|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Policies
|
Level 5
|
Level 4
|
Level 3
|
Level 2
|
Level 1
|
|
Current Policy
|
10 points
Clearly describes the current IT cyber security policy.
|
8 points
Basically describes the current IT cyber security policy.
|
6 points
Weakly describes the current IT cyber security policy.
|
3 points
Little description of the current IT cyber security policy. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
No description of the current IT cyber security policy.
|
|
Rationale
|
10 points
ID at least 2 IT security policies to implement based upon the case study. Clearly discusses the rationale for selection of these policies.
|
8 points
ID at least 2 IT security policies to implement based upon the case study. Basically discusses the rationale for selection of these policies.
|
6 points
ID at least one (1) IT security policy to implement based upon the case study. Weakly discusses the rationale for selection of the policy.
|
3 points
May ID at least one (1) IT security policy to implement based upon the case study. Little discussion of the rationale for selection of the policy. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
No policies identified or discussion of the rationale for the IT security policies.
|
|
New Technology
|
Level 5
|
Level 4
|
Level 3
|
Level 2
|
Level 1
|
|
Functionality of Technology
|
10 points
Clearly describes functionality of new technology selected for implementation.
|
8 points
Basically describes functionality of new technology selected for implementation.
|
6 points
Weakly describes functionality of new technology selected for implementation.
|
3 points
Little description of functionality of new technology selected for implementation. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
No description of functionality of new technology selected for implementation.
|
|
Challenges
|
10 points
Clearly describes challenges associated with the current cyber security policy based on the new technology.
|
8 points
Basically describes challenges associated with the current cyber security policy based on the new technology.
|
6 points
Weakly describes challenges associated with the current cyber security policy based on the new technology.
|
3 points
Little description of challenges associated with the current cyber security policy based on the new technology. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
No description of challenges associated with the current cyber security policy based on the new technology.
|
|
Cybersecurity Vulnerabilities
|
10 points
Clearly explains the cyber security vulnerabilities that could be introduced by the new technology that may not be mitigated by technological configuration management. Must address two (2) or more IT policies.
|
8 points
Basically explains the cyber security vulnerabilities that could be introduced by the new technology that may not be mitigated by technological configuration management. Must address two (2) or more IT policies.
|
6 points
Weakly explains the cyber security vulnerabilities that could be introduced by the new technology that may not be mitigated by technological configuration management. Must address at least one (1) IT policy.
|
3 points
Little explanation on the cyber security vulnerabilities that could be introduced by the new technology that may not be mitigated by technological configuration management. May address only one (1) policy. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
No explanation on the cyber security vulnerabilities that could be introduced by the new technology that may not be mitigated by technological configuration management. Doesn’t address any policies.
|
|
Recommendations
|
Level 5
|
Level 4
|
Level 3
|
Level 2
|
Level 1
|
|
Revisions and Modifications
|
10 points
Clearly discusses revision and modification to each IT cyber security policy to ensure new technology doesn’t compromise organization cyber security posture. Must address two (2) or more IT policies.
|
8 points
Basically discusses revision and modification to each IT cyber security policy to ensure new technology doesn’t compromise organization cyber security posture. Must address two (2) or more IT security policies.
|
6 points
Weakly discusses revision and modification to each IT cyber security policy to ensure new technology doesn’t compromise organization cyber security posture. Must address at least one (1) IT policy.
|
3 points
Little discussion on revision and modification to each IT cyber security policy to ensure new technology doesn’t compromise organization cyber security posture. May address only one (1) policy. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
Doesn’t discuss revision and modification any IT cyber security policy to ensure new technology doesn’t compromise organization cyber security posture. Doesn’t address any policies.
|
|
Challenges and Effects
|
10 points
Clearly addresses the inter- and intra-organization leadership, managerial and policy challenges and effects associated with the new policies.
|
8 points
Basically addresses the inter- and intra-organization leadership, managerial and policy challenges and effects associated with the new policies.
|
6 points
Weakly addresses the inter- and intra-organization leadership, managerial and policy challenges and effects associated with the new policies.
|
3 points
Little address of the inter- and intra-organization leadership, managerial and policy challenges and effects associated with the new policies. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
Doesn’t address the inter- and intra-organization leadership, managerial and policy challenges and effects associated with the new policies.
|
|
Communication Challenges
|
10 points
Clearly discusses challenges in communicating new policies across the organization.
|
8 points
Basically discusses challenges in communicating new policies across the organization.
|
6 points
Weakly discusses challenges in communicating new policies across the organization.
|
3 points
Little discussion of the challenges in communicating new policies across the organization. (Or, inappropriate or excessive copying from other authors' work.)
|
0 points
No discussion of the challenges in communicating new policies across the organization.
|
|
Finds and Applies Knowledge
|
Level 5
|
Level 4
|
Level 3
|
Level 2
|
Level 1
|
|
Use of Authoritative Sources
|
5 points
Used at least 5 authoritative or scholarly sources in paper. One must be NIST SP 800-53. No APA style errors in sources.
|
4 points
Used at least 3 authoritative or scholarly sources in paper. One must be NIST SP 800-53. No more than 1 APA errors in sources.
|
2 points
Used at least 2 authoritative or scholarly sources in paper. One must be NIST SP 800-53. No more than 2 APA errors in sources.
|
1 point
May have used 1 authoritative or scholarly source in paper. May use NIST SP 800-53. May not have used APA style formatting.
|
0 points
No authoritative or scholarly sources used in paper. NIST SP 800-53 not mentioned.
|
|
Citation of Sources
|
5 points
All sources cited. No errors in citing material in paper.
|
4 points
All but 1 source cited. Had no more than 5 citing errors in paper.
|
2 points
All but 2 sources cited. Had no more than 10 citing errors in paper.
|
1 point
All but 3 sources cited. Had less than 15 APA citing errors in paper.
|
0 points
No sources cited or had more than 15 APA citing errors in paper.
|
|
Organization, Execution and Appearance
|
Level 5
|
Level 4
|
Level 3
|
Level 2
|
Level 1
|
|
Formatting
|
8 points
Has separate title slide with title, student name, class and date. All slides have titles; not wordy and is easy to read; no spelling or grammar errors; and no distracting material.
|
6 points
Basic title slide with title, student name, class and date. Slides have less than 5 errors to include: missing titles, wordy; hard to read slides; spelling or grammar errors; distracting material.
|
4 points
Weak title slide with title, student name, class and date. Slides have less than 10 errors to include: missing titles, wordy; hard to read slides; spelling or grammar errors; distracting material.
|
2 points
Missing title slide with title, student name, class and date. Slides have less than 15 errors to include: missing titles, wordy; hard to read slides; spelling or grammar errors; distracting material.
|
0 points
Missing title slide with title, student name, class and date. Slides have more than 15 errors to include: missing titles, wordy; hard to read slides; spelling or grammar errors; distracting material.
|
|
Grammar and Punctuation
|
2 points
Provides at least 12 PowerPoint Slides
|
1 point
Provides at least 10 PowerPoint Slides
|
0 points
Provides less than 10 PowerPoint slides
|
0 points
Provides less than 10 PowerPoint slides
|
0 points
Provides less than 10 PowerPoint slides
|
|
Overall Score
|
Level 5
14 or more
|
Level 4
11 or more
|
Level 3
8 or more
|
Level 2
5 or more
|
Level 1
0 or more
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|