Design management
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
1
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING
IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
(Image 1)
Degree: MA design management
Word count: 2880
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents 2
1. Annotated Bibliography 3
1.1 Introduction 3
1.2 Mind map 1 5
1.3Thinking process 6
2. Literature Review 9
2.1 Direction 9
2.2 Overview of the research topic 12
2.3 Infographic 2 14
3. Reflective Commentary 15
3.1 Research gap 15
3.2 Planning 16
4. References 17
5. Appendices 22
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
3
1.Annotated bibliography
1.1 introduction
Packaging is one of the important part in design management. Packaging can
attract consumers' attention and stimulate consumption, and packaging play
an important role in marketing. (Shen,2016) Packaging design not only affect
people’s choices, but also is an excellent way to establish a brand
image. Packaging design has gradually become the link and bridge
between enterprises and consumers to establish cognitive brand
awareness. Packaging is an excellent way to convey information and
generalize brand in today’s gradually competitive marketing, especially in
the launch of new brands, reposition or extend the brand, when change the
product or distinguish product, using graphic will provide a strategy
approach to differentiation. (Garber et al. cited in Vergura and Luceri,
page218, 2000) Different products have different packaging needs, for
example, preservation is the main feature of packaging for food, however, a
attractive packaging effect the sales. The primary purpose of packaging is to
protect the product, with the customer awareness growth and the long-term
development of the consumer's social structure, packaging is not only
expected to protect product features, but also increase sales.(Yang, 2018)
For cosmetic, limited packaging maybe is a way to attract consumer. At the
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
4
same time, different people have different preferences for packaging, such as
different ages or different gender. Packaging affects the market of products in
varying degrees, hence, packaging will become the focus in design
management research. In people’s daily life, packaging effect people’s
decision when they buy something, Vergura and Luceri reported that
packaging affects people's purchase decisions and it is one of the important
issues. (Vergura, Luceri. 2018) With the improvement of people's living
standards, the definition and goals of packaging design have also changed.
Packaging design is an external reflection of the intrinsic product. In addition to
the protective function, the packaging of the product creates a beautiful visual
image for consumers through visual elements such as graphics, color and text,
and expresses and promotes the characteristics and functions of the product in
different forms to help consumers understand the product.
I choose this area because packaging plays an important role in marketing.
The reason why consumer buy something directly is that product display, in the
product display, attractive packaging play an essential role. (Ghani and Kamal
cited in Edward, page 805, 2013). In the absence of reference information or
the same quality and price, unique packaging can attract consumers' attention
and interest, and enter the consumer's choice range. Therefore, packaging is a
way to convey information to customer, it can not only describe the trademark,
name and quality of the product, but also introduce the special effects and
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
5
uses of the product, as well as the corporate image. Consumers can get
information about the product in a short time through the product box. A good
packaging is also conducive to building a brand image and brand awareness.
Packaging not only conveys brand information to consumers, but it can be
delivered to consumers at the lowest cost. (Hellstrom and Nilsso cited in
Edward, 2013) Packaging can attract consumer so that increase
purchasing, then, help the company get more revenue.
1.2 mind map
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
6
1.3 Thinking process
From my mind map, packaging is my research field in design management,
Packaging is not only to protect the integrity of the product, it is also a
brand strategy that the company attracts customers. Function, visual
design and brand marketing issues are involved into packaging, these
features effectively show the brand image and package content. (Orth &
Malkewitz cited in Yang, page 52, 2013).
Firstly, packaging is divided into five parts, they are design, marketing,
content, product categories and consumer preference. The aesthetics in
design will become basic section because one of the purpose of packaging
is to attract consumers, and the aesthetics design of packaging is the main
factor in attracting consumers. Customer preference is divided into two
parts, consumer behavior and groups. For customer, different ages and
different gender have different preferences when they choose a product.
An experiment about the choices of chocolate packaging show that conner
who under 20 age would like to choose tall thin shapes and more easier to
accept innovative shapes, however, the others who over 40 years old like
conventional shapes. And men recipients prefer angular shaped packaging
but women have more interest in the shallow and curved package. ( Barnes
et al., 2003)For instance, children maybe would like to choose a product
which packaging with cartoon or a toy, a survey indicate that children are
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
7
the most vulnerable to food packaging, attractive packaging can influence
children’s favour. (Elliott, 2018) Brand mascots and media characters on
food packaging can attract children’s attention in order to increase sales.
Furthermore, these characters also influence the tastes imagination before
they buy it. (de Droog et al. and Enax et al. cited in Elliott, page156, 2018)
And the elder maybe consider which packaging is more easy to open.
There is a new trend that design products and packaging for the elder, and
the elder think that the openability is very important. ( Jeeranuch and
Athakorn, 2018) Therefore, the survey of packaging preferences for
different groups of people is a part of packaging design.
The most important part of packaging in design management is packaging
aesthetic design, because it is the main reason that influence consumer
behavior. Consumers believe that the aesthetic design of the product can
bring them a sense of pleasure(Amel, 2018) And it is divided into four parts
named aesthetic, functional, psychological and social. At first, when it
comes to aesthetic in packaging, shape, color, graphic and material are
key components. As Edward in his article mention that according to the
research results, food company should focus on the visual packaging
design, such as color, font, logo, graphics, and size to establish positive
perceptions and brand awareness for target people.(Edward, 2013) The
color in aesthetic of packaging design will be the focus of this article because
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
8
color maybe is one of the important issue attracting customer’s attention when
they go shopping, all of the visual design tips for consumer, color maybe is the
most element. (Lynn cited in Spence and Velasco, page 226, 2018). And the
pattern in packaging is another factor that affects consumer behavior. The
other parts in design are functional, psychological and social.
Then product categories, content in packaging and the effect of marketing are
another relation with packaging. Products can be divided into foods, drinks and
cosmetic, and the content on packaging can convey information to people. For
marketing, packaging effect the awareness of brand because the attractive of
packaging. The physical structure, materials, surface treatments and
interactions of the packaging not only affect the consumer experience in a
large extent, but also influence customer awareness of brand follow-up.
( Timney and Chamberlain, 2017) Because of this essay will focus on how
color and pattern in packaging design effect consumer behavior, so the
analysis of packaging will focus on consumer behavior as well as color and
pattern in aesthetic of packaging design.
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
9
2. Literature Review
2.1 Direction
From the introduction part, different products have different target people,
companies need to understand the different preferences of consumers to
design attractive packaging. Packaging design influence consumer behavior,
this essay focuses on the impact of color and graphics on consumers in
packaging design.
Color is one of the important factors to beautify and highlight product features.
Color is the first element to attract consumers, it convey brand information to
people and it is also a reflection of consumer psychology. The color of the
design not only evokes the consumer's feelings about the product, but also
attracts the consumer's attention and affects the product. Therefore, the color
of the design is one of the basic elements that stimulate the consumer's visual
experience.(Amel, 2018) People will have some association with color and
different color have different feeling. People's perception of color can quickly
distinguish the preference for products.
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
10
Considering the particularity of packaging in the marketing market, the color of
packaging is one of the necessary elements to convey information. It can
quickly establish emotional intercommunication with consumers, evoke
people's association with products, and stimulate purchases.(Barchiesi et al.
2016 ) Hasani and Zeqiri think that Companies use different colors to reflect
different emotions. For example, black is considered to be power, blue is for
trust, red is for energy, and green is considered balanced or fresh and organic.
(Hasani and Zeqiri, 2015) Color also is one of the ways to distinguish the taste
of food, the research has shown that the color of the package will affect the
consumer's experience with the product, in fact, more and more research
indicate that the color of the package affects the initial judgment of the taste,
such as the scent of food and beverage products or even household or
personal care products.(Spence and Velasco,2018) “ Velasco et al
demonstrated that packaging color /product flavour congruence facilitated the
visual search for a particular flavour of crisps. Specifically, participants found it
significantly easier to locate a predetermined flavour variety (e.g., cucumber)
when the color of the packaging was congruent with the customer’s
expectations(e.g., green, with their color-flavour correspondences).” (Spence
and Velasco,2018) From the above literature research, it can be seen that
color affects consumers' first feelings about products, and also becomes a
necessary factor to attract consumers' attention in packaging design.
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
11
Therefore, in the packaging, in order to make the product out of the
competition, the designer can not ignore the importance of color.
Color has some influence on everyone's psychological choices,Regarding
people's preference for color, some experiments have shown that people love
color packaging more than grayscale packaging.(Marques da Rosa et al.,
2018)Through Soirer and Brée's research on the application of red and blue in
mineral water packaging, blue packaging is more exciting for consumers.
(Sohier and Brée cited in Amei, page 93, 2018) Colors can also convey
environmentally friendly information, such as green applications in packaging
that are implicitly related to sustainability.(Hoogland et al., Magnier and
Schoormans, and Pancer et al. cited in Steenis, et al. Page 287, 2017)
Accordingly, different colors have different expectations in consumer
psychology, that is the reason why designer should consider color when they
design a package.
Graphics is also one of the characteristics of packaging design, which also
promote brand or product to consumer. It is very important for brand or
company to use image on packaging because it can increase people's focus
on the product. (Hasani and Zeqiri, 2015) Firstly, graphic on packaging through
abstract or figurative visual graphics to create and convey aesthetics, to show
a rich corporate connotation, a perfect interpretation of products, to deliver
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
12
high-quality quality information to consumers, so that consumers fully
associate the use value of products, generate purchase desire. Packaging can
be thought of as consisting of many elements, and graphics can be used as
one of the language design features that prompt consumers. (Magnier and
Crié, Rettie and Brewer, Underwood cited in Steenis el al. Page 288, 2017 ).
On the food packaging, in order to reflect the delicious taste of the food, the
photos of the food are often printed on the product packaging to deepen the
consumer's vivid impression. According to Klimchuk & Krasovec, picture on a
food package can cause appetite to happen. (Klimchuk and Krasovec cited in
Cahyorni and Rusfian, page16, 2011)
2.2 overview of the research topic
My research topic analyze the impact of aesthetics on consumers in packaging
design, especially in color and graphics. For the brand, the company needs to
promote the product, or a certain degree of awareness, that is, marketing
communication(Cahyorini and Rusfian, 2011) Every brand needs to promote
its products through some methods, and packaging is an effective way to
attract consumers. (Hasani and Zeqiri, 2015) The company is more interested
in using packaging to promote sales. In packaging, colors and graphics are
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
13
visual elements, visual elements as a basic element of packaging design can
convey information to consumers effectively. (Chen and Song, 2018) Design
must attract consumers through its unique characteristics, but also to promote
brand information. (Cahyorini and Rusfian, 2011) Colors as visual elements
first attract the attention of consumers, and graphic can convey brand
information to consumer. Gollety think that “at 10 meters, color is the first
element seen by the consumer. At 4 meters, it is the shape, every bit as
important as the color that is seen. At just 1 meter away from a product, it is the
brand which the consumer sees”.(Gollety and Guichard,2011)Thus, when the
consumer does not understand the product, the first factor affecting the
consumer's choice may be the color of the package. On the other hand,
graphic is another method in packaging design to attract consumer. Different
consumers have different preferences for graphics. The reason why I choose
aesthetic in packaging is that a good design must satisfy consumer’s
requirements, and a successful design must not only be reflected in the
function, but also achieve the consumer's visual requirements in aesthetics,
and successfully catch people's eyes. (Hassenzahl, Jordan, Liu and Norman
cited in Westerman et al. 2012) Because of color and graphics are used as
visual elements in packaging design to convey certain brand information to
consumers, and from previous research, color is the main factor affecting
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
14
consumers. Accordingly, the research direction of this paper is the influence of
color and graphics on consumers behavior in packaging.
2.3 Infographic 2
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
15
3.Reflective Commentary
3.1 research gap
The literature review gives some points about aesthetic in packaging effect
consumer decision, color and graphic became the main research direction.
Through the above research packaging it is found that packaging does affect
the choice of consumers and affects the sales of products. But the negative
effect also can not be ignored. In people’s daily life, sometimes, they find that
the packaging of the products we buy is gorgeous and attractive, but it is
disappointing after opening. Some people think that some beautifully
packaged goods also have too high a price, but the goods themselves are not
worth the price, and people called this over-packaging. Over-packaging
describes a phenomenon which over use packaging to beautify products but
causing waste of packaging materials that were not originally needed
(Elgaaïed-Gambier, 2014) The first problem of over-packaging is that the price
is too high, some package is more expensive that the product itself, and the
second one is waste and environmental pollution. A study shows that
over-packaging can account for 65% of the total cost of the product, so for
manufacturers, over-packaging saves the cost of the product itself. (Sevadec
cited in Monnot et al., 2017) On the other hand, Some packaging will be made
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
16
of materials such as cardboard, which invisibly increases the cost of the
product, and the bearer can only be the consumer, which means that the final
sales price rises. (Elgaaïed-Gambier, 2014) Over-packaging is a waste of
resources, and it will generate more household waste and pollution.
(Elgaaïed-Gambier, 2014) Therefore, over-packaging not only increase the
cost of product, but also causing environmental pollution.
To sum up, proper packaging is necessary. But over-packaging goes to the
other extreme, exaggerating the function of packaging, misleading consumer
attitudes, and damaging the interests of consumers and society. Packaging is
no longer just the traditional appearance of the product, but is integrated with
the product, which is more simple and individual while reducing costs. This is
the art of packaging. Recently, people pay more attention to sustainable
packaging in order to protect environment, thus, we should reduce the use of
over-packaging.
3.2 planning
Through the study of this course, I discovered the importance of reading and
critical thinking. Reading can not only help us gain professional knowledge, but
also help us have a sporadic thinking about the topic of our thesis. In the
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
17
writing process of this article, I read some literature about packaging and and
inspired some ideas for packaging. In the next semester, I will read more
literature and organize my thoughts about the direction of design management.
In the process of writing this essay, I realized the importance of time
management. I think good time management will improve learning efficiency
and make writing easier. Therefore, I will divide my time, plan my future time,
arrange time during Easter holidays, and visit more museums and increase my
knowledge. In the remaining time, you should try to learn English well, learn
your major, and obtain a degree certificate. If i can get an opportunity to find a
job in UK after graduation, I want to stay here in order to increase my
experience.In the future, I hope that I can find a satisfactory job and apply the
knowledge I have learned during my graduate studies to my work. In addition,
the research on packaging in this article allowed me to be exposed to various
aspects of packaging during the literature, such as sustainable packaging and
consumer behavior and psychological, and perhaps to focus on some cases
and literature on sustainable packaging and pay attention to consumer
psychology in future studies. Maybe it will help me in my future career.
4. References
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
18
Amel, A. (2018). Influence of cosmetic packaging’ color on price perception
and consumer preference. Annals of 'Constantin brancusi' university of
targu-Jiu. economy series, 2, p.92-100
Barchiesi, M., Castellan, S. and Costa, R. (2016). In the eye of the beholder:
Communicating CSR through color in packaging design. Journal of Marketing
Communications, 24(7), p.720-733.
Barnes, C. Southee, C. and Henson, B. (2003) The impact of affective design
of product packaging upon consumer purchase decisions. Proceedings of the
International Conference on Designing Pleasurable Products and Interfaces,
p.134-135
Cahyorini, A. and Rusfian, E. Z.(2011) The effect of packaging design on
impulsive buying, Journal of Administrative Science & Organization, 18(1),
p.11-12
Elgaaïed-Gambier, L. (2014). Who Buys Overpackaged Grocery Products and
Why? Understanding Consumers’ Reactions to Overpackaging in the Food
Sector. Journal of Business Ethics, 135(4), pp.683-698.
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
19
Elliott, C. (2018). Milk in a glass, milk in a carton: The influence of packaging
on children’s perceptions of the healthfulness of milk. International Journal of
Health Promotion and Education, 56(3), p.155-164.
Gollety, M. and Guichard, N. (2011). The dilemma of flavor and color in the
choice of packaging by children. Young Consumers, 12(1), p.82-90.
Hasani, V. and Zeqiri, J. (2015). Using Factor Analysis Tool to Analyze the
Important Packaging Elements that Impact Consumer Buying
Behavior. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social
Sciences, 5(6).
Hui Chen & Wu Song (2018) A multi-level study of evaluation indices and
weight comparison for food packaging designs, Journal of Interdisciplinary
Mathematics, 21:2, p.287-297
Jeeranuch, B., Athakorn, K. (2018) Criterion Evaluation of Accessible
Packaging Design for Aging Society, 2018 2nd International Conference on
Engineering Innovation. P86-89
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
20
Marques da Rosa, V., Spence, C. and Miletto Tonetto, L. (2018). Influences of
visual attributes of food packaging on consumer preference and associations
with taste and healthiness. International Journal of Consumer Studies.
Monnot, E., Reniou, F., Parguel, B. and Elgaaied-Gambier, L. (2017).
“Thinking Outside the Packaging Box”: Should Brands Consider Store Shelf
Context When Eliminating Overpackaging?. Journal of Business Ethics.
Shen, C. (2016). The Research on the Design of Colors, Patterns and Texts
for Paper Stocks Tea Packaging Visual Design. Applied Mechanics and
Materials, 835, p.665-669.
Spence, C. and Velasco C. (2018). On the multiple effects of packaging colour
on consumer behaviour and product experience in the ‘food and beverage’ and
‘home and personal care’ categories, Food Quality and Preference, 68(2018),
P.226-237
Steenis, N., van Herpen, E., van der Lans, I., Ligthart, T. and van Trijp, H.
(2017). Consumer response to packaging design: The role of packaging
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
21
materials and graphics in sustainability perceptions and product
evaluations. Journal of Cleaner Production, 162, p.286-298.
S.T. Wang, E. (2013). The influence of visual packaging design on perceived
food product quality, value, and brand preference. International Journal of
Retail & Distribution Management, 41(10), p.805-816.
Timney, T. and Chamberlain, P. (2017). Integrated package design: an
interdisciplinary approach to package design that benefits consumer
experience and brand perception. Computer-Aided Design and Applications,
14(sup1), p.33-40.
Vergura, D. and Luceri, B. (2018). Product packaging and consumers’
emotional response. Does spatial representation influence product evaluation
and choice?. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 35(2), p.218-227.
Yang, C. (2018). Applying Design Thinking as a Method for Teaching
Packaging Design. Journal of Education and Learning, 7(5), p.52.
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
22
Westerman, S., Gardner, P., Sutherland, E., White, T., Jordan, K., Watts, D.
and Wells, S. (2012). Product Design: Preference for Rounded versus Angular
Design Elements. Psychology and Marketing, 29(8), pp.595-605.
Website: Ieeexplore.ieee.org. (2019). Criterion Evaluation of Accessible
Packaging Design for Aging Society - IEEE Conference Publication. [online]
Available at:
https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=8448612
[Accessed 6 Jan. 2019].
Picture source: http://image.baidu.com
5.Appendices
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
24
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
25
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
26
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
27
REFLECTION ON THE PACKAGING IN DESIGN MANAGEMENT
28