Everything Inside

English 1121, College Writing and Critical Reading

Paper #2

Paper #2 ChatGPT Analysis Feedback/Grading Sheet

This paper: Excellent Competent / Acceptable Needs improvement has a catchy/relevant title x x x x

has an interesting introduction including an

attention-getter, book title (italicized) and author’s full name,

title of the Chat GPT essay (in quotation marks)

and the thesis x x x x

has a focused thesis statement that takes a clear

and reasonable stand, shows depth, and is subject

to disagreement x x x x

is well-organized between paragraphs and within

paragraphs/uses strong transitions x x x x

has a specific claim that takes an evaluative stand

in each paragraph and is appropriately placed x x x x

uses appropriate textual evidence in the form of

specific details/examples, facts, and quoted material

from the sources (shared via quotations, paraphrases,

and summary in each paragraph) x x x x

illustrates depth of critical thinking and

thorough analysis x x x x

uses academic language/tone

and has advanced style x x x x

contains no error (grammar,

spelling, or punctuation) x x x x

all details/facts/examples from sources that are

quoted, paraphrased, and summarized in the paper

are properly followed with a correct in-text citation x x x x

has a correct Works Cited page

and follows MLA format x x x x

I expect papers also to

illustrate extensive, comprehensive revision yes somewhat no

meet the length requirement yes no

be turned in on time in D2L yes no