Peer Review

  HLT-317V Peer Review Template

Part of your responsibility as a student in this course is to provide quality feedback to your peers that will help them to improve their writing skills. This template will assist you in providing that feedback. Submit the template to your instructor through the LMS, and make sure that the writer gets a copy as well.

Name of the Draft’s Author:

Name of the Peer Reviewer:

Summary: After reading through the draft one time, write a summary (3–5 sentences) of the rough draft in the box below.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Health Care Field Research Draft

After a second, closer reading of the draft, evaluate the essay using the Health Care Field Research Draft rubric from Topic 2. Determine the level of achievement appropriate for each assignment criteria. (Level of achievement ranges from Unsatisfactory to Excellent and is found at the top of the rubric. Assignment criteria are found in the left column of the rubric.)

Introduction of the Topic

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence do you have for this score?

Explanation of Research Articles as it Relates to the Allied Health Care Profession

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Ethical Considerations for Data Collection

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Explanation of What the Data Reveals in Terms of Statistical Analysis

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Topic of Interest

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Summary of the Conclusions from the Articles

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Thesis Development and Purpose

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Argument Logic and Construction

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Mechanics of Writing

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Paper Format

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Research Citations

· What level of achievement did the author score for this criterion?

· What evidence from the paper do you have for this score?

Three positive things about this paper are:

1)

2)

3)

Three things that could be improved are:

1)

2)

3)

© 2020. Grand Canyon University. All Rights Reserved.

2