PPT ON identify an organizational challenge facing your own public agency ( 10 SLIDES )
*
Chapter 8
Motivation
*
*
Motivation - Chapter 8
- Explores theories of motivation as they relate to an effective organization
- 4 major types:
- Content
- Cognitive
- Behaviorism
- Motivation in bureaus
*
*
Focus Of Motivation Theories
- Can be on internal needs known as intrinsic motivators or
- Incentives known as extrinsic motivators
*
*
Content (Need) Theories
- Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
- Alderfer’s ERG theory
- McClelland’s social motives theory
- Herzberg’s two-factor theory
*
Content (Need) Theories
*
*
Hierarchy Of Needs
- Individuals are motivated to satisfy 5 unfulfilled needs
- hierarchy,
- Ranges from physiogical needs
- to self-actualization: activities are performed for satisfaction of doing them
Abraham Maslow
*
*
ERG Theory
- Reformulated Maslow’s 5 needs into 3 categories: (E) existence, (R) relatedness, (G) growth
- Contribution: ERG clarifies that needs are not necessarily in a hierarchical order
Clayton Alderfer
*
*
McClelland’s Social Motives
(1/3)
- Critic of Maslow
- Needs are socially acquired not biologically determined
- 3 needs:
- Affiliation
- Achievement
- Power
David McClelland
*
*
Social Motives (2/3)
- Leadership style and effectiveness vary with degree of achievement need
- High performance related to high-achievement needs
David McClelland
*
*
Social Motives (3/3)
- High-achiever managers: optimistic about subordinates, use participative methods, show concern for people and production
- Moderate achievers: concerned with prestige, symbols
- Low-achievers: focus on safety and security
David McClelland
*
*
Two-factor Theory (1/3)
- Satisfaction affected by two-factors: motivation & hygiene factors
- Motivation factors: intrinsic to the work itself
- Hygiene factors: linked to job context affected by management
- Also known as satisfiers & dissatisfiers
Frederick Herzberg
*
*
Two-factor Theory (2/3)
- Satisfiers & dissatisfiers are separate factors and not on a continuum
- Individuals associate
- Good feelings w/ job content: responsibility, advancement, etc.
- Bad feelings w/ job context, factors largely out of the individual’s control: supervision, policies, etc.
Frederick Herzberg
*
*
Two-factor Theory (3/3)
- Money can be satisfier and dissatisfier
- More of a satisfaction theory than motivation theory
- Satisfaction does not necessarily lead to motivation and higher productivity
Frederick Herzberg
*
*
Will all employees follow the same motivational patterns?
*
Motivation Patterns (Katz,Kahn)
*
*
Cognitive Theories
- Identify the factors that comprise the motivation process
- Determine how and why these factors result in motivation
- Vroom’s VIE theory
- Porter-Lawler Model
- Attribution or Locus of Control Theory
*
*
VIE Model (1/3)
- Motivation is the individual’s perception of the probability of achieving the goal
- Individual makes 3 determinations based upon perceptions of what will occur
Victor Vroom
*
*
VIE Model (2/3)
(V)alence is the strength of a person’s performance
(I)nstrumentality: perception that the individual can reach the goal
(E)xpectancy: perception the individual will receive the reward if meet the goal
*
*
Vroom’s VIE Model (3/3)
*
*
Porter-Lawler Model (1/2)
*
*
Porter-Lawler Model (2/2)
Extension of Vroom’s theory
- To affect job performance,
- Employee has to have desire, ability, and put in the effort
- Employer has to provide training, resources, reward
*
*
Porter-Lawler Model (2/2)
- Amount of effort to receive the reward
- Energy an individual puts into an activity to reach the reward
- Value of the rewards
- Do the actual rewards correspond to what the individual perceives as an equitable reward for the amount of effort
*
*
Attribution or Locus of Control Theory (1/2)
- Individuals outcomes are internally or externally controlled
- Individuals perceive control to others or self in the work environment
- Locus of control perceptions affect behavior and performance
*
*
Attribution or Locus of Control Theory (2/2)
- Employees who perceive an internal locus find work more satisfying
- Satisfaction affected by a participative leadership style
- Managers who perceive a subordinate’s poor performance as due to internal factors (insufficient ability, effort, attentiveness) tend to respond w/ punitive measures
Mitchell & others
*
*
Behaviorism Theory (1/4)
- Assumptions:
- Individuals are motivated by either rewards or punishments, external stimuli
- Individuals can be influenced (manipulated)
Skinner
*
*
Behaviorism (2/4)
- Operant conditioning is the process through which behavior is learned and reinforced
- Positive and negative reinforcers (stimuli) strengthen a desired behavior
- Undesired behavior can be extinguished by not providing a reward or punished
*
*
Behaviorism’s Interpretation (3/4)
- Negative reinforcement de-emphasized in theory
- Used in practice
- Punishment suppresses undesirable behavior but often fails to eliminate
*
*
Behaviorism’s Interpretation (4/4)
- Punishment’s effects are hard to predict and can be dysfunctional to the org
- Punishment can show an individual what not to do, but not what to do
*
*
Motivation and Organizational Commitment (1/2)
- Public servants are attracted to public and non-profit org
- Less value on material reward
*
*
Motivation and Organizational Commitment (2/2)
- Commitment dimensions, desire to remain members of the org, willingness to perform, acceptance of org goals
- Stability of the org goals
- Distinctive image and mission
- Money is important
*
Motivation in Bureaus
- Downs typology of officials:
- Climbers
- Conservers
- Zealots
- Advocates
- Statesman
*
Motivation in Bureaus
- Climbers
- Seeks to maximize power income and prestige by:
- Promotion
- Aggrandizement
- Jumping
*
Motivation in Bureaus
- Conservers
- Motivated to maximize their security and convenience
- Resist change to avoid risk to their power, income, and prestige
- Can be related to expectancy (less upward mobility due to age, etc.
*
Motivation in Bureaus
- Zealots
- Motivated by higher level needs
- Focus on narrow, sacred policies
- High energy
- Overcome bureaucratic obstacles to encourage change
- Can generate conflict and resentment
*
Motivation in Bureaus
- Advocates
- Motivated to promote best interests of bureau or assignment (loyal)
- Promote for entire area of responsibility
- Highly partisan externally, but impartial internally
- Only promote significant policies
- Magnify problems to obtain resources
*
Motivation in Bureaus
- Statesmen
- Loyalty to broad concepts of public interest
- Difficult to overcome formidable obstacles in bureau structure
- Although not common, more likely when overall bureaucracy threatened
*
*
Motivation Reconsidered
- Beliefs about motivation affect leadership style which in turn affects the culture of the organization
*