Hybrid Argument Draft 1 + Video Peer Feedback

Hybrid Argument Final Paper: Peer Review

(Higher Order Concerns) Tier 1 Claim Objective: Demonstrate an understanding of claim types, argumentation, and writing for a specified audience

• Utilize at least two claim type: Causal Proposal Evaluation Ethical Definition Hybrid

• Claim is clear and arguable • Argument matches the claim • Claim is appropriate for

intended audience

Research Quality Objective: Demonstrate an understanding of library and database researching, information literacy, and detecting bias

• 8-10+ separate sources well- integrated throughout the paper

• At minimum, 2 peer reviewed sources used

• Original research prioritized over commentary

• Variety of source types

Development Objective: Demonstrate the ability to flesh out ideas and support them with sources

• Examples and sources support the claim

• Balance of quotes and paraphrases • Strong source integration • Strong introduction that

familiarizes audience with topic • Strong conclusion that goes

beyond merely restating the introduction; rather leaving the audience with a new perspective on the issue

(Mid-Level Concerns) Tier 2 Rhetoric Appeals Objective: Demonstrate rhetorical awareness in regard to audience

• Appropriate Tone is used throughout

• Academic register is maintained • Academic Perspective is

maintained no I, you, or we past narrative portions or hooks

• Reasonable attempt to utilize at least 2 Rhetorical Appeals (Logos, Ethos, Pathos, Kairos)

Organization Objective: Demonstrate meaningful and logical organization

• Clear supporting reasons for claim

• Clear connection between paragraphs

• Clear organization within individual paragraphs

• PIE is clearly utilized in body of paper

Citation Objective: Demonstrate citation and attribution skills

• In-text citations always provided and every source is attributed

• Correct info included for citations

• Varied citation style throughout integrating attributive tags and in-text citations

• Correct MLA formatting throughout paper

(Lower Order Concerns) Tier 3 Works Cited Objective: Demonstrate the ability to produce a complete and correct works cited page

• Correct heading • Double Spacing Throughout • Hanging indent • Alphabetical order • Correct info included • Web URLs, permalinks, or DOIs

included but not hyperlinked • Correct MLA formatting

(including capitalization and italics)

Style Objective: Demonstrate attention to editing and proofreading

• Varied sentence constructions

• Attention to word choice • Avoidance of vague, tired, or

overgeneralized phrasing • Conventions and Grammar

are consistent • Spelling errors and typos are

minimal • Correct Punctuation

throughout

Document Formatting Objective: Demonstrate knowledge of MLA style

• Header (Last Name #) • Heading Matter

Student First/Last Instructor: Sarah Cohen ENGL 201 4 December 2020

• Title is centered and original • TNR or similar, 12pt Font • No extra or manipulated spacing • Meets word count requirement

2400 words before works cited