ET WK6 paper
%93
%4
%2
%1
SafeAssign Originality Report Fall 2020 - Emerging Threats & Countermeas (ITS-834-M4… • Week 6 Research Paper
%100Total Score: High riskSruthi Dhadvai Submission UUID: c7dbb6ca-41ed-3d54-7ec3-4a3b18f18021
Total Number of Rep…
1 Highest Match
100 % ThreatModelsinHealthCar…
Average Match
100 % Submitted on
10/01/20 05:17 PM EDT
Average Word Count
1,265 Highest: ThreatModelsinH…
%100Attachment 1
Institutional database (4)
Stud… Stud… My p…
Stud…
Internet (3)
com haide… rmus…
Global database (3)
Stud… Stud… Stud…
Scholarly journals & publications (1)
ProQ…
Top sources (3)
Excluded sources (0)
View Originality Report - Old Design
Word Count: 1,265
ThreatModelsinHealthCareFacilityPaper.docx
2 3 4
6
8 5 1
11 10 7
9
2 Stud… 3 Stud… 8 com
Running Head: THREAT MODELING 1
THREAT MODELING 6
Threat Models in Health Care Facility
Sruthi Dhadvai
University of the Cumberlands
Emerging Threats & Countermeasures (ITS-834-M41) (Fall 2020) Full Term Date
Threat Models in Health Care Facility
The e-health structures is familiar for empowering the social movement of protection and security of the board's records because of locking of workplaces to prepare for the flood of the general population needing emotional organization of therapeutic administrations. The e-health systems have affected improved cycles of work taking everything into account, with providers and the expanded number of patients getting to the fundamental human administrations by guaranteeing smooth and justifiable strategies which can be subject to partner the patients with the associations of medical care experts, (Ahsan & Rahman, 2017). The threat
modeling in this perspective is the act through which the potential risks and alleviations of security are recognized and organized to impact a significant worth, for instance, the privacy of information and innovation protection. Some of the threat models include; dread threat model, stride threat model, and trike threat model. In this paper I ill be discussing three threat modeling systems and clearly analyze them to provide for the most effective model. Example of threats that can occur in a healthcare sector is on the x-ray
machine that has a very low defence mechanism against intruders and which can be hacked easly.
DREAD Threat Modeling
DREAD framework refers to a structure concerned with surveying the security threats of a PC with a recent utilization in Microsoft and though that has a current usage in Open Mass and various organizations, with a study from the makers. The model assists minds in rating the security threats and hazards while utilizing fi classifications. Such classifications include; damage, reproducibility, exploitability, the clients affected, and discoverability. While the loss is all about how awful the results of the attack are, the factor of reproducibility focuses on how simple is the recreation of the attack in this context (Singhal & Banati, 2013). However, exploitability targets the amount of work done in dispatching the attack. Besides, the number of individuals affected by the crime is necessary, with the discoverability concerning the ease of finding the risks that potentially occur. Generally, the five initials in the model give the origin of the name DREAD model. The model was initially meant for displaying dangers, but the evaluations were found to be unpredictable and presented with a liability to the discussion. The model was among those utilized by Microsoft 2008, (Collyer, 2018). During the evaluation of dangers using the DREAD model, the entire classifications are rated from one to the total number of assessments of a particular issue that is applied when organizing other matters. According to most security specialists, the inclusion of the "discoverability" to represent the last D is found to be rewarding, by lack of definition with a few associations moving to
DREAD-D scale.
STRIDE Threat Modeling
The STRIDE model of dangers was created by Praerit Garg and Loren Kohnfelder for application in recognition of threats to PC Microsoft. The model classifies the target dangers into six classes: · Spoofing · Tampering · Rejection · Information disclosure ·
Denial of service · Elevation of privilege
The STRIDE model was initially made as an essential feature of displaying procedure for the security threats in PC. The model
is useful when helping reason and discovering the dangers within a PC in the framework. The utilization of the model is related to the physical structure that can equally be built. Therefore, the model incorporates the failure of entire procedures, stores for information, information streams, and the trust limits. All the dangers are perceived as breach for the attractive properties of the framework, (Fatima, et al, 2019) 1. Threat; it is the property of desire that he model targets. 1. Spoofing; refers to
Authenticity as a way of ensuring robust security. 1. Tampering; this denotes the integrity of the model. 1. Repudiation;
the framework is non-repudiable. 1. Information disclosure; this is the confidentiality of the network to availing sensitive
information to unauthorized hands. 1. Denial of Service; this is how readily the services are available. 1. "Elevation of
Privilege"; this all about authorization.
TRIKE Threat Modeling
TRIKE model is a particular threat modeling technique, which is an open-source process of displaying the threats with a lot of focus on the fulfillment of the process of examining the digital risks from the board perspective. The model can give a danger basing their approach on the extremely used methodology and a demonstration process for the hazards, (Jain & Ajmera, 2018). The TRIKE threat modeling is a necessity model guaranteeing chosen levels of the risks for well-intentioned benefits to various partners. Subsequently, the model makes the stream charts for the information, with the framework engineers making the outlines to the information streams to impart the manner of moving of the framework as well as stores and information controls.
1
2
3
4
2
2
2
5
2
2 2
2 2
2
2 2
Source Matches (35)
rmusser 64%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
My paper 100%
The model contained four components; · Information stores · Forms · Information streams · Interactors
Analysis
Although the entire methods seem to have great approaches, all of them are not ideal. First of all, the DREAD model has low
ratings with simple questions that are put on it credibly, and it seems to drop from Microsoft. The simple questions tent not to display all the necessary information to assess the threat effectively. TRIKE needs the designer to be careful while holding the
complete system for conducting an analysis of the search surfaces, which is challenging when it comes to large orders, this model can only be effective in small and mobile healthcare sectors. TRIKE model has several layers that requires a heavy investment of resources to develop it. More so, the model leaves unfinished data at the different levels of its application. The big health care
systems require a quality scale of 100 or 1000 threat model, which is a viable option, but when choosing one model, then STRIDE threat model is the best. The STRIDE model can be summarized to have a sole objective of development, meant to overcome the weaknesses associated with the other threat models. The model is well documented, owns a technology giant Microsoft Corporation, and is time tested. The application of STRIDE model does not prevent other models to be used in the healthcare sector making it more appropriate to be used. Despite of some disadvantages like not taking technical defense into the system as well as requiring a high level of competence in order to use it, it still stands out to be the best model to be used as compared to the other
two I have discussed above, (Spanakis, et al, 2020).
STRIDE Threat Model
HOSPITAL
Request response ADMIN
PATIENTS
Response request
Request Response
ANONIMOUS USERS
References
Ahsan, K., & Rahman, S. (2017). Green public procurement implementation challenges in Australian public healthcare
sector. Journal of Cleaner Production, 152, 181-197. Collyer, F. (2018). Envisaging the healthcare sector as a field: Moving from
Talcott Parsons to Pierre Bourdieu. Social Theory & Health, 16(2), 111-126. Fatima, K., Nawaz, S., & Mehrban, S. (2019, November). Biometric Authentication in Health Care Sector: A Survey. In 2019 International Conference on Innovative Computing (ICIC) (pp. 1- 10). IEEE. Jain, V., & Ajmera, P. (2018). Modelling the factors affecting Indian medical tourism sector using interpretive
structural modeling. Benchmarking: An International Journal. Spanakis, E. G., Bonomi, S., Sfakianakis, S., Santucci, G.,
Lenti, S., Sorella, M.,... & Magalini, S. (2020, July). Cyber-attacks and threats for healthcare–a multi-layer thread analysis. In 2020
42nd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC) (pp. 5705-5708). IEEE.
2
2
2
2
6
7 8
9
10 11
10 3
3
1
Student paper
THREAT MODELING 1 THREAT MODELING 6
Original source
Threat Modeling Book Threat Modeling Book
2
Student paper
Threat Models in Health Care Facility
Original source
Threat Models in Health Care Facility
3
Student paper
University of the Cumberlands
Original source
University of Cumberlands
4
Student paper
Emerging Threats & Countermeasures (ITS-834-M41) (Fall 2020) Full Term Date
Original source
Emerging Threats & Countermeasures (ITS-834-M41) (Fall 2020) Full Term Date
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 97%
Student paper 99%
Student paper 95%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
haiderm 88%
2
Student paper
Threat Models in Health Care Facility
Original source
Threat Models in Health Care Facility
2
Student paper
The threat modeling in this perspective is the act through which the potential risks and alleviations of security are recognized and organized to impact a significant worth, for instance, the privacy of information and innovation protection. Some of the threat models include; dread threat model, stride threat model, and trike threat model.
Original source
The threat modeling in this perspective is the act through which the potential risks and alleviations of security are recognized and organized to impact a significant worth, for instance, the privacy of information and innovation protection Some of the threat models include dread threat model, stride threat model, and trike threat model
2
Student paper
DREAD Threat Modeling DREAD framework refers to a structure concerned with surveying the security threats of a PC with a recent utilization in Microsoft and though that has a current usage in Open Mass and various organizations, with a study from the makers. The model assists minds in rating the security threats and hazards while utilizing fi classifications. Such classifications include;
Original source
DREAD Threat Modeling DREAD framework refers to a structure concerned with surveying the security threats of a PC with a recent utilization in Microsoft and albeit that has a current usage in Open Stack and various organizations, with a dissertation from the makers The model assists minds in rating the security threats and hazards while utilizing fi classifications Such classifications include
2
Student paper
damage, reproducibility, exploitability, the clients affected, and discoverability. While the loss is all about how awful the results of the attack are, the factor of reproducibility focuses on how simple is the recreation of the attack in this context (Singhal & Banati, 2013). However, exploitability targets the amount of work done in dispatching the attack. Besides, the number of individuals affected by the crime is necessary, with the discoverability concerning the ease of finding the risks that potentially occur.
Original source
damage, reproducibility, exploitability, the clients affected, and discoverability While the loss is all about how awful the results of the assault are, the factor of reproducibility focuses on how simple is the recreation of the attack in this context (Singhal & Banati, 2013) However, exploitability targets the amount of work done in dispatching the attack Besides, the number of individuals affected by the crime is necessary, with the discoverability concerning the ease of finding the risks that potentially occur
2
Student paper
Generally, the five initials in the model give the origin of the name DREAD model. The model was initially meant for displaying dangers, but the evaluations were found to be unpredictable and presented with a liability to the discussion. The model was among those utilized by Microsoft 2008, (Collyer, 2018). During the evaluation of dangers using the DREAD model, the entire classifications are rated from one to the total number of assessments of a particular issue that is applied when organizing other matters.
Original source
Generally, the five initials in the model give the origin of the name DREAD model The model was initially meant for displaying dangers, but the evaluations were found to be unpredictable and presented with a liability to the discussion The model was among those utilized by Microsoft 2008 During the evaluation of dangers using the DREAD model, the entire classifications are rated from one to the total number of appraisals of a particular issue that is applied when organizing other matters
2
Student paper
According to most security specialists, the inclusion of the "discoverability" to represent the last D is found to be rewarding, by lack of definition with a few associations moving to DREAD-D scale. STRIDE Threat Modeling The STRIDE model of dangers was created by Praerit Garg and Loren Kohnfelder for application in recognition of threats to PC Microsoft.
Original source
According to most security specialists, the inclusion of the "discoverability" to represent the last D is found to be rewarding, by lack of definition with a few associations moving to DREAD-D scale STRIDE Threat Modeling The STRIDE model of dangers was created by Praerit Garg and Loren Kohnfelder for application in recognition of threats to PC Microsoft
2
Student paper
The model classifies the target dangers into six classes:
Original source
The model classifies the target dangers into six classes
5
Student paper
· Spoofing · Tampering · Rejection · Information disclosure · Denial of service · Elevation of privilege
Original source
Spoofing Tampering Repudiation Information Disclosure Denial of Service Elevation of Privilege
Student paper 95%
Student paper 69%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 90%
Student paper 100%
2
Student paper
The STRIDE model was initially made as an essential feature of displaying procedure for the security threats in PC. The model is useful when helping reason and discovering the dangers within a PC in the framework. The utilization of the model is related to the physical structure that can equally be built. Therefore, the model incorporates the failure of entire procedures, stores for information, information streams, and the trust limits.
Original source
The STRIDE model was initially made as an essential feature of displaying procedure for the security threats in PC The model is useful when helping reason and discovering the dangers within a PC in the framework The utilization of the model is related to the physical structure that can equally be built Therefore, the model incorporates the breakdown of entire procedures, stores for information, information streams, and the trust limits (Scandariato, Wuyts & Joosen, 2015)
2
Student paper
All the dangers are perceived as breach for the attractive properties of the framework, (Fatima, et al, 2019) 1.
Original source
All the dangers are perceived as infringement for the attractive properties of the framework
2
Student paper
it is the property of desire that he model targets.
Original source
it is the property of desire that he model targets
2
Student paper
refers to Authenticity as a way of ensuring robust security.
Original source
refers to Authenticity as a way of ensuring robust security
2
Student paper
this denotes the integrity of the model.
Original source
this denotes the integrity of the model
2
Student paper
the framework is non-repudiable.
Original source
the framework is non-repudiable
2
Student paper
this is the confidentiality of the network to availing sensitive information to unauthorized hands.
Original source
this is the confidentiality of the network to availing sensitive information to unauthorized hands
2
Student paper
Denial of Service; this is how readily the services are available.
Original source
Denial of Service this is how readily the services are available
2
Student paper
"Elevation of Privilege"; this all about authorization. TRIKE Threat Modeling TRIKE model is a particular threat modeling technique, which is an open-source process of displaying the threats with a lot of focus on the fulfillment of the process of examining the digital risks from the board perspective.
Original source
"Elevation of Privilege" this all about authorization TRIKE Threat Modeling TRIKE model is a particular threat modeling technique, which is an open-source process of displaying the threats with a lot of focus on the fulfillment of the process of examining the digital risks from the board perspective
2
Student paper
The model can give a danger basing their approach on the extremely used methodology and a demonstration process for the hazards, (Jain & Ajmera, 2018). The TRIKE threat modeling is a necessity model guaranteeing chosen levels of the risks for well-intentioned benefits to various partners. Subsequently, the model makes the stream charts for the information, with the framework engineers making the outlines to the information streams to impart the manner of moving of the framework as well as stores and information controls. The model contained four components;
Original source
The model can furnish a danger basing their approach on the extraordinarily used methodology and a demonstration process for the hazards The TRIKE threat modeling is a necessity model guaranteeing allotted levels of the risks for worthy benefits to various partners Subsequently, the model makes the stream charts for the information, with the framework engineers making the outlines to the information streams to impart the manner of moving of the framework as well as stores and information controls The model contained four components
2
Student paper
· Information stores · Forms · Information streams · Interactors
Original source
· Information stores · Forms · Information streams · Interactors
Student paper 96%
Student paper 83%
Student paper 94%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
com 100%
ProQuest document 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 76%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
Student paper 100%
2
Student paper
Although the entire methods seem to have great approaches, all of them are not ideal. First of all, the DREAD model has low ratings with simple questions that are put on it credibly, and it seems to drop from Microsoft.
Original source
Although the entire methods seem to have great approaches, all of them are not ideal Exemplary, the DREAD model has low ratings with simple questions that are put on it credibly, and it seems to drop from Microsoft
2
Student paper
TRIKE needs the designer to be careful while holding the complete system for conducting an analysis of the search surfaces, which is challenging when it comes to large orders, this model can only be effective in small and mobile healthcare sectors.
Original source
TRIKE needs the designer to be careful while holding the complete system for conducting an analysis of the search surfaces, which is challenging when it comes to large orders
2
Student paper
The big health care systems require a quality scale of 100 or 1000 threat model, which is a viable option, but when choosing one model, then STRIDE threat model is the best. The STRIDE model can be summarized to have a sole objective of development, meant to overcome the weaknesses associated with the other threat models. The model is well documented, owns a technology giant Microsoft Corporation, and is time tested.
Original source
The big health care systems require a quality scale of 100 or 1000 threat model, which is a viable option, but when choosing one model, then TRIDE threat model is the best The STRIDE model can be summarized to have a sole objective of development, meant to overcome the weaknesses associated with the other threat models (Scandariato, Wuyts & Joosen, 2015) The model is well documented, owns a technology giant Microsoft Corporation, and is time tested
6
Student paper
STRIDE Threat Model
Original source
STRIDE threat model
7
Student paper
Ahsan, K., & Rahman, S.
Original source
Ahsan, K., & Rahman, S
8
Student paper
Green public procurement implementation challenges in Australian public healthcare sector.
Original source
Green public procurement implementation challenges in Australian public healthcare sector
9
Student paper
Journal of Cleaner Production, 152, 181-197.
Original source
Journal of Cleaner Production, 152, 181-197
10
Student paper
Jain, V., & Ajmera, P.
Original source
Jain, V., & Ajmera, P
11
Student paper
Modelling the factors affecting Indian medical tourism sector using interpretive structural modeling.
Original source
Modelling the factors affecting Indian medical tourism sector
10
Student paper
An International Journal.
Original source
An International Journal,
3
Student paper
G., Bonomi, S., Sfakianakis, S., Santucci, G., Lenti, S., Sorella, M.,...
Original source
G., Bonomi, S., Sfakianakis, S., Santucci, G., Lenti, S., Sorella, M.,
3
Student paper
Cyber-attacks and threats for healthcare–a multi-layer thread analysis. In 2020 42nd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC) (pp.
Original source
Cyber-attacks and threats for healthcare–a multi-layer thread analysis In 2020 42nd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC) (pp