Question in (sociology of poverty)
Critically discuss how the New Racial Politics and Social Policy in the Nixon years (1970’s) and Reagan and Bush years (1980) affected women and people of color. Also, discuss the factors that set the stage for the New Racial Politics. Nixon- Would allow unemployment to rise to counter inflation Impacts
1. Denies poor people from legally questioning the gov’t 2. Geared at the rich at the expense of the poor 3. Philadelphia plan
-All federal contractors to adopt numerical goals to ensure desegregation, diverse populations of different ethnic groups -Unions were not in favor- contractors could bypass unions. Racist unions could control who would reach higher level jobs. -Civil Right organizations supported this, affirmative action -Moving Black people away from the Republican Party
4. EEOC Staff from 359- 1969, 1972 1,600 5. Developed AA action policies and regulations esp. In housing Include his acts 6. Black social movement is weakened by desegregation + Black wealth deserting by moving into suburbs.. Blacks elected as leaders in the 1950s and 1960s + False sense of equality + increasing presence in electoral politics +Black community advocates became obsolete, replaced by Black politicians
- MLK + MX assassinations Reagan & Bush 1940s-1970s -”Golden Age of Capitalism”- WW2 destroyed Europe, US assumed supremacy
- Cost of Vietnam War was supposed to be put into domestic development - Business wanted tax cuts & poor social policies - White people were concerned about position in labor market, economy mostly sustained by
temp low wage jobs, no benefits - Inflation, low employment + globalization markets - Used Black people as scapegoats for the economic issues - Private sectors limited the influence of unions, wanted to limit social programs bc high
taxes, turn back labor laws, defeat consumer protections and labor laws in general - Conservative Think Tanks developed, mobilized -- linking race to violence, poverty, family
values
- Bush in election, used Willie Horton against opponent - Play on White fears of Black crime, exploited Black stereotype of Black people -
- CETA program replaced with job training - Grants eliminated - 400.000 people removed from stamps - Undid plans for subsidized housing - Raised required rental payment 25-30% - Penalized the poor with major cuts in welfare
Results- fam w/ kids during r/b era 63% of the increase in poverty was attributed to gov’t policies.
QUESTION #4 Critically discuss President Clinton’s crime bill and its effects on people of color. Also discuss the failure of the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) and other Black organizations to oppose the crime bill. In the wake of Reagan’s identity politics. Transition from Conservative to Liberal- economic fear of White males, conservation of White men and White supremacy, “Whitelash”--- Blame is shifted onto minorities. Blacks become scapegoat Society becomes vulnerable to racism, sexism, creates division Policy stand of Clinton to win relection, distances himself from Blacks, women, union but to win their votes at the same time. Create Balance to win everyone. He does this by:
1. Crime Bill- establishes conservative credentials (show to White people) Partisan Views of Crime Democrats- Believe that crime is structural, crime was not the cause of unemployment, urban decay, homelessness, etc… inst. Racism and inequality makes general society problems worse for African Americans. “Black on Black Crime” is an indication of lack of opportunity. “Crime” becomes a coded word to discuss Black Americans becsue Crime because of its associated with Black people. Structural perspective Solutions- Preventative actions like: Education, job training, greater youth employment opportunity, more drug treatment programs, grants for anti-guns initiatives, protect civil liberties and freedom of speech Republicans- individualistic perspective- result of social pathology, irresponsibility, genetic predisposition.. Solutions- Responsibility of the individual to rehab themselves. Putative system, death sentences, youth persecutions
Clinton viewed as being soft on crime, needed to please both sided “tough but smart crime bill” A Crime bill of accommodations To set up bill strategies
1. Redefine crime as a gun-control problem, lack of police funding (⅔ Americans supported strict gun control laws)
2. Challenge liberals over their support to civil liberties and republicans to their support of the death penalty
Bill Clinton aimed to be in the middle with the crime bill Criticism- CBC against Crime Bill, Republicans favored him because of this. All he had to do was keep quiet. CBC opposed it because bills 30.2 billion dollars over 6 years. Hire 100,000 more police officers. No regards for police brutality, discrimination, creates over policy Black organizations, political leaders, police Racial Justice Act of 1994-- Allowed accused to use statistical data showing that race was a factor in decision to use death penalty. Black interest groups failed to mobilized but opposed. Didn’t produce any new research. Didn’t utilize mass media or gain public attention. Contributed to the failure to defeat the crime bill. Expand prison system, Prison industrial complex develops, expanded penalty for federal crimes. Implements 3 strikes. “Federalizing Crime”-- Banning 19 different kinds of assault weapons. Establishes limited appeals for debtor inmates. Criticism Since 1996, 40% of death penalty were AA.. AA whose victims were white were more likely to receive the death penalty. No equal protection under the law. By 1994, Republicans establishes Draconian policy.
QUESTION 5 Critically discuss the background factors/conditions that led up to the 1996 Welfare Reform. Be sure to also discuss, the stereotypical image of welfare recipients; the deficit; the Contract with America; tax expenditures for business and the hidden welfare for the affluent; coded messages, etc. Foreshadowed by 1992 Budget, deficit 250 Billion… impacts policy you can carry out. Shifted attention from merits. Leads to several cuts. Republicans took control of the house and senate. Set up new criteria to determine who gets what. In the contract, spending reductions, education, job training cut, housing cut, anti poverty programs cut. New Subsidies for American Dream… Middle+Upper Class Welfare Reform was not race neutral. Children were ¾ welfare recipients, more Whites received benefits than Whites. Stereotypical “Welfare Queen” “End Welfare as we know it”
Clinton establishes Draconian policy in Welfare.. Max 5 years on Welfare.
Question 6 Critically discuss the 1996 Welfare Reform showing among other things that it was not “race neutral,” and the failure of the Congressional Black Caucus, Left Organizations, women and Latino Civil Rights Organizations to oppose it. Also discuss the effects of Welfare Reform on
women and people of color, recommendations to improve the conditions for women and people of color, etc.
Accountability Act of 1996, replaced AFDC-- Replaced by TANF AFDC- welfare recipients received cash, requirements of adults to work, must participate in educational training programs, or do community service. There are time-limits, max-5 years… The state could extend you but the federal gov’t would not cont to pay… Teenage parents must live with adults. States established family caps. Childcare was not guaranteed. Legal immigrants benefits were reduced or didn't qualify. States requires drug testing, could demand comm service, could deny assistance to mothers. “Individual Responsibility Plan” adult recipient to come up with a plan + recipient has to plan way to get off of welfare. If you don’t follow the plane, you are penalized. Black Grants- Set up to Aid families w/ children + reduce dependency on government + Encouraged marriage to boost “personal responsibility” Economic contraction-- No jobs available 24 billion cuts food stamps 7 supplementary income 3 billion- childcare 2.5 billion social service Welfare recipients - burdened to work and take care of children, working without education, training, no childcare etc Attacked women in welfare system, was not gender neutral Women’s responsibility to take care of children… If paternity cannot be established, women don’t qualify for child support. Didn’t make concessions for addicts Reform not race neutral, no gains were made +Recommendations
Question #7
What is new about today’s globalization- especially the technology of production, communication and distribution? How does this impact our lives- the political economy of the wages, market system; culture, ideology and the media: politics and structures of social control and domination? Globalization and Technology has always been there technology, production, communication, culture, ideology, media, politics, social structures, economy Not static, many continuous changes + Evolutions 3 major eras Mercantile Age Industrial/Financial Age -Labor creates value, maximization of profit, goods and services produces, commodities to be sold -shift from mass labor to elite labor due to technology + automation example of self check-out -human labor disappears Electronic Age -Rise of the laborless economy, introduction of new sophisticated technology and information -Changes work and relationship to work, less need for human labor -Tech shrinks role of gov’t
-Transnational Corporations become increasingly important, supercede influence of nation-states
-Counteract idea of technology as merely computers… permeates every aspect of life and living Expansion of the world economy Leaves proletariat behind. Cannot get a job, find income. Political leaders choose to make concessions or not. All eras focus on market economy-- Key aspect Failure-- creation of capitalism + sales