Project Risk Management
Project Scope
&
Project Resources, Schedule, and Cost
(Cooperative Milk Collecting Center)
Table of Contents
Up Dated Project Scope (Cooperative Milk Collecting Center)
Project Outcome……………………….…………………………………………….…….….……………..8
Requirements Traceability Matrix…..…..…….………………………………………………….….9
Project Scope Statement ……….……….………………………………………………………………12
Work Breakdown Structure……….…………………………………………………………………….13
Work Breakdown Dictionary………….……………………………..………………………...……...14
Project Resource Management……………………………………………………………………..…18
Project Schedule…………………………………………………………………………………………..….22
Project Cost………………………………………………………………………………………………………26
Project Outcome
This project is development of new business suggested and established from American Farmers Association as a partnership with one of the largest food organization in the middle East named Carrefour, Mr. Gorge Stuard the Head of Investment and development Sector in the organization , the one who will be responsible for following up funding provided by his organization required to execute the project. The Product will be directly under supervision from USFDA, to be sure for the safety of the Milk product before doing any sale to the consumer in the local market. The main idea of the project is to buy the milk from farmers and collected and stored it large frediges tanks dedicated for this purpose to maintain the validity of the milk for long as possible around four weeks. The milk before storage will go through a process to purified from any impurities after filtering and treatment of any harmful bacteria. Next step is to be packaged and sold in the local market under a trade name called Golden Milk. This profitable project distributes profits as follows:
1- 70% to the investor Carrefour Organization which is fully given the funds to execute the project.
2- 30% of the profits to the American Farmers Association in return providing the land on an area of 5,000 M2, they will responsible to do agreement with farmers to buy the milk from them on behalf of CMCC, in addition the Administration and full management of the Milk Collection & Processing Center furthermore, providing technical expertise, manpower and specialized team in marketing for the product . Also, they have to follow up all the necessary procedures inquired to take approvals from government authorities to approve the project execution and the commercial name of the milk product.
The project aims to build milk processing machines that will process the milk collected from different farmers to add value and packages it before selling it to retail shops and supermarket. Through processing, which adds value, the shelf life and prices of milk increases, and this help in profit maximization. The project will be particularly helpful and significant to the smallholder dairy producers because it will be collecting milk from them before processing. Payments that dairy farmers will be getting will help them increase their income.
Furthermore, the project will facilitate several methods that will assist in the improvement of milk safety, especially in the small-scale dairying; this is because most of the farmers depend on their dairy products they get from their dairy animals to sell and at least earn a living from this activity. This project, therefore, will enable farmers to eradicate milk spoilage. which is estimated at the rate of 30% of the whole milk produced (Ortuzar et al. 2018)and will further improve the quality of the liquid. The project is specifically aimed at solving Milk Spoilage Problem which we have observed happening for quite some years now. The project targets to reduce milk spoilage to about 10%, and it will be overcome through However, offering storage facilities for the Milk brought by the farmers and add value through processing, which increases the shelf life. The project will facilitate transportation of the milk to the market under product name: Golden Milk.
Requirements Traceability Matrix
There are several stakeholders' requirements for this project; the stakeholders' demands for the project are:
The largest food organization in the middle East Carrefour need to support the project financially to enhance its implementation. The American Farmers Association need to provide the land with 5000M2 to start doing the schematic diagram for the all the required facilities of the project which will include the following:
1- Administration Building 300 M2.
2- Milk Tanker Truck Dump load platform (Collection Area) 200 M2.
4- Storage Building 1500 M2.
5- Filling & packing Warehouse 1500 M2.
6- Workshop 350 M2
7- Trucks Pick up Area for the Packing Milk to be distributed to the shops 600 M2.
8- Labor Accommodation 400 M2.
Some of the facilities that are required to keep milk safe and in good quality are expensive. Therefore, stakeholders must come in handy and help raise funds to acquire those machines and equipment required like Fridges with complete cooling system and boilers to heat the milk to killed any harmful bacteria and Automatic Filling Systems, Central Filters machine , Automatic Drain System for all wastage, Temperature Instrument Gages .
The American Farmers Association Farmers is responsible as per their agreement with Carrefour to ensure that the farmers have sufficient cows in their farms to be able to provide the supplied the agreed quantities of milk to the collecting center to achieved the production planning strategy by making visits to those farms before concluding any agreement.
The Operations requirement- this stakeholder's need takes into consideration the maintenance of the features of the project. Furthermore. In this regard, the operational team further fosters constraints, for instance, the ability activities in the project.
The third stakeholder requirement is the customer's stakeholder's requirement; this requirement – users, usually give information regarding the product and services offered or provided by the project. Lead users generally help in contributing to the user stories as well as ideas regarding the product and services quality as well as usability. It enables the project to understand which area has to be improved (Eskerod & Jepsen, 2013). Besides, they required the skill to help in the process of the milk product so that wastages are minimized at all costs. Also, they need the marketing skill that allows the firm to sell its products to the final consumers.
These project solution requirements include the equipment that will be used to minimize milk spoilage while they are on transit or storage to the final selling point. The other element is the material used for packaging purposes to the quantities that will be offered to the final consumer.
The project needs to uplift society and create employment. About 15 employees will be hired to work in the milk processing plant and thus creating jobs. Farmers will also get the market for their milk and therefore make money, which will raise their standards of living. On the other hand, the project is required to lead to the development of the neighboring areas. Other businesses are expected to come up in the area where the cooperative will be built.
Quality requirements refer to specifications of the quality of the products as well as services that are offered by the project, it takes into consideration all the processes that take place in the project as well as the entire environment surrounding the project, including ensuring that the products meet the required standards and keeping the high standards of hygiene and cleanness. They are typically activities that may result in the quality improvement of the product as well as services. The quality requirements for this project include customer experience- customer experience refers to activities that may be able to contribute towards the pleasing of the product as well as services.
Furthermore, maintainability requirements ensure that everything works well, and things are easy to maintain (Pries & Quigley, 2012).
The requirements of a project are the conditions or capabilities that the deliverables of a project must meet in order to satisfy the project objectives. The requirements traceability matrix explicitly shows the connections between the requirements, the project objectives, and the deliverables.
· List each requirement for the project, the project objective that each requirement addresses, and the deliverable that satisfies each requirement.
|
Requirement |
Project Objective |
Deliverable |
|
Financial support |
To keep milk safe and in good quality |
Good Quality of Milk |
|
Operations |
maintenance of the project |
Maintain the project throughout the end |
|
Consumers Feedback |
Helps the company by contributing consumer feedback regarding their product and services quality as well as usability |
Improving the service or product by analyzing the consumer feedback |
|
Farmer’s Earning |
To pay the highest possible rate to farmers to encourage them to sale their milk to the CMCC. |
To get the supplied quantities from the milk as per expected. |
|
Equipment’s |
To process the milk storage and achieving the production Plans |
Best packaging service to avoid and distributing the product as per marketing business plan. |
|
Employment Creation |
Will raise the standard of living |
More amount of milk can be Sold in market. |
|
Quality |
Keeping the high standard of hygiene’s |
Quality improvement of the product |
Project Scope Statement
Project scope defines all the work that must be done to deliver the expected outcome or product of the project. The project scope statement describes precisely what is and what is not included in the project. The scope of the project is derived from project requirements and is used as input to create the work breakdown structure.
Compose a project scope statement:
· Describe, in detail, the characteristics of the product, service, or outcome that the project will produce.
The project will be particularly helpful and significant to the smallholder dairy producers because it will be collecting milk from them without any fatigue in the distribution of milk to the markets in a traditional way, where they must distribute in a timely manner so as not to be damaged milk since a large proportion of farmers do not have storage places and equipment because of the high cost to them. In addition to the transportation fees to distribute the milk to the shops. It is easier for them to supply the full quantities of milk to the center and collect the money immediately, without any effort incurred as it was in the past. Payments that dairy farmers will be getting will help them increase their income. The project aims to build milk processing machines that will process the milk collected from different farmers to add value and packages it before selling it to retail shops and supermarket. Through processing, which adds value, the shelf life and prices of milk increase.
The project intends to provide is the milk storage services in their storage areas constructed specially for this purpose and equipped with all cooling devices according to the appropriate cooling temperatures to save milk for long periods for more than 4 weeks.
· Describe the incremental deliverables that must be produced to create the final product, service, or outcome of the project.
A new delivery plan for farmers has to be developed. Moreover, a delivery plan is an essential external stakeholder. In addition to that, since there is readily available market, it is also important to establish a finished marketing plan that will ensure an expanded market for the milk. Marketing plan is an incremental deliverable that will help the project meet its objectives.
Here, in this project the incremental approach is how to produce more milk, how to check the quality of the milk and how to retain the same quality of the milk over the period. The storage of the milk to protect from germs or bacteria. And above all, the environment plays a vital role. Hygienic area, hygienic people as well as hygienic machinery is required to pull out the maximum benefit and along that also to provide quality of product which the company has promised to give to the society.
Furthermore, Screening is another incremental deliverable, screening ensures that the milk is screened for pathogens and other components. Screening is done to ensure quality of milk.
Finances is another essential incremental deliverable. It is important that enough budget is allocated to the project, this will ensure that the project meets all of the objectives set. Furthermore, enough budget will foster quick completion of the project.
· Describe the exclusions from the scope of the project.
MSPM 6900 Capstone: Social Impact in Project Management
The scope of project excludes the profit margins after 1 year of the running business. It should tell the stakeholders that at what time of frame they will get the profit from the business not the investment. It should have a proper plan for coming 5 years, that where the business stands and how much you can give to the society in terms of product or service and how much profit margin you will get from the business
©2019 - Walden University- Project Scope & Project Resources, Schedule and Cost 3
Work Breakdown Structure
Work Breakdown Structure Dictionary
· Complete this table for each work package in the WBS.
|
Project Title: Cooperative Milk Collecting Center (CMCC)- Product Name: Golden Milk |
|||
|
WBS Work Package ID: PP WBS Work Package Task Name: Project preparation |
|||
|
Description of Work: It is consisting of preparing design drawing and all inquired specification related to the work execution and all Cooling & Packaging System. In addition, the required legalization matters to find out who will be the partnership needed for the project, to get all funds required to execute the project. Deliverable: |
|||
|
Activities (Verb Noun Format) |
Labor Resources (Name or Type) |
Other Resources (Such as Equipment) |
Expected Duration |
|
1- Project Preparation |
Mr. Gorge Stuard. Head of Investors Committee |
· |
3 months |
|
1.1- Funds & Partnership |
|
|
2 months |
|
1.1.1- American Farmer Association |
Mr. David Lowis Financial Controller in (AFA) |
· |
One month |
|
1.1.2- Carrefour (Food Organization) – from Middle East |
Mr. Gorge Stuard Head of Investment and development Sector in Carrefour & Head of Investors committee for CMCC
|
· |
One month |
|
1.2- Design Document & Legalization |
Sam Smith- Head of Permits for Industrial Establishment |
· |
3 months |
|
1.2.1- Design Admin Building |
Michel Saad – CMCC Project Manager has been appointed for 15 months until completion of the Project. He will be responsible for the entire project.
|
Plotter, computers and Stationery |
15 days |
|
1.2.2- Design Collection Area |
Michel Saad – CMCC Project Manager |
Plotter, computers and Stationery |
15 days |
|
1.2.3- Design of Storage Building |
Michel Saad – CMCC Project Manager |
Plotter, computers and Stationery |
30 days |
|
1.2.4- Design of Filling and Packing ware |
Michel Saad – CMCC Project Manager |
Plotter, computers and Stationery |
30 days |
|
1.2.5- Design of Truck pick up Area& Labor Accommodation |
Michel Saad – CMCC Project Manager |
|
30 days |
|
End of Project Preparation Phase |
|
· |
0 days |
|
Total Duration: 3 months Acceptance Criteria: The Funds Availability for project financing. Person Responsible for verification of Completion: Head of Investors Committee Mr. Gorge Stuard. |
|
Project Title: Cooperative Milk Collecting Center (CMCC)- Product Name: Golden Milk |
|||
|
WBS Work Package ID: WE WBS Work Package Task Name: Work Execution |
|||
|
Description of Work: Start project mobilization to make the site ready for construction works and after that the construction work will be started. Deliverable: |
|||
|
Activities (Verb Noun Format) |
Labor Resources (Name or Type) |
Other Resources (Such as Equipment) |
Expected Duration |
|
2- Work Execution |
Michel Saad – CMCC Project Manager has been appointed for 15 months until completion of the Project. He will be responsible for the entire project |
Rental Construction Equipment, Wheel Loaders, Excavators Backhoe, Sewage Pipeline material and all material required for project services. |
7 months |
|
2.1- Site Mobilization |
Michel Saad - CMCC Project Manager- |
· |
2 months |
|
2.1.1- Infrastructure Works |
Michel Saad - CMCC- Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Wheel Loaders, Excavators Backhoe, Sewage Pipeline material and all material required for project services. |
40 days |
|
2.1.2- Temporary Site Office |
Michel Saad - CMCC Project Manager- |
Steel Structure Materials & Sandwich panels with other Building Materials |
20 days |
|
2.2- Construction work |
Michel Saad - CMCC Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Wheel Loaders, Excavators Backhoe, Concrete Mixer, Pumps, Building Materials. |
5 months |
|
2.2.1-Admin building construction |
Michel Saad - CMCC- Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Building Materials. |
4 months |
|
2.2.2- Collection Area Construction |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Building Materials. |
3 months |
|
2.2.3- Storage Building Construction |
Michel Saad - CMCC- Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Building Materials. |
2 months |
|
2.2.4- Filling & Packing warehouse construction |
Michel Saad - CMCC- Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Building Materials. |
3 months |
|
2.2.5-Truck pick up Area & labor Accommodation Construction |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Rental Construction Equipment, Building Materials. |
2 months |
|
End of Work Execution Phase |
- |
- |
0 days |
|
Total Duration: 360 days Acceptance Criteria: handing over the mobilization & construction work Person Responsible for verification of Completion: Michel Saad & Murad Nabil. |
|
Project Title: Cooperative Milk Collecting Center (CMCC)- Product Name: Golden Milk |
|||
|
WBS Work Package ID: FW WBS Work Package Task Name: Finishes Work |
|||
|
Description of Work: the beginning of the finishing works, which includes the external works including landscaping and paving, and the work of parking for trucks and irrigation works for external plantations. In addition the interior finishes work, such as plastering of walls and paints works, electrical works with installing the light fitting, applying floor tiles and installation of sanitary appliances. Deliverable: |
|||
|
Activities (Verb Noun Format) |
Labor Resources (Name or Type) |
Other Resources (Such as Equipment) |
Expected Duration |
|
3.0- Finishes Works |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Managers- |
Building Material, Rental construction Equipment, Irrigation material and tools |
4 months |
|
3.1- Exterior Work |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Managers - |
Building Material, Rental construction Equipment, Irrigation material and tools. |
15 days |
|
3.1.1- Landscape Work |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Managers- |
soil, paving equipment and building material. |
45 days |
|
3.1.2 - Paving Work |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Rental Paving Equipment, Water Tankers, sand &stone aggregates, Asphalt & Concrete for Paving |
2 months |
|
3.1.3- Truck Parking |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Steel Material, Concrete Rental Crane |
One month |
|
3.1.4- Irrigation |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Irrigation Material and Plants, electronic system. |
45 days |
|
3.2- Interior work |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Cement, Bricks, Tiles, Paint material electrical Material and light lamps |
4 months |
|
3.2.1- Plastering and Paint |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Cement, Bonding material , sand , and pant material |
3 months |
|
3.2.2- Light Fitting and Electrical Work. |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Tools , Electrical Wires and Plugs , lamps and switches, Breakers |
4 months |
|
3.2.3- Tiles and Flooring |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Cement, Sand, Bonding Material, Fixing tools and Tiles |
75 days |
|
3.2.4- Installation Sanitary Appliances |
Michel Saad - CMCC -Project Manager- |
Valves, Sanitary Parts and Accessories. Fixing tools |
One month |
|
End of Finishes Works |
|
· |
0 days |
|
Total Duration: 60 days Acceptance Criteria: Complete all Finishes works related to the project Exterior and Interior. Person Responsible for verification of Completion: Project Manager Mr. Michel Saad |
|
Project Title: Cooperative Milk Collecting Center (CMCC)- Product Name: Golden Milk |
|||
|
WBS Work Package ID: EI WBS Work Package Task Name: Equipment Installation |
|||
|
Description of Work: Supply and install of milk storage tanks and refrigerators with cooling system, in addition supply and install of milk filling system in bottles and assembly in cartons in preparation for loading in trucks for distribution in the local market. Deliverable: |
|||
|
Activities (Verb Noun Format) |
Labor Resources (Name or Type) |
Other Resources (Such as Equipment) |
Expected Duration |
|
4.0- Equipment Installation for new cold drink Product |
Mr. Murad Nabiel, Mr. Adam Abbas
|
Installation Tools, Forklift, cranes, Electrical connection & Manual. |
181 days |
|
4.1- Final Installation |
Mr. Murad Nabiel Procurement Manager (CMCC) Reported to Project manager Mr. Michel Saad Mr. Adam Abbas Technical Engineer (AFAS) |
Installation Tools, Forklift, cranes, Electrical connection & Manual. |
87 days |
|
4.1.1- Storage Containers Installation |
Mr. Murad Nabiel Procurement Manager (CMCC) Reported to Project manager Mr. Michel Saad Mr. Adam Abbas Technical Engineer (AFAS) |
Installation Tools, Forklift, cranes, Electrical connection & Manual. |
one month |
|
4.1.2- Fridges and Cooler System |
Mr. Murad Nabiel Mr. Adam Abbas |
Installation Tools, Forklift, cranes, Electrical connection & Manual. |
One month |
|
4.1.3- Packing System |
Mr. Murad Nabiel Mr. Adam Abbas |
Installation Tools, Forklift, cranes, Electrical connection & Manual. |
One month |
|
4.2- Project Closeout |
|
|
|
|
4.2.1- Testing & Commencing |
Mr. Adam Abbas |
Operation Manuals |
12 days |
|
4.2.2- Project Handing Over |
Mr. Michel Saad Mr. Gorge Stuard. |
As Built Drawing Complete Sets. |
0 days |
|
Total Duration: 87 days Acceptance Criteria: Start up the Machines and production Started. Person Responsible for verification of Completion: Mr. Murad Nabiel, Mr.Adam Abbas, Finally, Assigned by Head of Investors Committee Mr. Gorge Stuard. |
Project Resource Management
Project resource management includes the processes to identify, acquire, and manage the human and non-human resources needed to complete the work of the project and produce the final product, service, or outcome. The resource plan for a project is used as input to develop the project schedule and estimating the cost of a project.
Project Team
· In the table below, identify and assign roles and responsibilities for three to five (3–5) key project team members for the project using the definitions of role and responsibility provided on pages 318–319 of the PMBOK (PMBOK Guide).
|
Team Member Name |
Role |
Responsibility |
|
Gorge Stuard |
Head of Investors Committee including (Carrefour and American Farmer Association) |
Responsible for collecting funding for the project & Giving approval to start project works and handing Over and commissioning the production of Milk Collecting Center. |
|
Michel Saad |
CMCC Project Manager has been appointed for two-year contract until completion of the Project.
|
· Making the Project plan. · Developing a project Schedule. · Managing Project Team. · Leading all work Execution of the project.
|
|
Murad Nabiel |
Procurement Manager, employed in CMCC, and reported to the project Manager. |
Responsible for directing the purchasing of the milk from the suppliers, conducting interviews with milk suppliers, negotiating the supplier agreements. Responsible for supply all equipment and prepare the system for a start-up commissioning. |
|
Sarah Fouad |
Human Resources Manager (CMCC) |
Hiring employees and selecting qualified staff and withholding training courses. |
|
Adam Abas |
Technical support Engineer |
Approved all process from collecting the milk and storage it in the refrigerators up to fill it in bottles to be ready for distribution & Operation of equipment and manuals. |
· Describe the processes that will be used to develop and manage the project team.
Development and management of the project team requires some processes, the main intention is to improve the competencies of team members. On the other hand, management of the team members is meant to optimize project performance.
Develop Project Team.
This focuses on improving the competencies of team members, it is achieved through several processes such as training, team building. Training team members how to effectively carry out their duties to enhance their competencies. Furthermore, facilitating team-building activities is very essential in this process. Furthermore, Incenting the team using recognition and rewards is very important since it will motivate them to work even smarter than before (Chiocchio, Kelloway, & Hobbs, 2015).
Manage Project Team
This process is meant to monitor or tracks team member performance, give feedback to the team members, fostering the resolving of various issues et cetera. provision of the project performance appraisals on the team members. Using appropriate conflict management approach to solve issues that may arise among the team members (Chiocchio, Kelloway, & Hobbs, 2015).
Project Resources
Complete the table below for the project. The table should contain the key project team members identified, and all other human and non-human resources needed for the project.
· Project Team member name and rate
|
Resource Name |
Cost per hour |
|
Gorge Stuard - Head of Investors Committee |
$45 / Hour |
|
Michel Saad -Project Manager (CMCC) |
$40/ Hour |
|
Murad Nabiel Procurement Manager (CMCC) |
$40 / Hour |
|
Adam Abbas – Technical Support engineer (CMCC) |
$30 / Hour |
|
Jone Gawland-Producer Manager (CMCC) |
$35/ Hour |
|
Sarah Fouad – Human Resources (CMCC) |
$30 / Hour |
· Human resources other than the project team members
|
Rate or Cost |
|
|
Numbers of 15 Workers |
$20/Hours |
|
Auditor |
$15000/year |
|
Consultant |
$100/Day |
|
Transporters- 2 Drivers – Outsource |
$35 / Hour |
|
Advertising Advisor ( Out Source) |
500 per Task |
· Non-Human resources needed for the Project
|
· Resource Name |
Rate or Cost |
|
Land Purchasing (5,000 M2) - $30/ Meter Square |
$150,000 |
|
Rental Construction Equipment, Wheel Loaders, Excavators Backhoe, Concrete Mixer, Pumps |
Rent one Construction Equipment $30/Hour |
|
Building Material- as Bill of Quantities (Total) |
$80,000 |
|
No. 20 Mechanical Refrigeration $ 1500/ Unit |
$ 30,000 |
|
Packing System (Total) |
$15,000 |
|
Advertising Advisor (Outsource) |
500 per Task |
|
Water, Electricity, Telecommunication Services& Cleaning (Lump Sum) |
$35,000 |
· Tools & Technique used to Identify the project resources
When we have all required inputs for resource planning, here’s how to get down to it. Expert judgment comes from our professional experience, valuable insights that may come from our senior consultants hired by CMCC. As it may sound obvious, it’s important for the project’s success.
Next comes the alternatives identification. As a project may change during their lifetime, we need to take different scenarios into consideration. This way, we can come up with solutions to use as changes occur. Two methods we may use are:
· Pattern thinking – this method involves pattern recognition, which is useful while refining or improving, based on past experiences.
· Lateral thinking – this approach requires creative thinking and solving problems with ideas that may not be obvious at first.
Bottom-up estimating, which is the next method we can use while planning resources, is a simple concept based on involving people who are going to work on the project in estimating it. In this approach our team estimates tasks based on their knowledge and experience, resulting in a more detailed schedule, but it’s also more time consuming.
· Explain how will acquire the non-human resources for the project
The use of resource management software will come in handy during this duration in order to not only manage both human and non-human resources, but also tabulate all data that has been accumulated by the business during its operations. Software in this instance is more appropriate than the use of spreadsheets as it provides quick access to information through the use of filters, especially when dealing with bulky bits of information regarding, say, the names and units of milk for each farmer involved.
The project intends to acquire its non-human resources from an investor committee. The project investors along with other core members higher up the ranking chains will be consulted as the project expands and decisions on the trajectory of the business will be decided upon.
However, in order to get the funding necessary to kick start this project, the investor committee must approve the ideas and goals being pushed by the business and subsequently involve Mr. Gorge Saad in its decision-making processes once funding for the project has been secured.
Project Schedule:
A project schedule is developed by estimating the duration of the activities that must be performed in order to produce each of the sub-deliverables. The project schedule is typically represented in a Gantt Chart. The Gantt Chart depicts the project activities, durations, start and end dates, and predecessors. It also shows the project’s critical path. Activities on the critical path are those that, if delayed, will impact the project finish date.
Estimate Activity Durations
· Describe the tool/technique you used to estimate the activity durations:
There are several tools or techniques that can used to estimate the activates duration as per the following:
Analogous Estimation
The analogous, or top-down, estimation relies on information from similar projects to determine the activity duration for a current project. All we need the historical data and a degree of expertise about the similar projects, because the reliability of your estimation depends on how closely the activities match the projects we are using as comparisons. Use this method at the beginning of a project when we don’t have all the details. Adjust the estimates as we learn more about the tasks and how long they can be expected to take with the resources available.
Parametric Estimation
The parametric estimation is similar, but more accurate, than the analogous estimation. To use it, multiply the number of units we need by the time it takes to produce the units. We will need historical information about similar activities to complete our estimate. The method is scalable. This means if our historical data tells us that it takes one person an hour to produce one unit, we can reasonably estimate that we can complete three units within one hour if we allocate three workers to the task. When we use this method, it's important to account for all tasks that impact the activity. For example, if the workers spend part of the time preparing materials, account for that time in our estimates.
Expert Judgment
When the project is complicated and several factors can influence the duration of our activities, we might want to use expert judgment to estimate activity duration. Experts knowledgeable in an area can judge the time and resources that need to complete activities in this area. We also can gather estimates from external experts, if we can get external estimates at reasonable cost.
The Delphi Technique
The Delphi technique makes use of group intelligence to determine activity duration. The technique involves gathering opinions from several experts and then sending the responses back to the experts for their review. They can change their opinions after reviewing the responses. The process might involve several rounds, as we want to investigate differences of opinion and get to a consensus. To reduce bias and prevent individual experts from overly influencing results, experts submit their opinion anonymously. We can use a third party to gather the opinions.
Work Breakdown Structure
Certain activities might be too large or complex for a reliable duration estimate. If an activity takes up more than 10 percent of the project schedule, we might want to break it into several different tasks. we can use a work breakdown structure to reduce these activities into smaller, more manageable tasks. Doing this enables us to set priorities and estimate the duration of tasks more accurately. A work breakdown structure also is useful for building accountability, because we can assign specific tasks to designated project participants.
· Estimate the duration for each of the project activities and enter the durations in the table.
|
Deliverable/Activity |
Start |
Finish |
Duration |
|
Project Start (Cooperative Milk Collecting Center) |
3rd of October 2019 |
30 December 2020 |
15 months |
|
1. Project Preparation |
3rd of October 2019 |
3rd January 2020 |
3 months |
|
1.1. Funds& Partnership |
3rd of October 2019 |
3rd of December 2019. |
2 months |
|
1.1.1 American Farmer Association |
3rd of October2019 |
3rd of November 21, 2019 |
One month |
|
1.1.2 Carrefour Food Organization |
3rd of October 2019 |
3rd of December 2019 |
2 months |
|
1.2 Design& Document Legalization |
3rd of October 2019 |
3rd January 2020 |
3 months |
|
1.2.1 Design Admin Building |
3rd of October |
17th of October 2019 |
15 days |
|
1.2.2 Design Collection Area |
17th of October 2019 |
3rd of November 2019. |
15 days |
|
1.2.3 Design of Storage Building |
3rdof November 2019 |
3rd of December 2019 |
30 days |
|
1.2.4 Design of Filling and Packing Warehouse |
3rd of November 2019 |
3rd of December 2019 |
30 days |
|
1.2.5 Design of Truck pick up Area & Labor Accommodation. |
3rd of December 2019 |
3rd January 2020 |
30 days |
|
2. Work Execution |
3rd January 2020 |
3rd of August 2020 |
7 months |
|
2.1 Site Mobilization |
3rd January 2020 |
3rd of March 2020 |
2 months |
|
2.1.1 Infrastructure Works |
3rd January 2020 |
13th of February2020 |
40 days |
|
2.1.2 Temporary Site Office |
13th of February 2020 |
3rd of March 2020 |
20 days |
|
2.2 Construction Work |
3rd of March 2020 |
3rd of August 2020 |
5 months |
|
2.2.1 Admin Building Construction |
3rd of March2020 |
3rd of July 2020 |
4 months |
|
2.2.2 Collection Area Construction |
3rd of March 2020 |
3rd of June 2020 |
3 months |
|
2.2.3 Storage Building Construction |
3rd of March 2020 |
3rd of May 2020 |
2 months |
|
2.2.4 Filling and Packing Warehouse Construction |
3rd of May 2020 |
3rd August 2020 |
3 months |
|
2.2.5 Truck Pick up Area and Labor Accommodation Construction |
3rd of June 2020 |
3rd of August 2020 |
2 months |
|
3. Finishes Work |
3rd of June 2020 |
3rd of October 2020 |
4 months |
|
3.1 Exterior Work |
3rd of August 2020 |
3rd of October 2020 |
2 months |
|
3.1.1 Landscape Work |
3rd of August 2020 |
18 of September 2020 |
45 days |
|
3.1.2 Paving Work |
15th of August 2020 |
15th of October 2020 |
2 months |
|
3.1.3 Truck Parking |
4rd of August 2020 |
4th of September 2020 |
One month |
|
3.1.4 Irrigation |
3rd of August 2020 |
18th of September 2020 |
45 days |
|
3.2 Interior Work |
3rd of June 2020 |
3rd of October 2020 |
4 months |
|
3.2.1 Plastering and Paint |
3rd of June 2020 |
3rd of September 2020 |
3 months |
|
3.2.2 Light Fitting and Electrical Work |
3rd of June 2020 |
3rd October 2020 |
4 months |
|
3.2.3 Tiles and Flooring |
3 of July 2020 |
18th of September 2020 |
75 days |
|
3.2.4 Installation Sanitary Appliance |
3rd of August 2020 |
3 of September 2020 |
One month |
|
4. Equipment installation required for a new Gold drink product |
3rd of October 2020 |
30 December 2020 |
87 days |
|
4.1.1 Storage Containers Installation |
3rd of October 2020 |
3rd of November 2020 |
One month |
|
4.1.2 Fridges and Cooler System |
3rd of November 2020 |
18th of November 2020 |
15 days |
|
4.1.3 Packing System |
18th of November 2020 |
18th of December 2020 |
One month |
|
4.2 Project closeout |
|
|
|
|
4.2.1 Testing & commencing |
18th of December 2020 |
29 December 2020 |
12 days |
|
4.2.2 Project Handing Over |
- |
29 December 2020 |
0 days |
|
|
|
|
|
Gantt Chart
· Using the data in table above, construct a Gantt Chart for the project.
· The Gantt Chart should depict the following: Activity Name, Start Date, Finish Date, Duration, and Predecessors.
· The Gantt Chart should display the critical path.
· The Adjustment of dates may occur as per the Primavera Software Format and Data Output.
Project Cost
Project cost management involves estimating how much it will cost to complete all of the project activities and then aggregating those costs to determine the total cost of the project. In order to estimate the cost of the project, resources must be applied to the project activities.
Project Cost Estimates
|
Deliverable/Activity |
Duration |
Resource Name(s) |
Resource Quantity/Rate |
Activity Cost |
|
Project: (Cooperative Milk Collecting Center) |
15 months |
|
|
|
|
1.0- Project Preparation |
3 months |
|
|
|
|
1.1-Funds& Partnership |
2 months |
Carrefour Food Organization Middle East & AFA |
Finance |
Collecting Funds for project Budget |
|
1.1.1 American Farmer Association |
One month |
Feasibility study & cost Analysis |
Consultation |
$ 4,000 |
|
1.1.2 Carrefour Food Organization |
2 months |
Feasibility study & cost Analysis and financial studies |
Consultation |
$8,000 |
|
1.2 Design& Document Legalization |
3 months |
Plotter, Computers and Stationery |
- |
- |
|
1.2.1 Design Admin Building |
15 days |
Design Document |
Complete Design documents set. |
$10350.00 |
|
1.2.2 Design Collection Area |
15 days |
Design Document |
Complete Design documents set. |
$1,100 |
|
1.2.3 Design of Storage Building |
30 days |
Design Document |
Complete Design documents set. |
$1,300 |
|
1.2.4 Design of Filling and Packing Warehouse |
30 days |
Design Document |
Complete Design documents set. |
$ 1,400 |
|
1.2.5 Design of Truck pick up Area & Labor Accommodation. |
30 days |
Design Document |
Complete Design documents set. |
$850.00 |
|
2.0- Work Execution |
7 months |
- |
· |
· |
|
2.1 Site Mobilization |
2 months |
· |
· |
- |
|
2.1.1 Infrastructure Works |
40 days |
Rental Construction Equipment, Building Material, Sewage Pipe line , manhole , steel bars and cement & concrete |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition. |
$ 25,000 |
|
2.1.2 Temporary Site Office |
20 days |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition. |
$15,000 |
|
2.2 Construction Work |
5 months |
· |
· |
· |
|
2.2.1 Admin Building Construction |
4 months |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition. |
$30,000 |
|
2.2.2 Collection Area Construction |
3 months |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition. |
$18,000 |
|
2.2.3 Storage Building Construction |
2 months |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition |
$22,000 |
|
2.2.4 Filling and Packing Warehouse Construction |
3months |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition. |
$20,000 |
|
2.2.5 Truck Pick up Area and Labor Accommodation Construction |
2 months |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition |
$26,000 |
|
3.0- Finishes Work |
4 months |
- |
- |
- |
|
3.1 Exterior Work |
2 months |
- |
- |
- |
|
3.1.1 Landscape Work |
45 days |
Rental,Bobcat Equipment, Loaders Soil Bricks |
As per Landscape survey Layout. |
$ 10,000 |
|
3.1.2 Paving Work |
2 months |
Rental equipment for leveling, compacting ground , Paving Equipment & water tank, Paving material |
2 leveling & 2 paving Equipment
5 Water Tanks, $ 50 per Hour for each. Estimated hours 16 . |
$7,200 for equipment + $ 3500 Asphalt Material Total = $10,700 |
|
3.1.3 Truck Parking |
One month |
Rental Construction Equipment& Building Material |
Estimate as per B.O.Q and Site Condition |
$ 4850.00 |
|
3.1.4 Irrigation |
45 days |
Rental,Bobcat Equipment, Drip Irrigation systems. Water Flow Meters, soil sensors, Drones |
As per Plants Layout refer to the approved landscape Drawing. |
$ 15,000 |
|
3.2 Interior Work |
4 months |
- |
- |
- |
|
3.2.1 Plastering and Paint |
3 months |
Cement, Sand, Bonding Material Mixing tools, Paint material Brushes, ladders, Plastic covers etc. |
Estimated as quantities and previous work done. |
$2,250.00 |
|
3.2.2 Light Fitting and Electrical Work |
4 months |
Ladders, electrical wiring, lamps, D.B Switches Breakers and Data Cables etc |
As per Elect B.O.Q
|
$12,000.00 |
|
3.2.3 Tiles and Flooring |
75 days |
Adhesives Sand, Cement, Bonding Materials, Tiles |
As Per Finishes Schedule for the project. |
$15,000 |
|
3.2.4 Installation Sanitary Appliance |
One month |
Sanitary Parts and accessories, |
As Quantities mentioned in the B.O.Q |
$4100 |
|
4.0-Equipment installation required for a new cold drink product |
87 days |
- |
- |
- |
|
4.1.1 Storage Containers Installation |
One month |
Storage Containers & Forklift, Power Connection, Control Panel Fixing Tools, carne |
As per the Detailed Drawing and B.O.Q |
$ 15,500 |
|
4.1.2 Fridges and Cooler System |
15 days |
Fridges and cooler System. |
As per the Design Drawing and B.O.Q |
$ 20,000 |
|
4.1.3 Packing System |
One month |
Packing Machine, Motors, Cartons, Bottles, Forklift |
As per detailed drawing & B.O.Q and manuals |
$15,000 |
|
4.2.1 Testing & commencing |
12 days |
Measuring & testing Tools |
Total No.3 of Measuring & testing tools |
$550.00
|
|
4.2.2 Project Handing Over |
0 days |
· |
· |
· |
|
Grand Total |
|
|
|
$ 280,850 |
· Describe the tool/technique you used to estimate the activity resources.
There are several tools and techniques that can be used to estimate activity resources in our project as follows:
Expert Judgment
Expert judgment is the first tool and technique. Experts can provide real perspective when it comes to estimating resources for our activities. First off, experts can help the project staff choose the right resource based on their wealth of experience with similar projects or activities. Once we have decided on which resource is correct for the task, experts can then help us to determine how many of these resources we should employ for a given activity. Experts usually know the optimum number so there is just enough work to go around and avoid idle time. Experts earn their big paychecks also by sharing their knowledge and insights about requirements for a given activity that is common in their area of expertise. Experts can give us choices of different techniques for estimating and because they have seen many different situations, experts can typically also provide a range of choices of resources appropriate for a given activity.
Estimating Tools
Next, we have the three common estimating techniques that we have already seen in both Cost Management. Bottom-up estimating it is time consuming, it is the most accurate of estimating approaches. Some call it the Engineering or Grassroots estimate because of the level of detail involved.
The key is in the detail. When we breakdown an enormous task into smaller, more manageable tasks then the tasks become small enough to make a considered estimate for the required resources. After we assign people, equipment, material and supplies, we get a total for that single task. Add up all these estimates and that is Bottom-up estimating. When each and every task on the WBS has its own detailed estimates, the number can be aggregated at a different level or totaled for the entire project.
Analogous estimating is certainly quicker and easier. This method uses the common features of similar past projects based on recent historical data.
And then Parametric estimates are simple math tools. They are algorithm-based. If you have current, up-to-date data, we can use a formula to make an estimate based on proven relationships. For example, a paving staff knows its past cost per lane mile paved and even the cost of a mile of painted centerline. Very handy but using this tool requires current, accurate and relevant data.
Data Analysis
We are moving on to our next tool and technique, which is Data analysis where we take the time to look at the activity resource related information so we can organize, assess and evaluate them.
Alternative Analysis
As a project manager, our project team and often experts will assist us in identifying several resource options for our activities.
When choosing resources, we must first determine what is the best choice and why. Is it faster? Is faster always the best? What about reliability and what about quality? The analysis of alternatives should consider all the ways to accomplish the activity. Should the task be done manually or is automation a better choice?
Questions such as whether it makes sense to do the work in-house or use external resources need to be considered when estimating resources. Very often, our project manager will also have to consider whether it makes more sense to build it or buy it or even rent it. For example, software, should we build it ourselves or purchase it from a vendor? Both the requirements of an activity or its product, as well as the current environment will limit our choice of alternatives.
One example that immediately comes to mind is a resource shortage and its effect on cost and considerations regarding alternatives. So, as we see, there are many considerations when choosing and estimating the resources required for the project activities and it’s good to have alternatives.
· Describe the tool/technique you used, to estimate the activity costs.
The cost of each project activity is estimated in the estimate costs process. An interesting point about this process is that it uses the same tools as in the estimate activity duration. In the estimate activity duration process, we determine the time taken by each activity. Now, in the estimate costs process, we will calculate the total cost of the project.
In estimate cost process, the cost of each activity is determined, including the cost of human hours, the cost of equipment, and the cost of materials used as well as the contingency cost (i.e., the cost to cover the identified risks).
There are several tools and techniques that can be used to estimate activity cost in our project as follows:
Analogous Estimating
This technique is employed to estimate the project cost when limited detail about the project is available. Therefore, this technique does not provide a very reliable estimation. The primary benefits of this technique are its lower cost and quick results.
In analogous estimation, the cost of the project is estimated by comparing it with similar projects previously completed by your organization. Here, you will look into your organization’s historical records (i.e., an organizational process assets) for prior completed projects similar to your own. You will select the project which is closest to your project and use your expert judgment to determine the cost estimate of your current project.
The analogous estimating is also known as the top-down estimating.
Parametric Estimating
Like analogous estimating, parametric estimation uses historical data to calculate cost estimates; however, it also utilizes statistical data. It takes variables from similar projects and applies them to the current project.
For instance, in a previous project, we take the cost of concrete per cubic meter, then calculate the concrete requirement for the current project and multiply it with the cost obtained from the previous project. This will provide the total cost of concrete for your current project.
In the same way, you can calculate the cost of other parameters (men, materials, and equipment).
The accuracy of this process is better than the analogous estimation because it employs more than one data set.
Bottom-up Estimating
The bottom-up estimating technique is also called the “definitive technique.” This technique is the most accurate, time-consuming, and costly technique for estimating the cost of a project. Here the cost of every single activity is determined with the highest level of detail at the bottom level and then rolls up to calculate the total project cost.
Here, the total project work is broken down into the smallest work components. Each component cost is estimated, and finally, it is aggregated to determine the project’s cost estimate.
Reference
Barroso, (2003). Writing the proposal for a qualitative research methodology project.
Eskerod, P., & Jepsen, A. L. (2013). Project Stakeholder Management.
Haugan, G. T. (2016). The New Triple Constraints for Sustainable Projects, Programs, and Portfolios. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
Pries, K. H., & Quigley, J. M. (2012). Total Quality Management for Project Management. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
Vida, K. P. (2012). The Project Management Handbook: A Guide to Capital Improvements. Rowman & Littlefield.
Zikwel O, (2000). Evaluation of models for forecasting final cost of a project: Project Management Journal.
Cooperative Milk Collecting Center
Project
Project Preparation
Work Execution
Finishes Work
Funds and Partnership
Design and Document Legalization
American Farmers Association
Carrefour Food Oganization Middle East
Exterior Work
Landscape Work
Paving Work
Truck Parking
Irrigation
Plastering and Paint
Light and Fitting and Electrical Work
Tiles and Flooring
Admin Building
Collection Area
Storage Building
Filling and Packing Warehouse
Truck Pick Up Area and Labor Accommodation
Installation Sanitary Appliance
Site
Mobilization
Infrastructure Works
Temporary Site Office
Interior Work
Construction Work
Admin Building
Collection Area
Storage Building
Filling and Packing warehouse
Truck Pick up Area & Labor Accommodation
Equipment installation required for a new Gold milk product
Final Installation
Storage Containers Installation
Fridge and Cooler System
Project Closeout
Project Handing Over
Testing and Commissioning
Packing System
MSPM
6900 Capstone: Social Impact in Project Management
©2019
-
Walden University
-
Project
Scope
&
Project Resources
, Schedule and
Cost
1
Project Scope
&
Project Resources, Schedule, and Cost
(Cooperative Milk Collecting Center)
MSPM 6900 Capstone: Social Impact in Project Management
©2019 - Walden University- Project Scope & Project Resources, Schedule and Cost 1
Project Scope
&
Project Resources, Schedule, and Cost
(Cooperative Milk Collecting Center)