English writing 3

4

3

2

1

Your Score

Reference

- HBR style is Perfect

- Appropriate article selection

Minor edits needed – follow the details.

Major edits needed. Learn the details.

- Does not follow HBR style or

-Inappropriate article selection

Review of

Article

Major points selected and discussed.

Same as 4, but selects couple minor issues or no supporting example explained

Does not focus on major issues

Missed the jest of the article.

Writing

Clear articulate writing used. One or two minor edits needed to be a perfect paper! Keep up the great work!

Minor edits needed. Proof-reading will help you. Read aloud to yourself and or ask others to read it out loud to you.

Major edits needed. Get help so you learn the process. You will write a lot as a teacher - need to be a competent articulate professional.

Turns in something. Not college level work at all. Get help at the writing center.

Organization of writing

Well organized thinking that reviews the article, discusses the major points in an order that makes sense, and closes with your thoughts.

Minor jumping around on points. Could be better with few minor moves.

Major jumping around on points made in review. Major organizational edits needed to articulate clearly.

No organizational thought demonstrated in writing of review, major points discussed in the article, or your thoughts and ideas.

Your Thoughts

Articulates your thoughts on the article in clear manner. Discusses what you learned from reading the article or ideas you might use in the future.

Brief mention of thoughts, but did not elaborate. No mention of learning from reading the article.

Does not write any of your own thoughts or ideas about what is discussed in the article.