term problems. They have fewer ties to relatives, fewer intimate talks with others, are less likely to care for aging parents, and less likely to socialize with friends during the couple formation period (Sarkisian & Gerstel, 2008). This can be a particular problem for women, whose close friendships are a major support in life. Close female friendships appear to be second only to good health in importance for satisfaction throughout the life cycle. The following list suggests possible adjustment issues we have found relevant in our clinical experience and through our exploration of the literature over the past decades. Many aspects of a marriage are hard to research. Evidence of marital adjustment is difficult to ascertain, since marriage is so complex to study. For example, just staying married is not necessarily a positive measure of a marriage. The quality of marriages is difficult to show, as Vaillant’s longitudinal research over more than 50 years makes very clear. Many individuals in his study did not tell the truth until they were in their 80s, though they had been participating in interviews since they were adolescents (Vaillant, 2012). People do not easily tell all the truth about crucial aspects of their lives. Furthermore, researchers almost never explore extended-family relationships over any meaningful period of time, if at all, because they are so difficult to study. Hopefully, computerized health care records will soon make meaningful longitudinal research on family systems more possible. This would be the only way we could answer the complex questions about marriage and family relationships across the life cycle (Figure 14.1). Fusion and Intimacy A basic dilemma in coupling, once one acknowledges the hidden dimension of power in all relationships, is the confusion of intimacy with fusion. There is a profound difference between forming an intimate relationship and using a couple relationship to complete one’s self. Poets have long talked about the difference. To paraphrase Rainier Maria Rilke: Real love does not mean merging, giving up self, Figure 14.1 Issues that tend to make marital adjustment more difficult. Contextual factors Couple do not have jobs or resources to support themselves adequately. The wedding occurs without family or friends present. Either spouse started but did not complete either high school or college. Timing of the relationship The couple meets or marries shortly after a significant loss. The couple marries early (before age 20) or late (after age 40). The couple marries after an acquaintanceship of less than 6 months or more than 5 years of engagement. The wife becomes pregnant before or within the first year of marriage.

Partners differ in Religious, racial, ethnic, or class background. Financial power, socioeconomic status, education, career options, or skills. The husband believes that men’s rights, needs, or privilege should predominate in marriage and that women should serve the needs of others over their own needs. The danger increases if he tries to Dominate the wife. Isolate her from work, friends, or family. Control her financially or intimidate her physically. Family of origin issues Either partner has a different level of success or social location from his or her own parents, especially a lower success and social location than his/her parents, or the couple comes from a disrupted family. The couple resides either extremely close to or at a great distance from either family of origin. The couple are from incompatible sibling constellations. Either spouse has a poor relationship with siblings or parents, or the parents had poor or unstable relationships themselves. Either spouse considers his or her childhood or adolescence to have been an unhappy time. and uniting with another. What would a relationship be with someone unclarified, undeveloped and undefined. Love is an inducement to both partners to ripen. . . It is a great exacting claim. (Rilke, 1954, p. 54). There are, of course, sex differences in the way fusion is experienced, since women have traditionally been raised to consider “giving themselves” in a relationship as normal, and men have generally been raised to see the vulnerabilities of intimacy as “unmanly.” Thus, men more often express their fusion by maintaining a pseudo-differentiated distant position in relationships, or by jealousy and possessive demands that their partners conform to their wishes, and women by giving up their dreams, their opinions, and even their identity in the relationship. The romantic mythology about couples has led to much confusion in notions of closeness, enmeshment, and fusion, on one side and differentiation, autonomy, disengagement, and distance on the other. The categories offered by Green and Werner (1996) as shown in Figure 14.2 have provided a useful and demystifying framework for understanding the individual and collaborative aspects of intimate couple relationships.

Gottman (1993) and his colleagues (Carstensen, Gottman, & Levenson, 1995) found that the expression of negativity was as necessary as positivity in a marriage, though the ratio between the two needed to be about 4 to 1:4 positive messages to 1 negative message for the relationship to be successful! In addition, we must keep in mind that relationships of heterosexual couples tend to be defined along power and status lines. That is, the partner who makes more money and has more status (usually the man) tends to control the relationship decisions, right down to where they will go on vacation and who will clean the toilet. There have been indications that lesbian couples had more flexibility to define their roles and relationships on a basis other than money, power, and status (Blumstein & Schwartz, 1983). Both lesbian and gay couples appear to have more intimate, cohesive relationships than do heterosexual couples, lesbians the most so, possibly because there is so much they must overcome in the larger social context to have their relationship at all (Gotta et al., 2011). Others may expect a couple to fuse and view the wife as somehow joined to the identity of her husband, increasing the difficulties for a woman in maintaining her separate identity. Men’s fear of intimacy and the social expectations of his “independence” along with women’s adaptiveness tend to inhibit men from developing intimacy in relationships, which requires them to learn a new model of human development, within which they can allow Figure 14.2 Characteristics of intimate relationships. Closeness-Caregiving: made up of warmth, time together, nurturance, physical intimacy, and consistency Openness of Communication: made up of openness, self-disclosure, and the ability to face conflict and differences without avoidance Lack of Intrusiveness made up of: Lack of separation anxiety, possessiveness or jealousy Respecting the other’s need for privacy and time & space alone Lack of emotional over-reactivity to the other’s life problems Lack of mindreading of the other–thinking one knows the other’s thoughts or wishes better than he or she does Lack of aggressive criticism, hurtful attacks, attempts to diminish the other or dominate the other in Disagreements themselves interdependence in their relationships (Dolan Del Vecchio, 2008; Kimmel, 2013).

The tendency to seek fusion with a partner is related to a person’s lack of maturity in relation to his/her family of origin. In other words, couples seek to complete themselves in each other to the degree that they have failed to resolve their relationships with their parents, which would enable them to build new relationships based on each person’s freedom to be himself or herself and to appreciate the other as he or she is. When people seek to enhance their self-esteem in marriage, they deny their “differentness” from their spouse and may develop severe distortions in communication to maintain the myth of agreement. As one woman put it: My husband and I have always been afraid of the stranger in each other. We keep wanting to believe that the other thought the same as we thought they were thinking. We just couldn’t appreciate that here was a new and different person, with his or her own thoughts and feelings, who would make life more interesting. During courtship, couples are usually most aware of the romantic aspects of their relationship. Marriage shifts the relationship from a private coupling to a formal joining of two families. Issues that the partners have not resolved with their own families tend to be factors in marital choice and are likely to interfere with establishing a workable marital balance. Our beliefs about romantic love may be largely determined by our experiences in our family of origin. From this perspective, Romeo and Juliet may have felt intensely attracted to each other precisely because their families prohibited their relationship. Such obstacles may lead to an idealization of the forbidden person. Like so many romantic heroes, Romeo and Juliet were conveniently spared a deeper view of their relationship by their untimely deaths, preserving the romance and perhaps obscuring the more pedestrian underlying family dramas that probably fostered their attraction in the first place. In everyday life, the outcome of such love affairs is often not so romantic, as the following case illustrates. Case Illustration Susan and Joe Susan, the older of two children of a middle-class Jewish family, met her future husband, Joe, in the summer of her first year of college. Her parents had been unhappily married and had invested all their energies in their children’s success. Susan planned to go away to college as did her “computer genius” younger brother, Jon. A month after her high school graduation, Susan’s lawyer father had a stroke. Her mother, who had always been anxious, had been hospitalized for depression when Susan was 10. Ever since the mother was viewed as fragile and now seemed quite close to the edge, criticizing her husband continuously, now that he was so dependent. Susan gave up her plans for going away to college and enrolled in a local college. Over the next year, her father recovered, but then he had a second stroke and had to stop work. Shortly afterward Susan began dating Joe, a machinist whom she met at her summer job as a secretary. Joe was an only child from a working-class Puerto Rican family. Joe hoped to improve his situation by marrying Susan, whose family represented social and financial stability for him. These issues were important to him because of his own experience of racism as a Puerto Rican in New York City and his family’s poverty, related to his father’s disability from a work accident when Joe was a child. Joe’s mother had cared for her husband, as well as for her own mother. Joe had always felt responsible for his parents but powerless to make them happy. He was delighted when Susan gave up college and began

pushing to marry him. He had felt threatened by her college pursuits anyway. For Susan he represented the only way she knew to get away from her family’s expectations. She had been conflicted about school, having felt inadequate in comparison to her brother, whose accomplishments were so much the focus of family attention. She had received mixed messages from her family about continuing her education. She had grown up not believing she was really smart and had felt under great pressure about schoolwork. Joe would free her from this pressure, and would not push her to achieve. He accepted her as she was. He had a steady income, which would mean she would not have to worry about her inability to concentrate on her fears of failure. She could be Joe’s wife, raise a family, and her worries about her own identity would be over. Joe and Susan were attracted to each other and felt better in their relationship than either remembered ever feeling before. Joe’s parents disapproved of Susan’s not being Catholic and suggested strongly that they wait. Susan’s parents disapproved of her marrying someone without a college education and thought she should finish school herself first. They also disapproved of her marrying someone who was not Jewish, though the family was not religious. In quiet moments, Susan herself wondered if she might want someone more educated, but her parents’ disapproval pushed her to defend her choice and to reject their “snobbery.” Prior to marriage, Susan and Joe had little chance to be alone together. What ever time they did have was filled with wedding arrangements and discussion of the families’ pressures on them. But after the wedding, Susan felt restless. Things within her family had quieted down; they had no more reason to protest. Susan quickly became bored and began to pressure Joe to get a better job. Joe felt guilty for having “abandoned” his parents, something he had not let surface during courtship. To improve their financial situation and to deal with his guilt, he suggested they move into his parents’ apartment, while the parents would move to a smaller apartment upstairs. It would save on expenses and be a good investment. Susan agreed, because it meant they would have much nicer living quarters. Almost immediately she began to feel pressure from Joe’s parents to socialize with them and to have children for them. Having married to escape her own parents, she now felt saddled with Joe’s parents, with the added burden of not knowing them well, and often not understanding their conversations, because they spoke Spanish and she did not. Suddenly Joe’s personality irritated her. Where initially she had liked him for his easy-going style and his acceptance of her, she now saw him as lacking ambition. She was embarrassed to have him spend time with her friends, because of his manners, grammar, and lack of education, so she began to avoid her friends, which left her even more isolated. She tried pressuring Joe to fulfill her dreams and satisfy all her relationship needs. He felt increasingly inadequate and unable to respond to her pressure. She felt he was a good lover but began to be more attracted to other men at work and to turn him away. His sense of inadequacy led him to retreat further and he took to going out in the evening with his own friends, with whom he felt more accepted. Susan’s resistance to parental expectations had now been transferred into the marriage. Joe’s hopes for moving beyond his parents’ disappointing lives had now been transformed into pressure from Susan for him to succeed, and he resented it. Neither partner had worked out

individually what they each wanted in life. Each had turned to the other to fulfill unmet needs and now each was disappointed. What began to happen between Susan and Joe is what happens to many couples when the hope that the partner will solve their problems proves unrealistic. There is a tendency to personalize stress and place blame for what goes wrong on the spouse. Given enough stress, couples tend to define their problems solely within the relationship. Once this personalizing process begins, it is difficult to keep the relationship open. Susan began to blame her disappointments in life on Joe, and he saw himself as responsible for her unhappiness. One major factor that tightens couple relationships over time is their tendency to interpret more and more facets of life within the marriage. This is often promoted also by the wider social context, which supports this narrow focus on one’s partner. During courtship, if one partner becomes depressed, the other is not likely to take it too personally, knowing that there are many reasons to get depressed and this may have nothing to do with him or her. The assumption that one is not responsible for the other’s feelings permits an empathic response. After several years of marriage, however, partners have a greater tendency to view the other’s emotional reactions as a reflection of their input and to feel responsible for getting the partner out of the depression. Once a partner begins taking responsibility for the other’s feelings, more and more areas in the relationship may become tension filled. The more one spouse defines him or herself by the other, the less flexibility there will be in the relationship and the more their communication will become constricted in areas that are emotionally charged. These responses are profoundly “gendered” as well. Because women have long been socialized to take responsibility for others’ lives, feelings, and behavior and to consider it selfish to have a life of their own, they are more likely to internalize their problems and feel overresponsible for the marriage. Because men are socialized to define themselves primarily by their ability to provide for their families financially, perform sexually, and handle their emotions without overt emotional dependence, these dimensions will tend to organize their feelings of success. Beyond this they may externalize blame when things go wrong. As Anna Quindlen (2012) has pointed out, in any marriage where two hearts beat as one, that one is likely to be his, not because he is a tyrant, but because realistically that is the way the gender socialization of patriarchy operates. In the case of Susan and Joe, neither of them probably had any awareness that she was bringing into the relationship a lifetime of feeling like a second-class citizen in relation to her brother. Nor did she realize that her mother’s depression, anxiety, and frustration may have related to her having lived a life that disallowed any personal fulfillment, while she was supposed to devote herself to caring for others: her husband, her children, and her extended family. Her mother had been a brilliant student herself and had wanted to go to medical school, but she had been told by her parents that this was an inappropriate goal for a woman and would mean she would “never find a man.” So she found a man, but probably lost herself in the process. Now Susan was perhaps repeating her mother’s mistake, having absorbed her mother’s feelings of being a second-class citizen in childhood. Joe could not see that the very “life force” that attracted him to Susan soon became the rub. He felt “inadequate” in relation to her intelligence and drive. If he had not had to measure himself by

a yardstick that said men should be smarter and more successful, he could have enjoyed her strength and intensity. Instead he saw it as a measure of his failure and tried to stifle or avoid it. Had Susan felt freer from the gender inequities and constraints of our society, she might have appreciated Joe for his sweetness and commitment to his family and used the marriage as a base from which to evolve her own life and develop her confidence and skills. Courtship is probably the least likely time of all phases of the life cycle for couples to seek therapy. This is not because coupling is so easy, but rather because of the tendency to idealize each other and not to want to look at how difficult it is to establish a lasting intimate relationship. While the first years of marriage are the time of greatest overall marital satisfaction for many, they are also a time of likely divorce. The degree of mutual disappointment will usually match the degree of idealization of the relationship during courtship, as in the case of Susan and Joe. The pull during courtship to ignore potential difficulties means they are avoided until further down the road. On the one hand, most spouses have their closest and most open relationship during this period. It is common for living-together relationships to be harmonious and for symptoms of fusion not to develop until after marriage. The fusion may not become problematic as long as there is still a relatively flexible option to terminate the relationship. The commitment and boundaries of marriage may tighten a relationship, especially if a pattern of pseudomutuality developed earlier where partners felt pressured to pretend they liked everything about each other and wanted to share all their free time together, keeping all differences hidden. In fact, Susan and Joe did not seek therapy until she became depressed in the wake of a miscarriage and began to look at what had happened to her in the marriage and before. Initally she sought therapy alone, but as she explored her own issues, Joe became motivated to deal with the marital problems. Over the course of exploring their very unformed relationship, Susan decided to return to college and Joe, after a period of anger and resentment, began to accommodate to her wishes and work his schedule around hers, which allowed her to finish school. Although there were many ups and downs, the couple did not separate during the period of therapy but rather found ways to deepen their connection and accept their cultural and educational differences. It is not uncommon for two people who have been living happily together to find that things change when they marry, because they and society have now added to the situation the burdensome definitions of “husband” and “wife.” These concepts often bring with them a heavy responsibility for rather than to each other, which living together did not engender, compounded by the feeling of no exit imposed by most religions. There may also be the burden of having passed definitively beyond youth into “serious” adulthood. Couples may also have the misperception that marriage will automatically fulfill them, regardless of other aspects of their lives. Of course, this is an even greater problem in our era when it is so difficult for those without a college education to support a family, and increasingly even for those with a college education. Family attitudes and social myths about marriage filter down from generation to generation, making such transitions smoother or more difficult.

Couples can become bound in a web of evasiveness and ambiguity, neither daring to be honest with the other for fear of hurting the other’s feelings, if their families of origin had tenuous or negative relationships. Communication may become more and more covert, the more they define their own worth by the relationship. The concept of “marriage” may have taken on a meaning far beyond the fact of two people sharing their lives with each other. Couples may fall into stereotypical roles where she can think of nothing but getting married, the one thing he cannot think about. These patterns reflect the gendered opposite sides of the same lack of differentiation from their families of origin. Men who are not comfortable with their level of differentiation typically fear commitment, whereas women typically fear being alone. Recently, women want the freedom to develop their own lives and relationships while men may want them to stay at their side (Rosin, 2012). Gay and Lesbian Couples The patterns described here for heterosexual couples may be both simpler and more difficult for gay and lesbian couples (Green & Mitchell, 2008; Gotta et al., 2011). It appears to be an advantage for gays and lesbians that they are less bound by the constricting rigidities of traditional gender roles, which may leave them freer to develop intimate relationships (Green et al., 1996). Both partners being of the same gender may increase the couple’s understanding of each other. Although some therapists have thought that being of the same gender might increase the likelihood of fusion, research indicates both gay and lesbian couples seem to have more cohesive relationships than heterosexual couples, lesbians tending to have the greatest level of closeness (Green et al., 1996; Gotta et al., 2011). On the other hand, the lack of acceptance that many gay couples experience from their families and from society at large throughout the life cycle is a serious issue and one clinicians are often in a position to help families modify. The price of the secrecy forced on many gay and lesbian couples by society’s disapproval is one we must change. The stigmatizing of homosexual couples by our society means that their relationships are still often not validated by their families or communities and they must cope with prejudice on a daily basis. The AIDS crisis produced a terrible trauma for the gay community, and its impact on a whole generation of gay men at the point of forming couple relationships must not be underestimated. Clinicians can help couples and their families counter familial and societal negativity by developing life cycle rituals to celebrate and affirm their relationships. Special effort is often required on the couple’s part to receive adequate recognition of their relationship transitions. Case Illustration Katherine Moore and Rita Hidalgo Katherine Moore, a 27-year-old journalist, and Rita Hidalgo, a 30-year-old graphic artist, had been living together for almost 2 years when they sought help for their relationship problems. Katherine was not sleeping, and Rita was concerned that she was depressed, anxious, and drinking too much. Katherine had been withdrawing from Rita, feeling she was becoming intrusive and bossy. Katherine had struggled since her midteens with her lesbianism. In college she dated men occasionally, hoping this would release her from her homosexual feelings and the disruption she believed a homosexual lifestyle would create for her and her family of origin. In fact, after college she kept a great distance from her parents, with whom she had always had a stormy relationship. She had been known in her family as the problem child since elementary school.

Her conservative Anglo-Irish family operated on the basis of keeping up appearances. Her older sister was the “good girl” and never went beyond the limits accepted by the family. Katherine was the outspoken rebel. She argued politics with her father, and when she became involved in women’s rights he became particularly incensed. Katherine felt that her mother covertly sided with her at times but never dared to disagree openly with her father. After she became involved in women’s rights, Katherine had several lesbian relationships, but Rita was her first live-in partner. Four months earlier, they had decided to commit to their relationship permanently, at which point Katherine’s symptoms increased. Rita, who came from a Puerto Rican family, had known clearly since high school that she was a lesbian and had socialized with a gay social group from the time she began college. She had not seen her father for years but felt close to her mother and sister. She had never directly spoken of her sexual orientation at home, but she had occasionally brought home female friends and sensed that her mother, who had never remarried after divorcing her father when Rita was 7, might be lesbian herself without knowing it. She suspected that a paternal aunt who had lived for years with another woman was lesbian too. What precipitated Katherine’s turmoil was her announcement to her parents during a visit, which she always made without Rita, that she was lesbian. She had decided to tell her parents about this because she was tired of keeping her life a secret. The resolution to have a commitment ceremony was part of this decision. Her mother initially seemed not unsupportive, but her father became extremely angry and told her this was just the last in a series of her “bad judgments” over many years. In several phone calls to her parents over the next weeks, she was greeted with stony silence by both parents. Rita tried to be supportive, but she had disapproved of Katherine’s telling her parents about her homosexuality, believing that “parents never understand and there’s no point getting into all that.” Katherine’s symptoms had begun just after this. Rita became increasingly resentful of Katherine’s preoccupation with her parents, feeling it was destroying their relationship. Katherine had spoken to a number of her lesbian friends who also advised her to forget about her parents, because her father sounded like “an insensitive redneck” and why bother. As Katherine described her relationship with her parents, it became clear that she was seeking not only greater closeness with them but also their approval for her lesbian choice. Rita had trouble appreciating that she had to let Katherine work out her own relationship with her parents, whatever happened, but after a few discussions she agreed to back off and let Katherine figure things out for herself. The initial therapy sessions focused on helping Katherine sort out her feelings and desires. She struggled to distinguish between her wish that her parents would approve of her lesbianism, her desire to be closer to them in general, and her wish for their approval of her behavior in particular. How could she remain connected to her parents even if they disapproved of her lesbianism, and how could she let go of her need for their approval? She was coached to write a series of letters to each parent about her years of distancing and rebellion, her criticism of them (for which she now apologized), and her appreciation of how difficult her lesbian choice must be for them. She spoke of her earlier fears that they would cut her off completely and her relief that they had not.

Katherine’s letters helped her clarify for herself that her lesbianism was not a matter for her parents’ approval or disapproval. She came to see that discussing her lifestyle with them came from a deep need to solidify her identity as an adult and end the secrecy of her life that had kept her distant from them. Luckily, through her motivation to understand herself and her respect for her parents’ limitations, she was able to keep her couplehood with Rita from being overburdened by her hurt. After 6 months of therapy, Rita decided it was time to speak directly with her own mother, realizing through Katherine’s efforts, how much could be gained by ending the secrecy, even when, as with Katherine, the response had not been particularly positive. Rita’s mother said she had known for years and was just waiting for Rita to feel comfortable telling her. When, a few months later, they had their marriage ceremony, Rita’s mother, sister, and paternal aunt came (though the aunt left her partner at home), but only Katherine’s sister attended from her family. While this was not what they both had hoped for, Katherine felt reassured that her “good girl” sister had come. Perhaps in the future, when they planned to have a baby, Katherine’s sister would be able to assist the parents in moving toward more acceptance, now that the “sisterhood” was solidified. As can be seen from this example, the systemic problems around couple formation are generally similar, regardless of the content of the problems. However, certain patterns are quite predictable for gay and lesbian couples, as they are for religious, social class, ethnic, or racial intermarriages. When the extended family is extremely negative toward the couple, for whatever reason, we encourage couples to take a long view, not trying to turn the acceptance of their relationship into a yes-or-no event, but working gradually over time to build bridges for family closeness. Other life cycle transitions, particularly births and deaths, often create shifts in family equilibrium that may allow the couple to further redefine their family status. The Wedding The wedding is often seen as the end of a process: “And they lived happily ever after.” But it is really just the beginning. Whether weddings involve jumping the broom, as in African American tradition; standing under a huppa and crushing a wine glass, as in Jewish tradition; feasting for many days, as in Polish tradition; or other customs, they are among the most interesting family rituals to observe and among the best times for preventive intervention in family process. Even now with marriage rates going down and divorce rates high, weddings are becoming ever more expensive and elaborate, even for those who cannot afford them, perhaps reflecting the ongoing idealization of marriage in a world where marital relationships are relatively fragile. As family events, weddings are generally the largest ceremonies organized by families themselves. The organization of the wedding, who makes which arrangements, who gets invited, who comes, who pays, how much emotional energy goes into the preparations, who gets upset and over which issues, are all highly reflective of family process. In general, when couples marry in unconventional ways, in civil ceremonies, or without family or friends present, there are reasons, such as the inability or unwillingness of the parents to meet the costs of the wedding; family disapproval because of race, religion, class, money, or ethnicity; premarital pregnancy; an impulsive decision to marry; and a previous divorce. From a clinical point of view, the emotional charge of such situations, when they lead to downplaying the marriage as a family event, may well indicate that family members are unable to make the status changes required to adapt to this new life cycle phase that requires an expansion of family boundaries to include the new spouse

and his or her family, culture, life style, etc. Families that have difficulty making this transition are likely have difficulty at future phases. As rituals, weddings are meant to facilitate family transition to a new constellation. As such, they can be extremely important in helping families mark the change in status, relationships, and organization of the family. Some families overfocus on the wedding, putting all their energy into the event, spending more than they can afford, and losing sight of the marriage as a process of joining two families. The average wedding (not including the ring or honeymoon) exceeds the median U.S. income (Safdar, 2012). Such spending appears to reflect distorted social mythology that makes it difficult for couples and families to focus on the true meaning of marriage. With changing mores, this focus on the wedding may become less intense, but there is still a large overlap of myth associated with marital bliss, which can get displaced onto wedding celebrations in counterproductive ways. Marri-age may indeed become a toxic issue for families because of their particular history. Case Illustration Ted and Andrea Ted and Andrea had toxic issues on both sides of their extended family and sought consultation to see if there was anything they could do to improve their situation. Through premarital coaching, they were able to field stormy reactions in their families and probably prevent years of simmering conflicts that had hampered both extended families over several generations. When they sought help they said they were planning to marry in their apartment with only a few friends present, unless they could bring their families around to accepting them as they were. Andrea’s parents had eloped after her grandparents opposed their marriage because of religious differences and they had hardly seen their families since. Ted’s paternal grandfather had had a heart attack at his son’s (Ted’s father’s) wedding reception and died the next day. Thus, weddings had become dreaded events for both extended families. Ted and Andrea began their work by contacting extended-family members to invite them personally to their wedding. They used these conversations to mention in a casual way the pain of the wedding history for the family. For example, Ted phoned his paternal grandmother, who was 85, and who his parents had assured him would never come to the wedding. He told her that his parents were sure she could not make it, but that it would mean a great deal to him to have her there, since he feared his father might have a heart attack and he would need her support. The grandmother not only made her own arrangements to have a cousin fly with her but also arranged to stay with her son, Ted’s father, for the week after the wedding. At the reception, both bride and groom made toasts in verse to their families, in which they ticked off the charged issues with humor and sensitivity and made a special point of spending time with family members. Surprisingly, few couples seek premarital counseling, in spite of the obvious difficulties in negotiating this transition, and in spite of the fact that preventive intervention in relation to the extended families might be much easier than dealing with issues down the road. The most that can be said is that it is extremely useful if one has access to any member of a family at the time of a wedding to encourage him or her to facilitate the resolution of family relationships through this nodal event. For example, it is often fruitful to convey to the couple that in-law struggles are predictable and need not be taken too personally. It is important for couples to recognize that the

heightened parental tension probably relates to their sense of loss regarding the marriage. They generally fear they are losing their child rather than gaining another. When families argue about wedding arrangements, the conflicts often cover up underlying systemic issues. Family members often view others as capable of “ruining” the event. A useful guideline is for each person to take his or her own responsibility for having a good time at the wedding. It is also useful for the couple to recognize that marriage is a family event and not just for the two of them. From this perspective, parents’ feelings about the service need to be taken into consideration in whatever meaningful ways are possible. The more responsibility a couple can take for arranging a wedding that reflects their shifting position in their families and the joining of the two systems, the more auspicious for their future relationship. Case Illustration Jim and Joan Jim Marcus spent 6 months in “coaching” for his wedding, at which he wanted the participation of his actively alcoholic mother and the three other mothering figures who had been important in his life. His parents had divorced when he was 5. His father remarried for 6 years when Jim was 8 and again when he was 15. He had grown up in his father’s custody, with a family housekeeper-caretaker involved during and between his father’s marriages. Jim had distanced himself from his alcoholic mother and from both stepmothers. Through coaching, he was able to reverse the process of cutoff in his arrangements for the wedding. He called his stepmothers and his childhood housekeeper to invite them specially to the wedding, discussing with each her importance in his life and how much it would mean to him to have her present at his wedding celebration. He wrote to his own mother and similarly reviewed the moments in their lives that were most meaningful to him. He arranged with his older brother to be on duty on the day of the wedding and escort the mother out if that became necessary. The next problem was the parents of his fiancée, Joan, who were planning an elaborate celebration and wanted everything to go according to the book. This would have made Jim’s less affluent family very uncomfortable. Initially, Joan became quite reactive to her mother’s fancy plans and her way of making decisions without discussion. At the therapist’s suggestion, she arranged to spend a day with her mother, during which time she could discuss her feelings about her upcoming marriage and approach her mother as a resource on how to handle things. She discovered for the first time that her mother had been married in a small civil wedding, because her Catholic parents disapproved of her marriage to a Jewish immigrant with no college education. Joan learned how her mother had yearned for a “proper wedding.” She realized that her mother’s wishes to do everything in a fancy way had grown out of her own unrealized dreams and were an attempt to give Joan something she had missed. With this realization, Joan could share her own wish for a simple celebration to make Jim feel comfortable, especially because of all the problems in his family, which she had never mentioned to her mother before. She asked her mother for advice on how to handle the situation. She told her how uncomfortable she was about the divorces in Jim’s family and her fears that her own relatives would disapprove of him, especially if all his mothering figures attended the wedding. Suddenly her mother’s attitude changed from dictating how things had to be done to a helpful and much more casual attitude. A week later, Joan’s mother told Jim that if there was any way she could facilitate things with his mother, stepmothers, or other guests, she would be glad to do it.

It frequently happens that friendship systems and extended-family relationships change after the wedding. Many couples have difficulty maintaining individual friendships and move, at least in the first years, toward having only “couple friends.” We encourage spouses to keep their individual friendship networks as well, since “couple friends” typically reinforce fusion and may not allow the spouses their individual interests and preferences, which are so important to their lifelong well-being. Sexuality Our society has almost no images that would help us in developing sexually gratifying partnership relationships (Carter & Peters, 1996). Working with couples means helping them to become pioneers in their sexual relationships, just as it does in other aspects of forming a partnership, as opposed to the traditional couple relationship of a powerful, dominant male and a submissive, responsive female. Helping couples establish flexible and intimate sexual relationships involves freeing them from the gender stereotypes that are part of their familial and cultural heritage (Schnarch, 2010). From early childhood, boys are encouraged to feel positive about their bodies sexually, whereas girls have rarely been encouraged even to be familiar with their genitalia, let alone to enjoy their sexuality. Boys typically begin to masturbate from early childhood, girls not till mid- adolescence, if then. Women generally have to bear the burden of the repercussions of sexuality in terms of contraception, and in many groups they are prohibited from using contraception or refusing sex, subjecting them to all the consequences of sexuality, from pregnancy to sexually transmitted diseases, but not to being proud of being sexual or even knowing how their bodies work. What is surprising is not that sex so often becomes a problem for a couple, but that it works out as often as it does. The current generation has much more sexual experience and knowledge than previous generations. Unlike the increasng age at marriage, the age at sexual maturation and first intercourse have decreased. Males and especially females are having sex with more partners at younger ages than ever before. The vast majority of young adults (approximately 90 percent) are sexually experienced, and most have sex regularly. At the same time, anxieties about AIDS, herpes, and other sexual transmitted diseases are active concerns for young couples today. In the past, if a husband lost interest in sex, we assumed he was having an affair. Now we ask about recent changes in the wife’s income and status, since sexuality seems so clearly linked with power issues in marriage for both partners. Even where a woman develops a flirtation or affair, as in the case of Susan and Joe, we explore whether her behavior might be an attempt (however misguided) to empower herself through a sexual relationship, because as a woman she has felt disempowered overall in the relationship. Our experience is that techniques to enhance sexual enjoyment are only a small part of dealing with a couple’s sexual problems. It is important to consider the power dimension in a couple’s relationship when the partners are experiencing sexual difficulty. Sex is at the heart of expressions of intimacy, and the inability to express intimacy is very likely to be related to familial and cultural factors that have made intimacy in this form and most forms are very difficult for men and women in our society. In addition to exploring sexuality in the extended family in order to understand the specific messages that partners have been given about their bodies, their own sexuality, and their expectations about

what is “sexy” with a partner, therapists need to take into account the larger cultural dimensions within which our sexual relationships evolve (Schnarch, 2010). We must pay attention to the implicit power dimensions influencing this aspect and all other aspects of a couple’s relationship. Given the very high levels of violence against wives in marriage and the trouble our nation still has acknowledging marital rape, we must be very careful not to limit our work with a couple to the interior of their intimate relationship without taking account of the power dimensions that operate in all couple relationships. One of the most interesting, and usually forgotten, aspects of human sexuality is that unlike most other animals whose sexuality is limited to times when they can reproduce, human sexuality operates regardless of fertility, which may suggest it is an adaptive development to help maintain joie de vivre, affection and caretaking in human relationships over the long haul of couples’ lives (Bateson, 2010). Patterns with Extended Family Women tend to move closer to their families of origin after marriage, while men may become more distant, shifting their primary tie to the new nuclear family. In any case, spouses’ ways of dealing with their families may differ. Many find marriage the only way to separate from their families of origin, but their underlying enmeshment in the family continues even after marriage. Patterns of guilt, intrusiveness, and unclear boundaries are typical of such systems. Other couples may cut off their families emotionally even before marriage, some going to the extreme of not inviting them to the wedding. Sometimes parents are seen as withholding and rejecting and the couple decides to do without them. Others push ongoing conflicts or tension under the rug. In such families, there is usually involvement of the extended family in the marriage plans, but often with fights, hurt feelings, and “scenes” around the wedding. This pattern of conflicts indicates that the family is at least struggling over the transition and is not forcing the feelings underground as in enmeshed or cutoff families. The ideal situation is where the partners have become independent of their families before marriage and at the same time maintain close, caring ties. In such instances, the wedding can serve for all the family as a sharing celebration of the new couple’s shift in status. Where couples cut off family relationships, their restrictive couple patterns may work until later life transitions destabilize them. Where conflicts are submerged, marriage may be an excellent opportunity to reopen closed relationships, for example, inviting to the wedding relatives with whom parents are out of touch. It is a good chance to detoxify emotional issues, reviewing marital and family ties over several generations as part of redefining the system. Otherwise underlying tensions may surface in emotional scenes or arguments around wedding plans, only to go underground again as family members try to act happy and friendly so as not to “create unpleasantness.” The attempt to smooth things over in itself may increase the likelihood of future relationship eruptions. The fact is that all change disrupts the system and needs to be dealt with if the developmental processes are to proceed. It may be easier for the family to move on if they are in touch with their sense of loss at the time of the wedding and confused and uneasy about how to manage the new relationships. Whatever the patterns of difficulty with extended family— conflict, enmeshment, distance, or cutoff—the lack of resolution of these relationships is the major problem in negotiating this phase of the family life cycle. The more the triangles in the extended family are dealt with by an emotional cutoff, the greater the likelihood that the spouse

will come to represent more than who he or she is. If the husband’s relationship with his wife is his only meaningful relationship, he is likely be so sensitive to her every reaction, and especially to any hint of rejection, that he may overreact to signs of differentness by pulling her to agree with him or blaming her for not accepting him. In time, the intensity may make the relationship untenable, jamming the circuits. Our culture’s social mobility and over-focus on the nuclear family to the neglect of all other relationships contributes to this tendency to place more emotional demand on a marriage than it can bear. Indeed the indications are that marriage actually tends to isolate partners from other people in ways that pose potential long-term problems (Sarkisian & Gerstel, 2008). Once a spouse becomes overly involved in the other’s response, both can become bound up in a web of fusion and unable to function for themselves. Some couples transfer parental struggles to the spouse directly. Others choose a spouse who handles the family for them. A man may choose a wife totally unacceptable to his parents and then let her fight his battles with his parents, while he becomes the “innocent bystander.” The price everyone pays in such situations is the failure to achieve any real connection, since issues can never be resolved when other members are brought in to handle one’s relationships. Similar problems arise when a person has served a central function in his or her parents’ lives or in the preservation of the parents’ marital balance and does not feel entitled to marry. In-laws Among the problematic triangles for the couple, the one involving husband, wife, and mother-in- law is probably the most obvious. In-laws are easy scapegoats for family tensions. It is always easier to hate your daughter-in-law for keeping your son from showing his love than to admit that your son does not respond to you the way you wish he would. It may be easier for a daughter-in-law to hate her mother-in-law for “intrusiveness” than to confront her husband directly for not speaking up to define the necessary boundaries for their relationship with his parents. In-law relationships are a natural arena for displacing tensions in the couple or in the family of origin of each spouse. The converse of this is the spouse who has cut off his or her own family and seeks to adopt the spouse’s family, forming a warm, enmeshed fusion with the in- laws, based on defining his or her own family as cold, rejecting, uninteresting, and so on. Our society generally focuses blame on the mother-in-law rather than on the father-in-law, who is usually seen as playing a more benign role. Just as mothers get blamed for what goes wrong in families because they are given primary responsibility for family relationships, so do mothers-in- law get primary blame by extension. Many factors contribute to this process. Just as wives are often given responsibility for handling a husband’s emotional problems, they tend to be put in the position of expressing issues for all other family members and then blamed when things go wrong. Sibling issues in couple formation Siblings may also displace their problems in dealing with each other onto the new spouse. Predictable triangles are especially likely between a husband and his wife’s brothers or between the wife and her husband’s sisters. Sisters may see their brother’s wife as having “no taste,” infusing the brother with superficial values, and so forth. What is missed by the system in such instances is that the brother probably chose his wife as a protection from his sisters, perhaps to set the limits he never dared set alone or to allow him to distance without the guilt of doing so

directly. Often the brother will get his wife to take over dealing with his family altogether, which usually succeeds only in escalating the tension. Good clues about a couple can be found in the marital relationships of each partner’s parents, the primary models for what their marriage is about. The other basic model for spouses is their relationship with their siblings, generally their earliest and closest peers. Couples who marry mates from complementary sibling positions tend to enjoy the greatest marital stability (Toman, 1976). In other words, the older brother of a younger sister will tend to get along best with a younger sister of an older brother. They are likely to have fewer power conflicts, since he will be comfortable as the leader and she as the follower. In addition, they will tend to be comfortable with the opposite sex, since they have grown up with opposite-sexed siblings as well. Those who marry spouses not from non-complementary sibling positions may have more marital adjustments to make in this regard. An extreme case would be the oldest of many brothers who marries the oldest of many sisters. Both would expect to be the leader and would probably be less comfortable with the opposite sex, having grown up in strongly single-sexed environments. Cultural differences Another arena that becomes problematic in a marriage under stress is the cultural or family style difference. This may be more of a problem in the United States where people from so many diverse cultural backgrounds marry and find themselves in conflict because each starts out with such different basic assumptions (McGoldrick & Preto, 1984; McGoldrick, Giordano, & Garcia Preto, 2005; Karis & Killian, 2011). Case Illustration Jack and Maria Jack and Maria applied for therapy after a year of marriage because Maria said she was convinced Jack did not love her and that he had changed after they got married. The wife was the fifth of seven children from a Brooklyn family whose grandparents had immigrated from Italy. She had met her husband in college and was extremely attracted to his quiet strength and strong life ambitions. He was from a midwestern Protestant family of British, German, and Dutch heritage where, as an only child, he was strongly encouraged by his parents to work hard and have a morally upright life. Jack had found Maria vivacious and charming and had also been attracted to her family, because of their open affection and because, in contrast to his own “uptight” parents, they always seemed to have a good time. Under stress, the couple found that the very qualities that had attracted them to each other became the problem. Jack became for Maria “an unfeeling stone.” She complained: “He doesn’t care about my feelings at all and ignores me completely.” For Jack, Maria’s vivaciousness now became “hysteria” and he found her “nagging, emotional outbursts, and screaming” unbearable. As we discussed in therapy, their very different family styles of coping with stress and their opposing assumptions became obvious. In Jack’s family, the rule was that you should keep your problems to yourself and think them out: With enough effort and thought, most problems could be worked out. Maria’s family dealt with stress by getting together and venting. The family related intensely at all times, but especially when they were upset. These styles had been turned inward in the marriage and were tightening things even more. The more isolated Maria felt and the more she needed contact, the louder she sought attention and the more Jack withdrew to

remain calm and maintain his balance. The more he withdrew, the more frustrated and alone Maria felt. Both had turned their differences, initially the source of attraction, into the problem and saw the other’s behavior as a sure sign of not caring. Neither could see that their family styles were just different. They were compounding the difficulty by blaming each other for the other’s response. Once the family patterns could be clarified in the context of the extended family and ethnic backgrounds, Maria and Jack were able to temper their responses and to see their differences as neutral, rather than as signs of psychopathology or rejection. Conclusion Marriage in the twenty-first century is being profoundly affected by the diversity of marriage partners, the changing definitions of marriage, the increasing physical distance from families of origin, the changing role of women, the increase in unmarried couples living together, the frequency of changing partners, and the diminishing role of community in supporting families. Couples are increasingly isolated and expected to manage their lives and families without the community supports that in the past were a primary resource in raising children and meeting family needs. Couples are less bound by family traditions and are freer than ever before to develop male–female relationships unlike those of earlier members of their families of origin. Couples are required to think out for themselves many things that in the past would have been taken for granted. This applies also to the enormous gap that often exists between parents and children in education and social status. Although these differences can cause strain, we also live at a time when the possibilities for couples to have creative and equitable partnerships are great. The cultural differences can add flexibility to the system and stretch the family to become adaptive over the life cycle in new ways. The marriage cycle of couples choosing to marry in the twenty-first century will surely require this creative adaptation, and we have probably only begun to imagine how couple relationships in the future may evolve. Chapter 15 Becoming Parents: The Family With Children Monica McGoldrick Barbara Petkov Betty Carter Learning Outcomes

 List and describe the changes that have occurred in the last generation in the timing and patterns of the life cycle phase of becoming parents.

 Discuss the impact a new baby has on its extended family system.

 Explore the stresses that the parenthood life cycle phase puts on couples and responses

that can help alleviate these stresses.

 Describe the importance of quality child care to both children and families.

 List and describe developmental tasks that are important for families with young

children.

 Examine important issues that should be addressed by parents and other care takers during early childhood.

 Discuss how single parenting, teenage parenting, infertility, adoption, and having children

with disabilities affect child rearing tasks.

 Explore the clinical guidelines for working with a family presenting at the phase of parents with young children.

Making the decision to have a child—it’s momentous. It is to decide forever to have your heart walking around outside your body.

—Elizabeth Stone Nobody has ever before asked the nuclear family to live all by itself in a box the way we do. With no relatives, no support, we’ve put it in an impossible situation.

—Margaret Mead (en.wikiquote.org)

The Transition to Parenthood Becoming a parent is one of the most definitive transitions in life, a crossing of the Rubicon. Life will never be the same again. It is lucky that most parents fall passionately in love with their new babies and consider them fascinating, because this helps carry them through the many difficulties in store for them. The roller coaster of the early months and years of parenthood come as a shock to most new parents: sleep deprivation, shredded schedules, endless chores, worry about the baby’s development or one’s own competence, and the need for ceaseless vigilance. The sudden threat of chaos puts enormous stress on new parents and on their relationship, since no amount of doing ever seems enough to get the job done before it needs to be done again. The timing and patterns of this life cycle phase have changed dramatically within the past generation. Precipitated by the availability of birth control and shifts toward more equitable relationships between men and women, having a child has become a more or less conscious choice for the first time in history. Families are having fewer children, less than 2 per couple, down from 3.2 in 1976, and this will profoundly influence families throughout life cycle for future generations. The percent of women who do not have children has also doubled since 1970 from 10 to 20 percent. Educated professional women are even more likely to remain childless (27 percent) (Zezima, 2008). Since 1950, the percent of births taking place outside of marriage has also gone from 4 to 41 percent, but the rate is 53 percent for children born to women younger than 30 years (DeParle & Tavernise, 2012), although this includes a fair percentage same-sex and other non-married couples (Cherlin, 2009). In the same time period, the percent of households made up of married couples with children has shrunk from 43 to 25 percent (Tavernise, 2011). Overall about 60 percent of parents are couples where the husband is the primary breadwinner. Of the other 40 percent, 15 percent are married women who are the primary earners of their families and the final 25 percent are single parents, almost all mothers, who are raising one third

of all our children (Anderson, 2013; Wang, Parker, & Taylor, 2013). The finances of parenting also reflect a most unfortunate imbalance. When a woman has a child (and the more children, the worse), her salary goes down. When a man has a child, his salary goes up! And this is when we control for type of job, education, experience, spousal income, and job hours (Miller, 2014; Budig & England, 2001). The tasks of the parenting phase flow from the adjustment of the couple system to make space for children physically, psychologically, and spiritually. Making space requires collaboration in child-rearing, financial and housekeeping tasks, and realigning relationships with grandparents and other extended family, the community, and larger social system. Each family brings to the transition to parenthood its own cultural history about intergenerational relationships, gender roles, and expectations for child–parent, grandparent, and aunt and uncle behavior, just as each person brings his or her own legacy from childhood. A person who remembers a happy childhood and good parents may want to repeat that experience, while someone escaping a terrible childhood wants to do it differently. There is no way to understand parenting without looking at this past, the cultural surround, and at families’ expectations for their future. The family demographics and patterns of childrearing demonstrate our society’s increasing diversity of family forms. The parenting cycle now extends from early teen years to as late as age 50 for women and 60+ for men, and couple and parenting arrangements are diverse as well.

Changing trends in American families for childrearing include the following:  At least one half of all children in the next generation will live in female-headed

households (Webb, 2005), and most mothers are in the work force, making child care an increasing issue for families in the United States (Coontz, 2013).

 An increasing proportion of U.S. families raising children are people of color,

multiracial families, adoptive families (often with multiracial children), and multicultural families often speaking two primary languages for at least two generations.

 An increasing proportion of families involve sexually variant parents and/or other

close relatives.

 Economic conditions affecting employment and the rising costs of child care, health care, and education are an ever-increasing factor in how well families can negotiate the stage of parenting children (Leonhardt, 2011; Reardon, 2013). These stressors create much more severe hardships for families at the margins: those who are poor, of color, immigrants, or whose children or other family members have special needs or experience social stigma.

What children need for their development Infancy to About Age Two

The earliest tasks of infancy and early childhood involve skills of autonomy, empathy, and emotional attunement to others. Children learn from their earliest infancy to communicate their needs and to have a sense of trust, comfort, and relationship with their caretakers and with the world around them. They begin to develop body coordination and motor skills. They also begin to talk, play, walk, and to feed themselves. They learn to overcome fears of new people and situations, to reognize themselves as separate, and begin to develop empathy for others. What parents, other guardians, and caretakers must do to support this growth is to meet children’s needs consistently, so they can develop trust in others and a sense of security. Early Childhood To Elementary School From the time children begin to walk until they enter primary school, their major tasks involve increasing the same skills of autonomy, self-management, emotional competence, and the ability to relate to others. They are developing language, communication, motor skills, control of their bodies, cognitive skills with numbers, words and objects, the ability to take direction, to cooperate, to share, to trust, to form peer relationships, and to explore the world around them. Children begin to recognize other’s pain as separate from their own and to comfort them. They begin to become aware of themselves as different from others on many dimensions including gender, race, and ability level. As children enter school, parents, guardians, and other caretakers must develop supportive parenting skills, especially in the area of discipline and rule setting. How this is handled will greatly influence a child’s identity and emotional competence. Shaming and physical punishment have deleterious effects, whereas support and consistent nurturing and mentoring promote childrens’ ability to stretch themselves in their learning and confidence. Children Through Elementary School The years of elementary school are a time when children make many developmental leaps in cognitive, motor, and emotional relationship skills and in perceptiveness of the interdependence of all relationships. Children are expanding their social worlds and learning about belonging and “otherness,”—inclusion and exclusion. They learn to communicate and to handle relationships with an increasing range of adults and children beyond their families. Their concerns often focus on competition, cooperation, expanded awareness of gender roles, race, culture, sexual orientation, class, and level of abilities. Children at this phase have increasing access to knowledge through reading, TV, the internet, and social media. Skills children need to work on at this phase include their ability to be intimate and empathic; and to express anger, fear, and pain in nondestructive ways, which increases their sense of morality and fairness, as well as their tolerance for differences. Children need their parents’ and caretakers’ active involvement in mentoring them to support cooperation, non-violence, and respect for others, or else competitiveness can become a serious problem. They need their parents’ support in not engaging in bullying behavior. Parents and other adults have a major role to play in teaching children to respect and support others in their social network and community.

Children may play adults off against each other to get what they want because they do not yet know how to confront adults to let them know when they feel neglected, rejected, or ignored (Comer & Poussaint, 1992). The quality of a child’s relationships with adults is more important than the gender of the adults, for both male and female children. Children are aware of unfairness and hypocrisy of adults and authorities. It is important for adults to help them understand adult failings and to model responses to unfairness so that they do not feel powerless and cynical. Abused or neglected children may become aggressive—picking fights out of frustration, disconnection, and hopelessness. As children grow in their cognitive, motor, and emotional relationship skills and interdependent perceptiveness, they expand their social world in terms of their ability to communicate and handle relationships with an increasing range of adults and children beyond their families. From quite an early age, they begin to understand their identity in terms of gender, race, culture, and sexual orientation and to differentiate themselves from others (Quintana, 2008; Bennett, 2007; Coll & Szalacha, 2004; Robbins, Szapocznik, Mayorga, Dillon, Burns, & Feaster, 2007). They also hopefully improve in their ability to follow directions, tolerate frustration, work independently, and cooperate with others. If they are not supported in developing these abilities for self-management, they may develop physical, emotional, or social symptoms—fears, anxieties, and withdrawn or aggressive behaviors. Through elementary school years, children often spend a lot of time discussing, arguing, and changing the rules of games. As their independence–dependence struggle intensifies, it is important to teach them to do chores and meet responsibilities for their own sake, rather than because they are told, to encourage them to establish their own standards. Doing chores teaches them that their contribution to the family is valuable. Family rituals and celebrations are important to children, who start learning how to plan and organize events if their parents do this well. It matters a great deal whether children get the message “I can” or “I can’t” from their school and family experiences. We know a lot about what children need throughout their childhood for their psychological, spiritual, physical and social development. They need, first of all, continuity of nurturance and trust to develop a sense of a safe “home base,” so they can learn discipline and self-management, the core of a solid identity, in order to function in their social world. They need to develop a sense of trust in order to communicate their needs, feelings and thoughts; to support their confidence in meeting new people; handling new situations and venturing out toward new learning; new connections; and new ways of communicating. One of the least constructive ways to raise children, as Kohn (2014) points out, is with “conditional regard,” that is, when parents offer children affection only based on their achievements and good behavior. Such attitudes promote children’s developing a fragile and unstable sense of self (Assor, Kanat-Maymon, & Roth, 2014; Assor, Roth, & Deci, 2004). Children need to learn to accept themselves even when others do not accept them, and eventually to trust their own judgment and values in order to form their own solid sense of self, rather than feeling they have to accept unquestioningly the values of others. Children need adult support and modeling to learn empathy. For children to learn to manage their interdependence with others— their caretakers, their peers, and relationships with those who are both more and less powerful

than they are, they require increasingly sophisticated negotiation skills. They need support from the adults in their lives to develop a sense of social justice. For children’s development in all these ways, they need parents and other supportive adults who have the energy to nurture and support them. But when parents are overstressed by work, poverty, racism, sexism, or heterosexism, they may be unable to give their children these essential supports. Early in the transition to parenthood sleep is one of the most important requirements for parental functioning, and especially for parental patience. Sleep deprivation compromises a person’s behavior as much as excessive alcohol or drugs (Senior, 2014). They more easily become irritable and to yell, which is likely to make them feel bad about themselves and can become a vicious downward spiral. Another major difficulty for parents is that children do not speak our language and they require constant monitoring. While children live in the present, parents must live in the future, taking precautions for children’s behavior and making plans for the child’s nurturance and care, since children cannot perceive future consequences. Meanwhile, because children live primarily in the present and their brains are not equipped to think about the future, they create chaos, messes, out of control situations, and are constantly testing the boundaries, whereas adults almost always like things to be predictable and in control. So children are a tremendous challenge to our preferred ways of being (Senior, 2014). It is as if everyone is moving at the same speed but children are moving with their eyes closed and adults are the ones who have to steer (Gilbert, 2007). One of the reasons parenting a young child may be boring (one of the hardest things for most parents to admit!), in addition to reading the same story or watching the same video over and over, may be the amount of time parents basically have to spend nagging their children, that is, teaching them the boring rules of civilization, “clean up your mess, go get your coat,” etc. Among the other major problems that interfere with children’s support is their parents’ not being present or not being able to demonstrate their caring. As African American journalist Charles Blow (2014), advises: “Sometimes men don’t see that masculinity is as much about tenderness as about toughness. Sometimes they don’t know how to manage emotions. Sometimes the world has so beaten them and so hardened them that expressing any vulnerability feels like providing an opening for an enemy. Blow movingly describes the life cycle impact of this: “When there is an empty space where a father should be, sorrow often grows” (Blow, 2014). We therapists have a job to do: As a society we must change the way we raise boys to teach them tenderness along with toughness. And we must encourage all parents and other adults who participate in the development of children’s lives—educators, uncles, aunts, grandparents, neighbors, health care providers—to nurture children becoming all that they can be, as they are our future. Expectations versus Reality Until the 1960s, the basic assumption was that motherhood and, by extension, parenthood meant an automatic leap ahead in fulfillment, joy, and status. But in the past decades and especially since the start of the new century, having children is increasingly being delayed, because women

feel they have a choice when and whether to become mothers. There are educational and career goals to consider along with the difficulty of supporting a family. Those who enter parenthood with fewer romantic expectations are more likely to emerge from the transition happier about their marriages and their spouses than those who believe they can somehow abide by the traditional gender rules of parenting (Belsky & Kelly, 1994). But more myths and romantic fantasies than realistic expectations are still attached to the transition to parenthood. Most of the mythology paints a glowing picture, especially of the mother and child, a central icon in cultures and religions from time immemorial. Women are still often vulnerable to the belief that a childless woman is not a “real” woman. For both sexes, parenthood seems to provide the final ticket for acceptance into adulthood: the woman mothering, and the man “providing.” But in real life, the rewards of parenthood, expressed in all cultures across the ages, can often seem largely theoretical in the face of the difficult realities of raising and supporting children, especially in a society that still does not support parenthood as a societal benefit (Friedman, 2012). But the deeply held personal and intergenerational expectations and dreams of most families conflict with our society’s astounding nonsupport for families with children. The nuclear family made up of good provider father and homemaker mother characterizes a very small percentage of families in the United States, and yet it is the group the entire educational and work structures of our society are still organized to accommodate. Only 14 percent of children have stay-at-home mothers (Saad, 2012) and 86 percent of families must therefore arrange child care. Mothers who do stay home tend to be younger, foreign born, and specifically Latinas (Edwards, U.S. Census Bureau, 2009). Child care is the number 1 practical problem at this phase of the life cycle. The United States is the only industrialized nation in the world that leaves it to individual families to arrange and pay for child care themselves. Poor children in the United States are worse off than poor children in all other industrialized Western nations (Friedman, 2012). The United States is one of only four countries in the entire world that do not have paid maternity leave, the others being Lesotho, Swaziland, and Papua New Guinea (Hall & Spurlock, 2013). U.S. support for health and education for children under 6, which is key to children’s future well-being, is only two thirds of what the other major developed countries pay for these supports (CBS News, 2009). Child poverty rates in the United States are nearly double the average of the OECD, the leading organization of 34 major industrialized democratic nations around the world! Of the many risks for children in postindustrial societies, poverty puts children more at risk than any other single factor. The families most likely to live in poverty are single mothers, 40 percent of whom live in poverty, raising 50 percent of the poor children in this country, bringing the poverty rate for children to 22 percent of the child population (Bennetts, 2011). Among the most forgotten children of all are the children in foster care, almost half a million at any time (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2013a). Many of these children would not need foster care if our government provided more social supports for families, schools, and communities. Children placed in foster care and those who become homeless are among the most stressed, their numbers having increased in recent decades (National Coalition for the Homeless, 2009). When children lose their homes, they also tend to lose the continuity of their schools and communities as well as their families. The more we as a nation can do to strengthen families, schools, and communities, the more we will be supporting our own future well-being. The dreadful statistics on our nation’s lack of support for our most

vulnerable children show how little we as a society care for our future citizens, a national catastrophe for our future. There is also still lack of accommodation and wide societal disapproval for nontraditional couples, women who choose or need to go to work, spouses with children who believe that divorce is their best or only option, the poor, the multistressed, and single parents. These families often experience double jeopardy: the same or more economic difficulties than other families compounded by the disparagement and nonacceptance of their place in society. The extended family The new baby enters an extended family system that must now make emotional and relationship shifts to accommodate him or her. Many families celebrate the event with a religious ritual: a christening, Bris, or naming ceremony, usually followed by a party for family and friends. When children are adopted, families tend to celebrate the baby’s or child’s arrival date. As with other family transition rituals, issues about how and where the event is celebrated and who gets invited reflect the ongoing extended-family process. Whether or not there is a ritual or party, the new member of the system is greeted with many differing emotional reactions, depending on its sex, its health, how it is named, how long it was awaited, what kind of relationship its parents have with other family members, whether grandparents approved of the marriage, and whether they are all doing their part to shift to relationships in the parent and grandparent generations. A first grandchild also creates new grandparents, who often jump into their new role without much planning or discussion with their children, not realizing that there are as many ways to grandparent as to parent. No way is “right,” but some ways fit their lives and their children’s lives better than others, and it is best when the issue is discussed early on. Complaints about intrusive or indifferent grandparents, or demanding or neglectful adult children, are signs of the need for such discussion. Whether parents maintain close or distant extended family relationships, they can expect to inherit any unresolved extended family issues and patterns—triangles, ghosts, and taboo issues that are best examined and dealt with at this time, lest they engulf the new family in emotional problems later on. This is a good stage to engage parents in family of origin work, even if they have previously resisted it. Parents will do many things for their children that they would not do for themselves, and this fact provides therapeutic leverage. It is also a good time for grandparents to give up old grievances and make new efforts to relate to their adult children and the children’s spouses. Grandparents may need reminding that in a society with such a high divorce rate, it is wise to be good friends with your daughter-in-law. Couple Relationships and Traditional Roles in the Parenthood Phase Conventional wisdom used to be that becoming a parent was the best route to a happy marriage (Coontz, 2009). But as many observers have realized, “three’s a crowd,” when it comes to marital satisfaction at the parenting phase of the life cycle. Once a child arrives, lack of paid parental leave often leads the wife to quit her job and the husband to work more, which is likely to produce discontent on both sides. Marital quality tends to drop, often quite steeply, after the transition to parenthood, especially because parents so often backslide into more traditional gender roles, which they experience as less satisfying. The wife may resent her husband’s lack of

involvement in child care and housework. The husband may resent his wife’s ingratitude for the long hours he works to support the family (Coontz, 2005). Parents of young children must often relegate their own needs as individuals and as couples to the “back burner,” while they cope with the many pressures of a helpless and demanding infant, one or two jobs outside the family, and all the tasks of an increasingly complex household. Time now becomes a rare commodity, with financial pressures, child care, home, and work demands. Establishing shared time is an important intervention to keep couples in balance during this task- overloaded phase of the life cycle. Nevertheless, parents today spend much more time with their children than they did 40 years ago. Married mothers spend 20 percent more time with their children than they did in 1985 and married fathers spend more than twice as much time as they used to, though still not nearly as much as mothers (Coontz, 2005). In light of the severe role conflict and socioeconomic squeeze on families with young children, it is not surprising that this is the phase with the highest divorce rate and that poorer couples have twice the divorce rate of those who are financially comfortable (Ford & Van Dyk, 2009). Money pressure, time squeeze, couple isolation, sexual dissatisfaction, and unequal distribution of chores often increase with the couple’s power shift toward traditional roles (Ault-Riche, 1994; Carter & Peters, 1997). These complaints often resound in therapy sessions, tempting clinicians to focus on practical solutions to specific issues instead of on the power imbalance itself, which, when righted, will enable the couple to negotiate fair resolutions of their own. Of course, many individual and marital problems have their roots in power inequities that existed long before the baby arrived. The sexual problems that appear at this stage, often arguments over frequency, may be a result of the new mother’s exhaustion, especially if she is nursing, and also may become an arena in which to conduct their power struggle. The first is transient and will pass; the second is an ominous threat to the couple’s relationship and, if not dealt with, is likely to corrode their subsequent life together. Arlie Hochschild’s landmark study (1997, 2012), two decades ago, drew family therapists attention to the unfair share of housework and child care done by women even when both parents worked outside the home. Both men and women are still socialized to believe that mothers have special inborn or intuitive skills related to child care and that all young children need a mother as primary parent. In spite of the actual changes in our lives and in our beliefs, the two sacred cows—a “real” man’s career and a “real” woman’s mothering—maintain a stubborn hold on our emotions. Even when the wife earns more money than her husband, she tends to minimize or deny the importance of her earnings and often continues to manage most of the housework (Mundy, 2012). The consequences of this are that mothers often remain central but overburdened and fathers often feel one-down, somewhat defensive and more on the periphery. When children have grown up viewing their mothers as the “real” parent expert, they are likely to pass along this paradigm unwittingly to the next generation. The idea of shared parenting is not new (Belkin, 2008). Society is increasingly realizing that fathers should be active, hands-on parents, fully participating in the tasks of parenthood. Men in this generation are much more involved in household work and child care than ever before.

Henneck (2003) says they average 16 hours weekly, though a report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics indicates it is more like 16 minutes per day compared to 52 minutes a day for women (Byron, 2012). Hochschild (2012) indicates that working women still do 5 to 7 hours a week more than their spouses. But traditional definitions of male success (career achievement, money, and power) still hold sway in most men’s lives. Many factors impede men from giving up the “good provider” role. Is his wife fully committed to being a co-provider for life, or will she suddenly decide that she will stay home with the children? Will he be penalized at work if he curtails his overtime or travel or takes family leave? In addition, male socialization has often left men cut off from their deepest feelings and somewhat fearful of intimacy. So most men still think of themselves as “helping” at home, even when their wives are employed full time. It still tends to be assumed in the workplace and by the couple themselves that the dilemma of juggling work and family is primarily the responsibility of the mother (Sandberg, 2013). Depending largely on their economic situation and the mother’s career aspirations, she may quit work altogether, cut back to part time, or make whatever child care arrangements she can to keep working full time. If these alternatives are not what she expected to face or do not work out satisfactorily, she may become increasingly resentful and exhausted, blaming her husband and envying his single-track pursuit of work. Often it is only when mothers are away that fathers take on the parenting, perpetuating the stereotype that caring for children and home is women’s work (Barnett & Gareis, 2008; Hochschild, 2012). But when men’s capacity for nurturing is activated early in their children’s lives, they tend to become deeply involved with their children (Pruett, 2001; Gerson, 1993; Barnett & Rivers, 2004). Caretaking their homes and children is not only good for their own health and stress levels, and improves their relationships with their children, but it increases their children’s ability to express the full range of emotions, for girls to be assertive and boys to express more interpersonal affiliation and warmth (Barnett & Rivers, 2004; Brody & Hall, 1993). And two-income couples tend to be healthier and happier in every way, in spite of long work hours and the still unequal division of their labor in the “second shift” (Barnett & Rivers, 1996). The highly charged debate about whether working mothers are detrimental for their children is misguided at many levels. Of course, competent child care is essential to children’s development. But assuming one has quality child care, research makes very clear that the responsive and positive relationship of parents to each other and toward their children, encouraging their emotional, physical, and spiritual competence, is vastly more important in child development than any particular form of child care (Sandberg, 2013; Meers & Strober, 2009). Furthermore, parents in our era cannot support their families without working. In addition, work is extremely beneficial for mothers’ mental health and well-being (Coontz, 2013). Thus, public funding that supports parents in caring for their children and guarantees that all American children receive high-quality child care is essential to our nation. The most important move that clinicians can make regarding this issue is to ensure that it is discussed as a societal problem, not a mothering problem. Child Care and the Work–Family Dilemma Because the two-paycheck family is now the U.S. norm, parental adjustment in work schedules is necessary when children are born. Seventy percent of U.S. women of working age are currently in the full-time workforce, including 65 percent of mothers with children under the age

of 6 (Lavery, 2013). The U.S. government devotes almost nine times as much to defense as it does to education (Chantrill, 2013) and families are left to bear the burden of paying for child care. As a nation, we are not providing quality care and education for our children. Even in the first year of life, a baby’s intellectual development depends on being spoken to regularly by attentive, engaged adults. Even the affluent, who can afford expensive live-in nannies, are not free from worry about what actually transpires in their absence. This, of course, has more serious implications for poor and working-class families, who miss out most when our society fails to provide adequate educational opportunities, including early education for all families. The poor, who need to rely on child care by relatives, have little or no other choice when early education and child care are not available. And poor families spend almost three times as much as middle- class families on child care, even though much of their care is done by relatives. The steady stream of media reports decrying the poor quality of U.S. child care fuels mothers’ guilt about leaving their children. Clinically, family therapists should educate families about this and, again, relieve from their anxiety that it is their fault. Social class is a primary determinant of children’s well-being and developmental options (Reardon, 2013). Economic distress contributes to couple and family instability, inadequate health care, a high degree of mobility, and elevated levels of stress and depression (Mintz, 2010). The proportion of children living with both parents varies greatly by cultural group: 82 percent of Asian children, 74 percent of Whites, 59 percent of Latinos, and 33 percent of African Americans are raised by both parents (Wang et al., 2013). Meanwhile, research has generally shown that the presence of a grandparent, mostly the maternal grandmother, can have a major positive impact on family well-being and children’s life prospects, especially in struggling families (Angier, 2002; U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2013b). Childrearing The minute a child is born and often before, the nuclear family triangle (parents and child) is ready for activation. One of the biggest surprises for new parents may be the degree to which they discover passionate feelings about childrearing, a subject to which they may have given little previous thought. However, the imprint of their own childhoods, their levels of maturity, and their internalized ideas about their roles as parents make this a potentially hot issue for many couples. Gender socialization, leading to unequal participation in child care, only makes matters worse. Fathers are often cast as “idealists,” responsible for preparing the child for the outside world, and mothers as “pragmatists,” doing whatever works to get them and the children through each day. These prescribed roles can unwittingly lead to many destructive triangles of family life, especially those which polarize the parents in “too strict” or “too lenient” positions. “Father knows best,” “angry mommy,” and “the naughty kids” are familiar, unhappy scenarios of family life in which one parent can come to treat the other like one of the children. What is clear is that societal prejudice about the abilities of girls and children of color need to be challenged by parents and teachers at every turn. The myth that girls are not as good as boys at science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM), or that they have a natural gift for reading emotions that boys lack, have been shown in repeated studies to be untrue (Rivers & Barnett, 2013). What is true is that when girls are told they are not as good as boys, they do less well (Rivers & Barnett, 2013). This is also true for children of color, who similarly internalize messages of inferiority (Watson, 2013) that need to be countered by the adults in their lives or they become self-fulfilling prophesies. Penner and Paret (2008) found in a longitudinal study of

gender differences in math education that where boys and girls start out equal, even highly educated parents tend to continue the gender segregation in math and science by their gendered attitudes. Parents’ responses are very important. Because children tend to develop a great passion to belong in middle childhood, they often exclude others so that they can feel “in.” They must be taught about oppression because they will be exposed to bullying whether as perpetrator, victim, or bystander. Parents have an important role to play in teaching their children to manage such situations, becoming role models demonstrating courage to challenge stereotypes and stand up for those who cannot always stand up for themselves (Comer & Poussaint, 1992; Comer, Joyner, & Ben-Savie, 2004; Quintana & McKown, 2008; Neblett et al., 2008; Suizo, Robinson, & Pahlke, 2008; Rivers & Barnett, 2013). Children learn competitiveness and cooperation to the degree their parents, caretakers, or teachers teach them. Competitiveness will remain a problem unless they are taught models of collaboration. They should learn the truth about the inequalities embedded in U.S. history: slavery, colonialism, war, and oppression, in order to understand what the ideals of “liberty and justice for all” really mean at a social and community level. As they start to read, watch television, and play video games independently, they should also be monitored by parents, especially for exposure to racist, sexist, homophobic, and violent content, which can have a profound influence on them. Music, for example, may filled with sexualized messages about girls and women, and Internet sites, at least 25 percent of which are pornographic, are explored by most children at least once (Rivers & Barnett, 2013). Children as they grow are deeply affected by parental and school definitions of “normal.” They learn to imitate racist, sexist, homophobic, and other discriminatory words and actions (Thompson, Goodvin, & Meyer, 2006; Thompson, 2006). Although White children often express discriminatory behavior toward children of color, such responses diminish when antiracist norms have been established in the community (Monteiro, de Franca, & Rodrigues, 2009) and children raised in nonauthoritarian homes are much more likely to become antiracist as adults (Flouri, 2004). Sex segregation increases greatly during grade school years, influenced by the fact that boys’ behavior, unless checked, comes to be characterized by competition and dominance. Girls have such difficulty influencing in play with boys that they tend to avoid them (Maccoby, 1999). Boys tend to play more roughly in larger groups, and girls are more likely to form close friendships with one or two other girls. Studies have indicated that 50 percent of 3-year-olds, 20 percent of the 5-year-olds, and virtually no 7-year-olds, have friends of the opposite sex (Liu, 2006). Children also segregate themselves by race, discovering that skin color is a code denoting rank and even fate (Comer & Poussaint, 1992; Ogbu, 1990; Bullard, 1997). Given their gendered socialization, girls become adept at reading verbal and nonverbal emotional signals and at expressing and communicating their feelings. Boys are taught to minimize emotions connected to vulnerability, guilt, fear, and hurt (Goleman, 2006). Without specific intervention, these unfortunate patterns will persist into adulthood. Boys especially, in their efforts to establish their own gender identity, may focus on their dislike of girls, which have been a longstanding part of the socialization toward masculinity (Kimmel, 2013); boys need adult validation of the girls’ interests and feelings to avoid internalizing negative stereotypes about them. As children begin to develop a sense of right and wrong, they may tattle on wrongdoers, and are concerned about

fairness, rules, and rule breaking, the foundation of their morals (Kochanska & Aksan, 2007). If they are continuously put down, they will lose faith in others; if they are not admonished for selfish or unfair acts, they will grow up with a false sense of privilege. In the dominant culture, boys grow up with a desensitization to violence and mistreating others (Kimmel, 2013). It is essential for parents to socialize their children about the larger societal structures that inhibit the full development of either sons or daughters. Clinicians play an important role whenever they are in the position of inquiring about children’s behavior and parenting patterns to help them explore their deeper values and challenge the dominance/oppression structures of our society. Much has been said about the dangers of mothers being too close to their sons (Dooley & Fedele, 2004). A much larger problem is fathers being too distant from all their children. All development occurs in the context of relationships, and it is essential for both parents to stay connected to their children. Clinicians should routinely encourage fathers’ involvement with their children. The therapist must take a non-blaming stance in talking with men frankly about their fear of incompetence, angry reactions, jeopardizing their careers, and the general sense that they lack the requisite access to their own emotions. Men must be expected and encouraged to participate in family life. The whole subject of cultural differences usually needs to be raised by the therapist, since some parents tend to be oblivious to their privilege and may not realize that they need to act early to prevent a later scenario of confusion, disorder, or even violence in relation to racism, homophobia, or sexism with their children. Parents can help their children by not pretending that discrimination does not exist, choosing children’s schools carefully to ensure diversity, expanding their circle of playmates to include children of other races and cultures. Minority parents are generally all too aware of the potential harm to their children of being part of a socially stigmatized group such as people of color and gay and lesbian families. Therapists should acknowledge parents’ concerns; pay close attention to the child’s level of self-esteem, feelings of competence, and positive group identification; and encourage families to join with others in their communities both for support and to counteract the negative effects of being stigmatized and alienated from the larger society. Therapists should, in other words, inform themselves about the impact of the social context on children and encourage parents to do the same. Parental support is essential for helping children cope with peer pressure and distinguish their own values and attitudes from those of their peer group. It is a generally last chance for parents to influence a child’s choice of peers and to widen the child’s social circle by encouraging diversity. Parents need to affirm their support of their children’s competence and abilities before teen struggles for independence begin. When children are preoccupied with prepubertal body changes and extremely sensitive to unkind remarks from others, they may not always cooperate or want to be affiliated with others who are “different.” But it is important for them to see parents actively handling social problems in constructive ways. Their identification with the causes, problems, and privileges of groups they belong to provides direction, and motivation to think and act in contructive ways. As their ability to experience empathy deepens, they learn to appreciate distress beyond an immediate situation and to feel for the plight of an entire group, such as the poor, oppressed, or outcast (Goleman, 2006). Children need resources and support to contend

with discrimination, bullying, racism, sexism, homophobia, and a general lack of safety in their communities (Coll & Szalacha, 2004; Robbins et al., 2007). Children who are shy need encouragement from adults to participate. They may be very sensitive to racial attitudes and may hide behind race or other “differences” to excuse poor performance, so adults should be careful not to permit children’s outrage to become an excuse for poor performance. Self-esteem is precarious in grade school years and pride in gender, race, and sexual orientation is crucial to self-esteem. Without safe learning environments that offer anti- harrassment and anti-discrimination policies that include LGBT identity and gender expression, children are reliant on parents and other close adults to support their development and protect them from bullying and other oppressive behaviors (Comer & Poussaint, 1992; Murry & Brody, 2002; Neblett et al., 2008; Rivers & Barnett, 2013; Ryan, 2013). Discipline Many parental arguments about disciplining children spill over into therapists’ offices, where we are called upon to say who is “right.” This is the time to have reading material for parents, or to recommend a book for them, rather than to step into that triangle ourselves. Harriet Lerner’s The Mother Dance (1998) is particularly effective against the pitfalls that precipitate discipline problems: parental guilt, anxiety, over-responsibility, and uncertainty. Family therapists should help parents agree on age-appropriate, practical approaches to discipline. If they cannot agree, we should help them to negotiate ways not to interfere with each other’s methods, assuming, of course, that they are not harsh or harmful. Unless there is actual danger, one parent should not intervene when the other is disciplining a child. If they disagree, they should discuss the issue in private and either agree to disagree or shift parental responsibilities so that the parent who cares more about an issue (e.g., table manners) assumes responsibility for dealing with it. If the issue has already become toxic for parent and child, it will generally be helpful to shift responsibility to the less concerned parent. The suggestion of shifting responsibility will usually unmask an underlying problem of the parents’ unequal involvement in parenting. Clinical approaches that do not address this imbalance will usually not end disputes over childrearing and discipline. We must also remember that ethnicity and social class are key determinants of what parents have learned is appropriate discipline, and we should ask clients about their experience and ideas. Comer and Poussaint (1992) remind us that Black parents have often been strict disciplinarians because they felt that they had to force their children to obey so that they would not violate racial rules and come to harm. While agreeing with many Black parents who find White middle-class parents too permissive, therapists need to be clear about the negative impact of spanking or shaming and provide parents with practical alternatives. Conflicts over discipline often reflect underlying marital problems. If parents are engaged in intense power struggles in other areas of their relationship, these will probably spill over into their approaches to childrearing. Parents may triangulate with a particular child because of the child’s physical or behavioral problems, which arouse parental anxiety. Such cases are usually referred to in the literature as “child-focused families” and are not generally about discipline or even about the child, but rather about family of origin or problems in the marital relationship that have created a triangle that then displaces the anxiety onto discipline concerns.

This is not to suggest that all or even most child-rearing arguments are a sign of basic marital problems or that such arguments will disappear automatically if parents work on their relationship. Even when marital or family problems are primary, it is necessary to address the problem that brought the family to therapy first. As the couple work on the childrearing or discipline problems, it will usually become clear whether work on the marital relationship or the families of origin is necessary to change the presenting problem. Protection against high-risk behaviors Ron Taffel (2009) considers this generation of children to be the freest generation because of Internet exposure, the media, and our fast-paced world. However, he thinks children are also “freer from the constraints of history—the stories of generations past are missing. . . . (Children) feel less guilt and connection to the everyday job or career sacrifices of their parents” (pp. 12– 13). Children’s new freedoms bring with them anxiety, infused by endless access to adult media. They get to make very early decisions about high-risk behavior. Parents are left with fear and frustration about their children’s safety. Children know parents feel helpless, and lose confidence in adults’ ability to contain and protect them. What is desperately needed is for families to spend time together and parents to give undivided personal attention to their children to reconnect, engage, and share their personal journeys and their family and cultural history, which are essential to creating deeper tolerance, empathy, and a solid sense of self (Taffel, 2009). It is the essence of a parent’s job to teach their children what they themselves have learned about how to live a meaningful life. If parents do not think about and articulate their own values, children will infer them from the way their parents live. It is better for us to think about what we want to teach. Children need to develop personal, social, and spiritual values and a sense of idealism such as the importance of kindliness, loyalty, and helping others. It helps to see their parents involved at school, in the community, and in the political process if they are to learn to care about others. Therapists can help parents look hard at how they are living and ask themselves about their real goals. In the scramble to make enough money, raise children, and pursue their own careers, parents often fall into one accommodation or another without meaning to. Because of the complexity of family life at this stage and the paucity of meaningful societal support, parents deserve the opportunity in family therapy to explore all options and possibilities for a more meaningful family life. Such discussions may lead them to redesign their own relationships to better suit themselves. Single parenting Single parenthood is a growing world phenomenon, mostly involving mothers, and we need to develop helpful attitudes toward it. Although there is much general condemnation of single- parent families, it is important to realize that the structure itself is not the problem. Single-parent families range from highly functional to highly dysfunctional, depending on economics and emotional, family, and community connectedness. Too often, problems resulting from poverty or emotional and social isolation are attributed to family structure. To counter this tendency, therapists should assess a single mother’s financial, familial, friendship, and social resources, which are her greatest protection against the stresses of parenthood. Financial stress is a major factor for many single parents, compounding all of the usual problems parents have, and causing

many additional problems. Clearly, the children of a financially stable, emotionally connected mother can thrive whether she is married or not. But because single parents do not have partners to share responsibility, the support of family, friends, and community becomes all the more important. Teenage parenting In our society, a teenager is, by definition, not ready to be a parent. In any social or economic bracket, a teenager is a child, regardless of intelligence, sophistication, or street smarts. Currently about 10 percent of births in the United States are to unmarried teenagers (U.S. Census Bureau, 2012). Fortunately, these rates have shown a dramatic drop in the past decade with particularly strong decline for Latinas and African Americans, who together account for 57 percent of teenage births (CDC, 2011). These early births are costly in additional health care and foster care needs of children of teen mothers and in the lower educational attainment of the fathers and the mothers, only 50 percent of who complete high school, compared to 90 percent of their peers (CDC, 2011). Any teenage child/parent needs further time to develop emotionally and intellectually before taking on the adult tasks of parenting and earning a living. Family therapy in this crisis should be aimed at protecting the young mother’s development, as well as the baby’s. Plans should be made to continue the teenager’s education and, if the decision is to keep the baby, for housing with mature family members who can provide assistance with baby care. Involvement of the baby’s father, of course, depends on his functioning, ability to provide financial and other support, and whether the parents plan to remain a couple. Tragically, up to 80 percent of fathers of children born to teenage mothers do not marry or support the mother or children (Brein & Willis, 1997), and children raised apart from their fathers are five times more likely to grow up poor than children with two parents at home (Horn & Sylvester, 2002). Since a solid majority of American teenagers have had sex by the time they graduate from high school, it is important for the therapist to investigate the level of sex education attained by the teenage mother. The dissemination of birth control and disease control information to teenagers is a sensitive area with some families, and therapists need to approach this discussion diplomatically. Infertility A client once said: “The only thing worse than having a child with problems is not being able to have a child at all.” The trauma of infertility generates grief and mourning, reactivated with every attempt and failure to conceive, whether through natural means or infertility treatments. The intensity of the experience is often overlooked by the couple’s family, friends, and even therapists. This creates the danger that the couple will feel damaged, stigmatized, isolated, and depressed. This is especially likely for couples of religious or cultural groups that expect all couples to produce many children. Some cultural groups even accept infertility as a premise for divorce. About one out of eight married couples in the United States is infertile, one third attributed to the woman, one third attributed to the man, and one third attributed to a combination of reasons (Resolve, 2013). However, women are more often blamed for infertility, regardless of cause, and exhibit greater emotional distress, probably because of their socialization to become mothers and also because most medical procedures for infertility involve the woman. Although

White professional couples are the largest consumers of infertility services, which are extremely expensive and rarely covered by insurance, poor people of color with little formal education are more likely to be infertile (Meyers et al., 1995). Poor women on Medicaid have little access to infertility treatment, as few states have programs that cover infertility diagnosis or treatment (Hendler, Kennelly, & Peacock, 2011). Almost invisible among infertility sufferers are lesbian women who may try endless cycles of alternative insemination before giving up the cherished goals of pregnancy and giving birth. Fertility treatments can also raise the agonizing dilemmas of multiple births following fertility drugs: “selective reduction” (abortion of some fetuses to save the others) or risks of serious birth defects that are much higher in multiple births. Obviously, all protracted fertility treatments place enormous stress on the couple. Family therapists need to keep informed of the developments and problems of fertility treatments so that we can help couples to determine when it is time to stop such treatments and seek other ways of becoming parents. Adoption The high cost of fertility treatments has kept this new technology from replacing the age-old alternative method of attaining parenthood: adoption. About 120,000 children are adopted each year in the United States, growing numbers of which are transracial or international. While the numbers have decreased by about one third since the 1970s, about 2.5 percent of all children under 18 are adopted (Adoption History Project, 2013), which means that a great many individuals and families (parents, siblings, grandparents, and extended family members) are touched by adoption. But the process and the prospects have become more complicated in recent years, due partially to the scarcity of White infants because of contraception and legal abortion and partially to the fact that more single mothers now feel free to raise their own children. Recently, open adoption has become more common, where birth parents and adoptive parents meet one another, share identifying and genetic information, and communicate directly over the years. Some may get together regularly and view each other as extended kin; others have written or mediated communication until the adoptees are in their late teens. While advocates list many obvious advantages in direct contact, which can break the negative power of the adoption triangle with its cutoffs, fantasies, and loyalty conflicts, critics fear an invasion of adoptive family boundaries and the possibility that birth parents may be inconsistent or even drop out of children’s lives. It is important for family therapists to pay close attention to the individual situation of each family to help clients think through which route they choose and then help them with its particular challenges. Most studies indicate that adoption outcomes are overwhelmingly positive (Groza, 2013). Until there is greater flexibility in the adoption-approval process and more understanding and respect for alternative family structures, single parents who adopt children will tend to be viewed from a deficit perspective. It is extremely important for family therapists to keep an open mind about the strengths of adoptive families, whether trans-racial, single-parent, or gay and lesbian. An important right still being fought for is the right to adopt one’s unmarried partner’s child. This bestows legal parental rights on unmarried heterosexual partners and gay and lesbian partners.

Informal adoption is especially common among families of color, reflecting the reciprocity among kin that has been one of the most important survival mechanisms of African Americans (Boyd-Franklin, 2003). This sharing has produced permeable boundaries around Black family households that contrast sharply with the rigid boundaries of most White nuclear families. These flexible boundaries have been an integral part of Black community life since the days of slavery, permitting adult relatives or friends of the family to take in children whose parents are unable to care for them for whatever reason. Since adoption agencies were not originally designed to meet the needs of Black children, this informal network provides unofficial social services to poor Black families and children. Since Black clients understand all too well how their family structure may be judged by White therapists, they may be extremely uneasy if White clinicians do formal genograms early in treatment. It is probably wise for the clinician to be cautious about prying and let information emerge naturally in conversation. Prospective parents need to be committed to teaching the child about his or her history and culture. Toward this goal, adoptive parents often join adoptive organizations, which offer support and affiliation with other families with similar intercultural relationships. Domestic interracial adoptions also require parental commitment to teaching children about their history and culture and develop a positive identity in both the birth and adoptive cultures (Zuniga, 1991). Comer and Poussaint (1992) emphasize also the importance of White adoptive parents’ examining their motives carefully and protecting their children from racism by acknowledging and discussing racial and social class differences along with the adoption story frequently as children develop. Case Illustration Jerome, Karen, and Susan Jerome and Karen, a white professional couple sought consultation about the acting out of their 10-year-old daughter, Susan, African American and adopted in infancy. The parents were idealists, who were puzzled by Susan’s growing rebelliousness and recent behavioral and academic problems in school. She had previously done excellent schoolwork, was cooperative at home, and had many friends. The parents had lost touch with Black friends they had known previously and had not found new ones in their white suburb. Susan’s friends were all white and were now starting to talk about the boys, clothes, and romance. Although she did not want to discuss it, Susan seemed afraid of what her standing would be, once dating commenced. The therapist told the parents the problem seemed to be that they were raising Susan as if she were white, or as if it did not matter that she was Black. The parents were encouraged to locate activities both for themselves and for Susan in adjoining towns where there was ethnic, religious, class, and racial diversity. After a short period of defensiveness, they took on the task enthusiastically, joining a bicycling club and volunteering as parent chaperones at the neighboring town’s school events. Susan joined after-school sports and recreation groups at the neighboring town’s YWCA. Her difficulties at her own school diminished as she socialized with the new group of friends. The parents reported enjoying breaking out of their own self-imposed segregation. After 6 months, the mother announced that they had decided to move to the next town so they could pursue their new friendships and activities “without all the driving back and forth.” They joked that this was “the community cure,” and it was. Gay and lesbian parenting

Gay and lesbian couples are both similar to and different from heterosexual couples and from each other. The variables that predict a positive transition to parenthood for lesbian and gay couples are the same as those for heterosexual couples: realistic expectations, good couple communication, partner adaptability, and the ability to tolerate chaos, noise, sleep deprivation, and a lack of solitude. Only accurate personal information will help us to avoid overgeneralizing about their parenting issues. The single most important factor in the development of a happy, healthy, and well-adjusted child in LGBT families as in all families is the nurturing relationship between parent and child (Perrin, Siegel, & Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health, 2013). In the past five decades, there has been a dramatic increase in lesbian and gay couples raising families with biological, step, adopted, and foster children. In spite of the discrimination that keeps many gay parents from acknowledging their sexual orientation in surveys, almost 50 percent of lesbians and 20 percent of gay men of childbearing age are raising children, compared to 70 percent of comparable heterosexuals (Gates, 2013). These percentages are increasing rapidly. LGBT parents struggle with issues of childrearing as do heterosexual couples, but they also contend with oppression, stigmatization, and economic disadvantages because of their sexual orientation (Gates, 2013). In addition, they are more likely to be racial or ethnic minorities and to be raising foster or adopted children, even more of whom are racial and ethnic minority children (Gates, 2013). Another challenge is that gay and lesbian couples have few role models of specifically gay families. This necessitates important ground breaking decisions such as the very decision to become a parent, the conscious evolution of support networks to counteract social stigma, the creation of family rituals to celebrate family life cycle transitions, and the division of chores, child care, and arrangements in case of death or breakup of the relationship, which is even more important because these relationships are not as protected by law as they are for heterosexual couples (Bigner & Wetchler, 2012). In clinical work with LGBT families, clinicians should stay informed about the social policy context these families face: they are excluded from the U.S. Census Bureau’s definition of family (U.S. Department of Commerce, 2013); their civil rights are not protected in every state; their sexual contact is criminalized in over 20 states, though luckily no longer in the U.S. military; and in spite of many recent efforts to change state laws, they still lack the overall legal protection our government grants to heterosexuals by marriage, divorce, custody, and inheritance laws, including Medicaid and Social Security (Kuvalanka, McClintock-Comeaux, & Leslie, 2004; Hartman, 1996). The pitfalls in the parental triangle are the same as with heterosexual parents; first is the possibility that parents may compete for who is the real parent: one parent may be closer as the primary caretaker, and the other parent may feel left out. This can be exacerbated if the primary parent is also the biological parent. Lesbian couples are often especially careful to divide child care, housework, and paid employment more evenly than do heterosexual couples (Tasker & Malley, 2012). Both partners seem to make equal sacrifices in exchange for this equality, working shorter hours or have turned down career opportunities to be more available at home. Stress and conflict may instead show up in competitiveness concerning bonding and

childrearing. The birth mother who breast feeds may feel possessive toward her child and assume more nurturing roles, leaving the co-mother feeling excluded. She may become the preferred parent for rough and tumble play. This can become a source of tension between the parents (Bigner & Wetchler, 2012). Gay and lesbian parents may be somewhat less vulnerable than heterosexual parents to children’s “divide and conquer” strategies, because both have received the same gender programming about parenting and are more likely to see eye to eye on childrearing. Gartrell, Bos, and Goldberg (2011) found that children raised by lesbian mothers, whether single or partnered, showed evidence of great confidence and self-esteem, which they attributed to the mothers’ active engagement in their children’s lives, fostering good communication, involving themselves in their children’s schools and extracurricular activities. They found that an environment of acceptance and love and a sense of community were among the most positive aspects for growing up in a lesbian family. The children not only felt unconditionally loved by their parents but being raised in a lesbian family required the families to develop a wider definition of family (Gartrell et al., 2011). What is not the same is the level of stress caused by social stigma and lack of social, and sometimes familial, support. While contact with a child may soften negative attitudes in the family of origin toward gay or lesbian offspring, the news of an impending child also brings all the coming-out issues to the fore again and may bring forth a new level of homophobia, as parents who have privately accepted their child’s sexual orientation feel threatened by how public a grandchild will be. It is also important for family therapists to remember that although many families reject their gay and lesbian children, most do not (Laird, 1996). When treating LGBT couples and families, it is essential to address issues of relationships and family history as well as the behavioral norms of the systems that surround them (Goldberg & Allen, 2013; Bigner & Wetchler, 2012). Questions from family and others may center on fears that a child will be hurt psychologically by the social stigma and/or by having parents of only one gender. Many studies have demonstrated that children’s well-being is affected much more by their relationships with their parents, their parents’ sense of competence and security, and the presence of social and economic support for the family than by the gender or the sexual orientation of their parents (Barlow, 2013). Children with disabilities When children have disabilities, parents have additional childrearing tasks to deal with and the child, siblings, and extended family will have additional complications in their relationships to provide extra support and to deal with the loss that disability entails of hopes and dreams that may be curtailed (Solomon, 2013). It is important for the clinician to help the parents share their grief and sadness with each other and with other family members and friends. Their perceived need to “stay strong” for each other may make them fearful of letting the child or each other down. It is also essential that very specific plans be made to give respite and encourage other activities for the chief caregiver, usually the mother. The gender imbalances so common at this life cycle phase tend to be greatly exacerbated by having a child with disabilities. The reversion to more traditional gender roles may be intensified, as fathers may back away and mothers may become overly centralized. Mothers may need help to give themselves permission to go to work,

go on vacation, or just pursue interests and hobbies. Probably it is both the burden of caretaking and the emotional stress that contribute to this problem, but it is worth a great deal to try to engage fathers and keep parents on the same page in managing their child and their family. Later in the life cycle, siblings will undoubtedly inherit the responsibilities of the disabled sibling, all of which should be taken into account from early on, including the direct impact on siblings of the disability. When parents express worry over a young child’s functioning, a good first question is whether the child’s caregiver, school, or teacher has brought any problem to the parents’ attention. Teachers and professional caregivers are generally quick to spot deviations from the norm. Spotting an apparent deviation and correctly diagnosing it, however, are two different things, and family therapists need to watch out for the “diagnosis of the year,” defined for children and then found everywhere: ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder), ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder), MBD, unspecified “learning disabilities,” and general “hyperactivity” are common examples (Thakkar, 2013). Since most, if not all, such disabilities of children now come with recommended medications, it is important to help the parents obtain a good assessment. Once a diagnosis and treatment plans have been made, possibly including special education, therapists can help parents not slip into an adversarial relationship with the school. Such a triangle, fueled by parents’ anxiety, will severely complicate the school’s work with the child. Child abuse This is a problem at every socioeconomic level in our society, and because so many of the assaults on children are perpetrated by their parents, relatives, caretakers, and family friends, they are all the more shocking. Therapists should be as alert to the signs of child abuse as they are to indications of wife battering. Any suggestion of child abuse is a reason to stop therapy as usual and explore in minutest detail the child’s level of risk. In most states, it is now possible to have the suspected perpetrator (rather than the child) removed from the home and denied access to the child. However, vigilant follow-up by the therapist is often necessary. Under no circumstances should a known child-abusing parent be included in family sessions until he or she has acknowledged the problem, agreed to whatever treatment and medication are recommended, and is able to be accountable in a meaningful way to the abused child and other family members. It should never be assumed that abuse will cease as a result of couple or family therapy alone. Clinical Guidelines Whatever the presenting problem is at this life cycle phase, the entire three- or four-generational family system should be assessed carefully at an individual, family and sociocultural context level. The following case describes the assessment and overview of a family presenting at the phase of Parents with Young Children. Case Illustration Sharon and Gary Sharon sought therapy because of her anger toward her husband Gary’s long work hours and his distant fathering style. Gary, a lawyer, commuted 2 hours a day, and worked 65 to 70 hours, 6

days a week. He was rarely home before 8:00 or 9:00 p.m. and brought work home for Sunday. He felt the necessity to work these long hours to pay for the families’ high expenses. The family lived in an affluent suburb, employed a live-in nanny, and contributed to the support of Sharon’s parents in Florida. Gary also felt the necessity to work these hours because his career goal was to become a partner in his law firm. Sharon was a social worker with a small private practice. She worked about 20 hours a week spread over 4 half-days and 2 evenings. Gary saw their two young children, Danielle, aged 6, and Sophie, aged 4, briefly in the mornings and tried to spend Sunday afternoons with Sharon and the kids. As a couple, they had “no time” (see Genogram 15.1). The evaluation

1. Each Individual All four immediate family members appeared to be physically healthy and functioning satisfactorily. Inquiry about the extended family did not indicate any major physical or psychological problems. Emotionally, Gary talked about work in a somewhat compulsive, distant way, and Sharon sometimes sounded more like the parent, than daughter or sibling, in her family of origin.

2. The Family

The Couple: The couple spent almost no time together and sex was infrequent. They said in

the early years together they had had a more balanced and open relationship and shared dreams. Now Gary was ignoring or vetoing Sharon’s suggestions. They had no effective method of discussing or negotiating differences. Family tasks were polarized, with Sharon doing or supervising all domestic tasks and Gary earning most of the income. She complained of his lack

of emotional expressiveness, and he, of her excessive emotionality, which seemed to correspond to their gender and ethnic backgrounds: she was more emotionally expressive and he was more self-contained and understated. Gary was completely uninvolved in the household schedules and tasks; Sharon was the only hands-on parent. The Family Emotional System: In the nuclear family, father and children spent little time together. The main triangle was that Sharon and the children were close and Gary distant. Families of Origin: Relationships with the families of origin were either distant and unsupportive or overinvolved. Gary’s Family: Gary was extremely distant from his parents, who hardly ever saw him or Sharon. The paternal grandparents were minimally involved with the children. Gary called his father “an uncaring workaholic” but was shocked that Sharon saw him as just like his father. Gary’s mother had never complained about the father’s work focus and, in fact, had delivered emotionally laden messages to him about the importance of work. Sharon’s Family: Sharon was a typical over-responsible oldest daughter who felt obligated to take care of everyone in her family of origin. She contributed money to her sister so that she would not have to move after her divorce; she shrugged off her affluent younger brother’s refusal to contribute financially to their parents; and she never objected to family members’ impositions on her time or money. When Sharon’s parents or sister insisted, Sharon took the children to visit them, but Gary rarely came. Intergenerational Triangles: There were significant family-of-origin triangles on every level: Gary with his parents, Sharon, with her parents and her siblings, and with the children. Emotional Issues: The major emotional issues were time, work, money, fathering, lack of intimacy, lack of negotiating skills, and not living according to their values. Major Emotional Threats:

A. Growing distance and resentment between the couple

B. Emotional and physical distance between father and children

3. The Sociocultural Context Community and Friends: This family was extremely isolated. Gary and Sharon’s schedules had no time for involvement in any community organization at all. Both spouses had rejected their parents’ religion—his Protestant, hers Jewish. Gary felt no interest in religious involvement and had elicited an early agreement from Sharon to leave religious affiliation out of their lives. For Sharon, this had become a problem. She had thought about joining a synagogue, but Gary always reminded her of their earlier agreement.

The Family’s Place in the Larger Social System: This White, heterosexual, affluent, educated, professional couple belongs by these qualities to the most powerful portion of our society. Thus, if they can get psychologically free enough to avail themselves of their options, they have more power to change their situation than any others have. The norms of the social system that militate against their getting psychologically free enough to use their options might include the following:

 The socially approved male focus on career and money, reinforced by Gary’s parents’ example and messages about the “work ethic.”

 Gary and Sharon’s affluent, consumerist, time-starved life-style, called “success,” and

envied by their peers.

 The rigidity of the fast-track career path for corporate lawyers.

 Sharon’s belief, socially approved and ethnically reinforced, that it is a daughter’s “duty” to respond to the wishes and needs of her family of origin, regardless of the strain it puts on her own emotional and financial resources.

 Gary’s belief, consistent with decades of social practice, that young children are fine as

long as their mother is available, and fathers need only “provide.” The therapy In therapy, Gary and Sharon accomplished the following:

 Gary agreed to come home “early” (by 7:00 p.m.) at least one night a week.

 Sharon stopped giving her sister money, while still maintaining a close connection.

 Sharon worked to restore a relationship with her brother and eventually requested that he start contributing his share of support to their parents. He agreed and resumed regular contact with them.

 Gary’s talks with his mother revealed a secret about the issue of work: his maternal

grandfather had been an alcoholic with a checkered work history who had once spent several years in jail for forgery, leaving his family on welfare. This had led Gary’s mother to preach the value of working hard ever after. Now Gary could see the emotionally programmed aspects of his own work habits. He agreed to come home before 7:00 p.m. two nights a week.

 Gary had difficult, but useful, talks with his father about work. His father finally

acknowledged that he regretted missing Gary’s youth. Gary urged him not to miss his grandchildren’s youth as well. The number of visits to and from Gary’s parents increased from once a year to four times, interspersed with calls and gifts. During their visits, Gary took off time from work to be with the whole family.

 Gary and Sharon spent many weeks going over their budget. Sharon said that she would

agree to sell their vacation house if Gary would get a less-demanding job. He said that he

would think about it, and he eventually did, moving to a slower-paced suburban firm at a lower salary.

 Sharon joined a synagogue after a long discussion of their religious and ethnic

differences. She participated in the temple’s discussion groups and in a social program to help the homeless and Gary even joined the men’s group.

 After much discussion of “mother guilt,” Sharon cut out one evening of work so that she

and Gary could parent together and then spend a quiet evening as a couple.

 Through their work in therapy, they were able to see how their early dreams, values, and ideals contrasted with the reality of what their life had become and vowed to continue their work downshift and relationship expansion.

 Gary and Sharon joined a group that met monthly for dinner and theater.

 Gary said that as “daddy time” with his kids got more frequent, it got more enjoyable.

“Like sex with Sharon,” he added with a smile. Gary and Sharon had three major advantages for making the many profound changes that they did: They had an earlier strong, passionate bond and dreams to return to; their families of origin, although problematic in many ways, were essentially free of major dysfunctional patterns; and their privileged positions in the social hierarchies gave them maximum flexibility for change once they decided to go for it. (Of course, their privilege might have kept them from seeing relationship values that are not so esteemed by the dominant culture.) Shifting focus among levels of the system Our clinical work does not lend itself to moving in an orderly way from one level of the system to the next, any more than real life does. So although therapy usually begins with the presenting problem—at this phase, often a child problem—the therapist’s work will need to address the marriage, the family of origin, the community, and the constraints of the larger social system in any given session. To get a sustained focus and eventual resolution of key issues, it is important to keep mental track of the issues at each level. Be aware of a client’s repeated shift away from an uncomfortable area—maybe the marriage—back to a more “comfortable” problem—maybe the child. It is important to address the parents’ preferred focus before shifting with some question about the marriage. Or one might work on the marriage indirectly through discussions of parenting roles. Similarly, if a task to change behavior with a grandparent gets followed in the next session with a child or marital crisis, as sometimes happened with Gary and Sharon, it is important to make mental note of this, even if the opportunity to ask about the grandparent is postponed until later. The important point is that the therapist should track the process. On the macro level, it is important to help a couple achieve some small initial resolution of their presenting problems before introducing the idea of actual work in the family of origin. The first move with Gary and Sharon was to get Gary to agree to come home early one evening a week.

However, in any session, one might openly refer to extended family information gathered in the evaluation and connect it to the presenting problem to show that family of origin is a relevant focus. Thus, questions about Gary’s parents and work made it clear that this was an intergenerational issue as well as a couple problem. Questions and comments about community and the rules and norms of the larger social system are usually quite easy to introduce into the discussion, since there is often not as much resistance to talking about these areas as there is to personal and family issues. Of course, it is all connected in the end, as Gary and Sharon discovered when questions about community led to their deeply personal exchange about their religious and ethnic differences. There is still debate in family therapy about when or whether to include young children in sessions. We believe that changes in children up to adolescence depend primarily on parental intervention on their behalf or on changes in parental attitudes and behaviors. Also, children are too powerless to change the system, but sometimes feel responsible if included in problem-focused discussion and complaints. We want to see them for assessment purposes and to see how family members relate together and separately. And even when we do not work with them directly because in our view the power to change the situation rests primarily with the parents, we always ask detailed questions about their development.When we do work with them, it is always and only in the context of work with their families. Conclusion In spite of all the complexities and difficulties of contemporary family life, we have never actually met any parent who regretted being a parent. Whenever we have done life cycle exercises with trainees, grouping people by life cycle stage and having them discuss the issues, one of the childless participants always says something like: “It’s too hard. Why does anyone have children?” At this point, the parents laugh in astonishment trying to describe the joys, pleasures, and transcendence of parenthood. Maybe it is like talking about sex to a virgin—the problematic aspects of it may be clear, but it is almost impossible to fully articulate the physical, sensory, intellectual, emotional, and spiritual experience of connectedness to one’s child through love.