Position Paper

Tasks Exemplary Acceptable Unacceptable

Content & Development

50%

9 - 10

Takes a strong, well

defined position; uses at

least three appropriate

reasons with at least

two supporting details

for each reason.

Counter arguments

effectively addressed,

w/o undercutting

position.

7 - 8

Clear position taken and

defined; some reasons and

some details present, but

not fully developed.

Counter arguments

addressed..

0 - 6

No clear position taken;

reasons undeveloped; no

supporting facts used

Organization & Structure

20 %

9 - 10

Structure of paper is

clear and easy to

follow. Paragraph

transitions are logical

and maintain the flow

of thought throughout

the paper. Conclusion is

logical and flows from

the body of the paper

7 - 8

Structure is mostly clear

and easy to follow.

Paragraph transitions are

present. Conclusion is

logical.

0 - 6

Structure of the paper is

not easy to follow.

Paragraph transitions need

improvement. Conclusion

is missing, or if provided,

does not flow from the

body of the paper

Format

10 %

9 - 10

Paper follows all

designated guidelines.

Paper is the appropriate

length as described for

the assignment. Format

enhances readability of

paper.

7 - 8

Paper follows designated

guidelines. Paper is the

appropriate length as

described for the

assignment. Format is

good.

0 - 6

Paper lacks many elements

of correct formatting.

Paper is inadequate/

excessive in length. Paper

is not double spaced.

Grammar and APA Style

20%

9 - 10

Has 0-25 issues with

grammar

7 - 8

Has 26-50 issues

according with grammar

0 - 6

Has 51 or more issues with

grammar