Review Work

_________________________________________________________________________________

1) Problem: How well did they explain the problem / need / opportunity they are looking to solve?

2) Solution: How well did they explain their idea for a solution to this problem or need?

3) Value: What forms of value is (can be) delivered by the idea? Make sure to dig deeper to explore all the types of value they may be creating with the idea. Are there some subtle forms of value that might be extra important but were not emphasized enough?

4) Strengths: What are the strengths of the idea? What do you like about the concept? What does it do that makes it good? Why might people like it? In what situations or contexts might it be or work best?

5) Uniqueness: What makes this concept different from what exists? What are the unusual aspects of this concept? What does this concept have that no others have? What competitors or alternatives offer similar value? How well did they explain / explore this?

6) Weaknesses: What problems do you see with the concept? Where is the concept weakest? What problems will other people notice in the concept? What technical challenges might this concept have? What business challenges might this concept have?

7) Unknowns / Assumptions: What unanswered questions or untested assumptions did you notice? What can they do to test or validate these assumptions (e.g., experiments)?

Idea #2: The name of the project you are reviewing:

_________________________________________________________________________________

1) Problem: How well did they explain the problem / need / opportunity they are looking to solve?

2) Solution: How well did they explain their idea for a solution to this problem or need?

3) Value: What forms of value is (can be) delivered by the idea? Make sure to dig deeper to explore all the types of value they may be creating with the idea. Are there some subtle forms of value that might be extra important but were not emphasized enough?

4) Strengths: What are the strengths of the idea? What do you like about the concept? What does it do that makes it good? Why might people like it? In what situations or contexts might it be or work best?

5) Uniqueness: What makes this concept different from what exists? What are the unusual aspects of this concept? What does this concept have that no others have? What competitors or alternatives offer similar value? How well did they explain / explore this?

6) Weaknesses: What problems do you see with the concept? Where is the concept weakest? What problems will other people notice in the concept? What technical challenges might this concept have? What business challenges might this concept have?

7) Unknowns / Assumptions: What unanswered questions or untested assumptions did you notice? What can they do to test or validate these assumptions (e.g., experiments)?