primary sources of crime data and crime trends.
Plmilano
PublicOpinionMediatheCrime.pptxPublic Opinion, Media, & the Crime Problem
Come to this class already familiar with the issue of crime; the problem of crime. You have opinions about the causes of crime.
Sources of knowledge: Media, family and friends, personal experience.
Talk with family and friends about crime; direct or indirect victim of crime.
Take a moment to think about “what do we know about crime”?
1
Mini-survey
What percentage of convicted felony defendants are found guilty by a jury instead of a judge?
How much of the average police officer’s time is spent “fighting crime” as opposed to other duties?
About how many people die each year from homicides?
What percentage of all felonies in a given year lead to someone being convicted of a felony and imprisoned?
What does the typical criminal in the U.S. look like?
2
Fewer than 10% of felons are found guilty by a jury trial.
10-20% of an officer’s time is spent “fighting crime”.
About 16K homicides each year.
Less than 10% of felonies each year lead to imprisonment.
The typical criminal is not restricted to those who are poor and nonwhite (see Reiman).
3
Public Perceptions of Crime
Crime is a Serious Social Problem.
Rising crime rates, esp. violent crime.
Terrorism, Gangs, Sex Offenders
Fear of Crime
Politicians and claimsmakers
CJ Policies and CJ populations
Comparisons with other countries
Personal experiences
Media
List things you do in your everyday life to reduce your chances of becoming a crime victim.
Lock doors, alarm systems, own/carry a gun/weapon, own a dog; avoid certain places; careful when/where you walk alone.
Mostly fearful of strangers, unfamiliar locations, at night, when alone.
Most fearful of “crime” in the abstract; few specific fears.
Some fear crime more than others.
4
Public Perceptions of Crime
Gallup Poll: Crime Trends, Crime in US
60%: more crime in the US this year than last
25%: less crime in the US this year than last
Public Perceptions of Crime
Crime in Local Area
42% less crime in local area than year before
39% more crime in local area than year before
Public Perceptions of Crime
Crime as a Serious Social Problem
2018:
Extremely – 16%
Very – 32%
Somewhat – 41%
Not too – 7%
Not at all – 2%
No opinion – 1%
Public Perceptions of Crime
Crime as a Serious Problem in Local Area
Consistent trends over past 10 years
Different trends compared to US
2018:
Extremely – 2% Very – 7% Somewhat – 32%
Not too – 36% Not at all – 32% No opinion – 1%
Fear of Crime
| Percent Worry Frequently/Occasionally – 2018 | |
| % | |
| Identity Theft Being Hacked (computer passwords, credit card numbers, etc.) Having your car stolen or broken into | 67 70 37 |
| Your home being burglarized when you are not there | 40 |
| Being the victim of terrorism *decrease from 39% in 2010 | 24* |
| Having a school-aged child of yours physically harmed attending school | 32 |
| Getting mugged | 25 |
| Your home being burglarized when you are there | 22 |
| Being attacked while driving your car | 22 |
| Being sexually assaulted | 20 |
| Being a victim of a hate crime *increase from 16% in 2010 | 22* |
| Getting murdered | 17 |
| Being assaulted/killed by a co-worker/employee where you work | 7 |
Fear of Crime vs. Victimization
| In the past 12 months, have you or a member of your household been a victim of … (2018) | |
| % NO | |
| Identity Theft Being Hacked (computer passwords, credit card numbers, etc.) Having your car stolen or broken into | 84 75 99 |
| Your home being burglarized when you are not there | 97 |
| Getting mugged | 98 |
| Attacked with a weapon | 99 |
| Being sexually assaulted | 98 |
| Have you EVER been a victim of … (2018) | |
| Crime of physical or threatened harm | 80 |
Fear of Crime Trends
Fear of Crime Comparisons
Fear of crime: Individual characteristics
Women and elderly most fearful of crime.
Least likely to be victimized than men or younger people.
Exception for women is in the case of rape.
Women’s fear of crime=fear of rape
Shadow Hypothesis
Explained by perception of physical vulnerability.
Minorities are more fearful.
Poor are more fearful.
Race and class relationship with fear of crime is partly explained by structural factors and media coverage.
Race and class relationship with fear of crime is partly explained by structural factors and media coverage.
13
Fear of crime: Structural factors
Where you live
How well you know your neighbors
Quality of living conditions
% nonwhite residents
Actual crime rates
Don’t matter too much
Subjective perceptions of crime and vulnerability are better predictors of fear of crime
Subjective perceptions of both crime and structural.
14
Fear of crime: Media representations
Triangular relationship
4 hypotheses tested in Weitzer and Kubrin article.
Real world hypothesis
Cultivation hypothesis
Substitution hypothesis
Resonance hypothesis
4 hypotheses tested in Weitzer and Kubrin article.
Real world hypothesis
Cultivation hypothesis
Substitution hypothesis
Resonance hypothesis
15
MEDIA
CRIME EXPERIENCE
FEAR
Media Representations of Crime
How much crime is represented in the mass media, esp. news and TV shows?
What types of crimes?
What types of offenders?
Thinking question: If you were a newspaper editor or TV news director, what sorts of stories would you cover and why? What if you were in charge of nightly programming for a TV network? (Think about the questions from the mini-survey).
Dramatic, violent, jury trials: capture audience and boost ratings.
16
Overdramatization of Crime
Over-reporting of violent crime
Crime waves
Unusual rather than representative
Stereotypical
Violent youth
Virtuous victims
If it bleeds it leads.
Crime is most popular story in news accounting for about 20% of all stories, 4 minutes of a 30 minute broadcast (tied with sports, behind commercials.
Homicides account for ¼ of all crime stories in TV and newspaper. (% varies from 12 – 50 % depending on city).
Also think about the types of crimes presenting in crime dramas.
What about violence/crime in children’s entertainment.
Overdramatize crime by depicting so many stories about it.
Crime waves make crime seem rampant and on the rise.
Present unusual cases rather than the typical crime (halloween sadists, kidnapping of children, and serial killers).
Media also present stereotypical images of crime and criminals esp. concerning racial and ethnic minorities.
Disporportionate attention to minorities’ crimes
Portray minority offenders in menacing contexts
Underestimates minority victimization
Reinforces negative stereotypes about minorties. Which increases fear of crime.
Violent youth: 14% of violent crime is committed by youth; 1% of all teenagers are arrested annually for violent crime.
Virtuous victims: innocent victims, elderly and children, wealthy; helps foster greater public concern about crime.
17
Media also:
Selective interviews.
Use value-laden language instead of neutral terms.
Present misleading data.
Neglect forms of white-collar crime.
Ignore broader social context/patterns.
Contribute to public misunderstanding of the crime problem and public’s fear of crime. Public opinion can be traced to fear of crime. Media fuels our fears.
18
