|
Position Paper Grading Rubric - 125 pts (1)
|
|
Criteria
|
Ratings
|
Pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeLength
|
|
5.0 pts
Meets length requirement
|
0.0 pts
Does not meet length requirement
|
|
5.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomePoint Analysis
|
|
30.0 pts
The central idea is developed and expanded with depth of critical thought.
|
25.5 pts
The central idea is discernible and developed.
|
22.5 pts
The central idea needs more development with points tying back to the thesis.
|
18.0 pts
The central idea is not developed, and the analysis lacks critical thought.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
30.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSupport
|
|
30.0 pts
The writing supports claims with several detailed and persuasive examples.
|
25.5 pts
The writing supports claims with examples, but additional analysis or examples could strengthen the argument.
|
22.5 pts
The writing supports claims with examples, but the examples are not well-developed or examined. Additional examples and analysis are needed to make the argument more persuasive.
|
18.0 pts
The central idea is not well-supported by claims and/or examples.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
30.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeOrganization
|
|
25.0 pts
Paper is clear and cohesive. Introduction and conclusion support the overall flow of the paper.
|
21.25 pts
Paper is basically clear and well-organized with a minimum of non-related material present.
|
18.75 pts
Paper has some issues with clarity, flow, and cohesion. Paper lacks organization.
|
15.0 pts
Paper lacks organization and has difficulty staying on track. Central themes are difficult to identify.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
25.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeWriting: Mechanics & Usage
|
|
10.0 pts
The writing is free of major errors in grammar, spelling, and punctuation that would detract from a clear reading of the paper.
|
8.5 pts
The writing contains a few major errors in grammar, spelling, and punctuation, but the errors do not detract from a clear reading of the text.
|
7.5 pts
The writing contains some major errors in grammar, spelling, and punctuation that need to be addressed for a clearer reading of the paper.
|
6.0 pts
The writing contains several major errors in grammar, spelling, and punctuation that impede a clear reading of the paper.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
10.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeClarity & Flow
|
|
10.0 pts
The writing contains strong word choice that clarifies ideas and masterful sentence variety aids with the flow of ideas.
|
8.5 pts
The writing contains varied word choice and sentence structures that clarify ideas and aid with the flow of ideas.
|
7.5 pts
The writing contains word choice and sentence structures that can be revised for better clarification of ideas and flow of ideas.
|
6.0 pts
The writing contains wording and sentence structures that are awkward and/or unclear, impeding the clarity and flow of ideas.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
10.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeVoice
|
|
5.0 pts
The writing maintains third-person point of view/objective voice throughout the entire text.
|
4.25 pts
The writing maintains third-person point of view/objective voice throughout much of the text.
|
3.75 pts
The writing has some deviation from third-person point of view/objective voice that needs to be revised so as not to sound biased or patronizing.
|
3.0 pts
The writing deviates significantly from third-person point of view/objective voice that needs to be revised so as not to sound biased or patronizing.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
5.0 pts
|
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeAPA Format
|
|
10.0 pts
All sources are properly integrated and cited in the text and references page demonstrating a mastery of integrating resources and APA format.
|
8.5 pts
Most sources are integrated and cited in the text and references page. Some minor errors may exist in integration and/or citation, but it does not interfere with understanding the source of the information.
|
7.5 pts
Most sources are integrated and cited in the text and references page. Some errors may exist in integration and/or citation that need to be addressed to clarify the source of information.
|
6.0 pts
Sources are not properly integrated/cited in the text/references page. Formatting contains several errors that suggest a lack of understanding of the integration of resources and APA format.
|
0.0 pts
No effort
|
|
10.0 pts
|
|
Total Points: 125.0
|
Masaira
PositionPaperGradingRubric.docx
