Bentham and Mill essay

Paper 2 Intro to Ethics Phil 2306 CRN 14270

DIRECTIONS FOR SUBMISSION

1. The paper must be typed. 2. Do NOT include a title. 3. Place your name, date, and course and section numbers in the header of the paper on one

line.

4. Make sure to save your paper with the following file name: [your last name] Paper 2.

Example: Bohorquez Paper 2.

5. You must submit your paper in a format that is compatible with

Microsoft Word. If I have difficulty reading your paper because of the

format in which it was submitted, I will consider your paper as not

submitted. Though pdf files are compatible with MS Word, the conversion process makes the files very difficult to read. Please do NOT submit your paper as a pdf.

6. Submit this as an attachment to Eagle Online. I will not accept hard copies or e-mail submissions of your paper. Make sure that you know how to and can submit to Eagle

Online before the deadline.

7. When referring to texts please use parenthetical citations in MLA format. Right-click on the link for MLA format info: MLA format.

8. The length of the paper MUST be at least the minimum. When determining word count do NOT include footnotes or endnotes. Only use words in the body of the paper toward

word count. Click on the following link for information on setting up word count on MS

Word: Word Count

9. Make sure to include a Works Cited section or page.

Write a 600 to 750-word response to ONE of the prompts below. This

assignment is due Thursday, February 14, 2019, at 5:30 pm. Submit this

to Canvas Eagle Online.

1. Euthyphro attempts to justify his actions by resorting to his religious knowledge and

belief. Socrates argues that such a justification is misguided. At 11e – 12d of the

Euthyphro, Socrates gets Euthyphro to agree that piety is a part of justice. Using an

evaluation of the various alternative descriptions of the relationship between justice

and piety, we explained why this must be the proper relationship between justice and

piety. (Our discussion of the Venn diagrams). What arguments could be made

against 1) individuals who maintain that the proper relationship between justice and

piety is that they are coextensive as well as 2) those that maintain that all just actions

are pious? With which of the five possible relationships between justice and piety are

you most in agreement? Why?

To respond to this assignment adequately you must use textual references. You must

have at least 2 quotes from Plato.

Paper 2 Intro to Ethics Phil 2306 CRN 14270

2. In response to the criticism that Utilitarianism is a doctrine worthy only of swine, Mill makes a distinction between higher and lower pleasures. How does he make this

distinction? Clearly and fully explain who, according to Mill, can distinguish between

higher and lower pleasures and how they make that distinction. I would strongly

recommend looking at the first several pages of Chapter 2 of Utilitarianism. Finally,

compare Mill’s position to that of Bentham. What argument does Bentham give that

undermines or challenges Mill’s position? With which philosopher do you agree?

Why?

To respond to this assignment adequately you must use textual references. You

should strive for at least 3 quotes from Mill’s Utilitarianism and Bentham’s Pushpin

vs. Poetry. You should have at least one from each author.