NYT_ScientistsReport.pdf

!"#$%&'()%#$%*'+%)',+%(-+$'./01%.'.&'22-+&#/0%,$-%'.0)3%4',%&/.%'+5-+%(+-$-.6/6#'.7+-/5)%&'(#-$%*'+%5#$6+#8,6#'.%6'

)',+%&'00-/9,-$1%&0#-.6$%'+%&,$6'2-+$1%(0-/$-%&0#&:%"-+-%'+%,$-%6"-%;<-(+#.6$;%6''0%6"/6%/((-/+$%.-=6%6'%/.)%/+6#&0-3

>#$#6%???3.)6+-(+#.6$3&'2%*'+%$/2(0-$%/.5%/55#6#'./0%#.*'+2/6#'.3% +5-+%/%+-(+#.6%'*%6"#$%/+6#&0-%.'?3%!

",9,$6%#$1%%&&&

!"#$%&#'&'()$*+,&(-.$/(012$(314$()+5+&(-.1&(316$' 7&'(89%()+5+&' ')%()**)!+%,+"*-

!"#$%&'$()#*%$%)+',$-"+./%'#$*-)'0%)*%*$&12'$-#'1%'3$1$#"4"%$%&1%$3'*)50*$103$4/)63*$"%&'#$#"4"%*,

16+"*%$'0%)#'67$8)%&"/%$&/+10$&'6.9

:0$%&'$*&"#%$#/0,$%&)*$13210-'$-"/63$6'13$%"$1$0'8$)03/*%#7$"($)0';.'0*)2'$#"4"%*$-/*%"+)<'3$("#

*.'-)()-$%1*=*9$:0$%&'$6"05$#/0$>>$3'-13'*$1%$6'1*%$>>$#"4"%*$+17$"0'$317$4'$%#/67$#'51#3'3$1*$??1#%)()-)16

6)(',??$146'$%"$#'.#"3/-'$103$'2"62',$4/)63)05$)+.#"2'3$2'#*)"0*$"($%&'+*'62'*9

/-&$3/#146',$131.%)2'$#"4"%*,$1*%#"0"+'#*$&12'$*/55'*%'3,$-"/63$*"+'317$4'$*'0%$)0%"$*.1-'$%"

';.6"#'$%&'$5161;7$"#$*'1#-&$("#$"%&'#$6)('9

!/%$%&'$"/'*%$%"$-#'1%'$1#%)()-)16$6)('$16*"$#'2)2'*$-"0-'#0*$%&1%$-"+./%'#$*-)'0%)*%*$-"/63$'2'0%/1667

-#'1%'$1$#"4"%)-$*.'-)'*$%&1%$8"/63$*/..610%$4)"6"5)-16$6)(',$)0-6/3)05$&/+10*9

?? "+'$%&)05*$8'$.#"41467$-10$3"$8'$*&"/630?%$3",??$*1)3$!)66$#"7,$-&)'($*-)'0%)*%$1%$ /0$$)-#"*7*%'+*,

8&"$8#"%'$1$#'-'0%$1#%)-6'$81#0)05$"($%&'$."8'#$"($'+'#5)05$%'-&0"6"5)'*9$??#/*%$6)='$8'$-10$=)66$%&)05*

8)%&$%%&,$4/%$8'$*&"/630?%9??

!"#$0"8,$%&'$#"4"%)-$+10/(1-%/#)05$*7*%'+$>>$1$-"+./%'#$&""='3$/.$%"$1$+1-&)0'$%&1%$4/)63*$.61*%)-

+"3'6*$>>$)0$%&'$614"#1%"#7$"($%#9$#"#310$!9$'"661-=$103$%#9$("3$)).*"0$1%$!#103')*$*0)2'#*)%7$)0

+16%&1+,$$1**9,$-100"%$-#'1%'$107%&)05$0'1#67$1*$-"+.6)-1%'3$1*$)%*'6(9$:0*%'13,$)%$.#"3/-'*$')5&%>

)0-&>6"05$-"0%#1.%)"0*$"($.61*%)-$41#*$103$4166$,")0%*9

+&'0$1$+"%"#$103$+)-#"-&).$1#'$133'3,$%&'$1/%"+1%"0*$&12'$"0',$103$"067$"0',$14)6)%7-$%"$-#186

*6"8679$&&'$(1*%'*%$-10$*-/%%6'$16"05$1%$1$('8$)0-&'*$1$*'-"039

??&&'7$6""=$6)='$%"7*,??$%#9$'"661-=,$1$.#"('**"#$"($-"+./%'#$*-)'0-',$*1)39$!/%,$&'$133'3,$??&&'7$8'#'$0"%

'05)0''#'3$47$&/+10*,$103$%&'7$8'#'$0"%$+10/(1-%/#'3$47$&/+10*9??

%#9$'"661-=$103$%#9$)).*"0,$1$#'*'1#-&$*-)'0%)*%,$#'."#%$%&')#$#'*/6%*$)0$%"317?*$)**/'$"($%&'$,"/#016

.1%/#'9

??&&)*$)*$%&'$()#*%$';1+.6'$"($.#'%%7$+/-&$/00$.'#-'0%$1/%"+1%'3$'2"6/%)"0$"($1$+1-&)0',??$*1)3$%#9

'&)6).$(/*4103*,$1$.#"('**"#$"($1#%)()-)16$)0%'66)5'0-'$1%$%&'$*0)2'#*)%7$"($ /**';$)0$10561039$??:%?*$1

#1%&'#$.#)+)%)2'$';1+.6',$4/%$)%?*$%&'$()#*%$*%'.$%"$*"+'%&)05$%&1%$-"/63$4'$"/)%'$*)50)()-10%9??

!"#$%&#'&'()$*+,&(-.$/(012$(314$()+5+&(-.1&(316$'(7&'(89%()+5+&'(:(-;;; .&&*<=='$>$"&;%/&#?$';"+?= '&=15'&,1"&;.&?>!,$'"#$$%&'#()#'*$+,-.#;;;

&(+/() &&=)$=-$&$(0<&*((3

!"#$%&#'($()&*#$%&#$&+%","(&#+.(/0#1&#(2&0#$.#0&2,3"#).1.$2#$%4$#422&51/&#64)$2#,"#'4+$.),&2*#+/&4"#(6

+%&5,+4/#26,//2#.)#74+((5#4#%.5&8

!&+4(2&#+.56($&)2#+.2$#5(+%#/&22#$%4"#&"3,"&&)2*#::!$#.6&"2#'.)#$%&#',)2$#$,5&#4#5.)&#&+.".5,+4/

466).4+%#$.#).1.$,+2*::#%)8#'.//4+=#24,08#::+&#+4"#".?#&22&"$,4//@#0&2,3"#'.)#')&&#4"0#1(,/0#'.)#4#'&?

$%.(24"0#0.//4)28::

&%&#+.2$#.'#0&2,3","3#4#).1.$#$.04@#$@6,+4//@#)("2#').5#%("0)&02#.'#$%.(24"02#.'#0.//4)2#$.#5,//,."2#.'

0.//4)2*#%)8#'.//4+=#24,08

&%&#+.56($&)#,"#$%&#!)4"0&,2#2@2$&5#%40#".#,0&4#?%4$#4#2(++&22'(/#0&2,3"#5,3%$#/..=#/,=&8#!"2$&40*#,$

?42#5&)&/@#3,7&"#4#/,2$#.'#6.22,1/&#64)$2#,$#+.(/0#?.)=#?,$%*#$%&#6%@2,+4/#/4?2#.'#3)47,$@#4"0#'),+$,."*#$%&

3.4/#.'#5.7,"3#."#4#%.),B."$4/#2()'4+&#4"0#4#3).(6#.'#200#)4"0.5/@#+."2$)(+$&0*#"."?.)=,"3#0&2,3"28

$,5,+=,"3#1,./.3,+4/#&7./($,."*#$%&#+.56($&)#400&0*#2(1$)4+$&0#4"0#+%4"3&0#6,&+&2#,"#$%&#0&2,3"28#3$

$%&#245&#$,5&*#$%&#+.56($&)#2,5,/4)/@#5($4$&0#$%&#6).3)455,"3#,"2$)(+$,."2#'.)#+."$).//,"3#$%&

).1.$:2#5.7&5&"$28#3'$&)#&4+%#2$&6*#$%&#+.56($&)#)4"#2,5(/4$,."2#$.#$&2$#$%&#0&2,3"2*#=&&6,"3#$%&#."&2

$%4$#5.7&0#?&//#4"0#0,2+4)0,"3#$%&#'4,/()&28

3'$&)#400#$.#500#3&"&)4$,."2#.'#&7./($,."#4"0#',"&I$(","3*#$%&#+.56($&)#2&"$#$%&#0&2,3"#$.#4

6).$.$@6,"3#54+%,"&*#(2&0#1@#54"('4+$()&)2#$.#1(,/0#$&2$#5.0&/2#.'#6).0(+$#0&2,3"2*#$.#1(,/0#$%&

).1.$8#&%&"*#,"#$%&#2$&6#$%4$#)&"(,)&0#%(54"#%&/6*#$%&#)&2&4)+%&)2#,"2$4//&0#$%&#).1.$:2#5.$.)#4"0

5,+).+%,6#4"0#0.?"/.40&0#$%&#).1.$:2#6).3)455,"3#,"2$)(+$,."28

6%4"3,"3#$%&#,",$,4/#+."',3()4$,."#.'#$%&#).1.$#64)$2#6).0(+&0#4#0,''&)&"$#0&2,3"#4"0#4#0,''&)&"$

466).4+%#$.#/.+.5.$,."8#7"&#6(2%&2#,$2&/'#4/."38#::!$:2#=,"0#.'#/,=&#4"#4++.)0,."*::#%)8#'.//4+=#24,08

3".$%&)#."&#::?4/=2#2.5&$%,"3#/,=&#4#+)41*::#%)8#),62."#24,08#::!$#/..=2#/,=&#,$:2#+)4?/,"3#."#$%&#'/..)8#!$:2

"(,$&#2()6),2,"3#$%&#0,7&)2,$@#.'#2./($,."2#?&#3&$8::

!"#&4)/,&)#?.)=*#.$%&)#)&2&4)+%&)2#(2&0#2,5,/4)#&7./($,."I,"26,)&0#4/3.),$%52#$.#&7./7&#,543,"4)@

+)&4$()&2#$%4$#&M,2$&0#."/@#,"#7,)$(4/#+.56($&)#?.)/02#.)#$.#0&2,3"#$%&#6).3)455,"3#,"2$)(+$,."28

&%&#).1.$2:#&7./($,."#,2#+())&"$/@#4#0&40I&"0*#42#$%&#0&2,3","3#+.56($&)#"&7&)#/&4)"2#%.?#?&//#,$2

0&2,3"2#?.)=#,"#$%&#)&4/#?.)/08#&%&#2,56/&#).1.$2#4/2.#%47&#".#41,/,$@#$.#,56).7&#$%&,)#6&)'.)54"+&8

3++.)0,"3#$.#$%&#)&2&4)+%&)2*#$%&#).1.$2#+())&"$/@#%47&#$%&#1)4,"6.?&)#.'#14+$&),48#::+&#%.6&#$.#3&$#(6

$.#,"2&+$#/&7&/#?,$%,"#4#+.(6/&#.'#@&4)2*::#%)8#'.//4+=#24,08#::&%&)&:2#".#04"3&)#.'#6.554"0&)#%4$4

?4/=,"3#.($#.'#.()#'41),+4$.)#4"@$,5&#2.."*::#%&#24,0*#)&'&)),"3#$.#$%&#4"0).,0#+%4)4+$&)#,"#:: $4)#&)&=8::

!"#'($()&#)&2&4)+%*#$%&#!)4"0&,2#)&2&4)+%&)2#,"$&"0#$.#400#2&"2.)2#$.#$%&#).1.$2#4"0#,56).7&#$%&

0&2,3"#6).3)4528#O($()&#).1.$2#54@#4/2.#1&#41/&#$.#&M+%4"3&#,"'.)54$,."#45."3#."&#4".$%&)#4"0#/&4)"

').5#&4+%#.$%&):2#&M6&),&"+&28

32#+.56($&)#+%,62#26&&0#(6#4"0#'41),+4$,."#54+%,"&2#1&+.5&#5.)&#2.6%,2$,+4$&0*#$%&#).1.$,+

0&2,3"&)2#?,//#6).0(+&#).1.$2#$%4$#4)&#5.)&#4"0#5.)&#+.56/&M8# .5&#%47&#?."0&)&0#?%4$#?,//#%466&"

?%&"#4#).1.$#+4"#0&2,3"#4"0#1(,/0#2.5&$%,"3#42#+.56/&M#42#,$2&/'8

!"#$%&#'&'()$*+,&(-.$/(012$(314$()+5+&(-.1&(316$'(7&'(89%()+5+&'(:(-;;; .&&*<=='$>$"&;%/&#?$';"+?= '&=15'&,1"&;.&?>!,$'"#$$%&'#()#'*$+,-.#;;;

-(+/() &&=)$=-$&$(0<&*((3

!"#$%&'()*%+$%#-$ %/0$ 0"1/'2+$'3$'1/#"3"(%#$'/$/0%$ 1&6$631/7/8/%$73$$"83/'73$87%;+$6'*7=-+$0'1

18>>%1/%?$/0'/$#%1%'#@0%#1$*71/%373>$="#$#'?7"$17>3'*1$=#"($'*7%3$@7A7*7B'/7"31$'#%$("#%$*72%*C$/"$=7#1/

@"(%$'@#"11$73/%**7>%3/$('@073%1$@#%'/%?$DC$'*7%31-

63$'3$'#/7@*%$73$/0%$3)#7*$7118%$"=$+7#%?+$$#-$#"C$'#>8%?$/0'/$1@7%3/71/1$10"8*?$)%#0')1$?%*7D%#'/%*C

1/%%#$/0%(1%*A%1$';'C$=#"($#%1%'#@0$/0'/$;"8*?$@#%'/%$1%*=H#%)*7@'/73>+$%A"*A73>+$'8/"3"("81$#"D"/1-

+7/0$="#%/0"8>0/+$0%$1'7?+$@"()8/%#$1@7%3/71/1$10"8*?$D%$'D*%$/"$/')$73/"$("1/$"=$/0%$D%3%=7/1$"=$/0%

%(%#>73>$/%@03"*">C$;07*%$'A"7?73>$/0%$?'3>%#1-

II&071$?"%13I/$0'A%$%3"8>0$"=$/0%$)7%@%1$/"$D%$DC$7/1%*=$?'3>%#"81+II$$#-$#"C$1'7?$'D"8/$/0%$!#'3?%71

;"#2-$!8/+$0%$'??%?+$II+%I#%$"3$/0%$#"'?$/"$1"(%;0%#%$;0%#%$/0%#%I1$D7>$7118%1$?";3$/0%$#"'?-II

7/0%#1$;"#273>$73$/0%$=7%*?$'#%$3"/$'1$;"##7%?+$%A%3$7=$/%@03"*">7@'*$'?A'3@%1$('2%$18@0$?%A7@%1

)"117D*%-$%#-$9'*)0$6-$$%#2*%$"=$/0%$3'3"/%@03"*">C$=7#($:CA%&$'3?$'3$'?A71%#$/"$/0%$!"#%17>0/

631/7/8/%+$1'7?$/0'/$07>0$@"1/1$;"8*?$)#"D'D*C$)#%A%3/$/0%$?%17>3$"=$?'3>%#"81$#"D"/1-$9'/0%#+$#"D"/1

;"8*?$@"3/738%$/"$D%$?%17>3%?$="#$1)%@7=7@$/'121$;7/0$*7//*%$"#$3"$'D7*7/C$/"$%A"*A%$'3?$'?')/-

II6/$*""21$*72%$0'A73>$'$?%A7@%$/"$;"#2$'/$'**$71$0'#?+II$%#-$$%#2*%$1'7?-$II&0%#%$71$3"$?%17#%$/"$'??

'??7/7"3'*$@"()*%&7/C-$&0"1%$1C1/%(1$?"$3"/$*""2$*72%$/0%C$;"8*?$D%$?'3>%#"81-II

&0%$!#'3?%71$#%1%'#@0%#1$=73?$/0%$1)%@8*'/7"3$)#%('/8#%-$II9%'**C+$7/I1$1"$='#$#%("A%?$=#"($'3C/073>

?'3>%#"81+II$%#-$)7)1"3$1'7?$'D"8/$/0%7#$;"#2-$II&0%#%$'#%$('3C$"/0%#$/073>1$/"$;"##C$'D"8/$D%="#%

/071-II

'0"/"-$&0%$II3##";II$*%=/$'$/#'7*$'1$7/$@#';*%?$'@#"11$'$D%?$"=$1'3?-$;!#'3?%71$*37A%#17/C<

,"#$%&'()*%&$&*.(/**/1*2"%3*.&4/5*,"4#67$ $ +"4/ $ .%&/6;$*."<&;$ $ 0/6%;( $ ,"%%/;)&"75 $ 123 $ +/<# $ ,"7)6;)*45 '6;3*)"*."#

!"#$%&#'&'()$*+,&(-.$/(012$(314$()+5+&(-.1&(316$'(7&'(89%()+5+&'(:(-;;; .&&*<=='$>$"&;%/&#?$';"+?= '&=15'&,1"&;.&?>!,$'"#$$%&'#()#'*$+,-.#;;;

)(+/() &&=)$=-$&$(0<&*((3