DNP Project
Snowball123
PeerReviewArticleEvaluationForm3.docxReview form -
Reviewer’s Information
Title:
First Name:
Last Name:
Manuscript Information
Title:
Date Published:
Evaluation Report
Kindly enter evaluation criteria ment in a commentary format for each section below. If not included in the article, please indicate. Also specify if information exempt was needed.
|
Introduction: |
|
|
Background/Literature Support: |
|
|
Methodology: |
|
|
Results: |
|
|
Discussion: |
|
|
Bibliography/References: |
|
|
Problem statement identified, population specified, other key factors noted: |
|
|
Decision: |
|
Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)
|
Originality: |
|
|
Contribution To The Field: |
|
|
Technical Quality: |
|
|
Clarity Of Presentation : |
|
|
Depth Of Research/Content: |
|
Recommendation
Please mark with an X below
|
Accept As Is: |
|
|
Requires Minor Corrections: |
|
|
Requires Moderate Revision: |
|
|
Requires Major Revision: |
|
|
Submit To Another Publication Such As: |
|
|
Reject on grounds of (Please be specific) |
|
Additional Comments
Please add any additional comments:
