English HOMEWORK HELP DUE SATURDAY

profilelongbeachgyal
PRECIOUSFILMNOTES.docx

Most of the books you pick up a history book and you don't really see any other cultures in there, but, you know, mostly Caucasian white people.

Ethnic studies is the knowledge of other than your own ethnicity.

Not only learning about the past of the US but also learning and having the opportunity to learn about our culture.

My grampa my grandma taught me to be proud that I'm Mexican, and these classes help me because I actually know my history now.

[Voiceover] For someone that's felt so out of place, it feels good to have a home.

The way things were going I probably would've just left school, this space saved me in a way.

I'm calling on Tucson Unified School District to shut down the ethnic studies program. Raza studies, African American studies, Asian studies, it's about their race, and that is contrary to American ideals.

The program's administered by vehemently anti-American and anti-western civilization zealots.

It's hard to tell if the criticism is based upon full knowledge that they're lying, or they just have been totally misguided in what they've heard.

It's people like you that come over here and ruin everything that we have settled, I'm a Mexican and very very proud of it.

Our students are graduating at a much higher rate, and our kids are going to college at a much higher rate, that is giving our students greater opportunities in life.

The superintendent of schools Ken, himself, declared these courses to be illegal, and so today I'm announcing that decision.

They can't take it away, they can't. (calm acoustic guitar)

Hello? Hello? Hi.

I wanna go to college 'cause I need to set that example for my sisters. But, it's a struggle.

I was the oldest, so I always had to, you know, same way as Crystal, stay home and you know having to take care of the kids at so young age, I mean she actually could do something better. (laughs)

You little liar. She said you buy her all the toys.

I'd rather her get her education and everything and keep on going, but it's been hard, it's been very very hard you know, for us, especially her high school years, trying to get through and everything. (calm acoustic guitar and harmonica)

(dog barking) Just to be together in one room with my whole family, that'd be great. (speaking Spanish)

My dad went to the DMV, and as time went by, we started to get worried, 'cause he was only going to the DMV, and he hadn't called us and he wasn't picking up his cell phone. And then, Bob ended up calling us.

And he told us that our dad got picked up and that he was in a holding cell. He was arrested and now he's in jail because they found out that he was undocumented.

You know it's hard the first time you see him and he's behind the glass, he's wearing the orange jumpsuit and you couldn't even have physical contact. Like it just hurt that you can only talk to him on the phone.

If he doesn't get to come back here legally then he might not come back at all. Other things like Christmas cards or like tickets.

School freshman year wasn't what I wanted, so I stayed home.

My dad was like, "You need to go to school and get your education." I was like, "I don't feel like going to school today."

When you grow up in a poor area, you don't have the same chances as other people do. (hip hop music)

We all grew up in my nana's house, it was my mom, and her other seven siblings and their kids all in a five bedroom house. So it was really crazy.

My dad was never around, 'cause he totally just booked on us. I've pretty much been around everything, drugs, gangs, where I originally grew up that was the people, most of 'em are locked up or dead.

I'm not gonna lie I've hated education. You know sometimes I feel like the education system is just so against me that they don't want me here, that they want me to just drop out. (calm acoustic guitar)

What I noticed, especially in regular history classes, is students really just don't give a shit about what they're studying historically. I mean their relationship with learning is just kind of dysfunctional in general, and it's not of a particular ethnicity.

But they are lazy, they are unengaged, they really are. Learning has just become irrelevant to their lives completely, they're just damaged, they're culturally damaged.

So step one is to identify the problem. Now I think the way that you've cast kids is so funny because if you read the literature historically, it's exactly the way they talked about you when you were a kid.

It's exactly the way they talked about me when I was a kid, right? We were apathetic, we were disengaged, the same narrative about the deficiency of our children has run the history of public schooling in the United States.

Right, and we just change the way we explain our inability to engage kids. There's nothing wrong with kids. I've never met a kid with a dysfunctional relationship to learning, I've met a lot of kids with a dysfunctional relationship to school. (bell rings)

Approximately 50% of Hispanics drop out of school year after year, and the numbers are not improving, they're getting worse.

We continue to perpetuate an educational experience that has been inadequate at best for the majority of Latina children.

Without that diploma, you're walking on this world with limited opportunity, limited chances.

You are the one that's gonna be out there being exploited for eight bucks an hour.

They're using second grade children of color data to determine what number of prisons they're gonna need in the future.

So, the idea that we are still losing these huge number of kids is appalling.

This problem has aggravated over four generations. (slow 50s dance music)

Chicano teachers, counselors, Chicanas in the class room, you didn't see them.

You know some schools couldn't speak Spanish even at lunch or when you're out hanging out on campus.

Later on a civil rights study found out corporal punishment and punishment in general was meted out to minorities at a four to one ratio.

And these kids knew that inside the school.

Many Chicanos and Chicanas were being relegated to vocational classes, secretarial classes, and in fact I had four years of air conditioning at Tucson High, and not enough was done to get us into college.

We knew that we had a school board and a superintendent that basically ignored, and at the best benign neglect to this community and to this population.

And, so it's just a question of time. (60s rock music)

[Voiceover] The practice here has been one of domination. The Anglos dominating the Latins.

But, the Mexican Americans say that day has ended. That they are on the move. That they will have a piece of the action.

[Dr. Romero] It was like a Chicano movement nationwide.

It was kind of a renaissance period for us, there was an urgency for us to make a statement here in Tucson, and the statement was the walkouts.

We don't know how many are gonna come out, or if any.

And then they just kept coming, and they kept coming, and then we had something bigger than we anticipated on our hands.

It was a water shed.

Like any group of young people our expectations were high.

And these next four five years we're gonna fundamentally change the way this world is and how we're treated.

Obviously we're still at that. (calm acoustic guitar)

It was really about how can we turn this around?

How can we really affect change more than just one person at each school?

I believe in my heart that there's an indigenous concept called Chinachle, you plant the seed, and that seed will grow. (calm acoustic guitar)

There's different staffs that come from different weblos and different nations and different communities from the entire continent, entire hemisphere, and this one represents Tucson.

Despite everything that has happened, everything that has changed, everything that has evolved, we continue to hold our ceremonial staffs to try to maintain and preserve our traditional ways of life of the Mexicano.

You hear a lot of talk about La Conquista de Mexico, and guess what it never happened.

Right, this is proof of that.

They try to teach you that our peoples were ignorant, they were illiterate, savages, cannibals, and sacrifice, all this stuff, they teach you to think that we're somehow we don't belong here.

Or that maybe we're part of a new culture, something, that we're brand new, that we just got here.

Well I'm here to tell you that your culture is at least 7,000 years old.

Let's go.

(clapping)

Enlaces!

[Students] Enlaces.

(speaking Spanish)

[All] You are my other me.

(speaking Spanish)

If I do harm to you, I do harm to myself.

(speaking Spanish)

If I love and respect you, I love and respect myself.

There's so many rules at a school.

There's rules of classroom rules, there's code of conduct that is school rules.

There's district rules, so those are my rules, they're not really rules, they're a way of living.

We must vigorously search within ourselves by silencing the distractions and obstacles in our lives, in order to be warriors for our health and injustice.

(speaking Spanish)

Precious and beautiful knowledge.

Gaining perspective on events and experiences our ancestors endured allows us to become more fully realized human beings.

At first I really didn't accept it, I didn't accept, just the posters up on the wall I didn't know what most of them meant.

Now, this is the fourth.

(speaking Spanish)

Or the Nahui Ollin,

the four movements of being a good human being.

It comes from central Mesoamerica.

The Aztecs, the Mayans, the Toltecs, tezcaliepoca is critical reflection.

Any time something happens to you, you have to ask yourself, "How am I at fault?"

Only through reflection and reconciliation, forgiveness, if you hate your dad you are hating yourself.

But by forgiving your father, who else do you forgive?

Yourself. - [Jose] Yourself, and now you become whole.

Now we can create positive change.

What they show us, how they teach us it's really different from regular classes.

Means knowing where you came from who you are inside.

It really got to my emotions too.

From there, you have this precious knowledge, what do you need to do?

Take action.

(speaking Spanish)

Positive action, when someone's being made fun of, don't sit there and be quiet, take positive action.

Raul, that was messed up man, you shouldn't be saying that, I'm not cool with that.

The reflection, reconciliation, stability as a human, action, a new world, a new person.

If you can narrow down what we advocate for, it's the idea of love.

It's not simply a love for myself, the love for those around me.

How can I change the world for the better?

And what this idea of social justice Pedagogia ask us to do is to seek the root of the truth.

And in that truth there is greater justice.

European Americans make up 70% of the US population right?

What percentage do you think they're doing time?

[Voiceover] 30.

30, 31%.

[Voiceover] Wow.

There is a bias in this system, now can we create change with the system?

Yes we can.

What they started teaching us was so interesting I just could not stop thinking about it.

I would go home with articles and I would just read 'em over and over again.

So now that I'm learning more you know it's becoming more important to me.

Now I started getting As and Bs.

They passed a rule.

that raises

"If I run fast enough I can fly."

It's not gonna happen.

There's something in place that's stopping them from achieving their goals, it's not to say that some people won't break past that and somehow do it, but what's the likelihood of that? - Monitor the way you think. When you start looking and blaming the person, that's a naive consciousness. - Everybody take out So Far From God. Because we're gonna read a little bit today. My class is the literature component and it's called Latino Literature. Why do we think this is a church? Why do you think this is a Catholic church, just from the cover?

[Voiceover] Because it looks like a church in Mexico.

A church in Mexico, southwest, even better. This looks like home. Right, this looks like where you from. It's a Chicano novel right?

I just wanna give you a little taste of what you're in. You are in a world called magical realism. Okay, and it is a little bit different than fantasy. 'Cause you know when you go to Lord of the Rings, everything's magical, when you go to the Wizard of Oz, everything's magical, but in here, it's like I got dumped by my novio and now my sister's flying to the top of the roof. Now why does that make sense for our gente? Why did it make sense that Latin America was the place where this happened?

I think it's something really big for me because I had the opportunity with Raza studies to understand my cultura. - [Voiceover] You have a big reading to do.

[Crystal] I was always the quiet girl in the back that like, I don't wanna talk, I don't know what this is about, I'm scared to talk. One of the Mexicans sitting in the back just sitting there. Well he tends to teach us how to express ourselves, so we can have that confidence. - The topics are environment, economic, and dehumanization. Analyze it as a group and see why we put it in that--

Ever since she started these Raza study classes, oh my god it's made such a big change. Her junior year, when she started those classes it just completely changed. - She was not an empowered Chicana of the 21st Century, she walked in here. And she certainly is now. Cool, does that make some sense? What's this? Oh is that for the thing? Oh that's cool.

With the tough kids, the ones with the thicker shells, you honor that they come to your class. And I know a lot of teachers are hesitant to use the word fun, or entertaining, but I'm sorry, I'm gonna use the gifts that I have, and if I can make them laugh I'm gonna make them laugh. Some say the blacker the berry, the sweeter the juice, they say the darker the flesh, the deeper the roots. Juice and roots? Juice and roots are not true, it's not true rhyming. The slant rhyme allows you to have more freedom, because back in the day when hip hop was starting, it was all true rhyme. All right it's like, "We be cool, we go to school, we're gonna go swim in the pool." (beat boxing) You know like Fat Boy 10 taught me that, you like that? Were you supposed to like that? Who liked that, it was pretty cheesy. - [Crystal] I mean really how many teachers do you meet like that? - So then, yeah it's tricky and stuff right? - Just to have him down and dancing in class and throwing jokes and making fun of you. You start getting used to it, you're like, "Okay this is him, this is his personality." You know he does this so he can connect with you on a level that way you guys can just. (laughing) I just feel comfortable here you know it's like a second home I guess you could say. I mean I hate it when I can't be here. (upbeat Hispanic music) - I fell in love with the classes, 'cause we learned so much. - In any other class I mean we're just thinking about, "Oh let's get this work done." - By the book, by the book, by the book, by the book. - But in this class like there's meaning to that work. - Let's get to work, roll up your sleeves, and it's time to work. - They expect more from you, they challenge us more, they challenge me more. - I've never pulled an all nighter for any other class, because now I'm writing about something that I actually care about, I get to choose the subject I wanna write about. - Who should have a say? - [Voiceover] We should! - You should have a say, absolutely. Look, it's say lon, exactly. Exactly. - it's something you do for my hint and my ancestors and me. (upbeat Hispanic music) - Our schools, our community are really part of the school. You choose the latter, our communities need to be part of the school. (upbeat Hispanic music) - I'm calling tonight, we're like a family. And then our students as they come through are very much like a family. So their family, they're obviously your family. - Hey what's up how are you doing? Good good good good I'm glad you made it is everyone else here? - Wanna meet my mom? - Yeah sure, love to meet your mom. - You're his favorite teacher. - Oh is that right? Yeah I appreciate that, I appreciate that. - Nothing but very good things to say about you. - Well thank you, you know what they-- - You know it's non stop. - Is that right? (clapping) - Erin told me, she says, "You know what? "In the previous 11 years of my son's education, "never did he come and come home "and talk to me about what he was learning "in school. I can't get him to shut up about this stuff." (upbeat Hispanic music) - I'm calling on Tucson Unified School District to shut down the ethnic studies program and start teaching kids to treat each other as individuals and not in the basis of what race they were born in. - [Voiceover] So you don't think they're doing anything right then? - I really don't, no I think they should be abolished. (chatter) - [Voiceover] Hi Jose. - Hey Bonnie, how are you doing? - [Voiceover] Good, how you doin'? - I'm good thank you. Hey y'all, let's get the room into. (speaking Spanish) Please. - Shine light on the cockroaches and watch them scatter. (speaking Spanish) Teaching TSD, Tucson students to hate America. What a great use of our tax dollars. This man should be fired, and then tared and feathered, I pay taxes to TSD and I'm outraged. - In the light that we're in, this political light, we are accused, ironically, of being racist. And that's the whole antithesis of what we believe. Do we talk about race in this class? - [Voiceover]

"Pedagogia, we have browsed,

my understanding is that if you go and look at the

citations you see Marx, Lenin,

Mao, Che Guevara, Fidel Castro,

and so our suspicion is inside these classes

these students are being indoctrinated

by people who are in power

to have a certain mindset

of us versus them.

But the essence of that book

is about humanity.

About creating stronger humanity,

greater humanity.

Well that's our suspicion,

we really think we know what's going on

behind those doors, the people in power

are doing something distasteful.

Members, by your vote of four ayes,

three nays, you are not voting, you have given

Senate Bill 1069 a due pass recommendation.

(banging)

My sense of it is that they were bringing

these kids in and saying,

"Okay, founding fathers are racist,

"these social systems are stacked up against you."

You know, look at these statistics,

look at all these odds who are against you,

you can't plan evil ideas in kids' minds

and expect healthy outcomes.

Do I indoctrinate my students?

I can be accused of doing that as can others

but I do not, and I firmly believe that.

Have I ruffled feathers, absolutely.

In this class you are taught to read the word

as well as what?

Read the.

[Voiceover] World.

World, Paulo Freire

wrote about that a lot.

Read the world, read it.

And you're gonna see that it's not a pretty place.

Since 1991, school districts throughout

the United States have been going back to

neighborhood schools, segregated schools,

'cause if you live in a poor side of town,

you're gonna go to that school.

And that school isn't gonna get the funding

due to the property taxes.

If you live on the rich side of town,

you're gonna go to a well-funded school.

What kind of cultural seeds are we planting here?

These systems aren't fair,

that these American systems aren't fair.

And, let me tell ya, I know from personal experience

that there are systems that we have set up

that aren't perfect.

But what we have in the United States

is more opportunity, more prosperity

than you could ever dream of.

Our department is the thorn in people's side

because we say, "You know what,

"the things you're saying about the

"trajectory of this country,

"about where we're at,

"the idea that race is no longer an issue,

"what we're saying is

"What we're saying is BS."

It's about the freedom to ask the questions that are the most pertinent in the way they view the world. That's what we're doing, that's freedom.

Some people are claiming because of Obama being president now that we have reached what Martin Luther King died for and that's the idea that people will be judged by the content of their character and not the color of their skin. Have we reached that?

[Voiceover] No.

Have we?

Yes, we have, right?

Have we?

(high-pitched whining)

[Voiceover] I believe that regardless of political party, mainline Republicans, mainline Democrats, independents, all people would be outraged if they knew what was happening in this TUSD ethnic studies department. The schools are turning these kids into angry young radicals; schools are supposed to be teaching the kids to think for themselves, not to indoctrinate them into left-leaning views of teachers, and I'm speaking out because I think if the people get the facts I think they will be outraged at this.

[Voiceover] They feel that they are so entrenched within TUSD that they are untouchable.

[Voiceover] I mean this is outrageous stuff. I mean we would never support hate groups such as the KKK in our school system. We would never tolerate that kind of garbage.

We wanna talk about the stuff that nobody talks about, they never cover our classes, they don't go inside 'em, they don't investigate and all we get is this John Justice, Tom Horne, you know, media blitz that says we're racist, we're hateful, and all the things we're not. We're getting jacked on the message, the narrative if you will has been hijacked.

Keep saying that this is American culture and ethnic studies is not part of it. I mean that's a radical thing for you to say. Our argument is, no actually we're part of that, and he forced us out. Him and the rest of the senate has forced us out. So we're talking about what message are we putting together, I mean that's the message that we can say, you know, we are being told that we're not part of this culture. And so we're being banished, and we're saying, "No, close back in, include us you know?"

We're supposed to be on the offensive here but not direct, not in people's faces. Because if we get in their faces, Republicans or whoever, our opposition, then they will attack us harder and stronger and rally their base. And we cannot win that fight, that's why we're gonna need to take the high route right now.

Community, service, and advocacy, service, serving each other, being there for one another. (speaks Spanish) All right, and advocacy, that idea (speaking Spanish), the idea of the will to get out there and do things not just complain about 'em, not just vote. Get your puppies on the ground and get your body in some spaces to help people on the daily.

It started getting me into that way of like, I gotta do more community events and see what's really going out there.

[Voiceover] These are the people who were recovered this last year. They're 183. We walk in memory of the deaths that there was in the desert from Mexico and Salvador and Guatemala, from last September, 183 of them did not make it. So we walk in memory of them since it's Dia de las Muertos. Jose Santo Rodriguez Sanchez. Jose Arjell Arfaro Salon. Olivia Noel Armandes. Jesus Enrique Morede Morales.

I can't be another Latina woman just sitting down at home. I want my voice to be heard.

(intense music)

(tense acoustic guitar)

(heavy drums banging)

Running has always been a part of the ceremonial way of life of indigenous people. It requires that physical discipline and allows you to become focused and be connected to the Earth. And this staff here represents Tucson, and it represents each and every one of you. It serves as a vestige to those things that are taking place.

We're running from Tucson to Phoneix to bring our prayer and our message to save the education of future children. The education of our children, our own education.

(drums banging)

It's almost a meditation. You listen and you hear rhythms, you know your heart, you know, the sweat coming down your face, your feet touching the ground. (drums pounding)

When we got to the Athem Reservation, we had to ask their permission if we were allowed to run on their land, and they accepted and they ran with us.

(drums banging)

We want to thank you Creator, for giving us this opportunity to express ourselves. It is important Creator that you have taught us, so that our children will be knowledgeable about all the things that are around them. And it is important that they should learn them in their own culture, in their own ways.

(intense music)

(crowd chanting in Spanish)

I wanna thank everybody that ran. Because it shows that no matter how far this bill goes, we're here together in the Lucha. And it will never end because we will always be united as one. (clapping)

(horn blows)

(cheering)

(high-pitched ringing)

(intense music)

(tense music)

(tense music)

To deem all head law enforcement and forced segregation laws we would have reverted 9 11.

We have seen parts of our neighborhoods nuclear bombed by the affects of illegal immigration.

This is hate speech,

this is anti-American seditious

revolutionary talk in a high school.

(tense music)

(chanting in Spanish)

(cars beeping)

(crowd chanting in Spanish)

U.S.A, U.S.A, U.S.A!

U.S.A!

[Voiceover] Burn baby burn!

[Voiceover] Baby burn.

Make sure you don't end up dead in a desert,

because you are trying to steal

another man's country.

Are you threatening us?

Once we are awakened to our danger,

we are very very skilled at warfare.

You saying you gonna kill us here?

You see the line there?

You stay on the outside of that line,

you get away from my border.

Stay there both of ya, you got it?

You stay outside my border.

You get everything from

physical threats, death threats on the email

on your telephones.

We looked at all the negative comments that

were being posted up at the Arizona Daily Star

and the Tucson Citizen and like

at the radio station, and it was just so much hate

and you had to keep being positive

and it's very tough sometimes because

we try to live life in a positive way,

and why is all this negativity from, you know?

I'll bring this to a personal level.

I can not operate with

any kind of degree of hate or animosity

towards Tom Horne.

Because then I would be exactly what he says we are.

We are not truly about love, we're about

something else.

These classes teach about forgiveness

and understanding but it's so hard

to take it to a personal level.

They talked about my classroom in the National Review

which is a conservative, very reputable

conservative magazine, it was an online edition.

So I'm sure there's people that

don't like us, don't support, critical of us,

all over the country.

There's plenty of things said about me.

Plenty of hurtful things.

Some of you, Antonio,

I have this whole beautiful monologue,

or have the name of whoever you interviewed,

was it your tio?

[Voiceover] Yeah.

Yeah it ain't no name there.

There were days where I'm supposed to come in

and the smiles when it's bright or

you know all those cliches, he's kinda just

in here and let's do what we gotta do guys, you know?

Thesis is what?

The main idea of what?

[Voiceover] The main idea.

Main idea of what?

[Voiceover] Your topic.

Your topic, eh,

main idea of what?

Oh I can see his frustration,

you know, it's affecting my teacher who's

being told by some guy that

you're teaching and you're not teaching this right

it's not important, you shouldn't be teaching it.

If you turn this up with herb spelled U-R-B,

so I know that's not me.

I really feel like I have to catch you up,

if I have you 11th and 12th,

I have to catch you up on those two years

for all the mistakes that were made from K to 10.

So it's a tremendous amount of pressure for me

that I personally put on myself.

(sighs)

What we're gonna be doing today,

is we're gonna be reviewing eighth grade

American government.

Information that you, as an educated citizen,

should know.

What was our first Constitution called?

(chatter)

(clapping)

(speaking in Spanish)

[All] You are my other me.

(speaking in Spanish)

If I do harm to you.

(speaking in Spanish)

I do harm to myself.

(speaking in Spanish)

If I love and respect you.

(speaking in Spanish)

I love and respect myself.

(speaking in Spanish)

Self-reflection smoky mirror.

We must vigorously search within ourselves

by silencing the distractions and obstacles

in our lives in order to be warriors

for our health and injustice.

We're honored that you're here,

and it means a lot to us.

we've rarely had any folks from the legislature

come into our space,

we're very honored that you've taken it

upon yourself to do so.

The fear is that when people look at

the la Raza program, they're very concerned that

you're breaking away from those traditions

that we know resulted in freedom,

that we know resulted in prosperity,

there's a real fear.

When we see books like the Pedagogia

the Oppressed that we're going,

you know that's Marxist, Leninist,

Collectivist, that's part of the fear

that people have about

these kind of studies.

But the Civil Rights Movement was something

that everybody was afraid of right?

Well, some were,

some other people--

Most people were afraid of that.

Yeah, there was,

I think there was concern,

it's legitimate to say there was concern.

A lot.

Yeah.

All right that's it

Yeah.

You know when I was growing up we were

short on food but we never felt that we were

oppressed because when you say the word oppressed

that means somewhere there's an oppressor.

What it's about is the American culture

has an outline for every single one of us.

And that is an oppression, it is an oppression on all of us.

Stereotypes, and people that

you don't see me the way I dress,

the way I look, and I started believing that.

You know I started thinking,

"Oh I'm a Chicana, I ain't gonna

"be able to graduate, I'mma have kids young."

You know, like that,

and then I started coming to these classes

and I started seeing, "Why am I believing all this?"

Instead of believing it, I should change it.

But when I look up at the wall

and I see a poster of Che Guevara,

who many of us think was a thug,

and I don't see anything on Benjamin Franklin,

I have a problem, I have a problem.

[Voiceover] It's the decor of the classroom.

I just want to thank you for coming

to these classes and seeing what they're about.

Well I appreciate your comments to

and for you, it takes a little bit of courage

to speak when there are TV cameras rolling,

and so I want to thank you for talking,

and speaking your mind, that was--

Well thanks for coming, you know,

a lot of people are against and don't really come

and see what they're about, and I think that was cool.

Okay.

That was good.

Thanks.

Well, you have a good day. - [Girl] You too.

I didn't think that my visit there that day

was a typical day,

I think it was more a discussion that took place,

I wasn't seeing anything that represented

a typical day whatsoever.

I thought the teacher himself,

he is, you know I might disagree with him

on the cultural aspect,

but he comes in there, he's perfectly groomed,

he's wearing a long sleeve white shirt,

he's wearing a tie,

so from that standpoint, the way he presented himself,

his obvious passion for educating kids,

he's presenting classic American values.

Now again, that was,

was that on show for me,

that's the question that remains to be answered.

(tense music)

Tom Horne has expressed an interest in the

attorney general's job.

I myself have opened up an exploratory committee

for superintendent of public instruction,

superintendent of public instruction

oversees all the schools in Arizona,

has the number one leadership role for

education policy,

and educational leadership.

Mr. Chairman, members, House Bill 2281

prohibits public schools from offering courses or classes

which promote overthrowing the US government,

or is that meant towards a race or class of people.

Additionally, this allows the superintendent and

public instruction to determine if a public school

is in violation relating to the prohibited courses.

I personally do not feel that students should be

taught victimization.

[Voiceover] Have you been in the classroom

and you witnessed this?

Or is this hearsay?

[Man] Um, I have not been in the class.

[Voiceover] I represent Tucson Unified School District,

you're insinuating that the school's teaching

they overthrow the government and they--

Their moves that I've seen, textbooks that they're using,

overwhelmingly show that that is the case.

[Voiceover] But not witnessed any of it,

based on hearsay--

I think I can perhaps provide some guidance

in this issue, the students asked me to come down

to the classroom, while I was in the classroom

the founder of la Raza started talking about

Benjamin Franklin being a racist.

And I think it's completely inappropriate

to trash our founding fathers,

they put their lives on the line

for our freedom and prosperity.

I vote aye.

[Voiceover] I vote aye.

[Voiceover] And so because of that I vote aye.

[Voiceover] All right four ayes, three nays,

and so not voting returned House Bill 2281

to the full senate because it did pass

recommendation.

(calm acoustic guitar)

[All] Jan Brewer.

(chanting in Spanish)

Jan Brewer.

(chanting in Spanish)

Jan Brewer.

(chanting in Spanish)

Jan Brewer.

(chanting in Spanish)

(cars beeping)

We gotta fight for what we know is right

and right now this is what is beautiful

to all of us.

(cheering)

Standing today with and for our community

in peaceful protest to the most hateful legislative session

in our state's history.

And we stand here today

with the stories in history of our families.

(speaking in Spanish)

Who have walked this continent freely

for thousands of years, have given their strength

of their backs and hands to build this

United States and sacrifice their own blood

in defending this country,

regardless of what anybody else says,

we have taught you law.

And I would like to ask my current and former

students to join me in reciting the part of

Luis Montez's poem, En la Kesh,

that we say each day before our classes begin.

(cheering)

(speaking in Spanish)

[All] You are my other me.

(speaking in Spanish)

If I do harm to you.

(speaking in Spanish)

I do harm to myself.

(speaking in Spanish)

If I love and respect you.

(speaking in Spanish)

I love and respect myself.

[Voiceover] We will win.

(cheering)

(chatter)

(car beeping)

[Voiceover] Hi.

[Voiceover] Mister.

(pictures snapping)

This picture right here says a thousand words,

the class itself is just one piece,

but when you have students demonstrating

wearing brown shirts, bandannas,

and sunglasses.

This is serious, to me this is very serious

we are teaching kids to hate the very country

that they're living in.

Students are being taught a revolutionary curriculum.

You mentioned that the group in the uniform there

and I spoke to one of them last week

and it's a movement scenario,

isn't something like that, if they're saying

it's not militant but more of a matter of

unity together to stay in school

and to succeed, is that a threat?

We're talking about people that are dressed up in

masks over their face, sunglasses over their eyes,

berets, so that you can't see anything on their face,

brown shirts, clearly revolutionary costumes,

and anybody who says that kids can't learn

unless they're subject to that kind of militancy

is clearest example

of racism that I can think of.

[Voiceover] Our education's under attack,

what do we do?

[Voiceover] Fight back!

Stay on the sidewalk,

if you have an empty water bottle we're trying to get

trash bags right now, we don't wanna make a mess right now.

[All] Our people, united,

we'll never be divided.

After a while, just got sick and tired

because we always did protest and rallies

but nothing has happened

like they haven't listened to us,

they haven't done anything.

The bill got passed,

so we decided to go past

what we usually do, you know something new

is always unexpected.

We just got word

that Tom Horne is holding a press conference

in a downtown state building,

so we're thinking about moving this over there.

Everybody down with that?

[All] Yeah!

(shouting and cheering)

[Voiceover] What do we want?

[Voiceover] Justice!

[Voiceover] When do we want it?

[Voiceover] Now!

[Voiceover] What do we want?

[Voiceover] Justice!

[Voiceover] How you doin'?

Hi.

This is a public building.

Yeah, but you can't come in here.

You can't come in here,

you guys can't come in here.

Asking you to not.

(shouting)

[Voiceover] We demand an entry climbing to

anyone in that building.

They immediately repeal,

and people can only remain a pet

for so long before they

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

Education's not a crime!

So we were there to make a stand

that we do not support that bill,

that is a racist bill against some

ethnic studies classes.

[Voiceover] Four underage high school students

and 11 adults arrested in all.

Again 15 people arrested in total,

four juveniles, 11 adults,

they were cited as well and they have a court date

coming up on June 7th.

Meanwhile, they all tell me,

they say it was worth it

to make this strong statement.

We need to be heard,

we have a message, we have a purpose here,

we have an objective and we're gonna do

what we need to do in the struggle

to achieve that goal.

(calm acoustic guitar)

I think your struggle as a human being

to be a good human being

has begun, and I will always hold you to that.

Always, look in the mirror.

Look at your heart.

Know your heart.

Have Quetzalcoatl precious knowledge

of who you are as a human being.

(calm music)

So, today's kinda

hard, but um,

it's a beautiful day too,

'cause I'm so proud of you,

so it's like a lot of emotions.

It's just a ton of pride.

To this day, we have to endure

hateful comments.

I've been attacked and hated, hated,

as well as you.

And you are the ones that made it

all worth it.

Thank you for being

the miestadol in this class and

like mentoring us and just being

that father figure to some of us.

And I do have a father and mother,

I have my parents but they don't understand me

the way you do or any of these people do.

For someone that's felt so out of place,

for the majority of their life, it's

it feels good to

to have a home.

And you guys are the people

who inspire me to try to be better.

Thank you guys for everything.

The struggle hasn't ended,

and it will never end,

but it will continue because of us.

Our generation, when they try to

take these classes away,

it's something impossible.

I want my little sisters to be able to

come to this class and feel like I felt.

They can't take it away, they can't.

(laughing)

(chattering)

(clapping)

(calm music)

[Voiceover] There were profound inequalities in our country

based on race and gender.

These issues still exist today,

although together we've made great strides.

[Voiceover] Pricilla Rodriguez.

Gilbert Esparza.

Crystal Paola Enriques.

(triumphant music)

Congratulations, you have earned admissions

to the University of Arizona for fall 2008

as an undecided major in the University College.

You have been chosen because your academic

and personal achievements qualify you for the U of A's.

You know, when I was little,

college was always something that I wanted to do

but it never really seemed like a possibility.

For my dad, for him to actually know that I'm

in college, I know that he's very proud

and that he feels accomplished inside.

(calm acoustic guitar)

I got a hummingbird representing.

(speaking in Spanish)

The will to act, and it's connected

to a flower where I saw that

more of being the movement

and I'm just the hummingbird slurping

the power of the rose.

So I could have the will to act

in my community, and I just put my last name

on top of it, so.

(calm acoustic guitar)

Think about it, I mean, we're all human,

we all got hearts that beat,

we all got minds that think.

And, people don't treat each other like we're humans

they treat others like they're animals.

Like they shouldn't be a part of this society

but you know we create a society

a Dystopia where we oppress each other.

And we don't really appreciate one another.

But you know we're all human, I mean,

what's the big deal?

Whether it be our color, you know,

I just believe in one race, the human race.

(calm music)

(tense orchestra)

(speaking in Spanish)

[Voiceover] Nourish its beautiful knowledge.

Gain perspective of events and experiences

our ancestors endured,

allows us to become more fluid as human beings.

To assist each other and elders

with humility and honor,

in order to adhere the weaknesses in our hearts.

(speaking in Spanish)

The will to act.

(crowd talking over each other)

With a revolutionary spirit

that is positive, progressive, and creative.

(calm acoustic guitar)

(upbeat Hispanic music)

TIME STAMPS FOR FILM

PlaySeek back 10 secondsSeek forward 10 seconds

1x

Playback Rate

Mute

Current Time 2:03

Remaining Time 1:07:21

 

Picture-in-PictureFullscreen

Precious Knowledge

Transcripts

00:01 

(booming tones)

00:08 

(high-pitched tapping)

00:10 

(quick orchestra)

00:17 

- Most of the books you pick up

00:18 

a history book and you don't really see

00:21 

any other cultures in there, but,

00:23 

you know, mostly Caucasian white people.

00:28 

- Ethnic studies is the knowledge of

00:30 

other than your own ethnicity.

00:31 

- Not only learning about the past of the US

00:34 

but also learning and having the opportunity to

00:37 

learn about our cultura.

00:39 

- My grampa my grandma taught me

00:40 

to be proud that I'm Mexican,

00:41 

and these classes help me because I actually

00:44 

know my history now.

00:46 

- [Voiceover] For someone that's felt so out of place,

00:48 

it feels good to have a home.

00:50 

- The way things were going I probably would've just

00:51 

left school, this space saved me in a way.

00:55 

- I'm calling on Tucson Unified School District to

00:59 

shut down the ethnic studies program.

01:01 

Raza studies, African American studies, Asian studies,

01:04 

it's about their race,

01:05 

and that is contrary to American ideals.

01:08 

- The program's administered by vehemently

01:10 

anti-American and anti-western civilization zealots.

01:14 

- It's hard to to tell if the criticism

01:15 

is based upon full knowledge that they're lying,

01:18 

or they just have been totally misguided in

01:21 

what they've heard.

01:23 

- It's people like you that come over here

01:24 

and ruin everything that we have settled,

01:26 

I'm a Mexican and very very proud of it.

01:29 

- Our students are graduating at a much higher rate,

01:31 

and our kids are going to college

01:32 

at a much higher rate,

01:33 

that is giving our students greater opportunities in life.

01:37 

- The superintendent of schools Ken, himself,

01:39 

declared these courses to be illegal,

01:41 

and so today I'm announcing that decision.

01:44 

- They can't take it away,

01:46 

they can't.

01:49 

(calm acoustic guitar)

02:03 

- Hello?

02:05 

Hello?

02:07 

Hi.

02:08 

- I wanna go to college 'cause I need to

02:10 

set that example for my sisters.

02:12 

But, it's a struggle.

02:20 

- I was the oldest, so I always had to, you know,

02:23 

same way as Crystal, stay home and

02:25 

you know having to take care of the kids

02:27 

at so young age,

02:29 

I mean she actually could do something better.

02:32 

(laughs)

02:45 

- You little liar.

02:47 

She said you buy her all the toys.

02:49 

- I'd rather her get her education and everything

02:52 

and keep on going, but it's been hard,

02:55 

it's been very very hard you know,

02:56 

for us, especially her high school years,

02:58 

trying to get through and everything.

03:01 

(calm acoustic guitar and harmonica)

03:12 

(dog barking)

03:26 

- Just to be together in one room

03:27 

with my whole family,

03:29 

that'd be great.

03:33 

(speaking Spanish)

03:38 

My dad went to the DMV,

03:40 

and as time went by,

03:41 

we started to get worried, 'cause he was only

03:42 

going to the DMV, and he hadn't called us

03:45 

and he wasn't picking up his cell phone.

03:47 

And then, Bob ended up calling us.

03:51 

And he told us that our dad got picked up

03:54 

and that he was in a holding cell.

04:00 

He was arrested and now he's in jail

04:01 

because they found out that he was undocumented.

04:05 

You know it's hard the first time you see him

04:07 

and he's behind the glass, he's wearing the orange

04:09 

jumpsuit and you couldn't even have physical contact.

04:12 

Like it just hurt that you can only talk to him

04:15 

on the phone.

04:18 

If he doesn't get to come back here legally

04:20 

then he might not come back at all.

04:21 

Other things like Christmas cards or like tickets.

04:24 

School freshman year wasn't

04:26 

what I wanted, so I stayed home.

04:31 

My dad was like, "You need to go to school

04:32 

"and get your education."

04:33 

I was like, "I don't feel like going to school today."

04:39 

- When you grow up in a poor area,

04:40 

you don't have the same chances

04:42 

as other people do.

04:43 

(hip hop music)

04:50 

We all grew up in my nana's house,

04:51 

it was my mom, and her other seven siblings

04:55 

and their kids all in a five bedroom house.

05:00 

So it was really crazy.

05:04 

My dad was never around,

05:06 

'cause he totally just booked on us.

05:11 

I've pretty much been around everything,

05:13 

drugs, gangs, where I originally grew up

05:15 

that was the people, most of 'em are locked up or dead.

05:19 

I'm not gonna lie I've hated education.

05:22 

You know sometimes I feel like the education system

05:25 

is just so against me that they don't want me here,

05:28 

that they want me to just drop out.

05:31 

(calm acoustic guitar)

05:41 

- What I noticed, especially in regular history classes,

05:45 

is students really just don't give a shit

05:48 

about what they're studying historically.

05:50 

I mean their relationship with learning is

05:52 

just kind of dysfunctional in general,

05:54 

and it's not of a particular ethnicity.

05:58 

But they are lazy, they are unengaged,

06:01 

they really are.

06:03 

Learning has just become irrelevant to their lives

06:06 

completely, they're just damaged, they're culturally damaged.

06:13 

- So step one is to identify the problem.

06:15 

Now I think the way that you've cast kids

06:19 

is so funny because if you read the literature historically,

06:23 

it's exactly the way they talked about you when you

06:25 

were a kid.

06:26 

It's exactly the way they talked about me

06:28 

when I was a kid, right?

06:30 

We were apathetic, we were disengaged,

06:32 

the same narrative about the deficiency of our children

06:35 

has run the history of public schooling in the United States.

06:40 

Right, and we just change the way we explain

06:42 

our inability to engage kids.

06:45 

There's nothing wrong with kids.

06:48 

I've never met a kid with a dysfunctional relationship

06:50 

to learning, I've met a lot of kids with a dysfunctional

06:53 

relationship to school.

06:54 

(bell rings)

06:59 

- Approximately 50% of Hispanics drop out of school

07:02 

year after year, and the numbers are not improving,

07:04 

they're getting worse.

07:05 

We continue to perpetuate an educational

07:07 

experience that has been inadequate at best

07:11 

for the majority of Latina children.

07:14 

Without that diploma,

07:15 

you're walking on this world

07:17 

with limited opportunity, limited chances.

07:19 

You are the one that's gonna be out there

07:21 

being exploited for eight bucks an hour.

07:24 

They're using second grade children of color data

07:28 

to determine what number of prisons they're gonna

07:30 

need in the future.

07:32 

So, the idea that we are still losing these huge number

07:35 

of kids is appalling.

07:39 

- This problem has aggravated over four generations.

07:43 

(slow 50s dance music)

07:47 

Chicano teachers, counselors, Chicanas in the

07:49 

class room, you didn't see them.

07:52 

You know some schools couldn't speak Spanish

07:54 

even at lunch or when you're out hanging out

07:57 

on campus.

07:58 

Later on a civil rights study found out

08:00 

corporal punishment and punishment in general

08:03 

was meted out to minorities at a four to one ratio.

08:08 

And these kids knew that inside the school.

08:10 

- Many Chicanos and Chicanas were being

08:12 

relegated to vocational classes, secretarial classes,

08:15 

and in fact I had four years of air conditioning

08:18 

at Tucson High, and not enough was done

08:21 

to get us into college.

08:23 

- We knew that we had a school board

08:25 

and a superintendent that basically

08:28 

ignored, and at the best benign neglect

08:31 

to this community and to this population.

08:33 

And, so it's just a question of time.

08:37 

(60s rock music)

08:49 

- [Voiceover] The practice here has been one of domination.

08:52 

The Anglos dominating the Latins.

08:54 

But, the Mexican Americans say that day has ended.

08:58 

That they are on the move.

08:59 

That they will have a piece of the action.

09:02 

- [Dr. Romero] It was like a Chicano movement nationwide.

09:04 

- It was kind of a renaissance period for us,

09:07 

there was an urgency for us

09:08 

to make a statement here in Tucson,

09:10 

and the statement was the walkouts.

09:13 

We don't know how many are gonna come out,

09:14 

or if any.

09:16 

And then they just kept coming,

09:18 

and they kept coming,

09:20 

and then we had something bigger

09:22 

than we anticipated on our hands.

09:24 

It was a water shed.

09:26 

Like any group of young people our

09:27 

expectations were high.

09:30 

And these next four five years we're gonna

09:31 

fundamentally change the way this world is

09:34 

and how we're treated.

09:36 

Obviously we're still at that.

09:38 

(calm acoustic guitar)

09:51 

- It was really about how can we turn this around?

09:55 

How can we really affect change more than just

09:59 

one person at each school?

10:01 

- I believe in my heart that there's an indigenous

10:05 

concept called Chinachle,

10:07 

you plant the seed,

10:09 

and that seed will grow.

10:11 

(calm acoustic guitar)

10:54 

- There's different staffs that come from

10:55 

different weblos and different nations

10:57 

and different communities from the entire

10:59 

continent, entire hemisphere,

11:01 

and this one represents Tucson.

11:04 

Despite everything that has happened,

11:05 

everything that has changed,

11:06 

everything that has evolved,

11:08 

we continue to hold our ceremonial staffs

11:11 

to try to maintain and preserve our traditional

11:14 

ways of life of the Mexicano.

11:18 

You hear a lot of talk about La Conquista de Mexico,

11:21 

and guess what it never happened.

11:23 

Right, this is proof of that.

11:25 

- They try to teach you that our peoples were ignorant,

11:28 

they were illiterate, savages, cannibals,

11:30 

and sacrifice, all this stuff,

11:33 

they teach you to think that we're somehow

11:35 

we don't belong here.

11:37 

Or that maybe we're part of a new culture, something,

11:40 

that we're brand new, that we just got here.

11:42 

Well I'm here to tell you that your culture

11:44 

is at least 7,000 years old.

11:48 

- Let's go.

11:49 

(clapping)

11:55 

Enlaces!

11:56 

- [Students] Enlaces.

11:57 

(speaking Spanish)

11:59 

- [All] You are my other me.

12:01 

(speaking Spanish)

12:03 

If I do harm to you, I do harm to myself.

12:06 

(speaking Spanish)

12:09 

If I love and respect you,

12:10 

I love and respect myself.

12:12 

- There's so many rules at a school.

12:14 

There's rules of classroom rules,

12:16 

there's code of conduct that is school rules.

12:18 

There's district rules,

12:20 

so those are my rules,

12:22 

they're not really rules,

12:24 

they're a way of living.

12:26 

We must vigorously search within ourselves

12:28 

by silencing the distractions and obstacles in our lives,

12:31 

in order to be warriors for our health

12:33 

and injustice.

12:34 

(speaking Spanish)

12:36 

Precious and beautiful knowledge.

12:38 

Gaining perspective on events and experiences

12:40 

our ancestors endured

12:42 

allows us to become more fully realized human beings.

12:45 

- At first I really didn't accept it,

12:47 

I didn't accept, just the posters up on the wall

12:51 

I didn't know what most of them meant.

12:53 

- Now, this is the fourth.

12:55 

(speaking Spanish)

12:56 

Or the Nahui Ollin,

12:58 

the four movements of being a good human being.

12:59 

It comes from central Mesoamerica.

13:03 

The Aztecs, the Mayans, the Toltecs,

13:06 

tezcaliepoca is critical reflection.

13:09 

Any time something happens to you,

13:11 

you have to ask yourself,

13:12 

"How am I at fault?"

13:14 

Only through reflection and reconciliation,

13:17 

forgiveness, if you hate your dad

13:20 

you are hating yourself.

13:23 

But by forgiving your father,

13:26 

who else do you forgive?

13:27 

- Yourself. - [Jose] Yourself,

13:28 

and now you become whole.

13:30 

Now we can create positive change.

13:32 

- What they show us, how they teach us

13:35 

it's really different from regular classes.

13:37 

Means knowing where you came from

13:39 

who you are inside.

13:41 

It really got to my emotions too.

13:43 

- From there, you have this precious knowledge,

13:46 

what do you need to do?

13:49 

Take action.

13:50 

(speaking Spanish)

13:52 

Positive action, when someone's being made fun of,

13:55 

don't sit there and be quiet,

13:56 

take positive action.

13:58 

Raul, that was messed up man,

14:00 

you shouldn't be saying that,

14:01 

I'm not cool with that.

14:02 

The reflection, reconciliation,

14:06 

stability as a human, action,

14:10 

a new world, a new person.

14:12 

- If you can narrow down what we advocate for,

14:15 

it's the idea of love.

14:18 

It's not simply a love for myself,

14:20 

the love for those around me.

14:22 

How can I change the world

14:24 

for the better?

14:26 

And what this idea of social justice Pedagogia

14:29 

ask us to do is to seek the root of the truth.

14:32 

And in that truth there is greater justice.

14:35 

- European Americans make up 70% of the US

14:40 

population right?

14:42 

What percentage do you think they're doing time?

14:46 

- [Voiceover] 30.

14:47 

- 30, 31%.

14:49 

I teach American Government with a social justice perspective.

14:52 

This class is based on critical thinking.

14:55 

Students are often taught to read the word

14:58 

and Paulo Freri said,

15:00 

"You have to teach students to read the world,

15:02 

"and in order to make change you have to

15:04 

"look at the structure, the institution."

15:07 

African Americans make up 12% of the population

15:11 

right, yep, they make up what percent of

15:13 

the jail population?

15:14 

- [Voiceover] 40.

15:15 

- 41%.

15:17 

- [Voiceover] Wow.

15:17 

- There is a bias in this system,

15:21 

now can we create change with the system?

15:24 

Yes we can.

15:25 

- What they started teaching us was so

15:28 

interesting I just could not stop thinking about it.

15:31 

I would go home with articles and I would just read 'em

15:34 

over and over again.

15:36 

So now that I'm learning more you know

15:38 

it's becoming more important to me.

15:40 

Now I started getting As and Bs.

15:42 

- They passed a rule.

15:44 

that raises standards.

15:48 

What did this African American coach do?

15:50 

He walked off the court,

15:51 

no pass, no play.

15:53 

It doesn't only affect minorities,

15:56 

it affects poor white kids.

15:58 

Who can explain how that happens?

16:00 

- The policy's not asking you to have an A,

16:03 

it's just asking you to pass,

16:05 

and everyone should pass their classes.

16:07 

- Hold on.

16:09 

- I think every athlete should be able to push their selves,

16:14 

like if you're white, black, Mexican, anybody,

16:17 

if you're rich or poor.

16:19 

It's not cautious at all.

16:21 

- This is exactly what he said,

16:22 

depends how dedicated you are.

16:24 

- It's not about, I mean you keep saying,

16:26 

"If you're dedicated you can do it,

16:28 

"if you're dedicated you can do it."

16:29 

If it's all on the individual you don't have a

16:31 

four point oh, then are you not dedicated?

16:35 

It's kinda like saying,

16:36 

"If I run fast enough I can fly."

16:38 

It's not gonna happen.

16:39 

There's something in place that's stopping them

16:42 

from achieving their goals,

16:44 

it's not to say that some people won't

16:47 

break past that and somehow do it

16:48 

but what's the likelihood of that?

16:50 

- Monitor the way you think.

16:52 

When you start looking and blaming the person,

16:57 

that's a naive consciousness.

17:00 

- Everybody take out So Far From God.

17:02 

Because we're gonna read a little bit today.

17:04 

My class is the literature component

17:06 

and it's called Latino Literature.

17:09 

Why do we think this is a church?

17:10 

Why do you think this is a Catholic church,

17:12 

just from the cover?

17:13 

- [Voiceover] Because it looks like a church in Mexico.

17:15 

- A church in Mexico, southwest, even better.

17:19 

This looks like home.

17:22 

Right, this looks like where you from.

17:24 

It's a Chicano novel right?

17:27 

I just wanna give you a little taste of what you're in.

17:29 

You are in a world called magical realism.

17:32 

Okay, and it is a little bit different than fantasy.

17:35 

'Cause you know when you go to

17:37 

Lord of the Rings, everything's magical,

17:39 

when you go to the Wizard of Oz,

17:40 

everything's magical, but in here,

17:42 

it's like I got dumped by my novio

17:46 

and now my sister's flying to the top of the roof.

17:49 

Now why does that make sense for our gente?

17:51 

Why did it make sense that Latin America

17:53 

was the place where this happened?

17:54 

- I think it's something really big for me

17:56 

because I had the opportunity

17:58 

with Raza studies to understand my cultura.

18:01 

- [Voiceover] You have a big reading to do.

18:04 

- [Crystal] I was always the quiet girl in the back

18:06 

that like, I don't wanna talk, I don't know what this

18:07 

is about, I'm scared to talk.

18:09 

One of the Mexicans sitting in the back

18:11 

just sitting there.

18:12 

Well he tends to teach us how to express ourselves,

18:16 

so we can have that confidence.

18:19 

- The topics are environment,

18:20 

economic, and dehumanization.

18:22 

Analyze it as a group and see

18:24 

why we put it in that--

18:25 

- Ever since she started these Raza study classes,

18:29 

oh my god it's made such big of a change.

18:32 

Her junior year, when she started those classes

18:35 

it just completely changed.

18:37 

- She was not an empowered Chicana of the

18:39 

21st Century, she walked in here.

18:43 

And she certainly is now.

18:45 

Cool, does that make some sense?

18:47 

What's this?

18:49 

Oh is that for the thing?

18:50 

Oh that's cool.

18:51 

With the tough kids,

18:53 

the ones with the thicker shells,

18:56 

you honor that they come to your class.

19:00 

And I know a lot of teachers are hesitant

19:02 

to use the word fun, or entertaining,

19:05 

but I'm sorry, I'm gonna use the gifts

19:07 

that I have, and if I can make them laugh

19:09 

i'm gonna make them laugh.

19:10 

Some say the blacker the berry,

19:11 

the sweeter the juice,

19:13 

they say the darker the flesh,

19:14 

the deeper the roots.

19:15 

Juice and roots?

19:17 

Juice and roots are not true,

19:19 

it's not true rhyming.

19:21 

The slant rhyme allows you to have more freedom,

19:23 

because back in the day

19:24 

when hip hop was starting,

19:26 

it was all true rhyme.

19:27 

All right it's like,

19:28 

"We be cool, we go to school,

19:31 

"we're gonna go swim in the pool."

19:33 

(beat boxing)

19:35 

You know like Fat Boy 10 taught me that,

19:37 

you like that?

19:39 

Were you supposed to like that?

19:40 

Who liked that, it was pretty cheesy.

19:42 

- [Crystal] I mean really how many teachers do you meet

19:43 

like that?

19:44 

- So then, yeah it's tricky and stuff right?

19:49 

- Just to have him down and dancing in class

19:51 

and throwing jokes and making fun of you.

19:54 

You start getting used to it,

19:55 

you're like, "Okay this is him,

19:57 

"this is his personality."

19:58 

You know he does this so he can connect with you

20:00 

on a level that way you guys can just.

20:02 

(laughing)

20:04 

I just feel comfortable here you know

20:06 

it's like a second home I guess you could say.

20:10 

I mean I hate it when i can't be here.

20:12 

(upbeat Hispanic music)

20:26 

- I fell in love with the classes,

20:28 

'cause we learned so much.

20:29 

- In any other class I mean we're just

20:31 

thinking about, "Oh let's get this work done."

20:33 

- By the book, by the book, by the book,

20:35 

by the book.

20:36 

- But in this class like

20:37 

there's meaning to that work.

20:38 

- Let's get to work,

20:39 

roll up your sleeves, and it's time to work.

20:42 

- They expect more from you,

20:44 

they challenge us more,

20:45 

they challenge me more.

20:47 

- I've never pulled an all nighter

20:48 

for any other class,

20:49 

because now I'm writing about something

20:51 

that I actually care about,

20:52 

I get to choose the subject I wanna write about.

20:54 

- Who should have a say?

20:56 

- [Voiceover] We should!

20:56 

- You should have a say, absolutely.

20:58 

Look, it's say lon, exactly.

21:00 

Exactly.

21:02 

- it's something you do for

21:04 

my hint and my ancestors

21:05 

and me.

21:07 

(upbeat Hispanic music)

21:14 

- Our schools, our community

21:16 

are really part of the school.

21:18 

You choose the latter,

21:19 

our communities need to be

21:22 

part of the school.

21:23 

(upbeat Hispanic music)

21:28 

- I'm calling tonight,

21:29 

we're like a family.

21:30 

And then our students as they come through

21:33 

are very much like a family.

21:34 

So their family, they're obviously your familiy.

21:37 

- Hey what's up how are you doing?

21:39 

Good good good good I'm glad you made it

21:41 

is everyone else here?

21:42 

- Wanna meet my mom?

21:43 

- Yeah sure, love to meet your mom.

21:44 

- You're his favorite teacher.

21:46 

- Oh is that right?

21:47 

Yeah I appreciate that, I appreciate that.

21:48 

- Nothing but very good things to say about you.

21:51 

- Well thank you, you know what they--

21:52 

- You know it's non stop.

21:53 

- Is that right?

21:53 

(clapping)

21:57 

- Erin told me, she says,

21:58 

"You know what?

21:59 

"In the previous 11 years of my son's education,

22:02 

"never did he come and come home

22:05 

"and talk to me about what he was learning

22:07 

"in school.

22:08 

"I can't get him to shut up about this stuff."

22:12 

(upbeat Hispanic music)

22:20 

(singing in Spanish)

22:28 

- [Voiceover] Live, this is News 4 Tucson at 10.

22:33 

- State School Superintendent Tom Horne

22:34 

wants to end ethnic studies programs

22:36 

in the Tucson Unified School District.

22:39 

He's taking his push to state law makers next week,

22:42 

a bill that would ban schools from

22:43 

grouping or teaching students based on their

22:45 

ethnic backgrounds.

22:49 

- When I was in high school in 1963,

22:51 

I participated in the March on Washington

22:54 

where Martin Luther King said

22:55 

he wanted his son to be judged by the quality of his

22:58 

character, and not the color of his skin,

23:00 

and I'm still fighting for that now.

23:02 

Against what I believe to be

23:03 

something that is very wrong, which is dividing students

23:06 

up by ethnicity, and treating them separately by ethnicity.

23:10 

(clapping and cheering)

23:14 

I'm calling on Tucson Unified School District to

23:17 

shut down the ethnic studies program

23:19 

and start teaching kids to treat each other

23:21 

as individuals and not in the basis of what race

23:23 

they were born in.

23:26 

And, excuse me,

23:28 

the chanting behind us, I think illustrates

23:30 

the rudeness that they teach to their kids.

23:34 

With ethnic studies, there's a desire to develop

23:36 

ethnic solidarity, this group,

23:39 

we're the Latinos, that other group,

23:42 

they're the African Americans, that other group

23:44 

they're the Asian Americans, the other group,

23:45 

they're the Anglos and so on.

23:47 

In the human being there is

23:49 

a primitive part that is tribal.

23:54 

And that will say,

23:55 

"I want to be with members of my own tribe.

23:57 

"Members of my own race."

23:58 

And that sort of thing, and the function

24:00 

of civilization and the function of our

24:02 

public school system is to get people

24:03 

to transcend that.

24:04 

And there are better ways to get students

24:06 

to perform academically and to want to

24:08 

go into college, than to try to enthuse them

24:10 

with racial ideas.

24:12 

- [Voiceover] So you don't think they're doing

24:14 

anything right then?

24:15 

- I really don't, no I think they should be abolished.

24:17 

(chatter)

24:22 

- [Voiceover] Hi Jose. - Hey Bonnie,

24:23 

how are you doing? - [Voiceover] Good, how you doin'?

24:23 

- I'm good thank you.

24:27 

Hey y'all, let's get the room into.

24:30 

(speaking Spanish) Please.

24:34 

- Shine light on the cockroaches and watch them scatter.

24:37 

(speaking Spanish)

24:40 

Teaching TSD, Tucson students to hate America.

24:43 

What a great use of our tax dollars.

24:45 

This man should be fired, and then tared and feathered,

24:48 

I pay taxes to TSD and I'm outraged.

24:52 

- In the light that we're in,

24:53 

this political light,

24:55 

we are accused, ironically, of being racist.

24:59 

And that's the whole antithesis of what we believe.

25:02 

Do we talk about race in this class?

25:04 

- [Voiceover] Yes.

25:05 

- Do we talk about class?

25:06 

- [Voiceover] Yes.

25:07 

- Do we talk about sexism?

25:08 

We talk about all systems of oppression,

25:11 

but that doesn't necessarily make us sexist, does it?

25:13 

Or classist, but they like to throw racist at us.

25:17 

- Okay, now listen up,

25:18 

there's two phrases that kinda get people

25:20 

all excited in this town.

25:22 

One's (speaking Spanish).

25:24 

The other one's Raza Studies,

25:25 

so just always carry yourself very respectfully,

25:28 

and don't engage.

25:30 

Okay don't engage with them,

25:31 

if they say anything like,

25:35 

they say ugly things.

25:36 

And they try to incite you

25:38 

to engage with them, just think all right,

25:39 

walk in, get your education on, and walk out proudly.

25:43 

Okay?

25:44 

- Let's get to work,

25:45 

how do we fix societal problems?

25:48 

Now specifically, how do we fix societal problems

25:51 

in our school?

25:53 

From this are gonna come your research projects, right?

25:57 

Finding the causes,

25:58 

and then offering solutions.

26:01 

Let's work.

26:03 

- How can you prove

26:05 

the Latin discrimination situations,

26:07 

which impact foreign individuals.

26:10 

My group is working on language discrimination.

26:13 

- Military recruitment.

26:15 

- Segregation within the school.

26:16 

- How security treats students.

26:17 

- How can THS stop making

26:21 

the student--

26:23 

- [Voiceover] Feel intimidated.

26:25 

- Feel intimidated.

26:27 

- [Voiceover] By police and security on campus?

26:29 

- All right, we need to work on that.

26:30 

- I'm trying to find out what can be changed

26:33 

and what does the average person think?

26:35 

- What do you guys think?

26:36 

Because you guys,

26:37 

you came from Washington--

26:39 

- [Girl] We're somewhere else.

26:41 

- Yeah.

26:41 

- [Voiceover] Kindergarten through third they wouldn't let us

26:43 

speak Spanish.

26:44 

- Another thing that we discovered is that

26:46 

the further west that you are, where there's

26:48 

less tress and less places to sit

26:51 

is where African American, Mexican American,

26:53 

Chicanos that's where they all hang out.

26:55 

They all kinda congregate in their own groups there.

26:57 

- So we kind of resorted back to our old ways,

26:59 

we had the segregation and the race riots

27:02 

and everything, then we had this moment

27:03 

of 70 we had peace,

27:05 

and then we went to 2009 and we're back to

27:06 

segregation again.

27:08 

So one of our main solutions

27:09 

is our Unity Festival, which is kind of

27:11 

just a big party where there's food,

27:14 

there's MCs, there's rappers, there's a whole bunch

27:16 

of stuff going on where everyone's just uniting.

27:19 

♫ Get peanut butter off the dance

27:21 

♫ Like we would not be another time the champ

27:24 

♫ And if you feel like peanut butter off your hands

27:26 

♫ Now put up your hands, now put 'em high

27:28 

♫ Now 26s over my

27:30 

♫ Creak it side to side in front of your ride hey

27:32 

♫ Now what I'm do is they're gonna ride it

27:35 

♫ They're gona ride and ride and ride ♫

27:39 

- My heart, piston pumps

27:41 

at an abnormal beat, beat, beat

27:44 

when I hear her speak.

27:47 

- I'm not a vine with negative intentions,

27:49 

I am the sun creating divine intervention.

27:51 

(rapping in Spanish)

27:59 

(hip hop music)

28:03 

(cheering)

28:10 

- [Voiceover] But leadership of TUSD.

28:12 

- Well what I've been critical of

28:14 

is the ethnic studies program,

28:15 

I think it's immoral, I think it's wrong,

28:17 

it's ethically wrong to divide kids up

28:20 

by their ethnicity, and teach them separately

28:22 

according to their ethnicity.

28:23 

- So you are trying to shut this program down?

28:25 

- [Tom] I am. - For the reasons you just outlined,

28:26 

now proponents of these programs say,

28:28 

this helps to energize kids because they are learning

28:31 

through the eyes of people who they see

28:33 

as themselves.

28:35 

If we as a white man,

28:38 

you perhaps can not understand the experiences

28:40 

that these kids are feeling in their hearts

28:43 

as a Hispanic or an African American.

28:46 

- Well that's the exact opposite of my philosophy.

28:48 

We don't see ourselves through what race

28:50 

we were born into, or what gender we are,

28:52 

we see ourselves as individuals,

28:53 

we're proud Americans.

28:54 

A lot better ways to energize students

28:56 

academically other than dividing them up by race.

29:01 

- Mr. Chairman, members of the committee,

29:02 

Senate bill 1108 has authorized a superintendent

29:05 

of public instruction to withhold public monies

29:07 

and take regulatory action if a public school

29:10 

is found to include curriculum that is in conflict

29:12 

with the values of American citizenship.

29:14 

- There's no reason for

29:16 

people from other countries to have to come here

29:20 

to this country and learn about their own cultures

29:23 

where they came from.

29:24 

- If you want a different culture,

29:26 

then fine, go back to that culture,

29:29 

but this is America.

29:30 

- We find hate and revolution is being taught

29:32 

in their books.

29:33 

- it's a very anti-American, hateful

29:36 

hate speech.

29:37 

- Mexico I believe is orchestrating this

29:39 

and they have an agenda known as

29:41 

lar de Conquista, may we conquest,

29:43 

or aslan.

29:44 

Many of our Chicano elected officials I believe

29:46 

are working directly for Mexico

29:49 

aim to take over.

29:50 

- I am offended by the tone of the rhetoric,

29:52 

and I disagree with the underlying premise

29:54 

of this proposal, I vote no.

29:57 

- I vote no.

29:58 

- I'm gonna vote no.

30:00 

- I do vote yes on this bill.

30:03 

- And so for that reason, I will vote yes.

30:04 

- I vote aye.

30:06 

- So I will just agree, I'm gonna vote aye.

30:07 

- We're at a body vote of nine aye's,

30:09 

six nay to object will pass,

30:11 

senate bill 1108 is amended.

30:13 

(banging)

30:26 

- [Voiceover] We have another bill on the agenda

30:28 

that will be Senate Bill 1069,

30:31 

- Mr. Chairman, what's been done

30:33 

down here in Tucson Unified School District

30:35 

is teaching of hate speech,

30:37 

sedition, anti-American

30:39 

if people wanna pay for that on their own dime

30:41 

in their homes, they can be as anti-American as they want.

30:44 

But they won't use my tax dollars to do it.

30:46 

- To answer your quesiton,

30:47 

it doesn't teach us to be anti-American

30:49 

it teaches us to embrace America,

30:50 

all of its flaws and all.

30:52 

But certain things like racism,

30:54 

and certain things like oppression they do exist.

30:57 

And we go for these classes first off

30:59 

from hearsay, because people that have graduated

31:01 

and gone to these classes have said

31:03 

nothing but positive things.

31:05 

They figure out who they really are as human beings,

31:08 

they figure out how to handle situations

31:09 

to their best abilities.

31:10 

So the word anti-American isn't even relevant

31:13 

in our classes.

31:14 

- [Chairman] Thank you, you're very articulate and eloquent.

31:17 

- Thank you.

31:18 

- Is it true that they

31:19 

of this program has actually invited you to go

31:22 

to the classes and you have not gone yet?

31:25 

- [Tom] They have not invited me.

31:27 

- I just find it very hard to

31:30 

believe you Mr. Horn,

31:32 

because actually I've heard that they did.

31:34 

And we'll have testimony on that.

31:36 

- There was a teacher who invited me actually

31:37 

now that I think about it.

31:38 

Yeah. - [Richard] Yeah.

31:39 

Mr. Chairman, Mr. Horn,

31:40 

you know you're trying to eliminate ethnic studies.

31:44 

Without actually going to the classrooms,

31:46 

I mean I'm just astounded that we would do

31:51 

something like this.

31:52 

- [Chairman] Thank you very much,

31:53 

let's hear from the program itself.

31:56 

Augustine Romero, would you please come forward

31:58 

and tell us a little bit about the program?

32:01 

- In terms of how we interact with students

32:04 

and parents, and community, it's about understanding

32:07 

respect and appreciation.

32:08 

That has led to the place where our students

32:11 

perform academically much better

32:13 

than the students not in our courses.

32:15 

That's something that should be applauded.

32:17 

- Well, the textbook that you use

32:20 

Pedagogia, we have browsed,

32:21 

my understanding is that if you go and look at the

32:23 

citations you see Marx, Lennon,

32:26 

Mao, Che Guivera, Fidel Castro,

32:28 

and so our suspicion is inside these classes

32:32 

these students are being indoctrinated

32:34 

by people who are in power

32:38 

to have a certain mindset

32:40 

of us versus them.

32:41 

- But the essence of that book

32:43 

is about humanity.

32:45 

About creating stronger humanity,

32:48 

greater humanity.

32:49 

- Well that's our suspicion,

32:50 

we really think we know what's going on

32:52 

behind those doors, the people in power

32:54 

are doing something distasteful.

32:58 

- Members, by your vote of four aye's,

33:00 

three nay's, you are not voting, you have given

33:02 

Senate Bill 1069 a due pass recommendation.

33:05 

(banging)

33:14 

- My sense of it is that they were bringing

33:16 

these kids in and saying,

33:18 

"Okay, founding fathers are racist,

33:21 

"these social systems are stacked up against you."

33:24 

You know, look at these statistics,

33:26 

look at all these odds who are against you,

33:28 

you can't plan evil ideas in kids' minds

33:31 

and expect healthy outcomes.

33:34 

- Do I indoctrinate my students?

33:36 

I can be accused of doing that as can others

33:39 

but I do not, and I firmly believe that.

33:42 

Have I ruffled feathers, absolutely.

33:45 

In this class you are taught to read the word

33:47 

as well as what?

33:49 

Read the.

33:50 

- [Voiceover] World.

33:52 

- World, Paulo Freri

33:53 

wrote about that a lot.

33:54 

Read the world, read it.

33:57 

And you're gonna see that it's not a pretty place.

34:01 

Since 1991, school districts throughout

34:04 

the United States have been going back to

34:06 

neighborhood schools, segregated schools,

34:09 

'cause if you live in a poor side of town,

34:13 

you're gonna go to that school.

34:16 

And that school isn't gonna get the funding

34:17 

due to the property taxes.

34:21 

If you live on the rich side of town,

34:22 

you're gonna go to a well-funded school.

34:26 

- What kind of cultural seeds are we planting here?

34:28 

These systems aren't fair,

34:31 

that these American systems aren't fair.

34:33 

And, let me tell ya, I know from personal experience

34:36 

that there are systems that we have set up

34:38 

that aren't perfect.

34:40 

But what have in the United States

34:42 

is more opportunity, more prosperity

34:44 

than you could ever dream of.

34:47 

- Our department is the thorn in people's side

34:49 

because we say, "You know what,

34:50 

"the things you're saying about the

34:53 

"trajectory of this country,

34:54 

"about where we're at,

34:55 

"the idea that race is no longer an issue,

34:58 

"what we're saying is BS."

35:00 

- It's about the freedom to ask

35:02 

the questions that are the most pertinent

35:05 

in the way they view the world.

35:07 

That's what we're doing, that's freedom.

35:09 

- Some people are claiming because of

35:11 

Obama being president now

35:13 

that we have reached what Martin Luther King died for

35:17 

and that's the idea that people will be judged

35:19 

by the content of their character

35:22 

and not the color of their skin.

35:24 

Have we reached that?

35:25 

- [Voiceover] No.

35:26 

- Have we?

35:27 

Yes, we have, right?

35:32 

Have we?

35:34 

(high-pitched whining)

35:39 

- [Voiceover] I believe that regardless of political party

35:42 

mainline republicans, mainline democrats,

35:44 

independents, all people would be outraged

35:48 

if they knew what was happening in this TUSD

35:51 

ethnic studies department.

35:52 

The schools are turning these kids into angry

35:54 

young radicals, schools are supposed to be

35:57 

teaching the kids to think for themselves,

35:59 

not to indoctrinate them into left leaning

36:01 

views of teachers, and I'm speaking out

36:03 

because I think if the people get the facts

36:05 

I think they will be outraged at this.

36:08 

- [Voiceover] They feel that they are so entrenched

36:09 

within TUSD that they are untouchable.

36:14 

- [Voiceover] I mean this is outrageous stuff.

36:16 

I mean we would never support

36:17 

hate groups such as the KKK

36:20 

in our school system.

36:22 

We would never tolerate that kind of garbage.

36:24 

(somber violin)

36:49 

- We wanna talk about the stuff that nobody

36:50 

talks about, they never cover our classes,

36:53 

they don't go inside 'em, they don't investigate

36:55 

and all we get is this John Justice,

36:58 

Tom Horne, you know,

37:00 

media blitz that says we're racist,

37:03 

we're hateful, and all the things we're not.

37:05 

We're getting jacked on the message,

37:07 

the narrative if you will has been hijacked.

37:10 

- Keep saying that this is American culture

37:13 

and ethnic studies is not part of it.

37:15 

I mean that's a radical thing for you to say.

37:18 

Our argument is, no actually

37:21 

we're part of that, and he forced us out.

37:24 

Him and the rest of the senate has forced us out.

37:26 

So we're talking about what message are we

37:27 

putting together, I mean that's the message that

37:30 

we can say, you know, we are being told

37:32 

that we're not part of this culture.

37:34 

And so we're being banished,

37:36 

and we're saying, "No, close back in,

37:38 

"include us you know?"

37:39 

- We're supposed to be on the offensive here

37:41 

but not direct, not in people's faces.

37:43 

Because if we get in their faces,

37:45 

republicans or whoever, our opposition,

37:47 

then they will attack us harder

37:50 

and stronger and rally their base.

37:52 

And we can not win that fight,

37:54 

that's why we're gonna need to take

37:55 

the high route right now.

37:56 

- Community, service, and advocacy,

37:59 

service, serving each other,

38:01 

being there for one another.

38:02 

(speaks Spanish)

38:03 

All right, and advocacy,

38:06 

that idea (speaking Spanish),

38:08 

the idea of the will to get out there and do things

38:10 

not just complain about 'em, not just vote.

38:12 

Get your puppies on the ground

38:13 

and get your body in some spaces to help

38:16 

people on the daily.

38:19 

(drums banging)

38:21 

- It started getting me into that way of like,

38:23 

I gotta do more community events

38:24 

and see what's really going out there.

38:26 

- [Voiceover] These are the people who were recovered

38:28 

this last year.

38:30 

They're 183.

38:31 

- We walk in memory of the deaths

38:34 

that there was in the desert from Mexico

38:36 

and Salvador and Guatemala,

38:38 

from last September, 183 of them did not make it.

38:42 

So we walk in memory of them

38:43 

since it's Dia de las Muertos.

38:45 

Jose Santo Rodriguez Sanchez.

38:48 

Jose Arjell Arfaro Salon.

38:51 

Olivia Noel Armandes.

38:54 

Jesus Enrique Morede Morales.

38:57 

(drums banging)

39:02 

I can't be another Latina woman

39:03 

just sitting down at home.

39:05 

I want my voice to be heard.

39:07 

(intense music)

39:15 

(tense acoustic guitar)

39:23 

(heavy drums banging)

39:29 

- Running has always been

39:30 

a part of the ceremonial way of life

39:33 

of indigenous people.

39:34 

It requires that physical discipline

39:36 

and allows you to become focused

39:38 

and be connected to the Earth.

39:40 

And this staff here represents Tucson,

39:43 

and it represents each and every one of you.

39:45 

It serves as a vestige to those things

39:47 

that are taking place.

39:48 

(drums banging)

39:51 

- We're running from Tucson to Phoneix to

39:53 

bring our prayer and our message

39:55 

to save the education of future children.

39:57 

The education of our children,

39:59 

our own education.

40:01 

(drums banging)

40:08 

- It's almost a meditation.

40:10 

You listen and you hear rhythms,

40:13 

you know your heart, you know,

40:15 

the sweat coming down your face,

40:17 

your feet touching the ground.

40:19 

(drums pounding)

40:25 

- When we got to the Athem Reservation,

40:28 

we had to ask their permission

40:30 

if we were allowed to run on their land,

40:32 

and they accepted and they ran with us.

40:34 

(drums banging)

40:39 

- We want to thank you Creator,

40:40 

for giving us this opportunity to express ourselves.

40:47 

It is important Creator

40:48 

that you have taught us,

40:50 

so that our children will be knowledgeable

40:55 

about all the things that are around them.

40:58 

And it is important that they should learn them

41:00 

in their own culture, in their own ways.

41:03 

(intense music)

41:23 

(crowd chanting in Spanish)

41:39 

- I wanna thank everybody that ran.

41:41 

Because it shows that no matter how far

41:44 

this bill goes, we're here together in the Lucha.

41:47 

And it will never end because we will

41:49 

always be united as one.

41:51 

(clapping)

41:54 

(horn blows)

41:58 

(cheering)

42:02 

(high-pitched ringing)

42:06 

(intense music)

42:26 

(tense music)

42:34 

- To deem all head law enforcement and forced

42:35 

segregation laws we would have reverted 9 11.

42:38 

- We have seen parts of our neighborhoods

42:41 

nuclear bombed by the affects of illegal immigration.

42:43 

(tense music)

42:52 

- This is hate speech,

42:54 

this is anti-American seditious

42:55 

revolutionary talk in a high school.

42:59 

(tense music)

43:04 

(chanting in Spanish)

43:15 

(cars beeping)

43:20 

(crowd chanting in Spanish)

43:30 

- U.S.A, U.S.A, U.S.A!

43:34 

U.S.A!

43:38 

- [Voiceover] Burn baby burn!

43:40 

- [Voiceover] Baby burn.

43:42 

- Make sure you don't end up dead in a desert,

43:45 

because you are trying to steal

43:48 

another man's country.

43:50 

- Are you threatening us?

43:51 

- Once we are awakened to our danger,

43:53 

we are very very skilled at warfare.

43:55 

- You saying you gonna kill us here?

43:56 

- You see the line there?

43:58 

You stay on the outside of that line,

43:59 

you get away from my border.

44:01 

Stay there both of ya, you got it?

44:03 

You stay outside my border.

44:08 

- You get everything from

44:10 

physical threats, death threats on the email

44:14 

on your telephones.

44:15 

- We looked at all the negative comments that

44:17 

were being posted up at the Arizona Daily Star

44:22 

and the Tucson Citizen and like

44:24 

at the radio station, and it was just so much hate

44:27 

and you had to keep being positive

44:30 

and it's very tough sometimes because

44:33 

we try to live life in a positive way,

44:37 

and why is all this negativity from, you know?

44:40 

- I'll bring this to a personal level.

44:42 

I can not operate with

44:47 

any kind of degree of hate or animosity

44:50 

towards Tom Horne.

44:51 

Because then I would be exactly what he says we are.

44:55 

We are not truly about love, we're about

44:58 

something else.

44:59 

- These classes teach about forgiveness

45:00 

and understanding but it's so hard

45:02 

to take it to a personal level.

45:04 

- They talked about my classroom in the National Review

45:07 

which is a conservative, very reputable

45:09 

conservative magazine, it was an online edition.

45:12 

So I'm sure there's people that

45:14 

don't like us, don't support, critical of us,

45:18 

all over the country.

45:19 

There's plenty of things said about me.

45:21 

Plenty of hurtful things.

45:25 

Some of you, Antonio,

45:27 

I have this whole beautiful monologue,

45:28 

or have the name of whoever you interviewed,

45:30 

was it your tio?

45:32 

- [Voiceover] Yeah.

45:32 

- Yeah it ain't no name there.

45:34 

- There were days where I'm supposed to come in

45:35 

and the smiles when it's bright or

45:37 

you know all those cliches, he's kinda just

45:40 

in here and let's do what we gotta do guys, you know?

45:43 

- Thesis is what?

45:45 

The main idea of what?

45:47 

- [Voiceover] The main idea.

45:48 

- Main idea of what?

45:49 

- [Voiceover] Your topic.

45:50 

- Your topic, eh,

45:51 

main idea of what?

45:52 

- Oh I can see his frustration,

45:54 

you know, it's affecting my teacher who's

45:57 

being told by some guy that

46:01 

you're teaching and you're not teaching this right

46:04 

it's not important, you shouldn't be teaching it.

46:06 

- If you turn this up with herb spelled U-R-B,

46:10 

so I know that's not me.

46:12 

I really feel like I have to catch you up,

46:15 

if I have you 11th and 12th,

46:17 

I have to catch you up on those two years

46:19 

for all the mistakes that were made from K to 10.

46:21 

So it's a tremendous amount of pressure for me

46:24 

that I personally put on myself.

46:26 

(sighs)

46:28 

- What we're gonna be doing today,

46:31 

is we're gonna be reviewing eighth grade

46:33 

American government.

46:35 

Information that you, as an educated citizen,

46:39 

should know.

46:41 

What was our first Constitution call?

46:43 

(chatter)

46:49 

(clapping)

46:55 

(speaking in Spanish)

46:58 

- [All] You are my other me.

46:59 

(speaking in Spanish)

47:01 

If I do harm to you.

47:03 

(speaking in Spanish)

47:05 

I do harm to myself.

47:06 

(speaking in Spanish)

47:08 

If I love and respect you.

47:10 

(speaking in Spanish)

47:12 

I love and respect myself.

47:14 

(speaking in Spanish)

47:15 

Self reflection smoky mirror.

47:17 

We must vigorously search within ourselves

47:20 

by silencing the distractions and obstacles

47:22 

in our lives in order to be warriors

47:24 

for our health and injustice.

47:26 

- We're honored that you're here,

47:27 

and it means a lot to us.

47:30 

we've rarely had any folks from the legislature

47:35 

come into our space,

47:37 

we're very honored that you've taken it

47:40 

upon yourself to do so.

47:42 

- The fear is that when people look at

47:45 

the la Raza program, they're very concerned that

47:49 

you're breaking away from those traditions

47:53 

that we know resulted in freedom,

47:54 

that we know resulted in prosperity,

47:56 

there's a real fear.

47:58 

When we see books like the Pedagogia

48:00 

the Oppressed that we're going,

48:01 

you know that's Marxist, Lennonist,

48:03 

Collectivist, that's part of the fear

48:05 

that people have about

48:07 

these kind of studies.

48:10 

- But the Civil Rights Movement was something

48:13 

that everybody was afraid of right?

48:17 

- Well, some were,

48:18 

some other people--

48:20 

- Most people were afraid of that.

48:22 

- Yeah, there was,

48:23 

I think there was concern,

48:25 

it's legitimate to say there was concern.

48:26 

- A lot.

48:27 

- Yeah.

48:28 

- All right that's it

48:30 

- Yeah.

48:31 

You know when I was growing up we were

48:33 

short on food but we never felt that we were

48:37 

oppressed because when you say the word oppressed

48:39 

that means somewhere there's an oppressor.

48:42 

- What it's about is the American culture

48:44 

has an outline for every single one of us.

48:48 

And that is an oppression, it is an oppression on all of us.

48:52 

- Stereotypes, and people that

48:54 

you don't see me the way I dress,

48:56 

the way I look, and I started believing that.

48:59 

You know I started thinking,

49:00 

"Oh I'm a Chicana, I ain't gonna

49:01 

"be able to graduate, I'mma have kids young."

49:03 

You know, like that,

49:05 

and then I started coming to these classes

49:08 

and I started seeing, "Why am I believing all this?"

49:10 

Instead of believing it, i should change it.

49:12 

- But when I look up at the wall

49:14 

and I see a poster of Che Guivera,

49:16 

who many of us think was a thug,

49:18 

and I don't see anything on Benjamin Franklin,

49:22 

I have a problem, I have a problem.

49:24 

- [Voiceover] It's the decor of the classroom.

49:26 

- Well, it's--

49:49 

- I just want to thank you for coming

49:51 

to these classes and seeing what they're about.

49:53 

- Well I appreciate your comments to

49:54 

and for you it takes a little bit of courage

49:56 

to speak when there are TV cameras rolling,

49:58 

and so I want to thank you for talking,

50:00 

and speaking your mind, that was--

50:03 

- Well thanks for coming, you know,

50:05 

a lot of people are against and don't really come

50:06 

and see what they're about, and I think that was cool.

50:09 

- Okay.

50:10 

- That was good.

50:11 

Thanks.

50:12 

- Well you have a good day. - [Girl] You too.

50:13 

- I didn't think that my visit there that day

50:16 

was a typical day,

50:18 

I think it was more a discussion that took place,

50:21 

I wasn't seeing anything that represented

50:23 

a typical day whatsoever.

50:25 

I thought the teacher himself,

50:27 

he is, you know I might disagree with him

50:31 

on the cultural aspect,

50:34 

but he comes in there, he's perfectly groomed,

50:36 

he's wearing a long sleeve white shirt,

50:38 

he's wearing a tie,

50:39 

so from that standpoint, the way he presented himself,

50:42 

his obvious passion for educating kids,

50:45 

he's presenting classic American values.

50:48 

Now again, that was,

50:52 

was that on show for me,

50:55 

that's the question that remains to be answered.

50:58 

(tense music)

51:04 

Tom Horne has expressed an interest in the

51:05 

attorney general's job.

51:07 

I myself have opened up an exploratory committee

51:10 

for superintendent of public instruction,

51:11 

superintendent of public instruction

51:14 

oversees all the schools in Arizona,

51:17 

has the number one leadership role for

51:21 

education policy,

51:23 

and educational leadership.

51:27 

- Mr. Chairman, members, House Bill 2281

51:29 

prohibits public schools from offering courses or classes

51:32 

which promote overthrowing the US government,

51:35 

or is that meant towards a race or class of people.

51:38 

Additionally this allows the superintendent and

51:40 

public instruction to determine if a public school

51:42 

is in violation relating to the prohibited courses.

51:45 

- I personally do not feel that students should be

51:49 

taught victimization.

51:51 

- [Voiceover] Have you been in the classroom

51:53 

and you witnessed this?

51:53 

Or is this hearsay?

51:54 

- [Man] Um, I have not been in the class.

51:58 

- [Voiceover] I represent Tucson Unified School District,

52:00 

you're insinuating that the school's teaching

52:03 

they overthrow the government and they--

52:04 

- Their moves that I've seen, textbooks that they're using,

52:07 

overwhelmingly show that that is the case.

52:09 

- [Voiceover] But not witnessed any of it,

52:11 

based on hearsay--

52:12 

- I think I can perhaps provide some guidance

52:14 

in this issue, the students asked me to come down

52:17 

to the classroom, while I was in the classroom

52:20 

the founder of la Raza started talking about

52:23 

Benjamin Franklin being a racist.

52:25 

And I think it's completely inappropriate

52:29 

to trash our founding fathers,

52:32 

they put their lives on the line

52:33 

for our freedom and prosperity.

52:35 

I vote aye.

52:36 

- [Voiceover] I vote aye.

52:37 

- [Voiceover] And so because of that I vote aye.

52:38 

- [Voiceover] All right four aye's, three nay's,

52:40 

and so not voting returned House Bill 2281

52:43 

to the full senate because it did pass

52:44 

recommendation.

52:46 

(calm acoustic guitar)

52:52 

- [All] Jan Brewer.

52:53 

(chanting in Spanish)

52:55 

Jan Brewer.

52:56 

(chanting in Spanish)

52:59 

Jan Brewer.

53:00 

(chanting in Spanish)

53:03 

Jan Brewer.

53:05 

(chanting in Spanish)

53:07 

(cars beeping)

53:12 

- We gotta fight for what we know is right

53:14 

and right now this is what is beautiful

53:16 

to all of us.

53:17 

(cheering)

53:19 

- Standing today with and for our community

53:21 

in peaceful protest to the most hateful legislative session

53:24 

in our state's history.

53:26 

And we stand here today

53:28 

with the stories in history of our families.

53:32 

(speaking in Spanish)

53:35 

Who have walked this continent freely

53:37 

for thousands of years, have given their strength

53:40 

of their backs and hands to build this

53:42 

United States and sacrifice their own blood

53:44 

in defending this country,

53:46 

regardless of what anybody else says,

53:49 

we have taught you law.

53:50 

And I would like to ask my current and former

53:53 

students to join me in reciting the part of

53:55 

Luis Montez's poem, En la Kesh,

53:58 

that we say each day before our classes begin.

54:01 

(cheering)

54:03 

(speaking in Spanish)

54:06 

- [All] You are my other me.

54:07 

(speaking in Spanish)

54:09 

If I do harm to you.

54:11 

(speaking in Spanish)

54:13 

I do harm to myself.

54:15 

(speaking in Spanish)

54:17 

If I love and respect you.

54:19 

(speaking in Spanish)

54:20 

I love and respect myself.

54:23 

- [Voiceover] We will win.

54:24 

(cheering)

54:27 

(chatter)

54:32 

(car beeping)

54:35 

- [Voiceover] Hi.

54:37 

- [Voiceover] Mister.

54:38 

(pictures snapping)

54:50 

- This picture right here says a thousand words,

54:52 

the class itself is just one piece,

54:55 

but when you have students demonstrating

54:57 

wearing brown shirts, bandannas,

54:58 

and sunglasses.

55:02 

This is serious, to me this is very serious

55:04 

we are teaching kids to hate the very country

55:08 

that they're living in.

55:09 

- Students are being taught a revolutionary curriculum.

55:11 

- You mentioned that the group in the uniform there

55:14 

and I spoke to one of them last week

55:16 

and it's a movement scenario,

55:18 

isn't something like that, if they're saying

55:20 

it's not militant but more of a matter of

55:22 

unity together to stay in school

55:25 

and to succeed, is that a threat?

55:28 

- We're talking about people that are dressed up in

55:31 

masks over their face, sunglasses over their eyes,

55:35 

berets, so that you can't see anything on their face,

55:38 

brown shirts, clearly revolutionary costumes,

55:42 

and anybody who says that kids can't learn

55:46 

unless they're subject to that kind of militancy

55:48 

is clearest example

55:52 

of racism that I can think of.

55:53 

- [Voiceover] Our education's under attack,

55:56 

what do we do?

55:57 

- [Voiceover] Fight back!

55:58 

- Stay on the sidewalk,

55:59 

if you have an empty water bottle we're trying to get

56:01 

trash bags right now, we don't wanna make a mess right now.

56:03 

- [All] Our people, united,

56:05 

we'll never be divided.

56:07 

Our people, united,

56:08 

well never be divided.

56:10 

- After a while, just got sick and tired

56:12 

because we always did protest and rallies

56:15 

but nothing has happened

56:16 

like they haven't listened to us,

56:18 

they haven't done anything.

56:19 

The bill got passed,

56:21 

so we decided to go past

56:23 

what we usually do, you know something new

56:25 

is always unexpected.

56:27 

- We just got word

56:28 

that Tom Horne is holding a press conference

56:30 

in a downtown state building,

56:32 

so we're thinking about moving this over there.

56:35 

Everybody down with that?

56:36 

- [All] Yeah!

56:38 

(shouting and cheering)

56:42 

- [Voiceover] What do we want?

56:43 

- [Voiceover] Justice!

56:43 

- [Voiceover] When do we want it?

56:44 

- [Voiceover] Now!

56:45 

- [Voiceover] What do we want?

56:46 

- [Voiceover] Justice!

56:48 

- [Voiceover] How you doin'?

56:49 

- Hi.

56:50 

This is a public building.

56:51 

- Yeah but you can't come in here.

56:53 

You can't come in here,

56:54 

you guys can't come in here.

56:55 

- Asking you to not.

56:56 

(shouting)

57:01 

- [Voiceover] We demand an entry climbing to

57:03 

anyone in that building.

57:05 

They immediately repeal,

57:07 

and people can only remain a pet

57:10 

for so long before they rise from the shadows.

57:12 

If these demands are not met,

57:14 

organized direct action and community organizing

57:17 

will continue!

57:19 

- [All] When education's under attack, what do we do?

57:22 

Fight back!

57:23 

- When education's under attack, what do we do?

57:25 

Fight back!

57:26 

When education's under attack, what do we do?

57:29 

Fight back!

57:30 

- This is not a way that Hispanic parents

57:33 

want their children to act in a militant way

57:36 

to get ahead in this country.

57:37 

And to be angry, and to feel oppressed,

57:40 

and to think that this country is looking at ways

57:43 

to make them feel downtrodden,

57:45 

but to lift them up, and to make them feel

57:48 

empowered.

57:50 

(radio chatter)

57:53 

- I have three younger sisters.

57:55 

I want them to have these classes.

57:56 

We've been at the 10 10,

57:58 

we've been running to Phoenix, we've been protesting,

58:00 

walking, and it's something that

58:03 

Arizona's becoming just a racist state period.

58:08 

- I take it as a no?

58:09 

You don't wanna leave?

58:10 

- [Voiceover] Who's state?

58:12 

- [Students] Our state!

58:13 

- [Voiceover] Who's state?

58:14 

- [Students] Our state!

58:15 

- [Voiceover] Who's state?

58:16 

- [Students] Our state!

58:17 

- [Pricilla] Who's classes?

58:18 

- [Students] Our classes!

58:19 

- Who's classes?

58:20 

- [Students] Our classes!

58:21 

- Who's classes?

58:22 

- [Students] Our classes!

58:23 

- When have you actually been in one of these classes?

58:26 

- It's my view that if I were to

58:28 

come into the class, that it would affect

58:31 

what was taught there,

58:32 

and I would not get a true picture.

58:34 

And then if I was asked what went on

58:36 

in the class I'd have to say,

58:37 

"Well it was just this benign class."

58:38 

- You would get a dog and pony show,

58:40 

I would not get what you would see every day

58:42 

I'd have to do a drop in unannounced,

58:44 

and then still they could change

58:46 

their go do that quickly,

58:48 

and I think this picture depicts

58:50 

what these kids are learning.

58:51 

- [Tom] Thank you all for coming.

58:55 

- I have a state police representative here.

58:57 

(mumbling)

58:59 

Okay?

59:00 

- [Voiceover] This isn't about police.

59:01 

- I understand, your issue's with Tom Horne,

59:03 

he's gone, he left.

59:04 

- You said you wanted to speak to 'em.

59:05 

Where is the justice?

59:07 

- [Police] What purpose is there of here sitting here?

59:09 

Just sitting here?

59:10 

- In this state of Arizona sir,

59:12 

we have been trying to be reasonable

59:14 

with Tom Horne, we've asked

59:16 

for him to come into our classes and talk to us,

59:19 

and he was in this office invited,

59:21 

and still would not speak to the students

59:25 

so we have no other option here.

59:28 

- [Voiceover] Education's not a crime!

59:30 

Education's not a crime!

59:32 

Education's not a crime!

59:33 

Education's not a crime!

59:35 

Education's not a crime!

59:37 

Education's not a crime!

59:39 

Education's not a crime!

59:41 

Education's not a crime!

59:42 

Education's not a crime!

59:44 

Education's not a crime!

59:46 

Education's not a crime!

59:47 

Education's not a crime!

59:49 

Education's not a crime!

59:51 

Education's not a crime!

59:52 

- So we were there to make a stand

59:54 

that we do not support that bill,

59:56 

that is a racist bill against some

59:58 

ethnic studies classes.

59:59 

- [Voiceover] Four underage high school students

01:00:01 

and 11 adults arrested in all.

01:00:03 

- Again 15 people arrested in total,

01:00:05 

four juveniles, 11 adults,

01:00:07 

they were cited as well and they have a court date

01:00:10 

coming up on June 7th.

01:00:12 

Meanwhile they all tell me,

01:00:14 

they say it was worth it

01:00:15 

to make this strong statement.

01:00:17 

- We need to be heard,

01:00:18 

we have a message, we have a purpose here,

01:00:21 

we have an objective and we're gonna do

01:00:22 

what we need to do in the struggle

01:00:24 

to achieve that goal.

01:00:25 

(calm acoustic guitar)

01:00:39 

- I think your struggle as a human being

01:00:42 

to be a good human being

01:00:44 

has begun, and I will always hold you to that.

01:00:47 

Always, look in the mirror.

01:00:51 

Look at your heart.

01:00:53 

Know your heart.

01:00:55 

Have Quetzalcoatl precious knowledge

01:00:58 

of who you are as a human being.

01:01:01 

(calm music)

01:01:05 

- So, today's kinda

01:01:07 

hard, but um,

01:01:09 

it's a beautiful day too,

01:01:12 

'cause I'm so proud of you,

01:01:14 

so it's like a lot of emotions.

01:01:16 

It's just a ton of pride.

01:01:21 

To this day, we have to endure

01:01:23 

hateful comments.

01:01:24 

I've been attacked and hated, hated,

01:01:27 

as well as you.

01:01:31 

And you are the ones that made it

01:01:33 

all worth it.

01:01:35 

- Thank you for being

01:01:37 

the miestadol in this class and

01:01:40 

like mentoring us and just being

01:01:44 

that father figure to some of us.

01:01:47 

And I do have a father and mother,

01:01:50 

I have my parents but they don't understand me

01:01:53 

the way you do or any of these people do.

01:01:58 

- For someone that's felt so out of place,

01:02:00 

for the majority of their life it's

01:02:03 

it feels good to

01:02:06 

to have a home.

01:02:08 

And you guys are the people

01:02:10 

who inspire me to try to be better.

01:02:14 

Thank you guys for everything.

01:02:17 

- The struggle hasn't ended,

01:02:19 

and it will never end,

01:02:21 

but it will continue because of us.

01:02:23 

Our generation, when they try to

01:02:25 

take these classes away,

01:02:27 

it's something impossible.

01:02:30 

I want my little sisters to be able to

01:02:32 

come to this class and feel like I felt.

01:02:35 

They can't take it away, they can't.

01:02:43 

(laughing)

01:02:47 

(chattering)

01:02:56 

(clapping)

01:03:00 

(calm music)

01:03:05 

- [Voiceover] There were profound inequalities in our country

01:03:08 

based on race and gender.

01:03:10 

These issues still exist today,

01:03:13 

although together we've made great strides.

01:03:19 

- [Voiceover] Pricilla Rodriguez.

01:03:24 

Gilbert Esparza.

01:03:30 

Crystal Paola Enriques.

01:03:34 

(triumphant music)

01:04:11 

- Congratulations, you have earned admissions

01:04:13 

to the University of Arizona for fall 2008

01:04:15 

as an undecided major in the University College.

01:04:19 

You have been chosen because your academic

01:04:21 

and personal achievements qualify you for the U of A's.

01:04:24 

You know, when I was little,

01:04:26 

college was always something that I wanted to do

01:04:29 

but it never really seemed like a possibility.

01:04:33 

For my dad, for him to actually know that I'm

01:04:35 

in college, I know that he's very proud

01:04:38 

and that he feels accomplished inside.

01:04:43 

(calm acoustic guitar)

01:04:47 

- I got a hummingbird representing.

01:04:49 

(speaking in Spanish)

01:04:50 

The will to act, and it's connected

01:04:52 

to a flower where I saw that

01:04:55 

more of being the movement

01:04:57 

and I'm just the hummingbird slurping

01:05:00 

the power of the rose.

01:05:02 

So I could have the will to act

01:05:05 

in my community, and I just put my last name

01:05:08 

on top of it, so.

01:05:10 

(calm acoustic guitar)

01:05:14 

- Think about it, I mean we're all human,

01:05:16 

we all got hearts that beat,

01:05:18 

we all got minds that think.

01:05:20 

And, people don't treat each other like we're humans

01:05:24 

they treat others like they're animals.

01:05:27 

Like they shouldn't be a part of this society

01:05:29 

but you know we create a society

01:05:32 

a Dystopia where we oppress each other.

01:05:35 

And we don't really appreciate one another.

01:05:38 

But you know we're all human I mean

01:05:39 

what's the big deal?

01:05:41 

Whether it be our color, you know,

01:05:43 

I just believe in one race, the human race.

01:05:46 

(calm music)

01:05:52 

(tense orchestra)

01:06:44 

(speaking in Spanish)

01:06:49 

- [Voiceover] Nourish its beautiful knowledge.

01:06:52 

Gain perspective of events and experiences

01:06:54 

our ancestors endured,

01:06:56 

allows us to become more fluid as human beings.

01:06:59 

To assist each other and elders

01:07:02 

with humility and honor,

01:07:03 

in order to adhere the weaknesses in our hearts.

01:07:06 

(speaking in Spanish)

01:07:08 

The will to act.

01:07:09 

(crowd talking over each other)

01:07:13 

With a revolutionary spirit

01:07:14 

that is positive, progressive, and creative.

01:07:16 

(calm acoustic guitar)

01:07:45 

(upbeat Hispanic music)