NR631 Q-2 PICOT
Guidelines and Rubric
Purpose:
Clear identification of the problem or opportunity is the first step in evidence-based nursing. In a previous course, you identified a practice problem of interest and developed a PICOT question. This assignment is a review of PICOT with the opportunity to revise or refine it. You will post your PICOT in the Week 1 discussion for your classmates to review and provide feedback.
Due Date: Sunday 11:59 PM MT at the end of Week 1
Total Points Possible: 50 points
Requirements:
Description of the Assignment
Use the PICOT worksheet found in Course Resources to complete the Week 1 Assignment PICOT Worksheet.
Step 1: State your PICOT question. This should be the PICOT question that you previously developed in NR505 and which you should have continued to build upon in the Nurse Executive–track courses. If your PICOT question has changed since NR505, please note the changes in this section so it’s clear to the instructor what was original and what has been updated.
Step 2: Clearly define your PICOT question. List each element: P (patient, population, or problem), I (intervention), C (comparison with other treatment or current practice), O (desired outcome), and T (time frame). Is the potential solution something for which you (as nurse or student) can find a solution through evidence-based research? Look in your book for guidelines to developing your PICOT question and read the required articles.
Step 3: Describe the issue or problem that will be the focus of your CGE evidence-based practice change project. What have you noticed in your work or school environment that isn’t achieving the desired patient or learning outcomes? What needs to change in nursing, and what can you change with the support of evidence in the literature?
Step 4: How was the practice issue identified? How did you come to know this was a problem in your clinical practice? Review the listed concerns and check all that apply.
Step 5: What terms did you use to make sure that your search was wide enough to obtain required information but narrow enough to keep it focused? How will you narrow your search if needed?
Criteria for Content
1. Access the PICOT worksheet found in the Course Resources area.
2. Follow the instructions on the PICOT worksheet and complete the form.
3. Submit the completed PICOT worksheet form.
Example 1:
What is the PICO(T) question?
Will influenza immunization compliance rates increase if flu clinics are provided in a flu PODs and immunization clinics at convenient times covering all shifts?
Define each element of the question below.
P (patient, population, or problem): Require hospital employees and volunteers to have the influenza immunization annually.
I (intervention): Offer multiple flu PODs and immunization clinics to hospital employees and volunteers, making it convenient to receive the required immunization. Offer them at a variety of times, available to all shifts.
C (comparison with other treatment or current practice): Compare analytics showing employees and volunteers who received a flu shot prior to 2016—when flu PODs and immunization clinics were not offered—to 2016, when flu PODs and immunization clinics are offered to accommodate shifts. Track the number of employees and volunteers coming at each hour time frame.
O (desired outcome): Increase of compliance (number of employees and volunteers receiving the annual mandatory flu shot).
Example 2:
What is the PICO(T) question?
For nondiabetic patients on corticosteroid therapy, does monitoring for headache, fatigue, nausea, vomiting, and blurred vision hourly promote improvement of pulmonary complications versus making no observations for signs of hyperglycemia?
Define each element of the question below.
P (patient, population, or problem): Nondiabetic patients on corticosteroid therapy
I (intervention): Monitoring for headache, fatigue, nausea, vomiting, and blurred vision
C (comparison with other treatment or current practice): No observations for signs of hyperglycemia
O (desired outcome): Improvement of pulmonary complications
T (time frame): 90 days
**Academic Integrity Reminder**
Chamberlain College of Nursing values honesty and integrity. All students should be aware of the Academic Integrity policy and follow it in all discussions and assignments.
By submitting this assignment, I pledge on my honor that all content contained within is my original work except as quoted and cited appropriately. I have not received any unauthorized assistance on this assignment.
Directions and Assignment Criteria
|
Assignment Criteria |
Points |
% |
Description |
|
Presentation of a suitable PICOT question |
20 |
40% |
Student presents a complete PICOT question in the proper format that addresses a practice change issue of interest to the nurse executive |
|
Identification of PICOT elements and measurable outcomes |
10 |
20% |
Student provides appropriate and correctly worded statements for each of the PICOT elements |
|
Description of the practice problem; need for change; practice area; identification of practice issue; clear scope |
10 |
20% |
Practice issue or problem is thoroughly described. The need for change is evident. The practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. The scope of the problem is identified. |
|
Identification of manageable search terms |
5 |
10% |
Student identifies search terms that are appropriate for the PICOT question and are manageable for the scope of the project |
|
Appropriate literature review scope identified |
5 |
10% |
Scope of the literature review is appropriate for the project and is neither too broad nor too narrow |
|
Total |
50 |
100 % |
|
Chamberlain College of Nursing NR505 Advanced Research Methods: Evidenced Based Practice
Chamberlain College of Nursing NR631 Nurse Executive Concluding Graduate Experience 1
NR505: W2 Assignment Refinement of Nsg. Issue Rev-7/31/2017 (AR)
|
NR631: Week 1 Assignment PICOT Worksheet 11/27/2017 (RD)
|
3 |
Grading Rubric
|
Assignment Criteria |
Exceptional (100%) Outstanding or highest level of performance |
Exceeds (88%) Very good or high level of performance |
Meets (80%) Competent or satisfactory level of performance |
Needs Improvement (38%) Poor or failing level of performance |
Developing (0) Unsatisfactory level of performance |
|
Content Possible Points = 50 Points |
|||||
|
Presentation of a suitable PICOT question |
20 Points |
18 Points |
16 Points |
8 Points |
0 Points |
|
|
Outstanding question or nursing problem identified that is an independent nursing decision |
Very good question or nursing problem is identified that is an independent nursing decision |
Competent question or nursing problem is identified that is an independent nursing decision |
Question or nursing problem is identified but is not an independent nursing decision |
PICOT question missing |
|
Identification of PICOT elements and measurable outcomes |
10 Points |
9 Points |
8 Points |
4 Points |
0 Points |
|
|
PICOT elements correctly identified. Outcomes are measurable. |
One PICOT element not correctly identified. Outcomes are measurable. |
Two PICOT elements not correctly identified. Outcomes are not measurable. |
Three or more PICOT elements not correctly identified. Outcomes are not measurable. |
PICOT elements missing |
|
Description of the practice problem; need for change; practice area; identification of the practice issue; clear scope |
10 Points |
9 Points |
8 Points |
4 Points |
0 Points |
|
|
Practice issue or problem is thoroughly described. The need for change is evident. The ractice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. The scope of the problem is identified. |
Practice issue or problem is partially described. The need for change is evident. The practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. The scope of the problem is identified. |
Practice issue or problem is vaguely described. The need for change is not obvious. The practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. The scope of the problem is identified. |
Practice issue or problem is vaguely described. The need for change is not obvious. The practice area is not identified. Identification of the practice issue is not clear. The scope of the problem is not identified. |
Not answered |
|
Identification of manageable search terms |
5 Points |
4 Points |
3 Points |
2 Points |
0 Points |
|
|
Thoroughly describes manageable search terms |
Good description of manageable search terms |
Partially describes manageable search terms |
Minimally describes manageable search terms |
Search terms are absent |
|
Appropriate literature review scope identified
|
5 Points |
4 Points |
3 Points |
2 Points |
0 Points |
|
|
Thoroughly describes how to narrow search |
Good description how to narrow search |
Partially describes how to narrow search |
Minimally describes how to narrow search |
No description given |
|
Total _____ of 50 Points |
|
NR631: W1 Assignment PICOT Worksheet 11/27/2017 (RD)
|
5 |