Mathematics Expert Only - Statistical Review Assignment
malibumark21
PeerandArticleCritiqueForm.doc
Peer and Article Critique Form
Summary of Research
Critique the article or proposal on each of these areas.
Area of Research |
Please fill in the pertinent information in this column. |
Research Question |
Enter your text here. |
Context of the Research |
Enter your text here. |
Significance of the Research |
Enter your text here. |
Research Hypothesis or Hypotheses (for Quantitative Research) |
Enter your text here. |
Operationalized Research Variables (Please Specify the Role of Each in the Research) |
Operationalized Research Variables (Please Specify the Role of Each in the Research) |
|
1. Dependent variables. |
Enter your text here. |
|
2. Independent variables. |
Enter your text here. |
|
3. Control variables. |
Enter your text here. |
|
4. Other variables or constructs of interest: |
Enter your text here. |
Research Design |
Research Design |
|
5. Sampling. |
Enter your text here. |
|
6. Instruments. |
Enter your text here. |
|
7. Data Collection. (including random assignment, if present, and control groups, if present). |
Enter your text here. |
|
8. Method or approach used (e.g., quantitative quasi-experimental, qualitative case study, etc) |
Enter your text here. |
|
9. Ethical Issues, as addressed. |
Enter your text here. |
|
10. Data Analysis. |
Enter your text here. |
|
11. Author's Conclusions. |
Enter your text here. |
Article Critique |
Article Critique |
Literature Review |
Literature Review |
|
12. Does it summarize the relevant material? |
Enter your text here. |
|
13. Does it clarify why this research is important? |
Enter your text here. |
Description and Evaluation of Possible Threats to Validity |
Description and Evaluation of Possible Threats to Validity |
Sample |
Sample |
|
14. Is the sample appropriate for the study? |
Enter your text here. |
|
15. Is the sample size sufficient for the research? |
Enter your text here. |
Instruments |
Instruments |
|
16. Are the instruments or measures appropriate for the study? |
Enter your text here. |
|
17. Are the reported reliability and validity of the instruments sufficient? Or, have the authors described the validation process for any new instruments sufficiently? |
Enter your text here. |
Ethical Considerations |
Ethical Considerations |
|
18. Does the study pose any risks to the participants? If so, what are these? |
Enter your text here. |
|
19. Have all reasonable steps been taken to protect the rights of the participants? |
Enter your text here. |
|
20. Do the benefits outweigh any risks to participants? |
Enter your text here. |
Data Analysis |
Data Analysis |
|
21. Are the analyses appropriate for the data, sample, et cetera? |
Enter your text here. |
Conclusions |
Conclusions |
|
22. Do the conclusions logically follow the research questions and methodology? |
Enter your text here. |
|
23. Does this study make a significant contribution to the field? |
Enter your text here. |
Other Issues |
Other Issues |
|
Address any issues not covered in the preceding sections. |
Enter your text here. |
1
